Cory and staff are the best around. Even though I moved to a different time zone they are still my…read morego too for any jewelry needed. I love dealing with a family business with Prompt response, fast shipping and great prices. Highly recommend anyone to give them a shot!

Beautiful little place great prices lots of beautiful jewelry felt very comfortable. Steph was…read moresuper helpful. I will definitely be back.

I was very nervous about resizing my engagement ring. Jimmy's did an amazing job with sizing and…read morepolish. They also did an excellent job with resizing my tennis bracelet. Diane was wonderful as well as the other staff. I definitely recommend bringing your cherished jewelry for fixing if needed. They will be treated with care!

Everything always good at Jimmys! Beautiful surroundings…read morerespectful staff and i have beautiful jewelry always! Thankyou always for your service Jimmy and staff

Frank was absolutely nothing short of a gentleman! His professionalism, respect, and understanding…read moreof my needs helped create this beautiful ring and moment for my fiancé and I! I cannot say enough wonderful things about Frank and the other members of the business. HIGHLY recommended for all of your jewelry needs!

This place is my go-to when I need to have a watch battery replaced. They're fast and courteous,…read moreand the prices they charge are reasonable.

Great people to deal with. Honest , knowledgeable, and great jewelry repaired! You will not be…read moredisappointed!

My family and I have been going to Fortune Jewelers ever since we moved to the island. It's a…read morefamily-owned business that truly treats you like one of their own. Over the years, they've become our go-to for everything from repairs to special gifts. The quality, honesty, and personal touch they bring is rare to find these days. Grateful for their service and happy to support a business that's been so good to us for so long!

We had the absolute BEST experience working with him! My fiancé and I are young, and from the start…read morehe treated us with so much respect, patience, and honesty. He never once made us feel pressured -- instead, he really took the time to educate us and guide us through the entire process. My ring was completely custom made, and he brought our vision to life perfectly. He walked my fiancé through every detail -- from the stone to the setting -- and made sure everything was exactly what we wanted while still staying within a comfortable budget. You can tell he genuinely cares about his clients and isn't just trying to make a sale. The craftsmanship is incredible. The ring is even more beautiful than I imagined, and the quality is flawless. It sparkles like crazy in every light (I literally can't stop staring at it). If you're young, first-time buyers, or looking for someone you can truly trust to create something custom and special, I can't recommend him enough. Such a smooth, positive experience from start to finish!

Very helpful with reasonable prices! Joseph was very helpful and they resized my watch on the spot,…read morewould recommend!

My husband purchased a necklace and ring for me as an anniversary gift. It was top quality and…read morelooks great! We've had repairs done there and also batteries replaced in watches. The staff and owner are wonderful and very easy to work with. I highly recommend this jeweler!

I have  $20-22k in diamond rings from Buono Jewelry.  I was looking to sell them and anywhere I…read morebrought them to I was basically offered less then $4000.  I was told to go back to the original jeweler instead, i'd have better luck. I attempted to bring them to Buono directly to sell them back but they weren't interested in them.   I am disgusted that they do not stand behind the quality of their work and product.   I do not recommend this establishment at all because they inflate their appraisals to make a sale and take advantage of their repetitive customers.

Great people, very helpful. The woman refused a tip on Christmas Eve then gave me a very nice…read morediscount on the holiday. Things like that are great business and make people want to come back.

Always friendly, with reasonable prices and great customer service. Always go there for my watch…read morebatteries. $7 and up for more expensive watches. Highly recomend.

Prior to visiting Gerald Peters, I have visited countless Rolex ADs where essentially the same…read moremessage was conveyed- Little to no inventory with a long waitlist for popular Rolex models. Hearing this was pretty disappointing for me as my husband is a watch enthusiast and is interested in growing his collection. However, my first experience at Gerald Peters has been exceptionally amazing and the customer service received was above and beyond their competitors. Samantha O is the epitome of a professional sales associate. She was very welcoming, had a wealth of knowledge on Rolex watches, transparent with expectations, and was GENUINELY eager to help me find the perfect watch as my anniversary gift to my husband. The very next day after my initial visit, she texted me with an available model that was very close to the preferred/ideal configurations. This prompt action proved that she kept me in mind and was sincerely trying to source the perfect watch as my husband's anniversary gift! She has won me over as a new client and I look forward to purchasing several watches and jewelries from her! Also, so happy that they're located in Staten Island and I look forward to building a long relationship with Gerald Peters!

I'd like to start this off by saying if you are looking for jewelry this is definitely the place to…read morego. They have a great selection and the staff is great. That being said my experience with buying watches from them hasn't gone as well as other people that have left reviews. I spent $26,000 on an engagement ring and had a watch serviced with them for another $1,100 all within the same month. I asked to be put on the list for 2 Rolexes and I haven't gotten so much as a call in about a year and a half. Again this is a great store I would recommend them to anyone and everyone in the Staten Island area looking for jewelry I just didn't have the same watch buying experience as other people leaving reviews.

Fabulous jeweler , HONEST, very reasonable prices, and a fantastic,warm,friendly staff. Worth…read moretraveling to, if you don't live in the area. Plenty of parking,located in a strip mall.

This place is AWESOME!!! The rings fit on my fiance's finger a week after I bought them, the…read morerolex's were real, and the earrings made my fiance GORGEOUS!!! I would for sure look in this place's direction, Save yourself and go here!!

I was once quoted over 200$ to repair this ring and I had it repaired- ten years later!- at this…read moreamazing jeweler for 60$. I was so happy my husband decided to buy me another ring from the right then and there!

Came here to get a few pearl necklaces restrung as a surprise holiday gift. Got here pretty close…read moreto Christma--a busy time for sure--but they exploded repairs--which were perfectly done--in time for a nice surprise holiday gift--much appreciated. I should note that the jewelry itself here is...not to my taste. I thought I'd get a new piece to go with the repairs, but for me things felt on the showy side. Then again I'm no expert, and tastes vary. Service here is great--I observed a very fun and entertaining interaction as a clerk helped someone pick out an engagement ring that eventually involved the whole store. A worthy place to try for repairs or to see if they have items to your taste.