Absolutely phenomenal! Tried it on a whim and one of the…read morebest patty melts I've ever had in my life. So good that I ordered a second to go to have for dinner. Staff is also terrific and super welcoming. If you make the time to sit inside you won't be disappointed. No pics to share because it didn't last long. Patty Melt and Regular Burger is what we ordered along with fries and the freshest okra we've ordered in a while. Getting the cobbler to go as we are stuffed but still wanted to try it, so that will get reviewed later as I'm writing this from our table before driving back to Texas.

Great service. Great food. A legend in Durant. It's a " don't miss" when in Durant. I came here…read moreoften 10/12 years ago when I lived here. Now I'm back again. Happy to report it's still great

I have been to this place several times in the past two years, and each time the food was…read moreexcellent! In fact, my sister came for a visit recently, and she requested the Old Ice House. That's the best compliment they could receive. The wait staff was great and it's been consistently great, along with the food and drinks. I think the atmosphere is just right; the fact that it was an actual ice house makes the place welcoming. I haven't been there during live music events but I'm guessing they're fun too.

We happen to be spending the night in Durant and came upon this restaurant on Yelp. It did not…read moredisappoint!! Food was excellent, the wine was great and inexpensive and the service was spot on! If your in Durant....Check the Old Ice House out....you won't be disappointed.

I love burgers. I've had so many burgers. I don't usually leave yelp reviews but I feel like this…read moreis a special case. THIS WAS THE BEST BURGER I HAVE EVER HAD IN MY ENTIRE LIFE. We came in and there were a few ladies in the kitchen and they absolutely seasoned the heck out of these burgers. They were so seasoned the flavor was out of this world. It was also MASSIVE. It is "smash burgers" I'm not upset at all. It was like the biggest bun and then the patty was even bigger. And fatter. I got a double cause that's how I do smash burgers. It was like 1.5 in of straight seasoned beef. Protein goals and all that. 10/10 not only that but I saw seasoning on top of the cheese. The flavor I can't believe I have to travel 2 hrs to get it again. Nothing will ever compare. Every burger I eat I will think of this one. Not only was the burger the best ever but I am also a huge fan of sweet potato fries. They made theirs waffle cut style but like so thin that it was an insane crunch like a potato chip but not too crisply for a fry. It was just the perfect sweet potato fry and they have the good ranch. The bathroom was clean too. Super important to me also lol Quick service. Best burger of my life. Best sweet potato fries. 10/10 in all areas. They had a rush come in after we got there and I can see why. Those ladies make a dope burger. I hope this place never goes away. I'm going to go back every time I go to lake texoma.

UPDATE NICKS BURGERS…read more Burger is fresh meat, had cheese (I liked that it was actually melted). The lettuce is leaf lettuce which I like. The pickles I do not like. (The Best Maid Hamburger Pickles are the Best), the edges of the bun was soggy I just cut it off. Like the Tatir tots, did not like the fires (it's those breaded fries), like the Tea but not as sweet as I am use too.

I was in Sherman visiting my brothers and my younger brother mentioned going to The Farmstead in…read moreColbert for lunch. Our waitress was very busy but quickly brought our drinks. I ordered the chicken fried steak with mashed potatoes and fried okra. My CFS was a tasty, tender steak with a nice crispy crust and sides were good. My brother has the fried catfish and enjoyed it. I was full so got a slice of coconut pie to go (picture would have been better if the pie hasn't traveled an hour home). Pie was okay but maybe should have gotten chocolate or lemon. Overall, I can definitely recommend The Farmstead.

A small town locals diner…read more Service was friendly and prompt. The food was good and the hamburger soup special was excellent Got the BBLT that was huge and very tasty Did not order deserts but seeing them on the way out made us wish we had ordered one Worth turning off I-75 when driving to Oklahoma

Was visiting from out of town and this place came highly recommended however somehow, it missed the…read morespot for us. We arrived and got seated, the waitress was plenty friendly, made suggestions, made sure coffee cups stayed refreshed. However the food just seemed to be lacking. We ordered the biscuits and gravy and literally it was a biscuit with white gravy no sausage or seasoning that could be tasted. I had specifically asked that the hashbrowns be cooked crispy. However what was served was far from that. The skillets were more like a scramble. The creamer container was filthy where the server ended up taking the container from the table. We were asked if we wanted to go containers which we declined. It just didn't meet our expectations based off the reviews we had read nor the recommendations given to us, to which we left disappointed. We can put this on the been there, done that list.

I am so happy that I found the Magnolia Cafe in Durant, Oklahoma! This is the best run cafe I have…read morebeen to in a long time! The manager, Chris stays right up front and is a real hands on style manager. He makes sure that the customers are well taken care of by the wait staff( who are all friendly and knowledgeable as well as hard working). The decor is attractive and spotlessly maintained. The kitchen staff gets the food out very promptly and the bacon, eggs, potatoes, biscuits and gravy were all cooked and seasoned to perfection! Everything was so good that I drove through a flooding deluge of rain and lightning to eat there the next morning! Chris remembered me(after only one visit) and greeted me by name! I will definitely be eating here on every trip I make to Durant!

The cashier was nice and helpful. The dining room was clean and organized. The burger was hot and…read morefresh.

Fine in a pinch. Overall on par with a fast food burger…read more This is the only burger option on-site aside from the few on Guys menu

Date of visit: 8/8/26. The food is good, and the staff is wonderful!…read more This review is being giving because my server, Mo and the manager, Allison deserve the recognition. From the moment my husband and I sat in Mo's section, Mo was friendly, personable and attentive. I drink a lot of water with my dinner and not having to ask for refills was great. Mo was on top of it the entire time, all while still ensuring her other customers had what they needed too. This visit was prior to the doors opening for Kane Brown's show. They were very busy but yet Mo still managed to make me feel like I was the most important customer (I observed her doing this for all her customers). Very pleasant and very efficient! Greatly appreciated. When it was determined that my host did not have a chance to add comp for my dinner, Mo offered to try to take care of arranging it on her end. This service has never been offered previously by any other staff member at any location at Choctaw. When Mo was unsuccessful (to no fault of hers!), Allison tried. Not only did Allison try, she also came over to explain all the details and all with a smile! In the end, I went to the Rewards Club, but Mo and Allison tried really hard to resolve for me. Exceptional service by Mo and Allison from the moment we walked in until we left. Thank you!

Ordered to salad with chicken and hamburger nachos. Order took 40 min to complete. When returning…read moreto our room we discovered that there was no chicken on the salad. While waiting for the 49 min for our Togo order, we waited at the bar to have a drink. We waited over 10 min to be greeted. I asked what was on draft. Bartender said all drafts are not working. I asked what beers were available. Bartender seemed upset to have to tell me the beer list. Noticed the bartender's not bussing the dirty dishes on the bar. Several bar guest had to sit at the bar with previous guests dirty dishes in front of them. Very disappointing experience. I'm sure Guy Fieri would not be happy with this location.

I don't know what to say bad about it. It's fresh, the workers are very prompt and nice. And the…read moreplace is clean. The food was good, shoe string fries are crisp, and the concretes are delicious. I'm not from here but, it's been a weekly staple while I've been here.

Food tasted of old dirty cooking oil, kind of a sour bitter note that you couldn't get out of your…read moremouth

Wife and I, passing through, stopped here for late lunch today. I was sorry to hear elder Sherrer…read morehad passed since our last occasion to dine here. However his son and grandson are still operating. The food and selection is still good. The bad news is They are only open now for lunch. 11 am-2pm. If you are like me, I love chicken fried steak, order it whenever, and Sherrers offer it served three ways. 1. Sandwich on a bun in a basket with fries or substitute.(I had a fresh salad ) 2. Traditional plate with mashers, gravy and fresh salad 3. Played open face on Texas toast with gravy, fries and a salad.

We traveled to Durant Oklahoma Friday to the Choctaw health center. And after we left there we…read moretraveled the back road into Durant and came across Sherrer's Restaurant. We decided to give it a try. I like mom and pop restaurants and it looked like it would be one. And my husband ordered the catfish. And I had a burger and onion rings. And we were not disappointed at all. It had that old fashioned taste and everything was wonderful. I especially enjoyed the onion rings! My husband had two big pieces of catfish which he said was great. The lady that waited on us was so friendly and gave us great service! The restaurant was kind of old but it had a great flow thru it and plenty of room.