Great cake both taste and look. We were thrilled with how they made it extra tall to accommodate…read morethe additional people guests attending the party.

I feel bad to write this review because I want to support a woman owned small business but...I wish…read moreI had not ordered my birthday cake from here. I was initially lured in by the good Yelp reviews. I liked that I could do everything online, I had a particular vision for what I wanted my birthday cake to look like and they communicated with me via email that could make my vision come true. I had a birthday celebration at a restaurant, which I asked The Evercake to have delivered directly to the restaurant. The delivery was smooth and the restaurant had the cake before I even got there. The cake was very cute and did look like what I had pictured. But...what I majorly disliked was the actual taste of the cake and being misled about what the contents of the cake would be. I selected the strawberry shortcake option for my cake and what I got was not what I thought it would be. I think it's quite normal for a strawberry shortcake to have like...real strawberries in between the layers. My cake didn't really have that, and if it did it was hidden in all the strawberry jam that there instead. I was not a fan of the cake texture too and the cream outside of the cake. Overall I felt so sad that I was feeding this to my friends and I told them that they didn't have to finish it because I wasn't going to either. So embarrassing :( Would you believe that this flop of a cake was nearly $200? And that's after the 10% coupon. I'm giving 2 stars instead of 1 because it wasn't completely bad, but the cake not tasting good was the biggest thing for me. I would have preferred it the other way around at least, like if the service was so bad but the cake tasted amazing, but unfortunately that was not the case for me. After digging through the reviews some more, I found that this happened to another customer as well. I wish I had seen their review before ordering a "strawberry" shortcake from here lol dang

Cute little store front bakery featuring some cupcakes , cookies, and brownie type sweets…read more There are two locations: we went to the Rutherford location and the other one is in cliffside park, I couldn't find the Rutherford location to do the review. Prices were decent. We tried the sweet potato squares and the apple squares. Both tasted fresh and not too sweet, the crust was a mix between a shortbread and a cake.

There is not a single sub-par item from GoodieBox! We adore every thing we try and Carrie is such a…read morepleasure to work with. Whether you need something for a mid-day treat or a big event, you won't be disappointed when you order from GoodieBox!

2026 update: another year, another stunningly designed cake. Not only was it as perfectly decorated…read moreas last year's, but the taste was perfect. I'm eating leftovers of the cake right now while typing this update. Endless compliments on how beautiful the cake was, and most importantly, the birthday boy was happy!

Hudson Cakery is simply the best! We've ordered many cakes and treats over the years. Everything…read morealways comes out gorgeous like you would see on Pinterest and more importantly they're delicious. It all started during Covid when I wanted something special for my child's first birthday, and now it's become a tradition we look forward to every year. Highly recommend Hudson Cakery for any special occasion -- they never disappoint!

Erika is truly exceptional! We came to her for our baby's 100th day celebration, and the cake she…read morecreated was nothing short of magnificent. We wanted the 3 Chinese zodiac animals incorporated into the cake, and she executed it in an amazing fashion (she hadn't done it before for her clients). Erika's professionalism shone through, as she not only crafted a stunning cake but also provided instructions on caring for it until the right moment--an above-and-beyond touch in my extremely humble opinion. We were so impressed that we returned to her for our baby's 1-year birthday (a significant occasion in Asian culture), and once again, she exceeded our expectations! My wife and I never had a single criticism of her work; it was always just "wow, this cake is perfect and how the heck did she do this." Erika is incredibly talented, professional, and personable. I highly, highly recommend choosing her for your special occasions. The taste matches the impeccable appearance, and I'm 100% certain we'll be turning to her for all our future cake (and cupcake, we haven't tested it out yet) needs!

Yay! They finally open the yelp account! I was waiting for this because it is the world best cake…read morethat I've ever tried. I went to my friend's b-day party last year and saw the cake by Peory L'atelier for the first time. I am neither a cake lover nor sweet tooth, so I am not interested to have cake at all. However, how can I not try to have a piece of cake while the appearance of cake is so gorgeous and fancy?! My friend told me the flower on the cake is also handmade EDIBLE BUTTERCREME, not fresh flowers. Before I tried a bite, I did not have any expectation about the flavor because I assumed it may be too sweet and buttery. But it was neither too sweet nor buttery. It was just perfectly and enoughly flavorful and mellow. I started to order cakes from here to celebrate special events, so my beloved ones also can try what I have experienced. They reply very fast once I submit the application and they also deliver occasionally depends on the date/time and location which is great! If you have not tried this cake, if you are not sweet tooth but want to have some cake, if you are a sweet tooth but want to try mellow and flavorful cake, and if you want to make celebration or your day more special, this cake is the one.

Very old school style bakery with German and Italian style goodies. Saw huge logs of strudels,…read morelintzers, cannolis, butter cookies of all shapes and sizes and beautifully decorated special occasion cakes. This is not a place to get trendy or fusiony style things (bubble tea, matcha desserts) and they don't have vegan or gluten free goods. However the classics they make are solid. Had an Oreo cupcake. The batter was rich chocolate cake. The white cream icing had massed up Oreo cookies in it and a thick layer (removed some of it). A whole Oreo cookie sat on top of the piped icing. A good treat.

German bakery, and this location is almost 80 years old. Street parking. (2nd location in Tenafly)…read moreAll types of baked goods; Italian bread, cookies, pastries as well as German linzer cakes\cookies, and strudels. Donuts, buns, wedding cakes, specialty cakes. I stopped in last week for the first time in over 30 years and still the same delicious products. I had to get their infamous Pecan Bavarian ring cake ( see pic) which was so good. Grabbed a few pastries called Lobster Tails which is a crisp, shell-shaped Italian-American pastry with hundreds of paper-thin, flaky layers, resembling a lobster's tail. This version was filled with whipped cream ( as others are with French or custard cremes. ) Always a safe bet when you need good bake shop goods. Only thing off to me was on a recent Saturday afternoon there were only 2 clerks working and between the phone call orders and the 2 people in front of me it took almost 30 minutes to get a few items. Still worth the visit and I wasn't leaving without !

Been hearing about this bakery spot for a while now…read more There's a nice selection of pastries and all of them look delicious. Got the red bean matcha sandwich which was interesting tasting, but overall it was a nice experience and taste pretty good. Service was quick and efficient. Interior is well designed, moderate noise.

My husband just came home with pastries from heaven! He got the cinnamon roll and this croissant…read moresquare thing that is absolutely incredible!!! This location was very calm and had quick service. It was pretty quiet and like a great spot to sit and enjoy your coffee and pastries.

I usually go to the UES location but I happened to be in the UWS area a few months ago and wanted…read moreto stop at By the Bakery to buy some baked goods for my friends since I love this bakery and want everyone to know how wonderful it is! I got two bags of their almond cookies and four of their cupcakes: two black and white cupcakes (chocolate cupcake with white frosting) and two of the "M" cupcakes (vanilla cupcake with chocolate frosting). This was my second time having their almond cookies and it was still delicious and not too sweet! I also had their "M" cupcake before so this time, I tried their black and white cupcake. It was okay, a tad bit bitter for me and reminded me of an oreo, I wouldn't get it again but that's just my preference. My friends who have tried their black and white cupcakes loved it though. Their "M" cupcake still remains the superior cupcake flavor and just overall my number one item from this bakery! Both locations seem to be consistent in their products, however, two things I noticed different in terms of this location was that I couldn't just enter the bakery, you need to wait for the employee to ring you in. And they also packaged the almond cookie bags kind of fancy, they wrapped it with a ribbon and attached their logo on the bag. I thought it was a cute touch :)

The gf and dairy free options are great but staff need more training. I told the person at counter…read moreof my wheat and dairy allergies. I asked for gf lox bagel w/ vegan cream cheese. I was a bit confused as to why gluten free and dairy free baked goods were so near each other on the display. I asked for a donut that was not dairy free and was not able to exchange it when I realized it had dairy. Not a big deal however better signs would help out. Also it's great that staff is polite but a smile wouldn't hurt.

My cake was beautiful and delicious I recommend using bake…read morestreet. I picked the cake up in Queens with minimal contact. I paid online.

WARNING! CAKE was AWFUL! FELL APART!…read more I ordered a cake from a professional baker (Soma cakes) a few years ago that was beautifully made but was a bit bland, so I decided to look for a different baker. I found BakeStreet online, and I chose a baker, only to find out these are not "professional" bakers but HOME BAKERS! I didn't realize they employ home bakers until I asked my baker for the address. The NYC address they use for their business is NOT a real bakery! I thought these were professional bakers working out of a bakery. I found this part to be very misleading and only found out after I selected my baker and paid a deposit. My baker was 30 minutes from the city by car. I had made a deposit, and even though my intuition told me to back out, I decided to take a chance based on her reviews. I'm really curious if the reviews for the bakers are from real customers. Makes you wonder. You have to realize these cakes are being made in their homes! There are no sanitary rules that you know are being observed. My cake was placed in a cardboard box, and although it didn't really look like what I wanted, and the tassel, lettering, and diploma looked amateurish, what can a customer do after they paid for the cake and need it for a special occasion. Seriously, this is a great way to get ripped off! Once we got home and took the cake out of the box, it was falling apart, and the company had the nerve to tell us it was made properly! This cake was worth $100 maybe $150 but NOT almost $400. A cake that is baked properly will not fall apart after a 15 minute car ride! At the time that I picked up the cake, I told her I could hold it in my lap, but she said it wasn't necessary and placed the cake in the car. My Soma Cake that lasted an hour in the car to a different location never fell apart! The company had the nerve to offer me a $50 credit for a future cake that I would NEVER purchase! Why would I purchase another cake from a home baker? Poor customer service! They can enjoy my money! What a RIP-OFF! If a cake cannot make it in 15 minutes from pick-up to your location, there is something wrong with the cake! If you want to have a cake beautifully made, use Soma Cakes but don't get the red velvet. She is very talented. Her cake looked so realistic and we received a lot of compliments, but unfortunately it was bland, but it was a lot cheaper than what this company charged me, or you can just make your own cake. I'm sure it will be better than the disaster I received! Also, PLEASE do your research on this company. They have bad reviews on TrustPilot! If you want an okay cake, order from here. If you want a cake for a really special occasion, please go somewhere else. Find a place with an actual bakery and professional bakers. You will pay the same amount but get better results and not have to deal with their awful customer service!

Stopped in to get some cookies for a party I was heading to. They have a large selection. 1 lb of…read morecookies was $28 which is a little overpriced but I was in a time crunch. Staff were helpful and friendly. They have a lot of seating inside if you would like to enjoy your pastries there before heading out.

Decent cupcakes with a lot of different selections. I liked the cupcakes and cake from…read moreHere. It's a decent bakery that will make for great gifts

Got a last minute custom apple cider cake with cream cheese frosting. Turned out beautifully and…read morewas absolutely delicious. Actually got better each day after.

This place has the greatest chocolate chip cookie on the entire planet. I cannot overstate the…read morelevel of perfection. Texture is what you dream about - not necessarily crunchy on the outside but it's like the perfect combination between the crisp (NOT crispy, I mean crisp) / chewy bite that is the perfect amount of carmelization. Then the inside is that incredible, soft bite on top and throughout, with that slightly crisp bottom that melds right into the chewiness of the center of the cookie. Perfect balance of dough and chocolate. Finished with a beautiful sprinkle of sea salt on top that actually stays on the cookie and is present in every bite. I have no idea how this cookie hasn't gone viral yet - it is better than every chocolate chip cookie I have had in NYC. Perfect cookie.