Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Sour Sister Bakery

    5.0 (1 review)

    Sour Sister Bakery Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Sour Sister Bakery

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    9 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - Sour Sister Bakery

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Desserts 590 times last month within 10 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Edgar's Bakery

    Edgar's Bakery

    3.5
    (251 reviews)
    7.2 km
    $$

    Stopped in early to grab some breakfast and a few goodies before leaving town. Loved the hometown…read morefeel of the bakery. Staff members were very friendly and helpful. French Toast was excellent! Huge portion size. Cinnamon rolls that I brought were a hit as well. Only negative feedback was with the 12 count assorted homestyle cookies. Cookies were very crunchy, in my opinion a little over baked. Great experience, great area, with a very welcoming environment.

    We had our one year old's cake picked up this morning at 9am. The order was placed in advance…read more While the cake isn't terrible... the price and quality just don't match. The color is wrong, the wording is not where it was discussed. The wording itself is wrong. We were told we could pick it up as early as 6 but opted for 9. Her party started at 10. She arrived at 8:50 and she was told the cake wasn't ready. They were rushing to do the lettering on the cake. She did finally get it at 9:20 but with her being 19 she was not going to point out the defects. She waited to get with us, adults, so we could address it. They did show her the cake as they quickly boxed it. So they didn't ask her if it was right... Realistically they wouldn't be able to fix it. The color is supposed to be light blue but I suppose turquoise is close... smh. This would not be easily corrected and it's fine. It would have just been nice for them to do what was discussed like the lettering around the base because our daughter's name is too long for the top. I like how they wrote it over the decoration even though this was not supposed to happen. Oh! And instead of "Charlotte's First Birthday" it's "Charlotte first birthday" in poor condensed font to fit it in. The cake isnt terrible but I expect better quality for $80. It isn't what we wanted. I did call them and let them know but again, what can they do. I'm including photos. I would have rather pay a fraction and order from Publix. They never do me wrong. And while it's more basic I get what I ask for. We did get cupcakes too. They turned out ok but it's a real disappointment about our daughter's first cake. Not the end of the world but a disappointment I'd like to spare others from if possible.

    Photos
    Edgar's Bakery
    Jr breakfast
    Jr breakfast
    It's funny I know it's like "she won't remember" she won't but we will...

    See all

    It's funny I know it's like "she won't remember" she won't but we will...
    Cinnaholic

    Cinnaholic

    3.2
    (18 reviews)
    2.4 km

    02/20/26 came here to get birthday celebration rolls. Due to dairy restrictions this place will…read moreaccommodate. We preordered a dozen Old Skool cinnamon rolls. Wow just like the dairy ones. Can't tell the difference. Everyone really enjoyed them. The non-dairy birthday girl and family really like reheating them a day after with a little butter on them. It was like celebrating her birthday again. We had a Cinnaholic in our city in the bay area but it closed down. We were so happy to find one near Decatur Alabama that we didn't mind a little drive to Madison Alabama. While we visited the store it was nicely kept including the restroom. We got greeted as we walked in. Nice décor for the interior. We enjoyed a brownie $3.00. It's very fudge to perfection. Make sure to have something to help wash it down in a good way. We had a Banana Pudding Roll $8.00. The roll was nicely done not too chewy and just enough cinnamon. The slices of banana add wow on this one. We also had a Strawberry Shortcake Roll. Again the base of all the rolls is the same. Not too chewy baked just right with a nice amount of cinnamon inside. The strawberry spread and slices made it into another wow creation. Thank you and if we come back to Decatur we're going to visit again.

    The service was amazing. From the moment I entered the door the lady had a smile on her face. The…read moreatmosphere was very festive and inviting. Their food items offered a venue That matched the season. It was a very cozy and inviting experience. The lady behind the register was cute to boot As well! This place is amazing!¡

    Photos
    Interior
    Interior
    Cinnaholic
    Cinnaholic

    See all

    Cookie Fix

    Cookie Fix

    4.0
    (10 reviews)
    2.3 km

    Hubs picked up some cookies for our daughter and her family from here that were supposed to be…read moreHalloween themed. Primarily, frosted with the shapes of ghosts and some with sprinkles shaped like candy corns. This store is maybe seven miles from our home, and these cookies were not packed/boxed well to travel and retain their decorations. The ghosts were ridiculous looking and the sprinkle candy corn shapes were executed with zero thought - despite the travel, they were just executed badly. Hubs sent them photos of the cookies (the box all six cookies were in was sealed with a sticker when he picked them up) and the store set him up with four replacement cookies. I thought this was a great, kind gesture! Hopefully Cookie Fix will fix their packaging issues and will correct their design problems. Thanks Cookie Fix, for making good on your product satisfaction!

    Dropped in on opening day to get our cookie fix. We tried the Chunky Mama and the Coffee Toffee…read morecookies and both were excellent. Staff was incredibly friendly and helpful. Cookies are available individually and can also be grouped in tins, and there's even some frozen dough available to take and bake. There's a beverage cooler available and options for ordering cookie cakes and setting up fundraising opportunities as well. It's worth noting that there doesn't appear to be any seating indoors or out. I'd guess that their most direct competitor would be Crumbl, so a few things worth noting for comparison: pricing of these cookies is cheaper than Crumbl at around $3 each, but they are also much smaller than Crumbl cookies despite having a thick center. The Cookie Fix cookies didn't seem overly sweet in the off-putting way that some find Crumbl's to be, which is great. Both cookies we tried were soft, fresh, and warm with great notes of cinnamon, coconut, oats, and walnuts. The Coffee Toffee didn't really have much of a coffee taste in my opinion, but it had a gooey, chocolatey center that was delicious. Overall would recommend for an occasional treat, just know that you'll be looking at $3ish per cookie!

    Photos
    Cookies ready to bake at home
    Cookies ready to bake at home
    Building exterior
    Building exterior
    Entrance

    See all

    Entrance
    Sweet Charlie’s

    Sweet Charlie’s

    3.6
    (31 reviews)
    3.5 km

    Review is only for atmosphere and service; I was unable to actually try the food because of, well,…read moreservice. Only reason this is a 2 star instead of a 1 -- it's possible the ice cream is good, but I sure didn't get to try it. Located off the main drag of highway in Madison, this is a small chain offering rolled ice cream, milkshakes, cookies, and liege waffles with decadent toppings. It's been here a little while and so I thought I'd stop by for an afternoon treat while waiting to attend an event nearby. I entered into the smallish, narrow space and was immediately struck by how...dead it felt. There was one other customer (or perhaps an owner/manager, though if it was, that's kind of disappointing given my experience). It was kind of dark inside and it smelled weird -- not noxious or anything but a little musty and certainly not a yummy, sweet, ice cream, cookie, or waffle scent like you might expect. I wasn't greeted but I wandered up to the register where an employee was listlessly -- and I mean LISTLESSLY - pushing around a few sad ice cream rolls. Every other time I've watched ice cream get rolled the worker has almost been like a hibachi chef, rapidly cutting, dicing, rolling, and flipping. This reminded me of picking a scab. I said hello; I don't remember if the young female employee said anything back, she might've muttered an acknowledgement but it definitely wasn't a warm welcome. Having never been here before, I was a little unclear on the process (eg, what are mix-ins vs toppings; what's available; are there pre-made creations, etc), but she never offered to answer any questions or render assistance, even as I stood for several minutes gazing up at the menu. All I heard from her for a while - as she continued to listlessly scrape the ice cream around - were several very loud, gnarly-sounding sniffles. They were bad enough that I started to feel concerned she was sick. These concerns were further worsened by the fact she wasn't wearing gloves. While that thought flickered through my mind, I abruptly heard her say, "I'm sorry." I assumed she was talking to me since I'd been waiting for a while, and so I reflexively said, "You're fine!" I quickly realized she wasn't speaking to me at all and was instead having a conversation on the phone through the headphones she was wearing. Nice. This went on for another minute or two -- it was a fairly personal conversation and she seemed to be consoling someone on the other end -- and I just decided it wasn't worth the hassle and frustration. Y'all know I try my best to be very forgiving of service and such but this was a bridge too far for me. I had read reviews prior to coming here about service being bad and I thought surely people were overreacting or being entitled but now I don't think so. Perhaps the product is good, but you'll be hard-pressed to sell much of it if employees aren't even willing to make it for customers.

    After the owners response about the expired milk, I've been back 3 times. They're n e v e r open…read more When I visited today, just now around 320 pm on a Friday, 2 other sets of people were walking away from the door to their cars too. Looks like a story that doesn't end well.

    Photos
    I came here twice during business hours and its closed.
    I came here twice during business hours and its closed.
    Inside
    Inside
    Sweet Charlie’s

    See all

    Jeremiah's Italian Ice

    Jeremiah's Italian Ice

    3.8
    (8 reviews)
    8.2 km

    The customer service was rude. The bigger boy with dirty blonde curly hair and tall has an attitude…read moreproblem.

    Came by here the other day for a treat. It's a cute little shop that makes me super nostalgic for…read moremy years working at a froyo shop in high school (even though, mind you, this is Italian ice and soft serve). This dessert shop is located in a sort of inauspicious looking shopping mall in Madison. It's right next door to Just Love Coffee and a storefront that says it's about to become "Dogtopia." The parking lot is very long and fairly wide; no troubles there. I arrived right after they opened and it was spotless and had that nice, bright, clean scent I associate with freshly mopped floors. I understand it's sometimes annoying to have a customer come in on the early side of opening, but a staff member came out and served me politely. I explained I'd never visited before and she gave me a brief run down of what kind of treat I could build. They have Italian ice, soft serve, and then what they call gelati -- not to be confused as the plural of gelato; this means a mixture of both Italian ice AND soft serve. This seems to be their signature thing. You can build your own gelati by selecting flavors and toppings, or pick from a curated menu of popular combinations. I chose the latter, since it was less intimidating, lol. If I remember correctly, what I got was called an Oreo mud pie. It had cookies and cream Italian ice, vanilla and chocolate swirled soft serve, and crumbled Oreo pieces layered in. I got the smallest size serving and thought the price was reasonable and the serving size satisfying. Overall, I enjoyed this dessert. I definitely liked the soft serve more than the Italian ice, but that doesn't really surprise me; I usually prefer creamier treats. The soft serve was smooth and had a distinct vanilla flavor. The Italian ice was okay; oddly, it had a peculiar minty taste to it, in addition to the faintly chocolatey, faintly creamy cookies and cream vibe. Perhaps it was made in the same machine as a different, minty flavor? Not really sure what caused it, but I didn't dislike it. I appreciated that the staff member asked while I was eating if I was happy with what I got. This seems like a sweet place to bring kids and family members for a unique dessert. Give it a try sometime.

    Photos
    Oreo mud pie
    Oreo mud pie
    Jeremiah's Italian Ice
    Jeremiah's Italian Ice

    See all

    Sour Sister Bakery - desserts - Updated August 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...