Smitty's Overtime Inn

Double review. P'Zones has a great buffet for lunch. Soup, Salad, & Pizza on the buffet with a…read moredesert pizza. And we came back to watch football at the bowling alley... also fantastic. My group had a calzone, double decker club, pizza, 8 appetizers. All were super good. I will jump over and also do a review of the Strike Zone bowling alley. Fun place

We stopped in intending to order the pizza, soup and salad bar but our visit happened to be at a…read morelull, so we ordered our own pizza and I did ask for one trip to the salad bar. The best part of our visit was our server, Odin. He was attentive, without being smothering. The salad bar was really fresh and plentiful. We liked the crispy crust on the pizza, but we thought the sauce was pretty bland so we had to add parmesan and red pepper flakes to try to jazz it up (italian seasoning would have been appreciated if they aren't going to give pizza sauce options like they do for crust).

(Sorry) Pizza after we tore into it.

A tiny sample of what the salad bar has to offer.

See all

Uptown Pizza Tomah

3.4(41 reviews)

6.6 mi

Called in an order for pickup to bring over to my grandparent's house for a suprise pizza party…read more I ordered a 16" thin crust w/alfredo sauce and spinach and tomatoes for my vegetarian grandma, a 16" regular crust w/pepperoni and Italian sausage for my Grandpa, an an order of cheesy garlic bread. Picked it up about an hour later and the resturant was poppin'! Several cars in the small lot out front, some patrons inside, staff making the pizza left and right... it seemed like the place to be! It was warm inside, due the pizza ovens working like crazy and lack of air conditioning. But the staff was very friendly and got our order out right away. We brought eveything over to my grandparents and it was indeed a wonderful surprise!! There were 5 pieces of cheesy garlic bread and 2 ramikins of marinara included in the regular order. There was just the right amount of cheese to satisfy your typical Wisconsinite and the bread was seasoned and baked perfectly! The marinara was hearty and also seasoned perfectly. Pizza: YES YES YES! The thin crust was amazing, it had great flavor and was still a little chewy. The alfredo sauce was not bland at all! The tomatoes seemed grilled/toasted and both tomatoes and spinach tasted fresh. The regular crust meat pizza was also 100%. Again, great crust and fresh ingredients. The love and passion that went into our meal was apparent :) I definitely recommend Uptown to any local or visitor. We were very impressed by the quality and quantity of the food we received. My grandparents will be ordering from Uptown in the future and I will also be stopping by when I'm visiting :)

Uptown pizza was tasty. The service was friendly and speedy and the place was clean and quiet. I…read morecant give it the full five stars until I try it again ( I got an upset stomach immediately after leaving so I need to try it again to make sure it wasn't just a coincidence) , but if you're ever in Tomah check them out!

Uptown Deluxe

See all

Uptown Deluxe

Sportsman's Bar

5.0(2 reviews)

7.1 mi

Hi Lo has a good menu. I highly recommend the chili nachos supreme. The bar has great character,…read morethe patrons are friendly, and Hi Lo Serves a good drink with a warmth not found in many of the other bars in Tomah. This place is what CHEERS was trying to be........Dick L.

The food is great, we really liked the burgers and pizza. Service was awesome, the bartender kept…read moreus entertained.

Murray's On Main

3.3(75 reviews)

6.9 mi

Our food was excellent. My wife and I each had a Ruban sandwich. I had a bowl of chili and my wife…read morehad a bowl of potato soup. Again, both excellent. The menu lists several excellent and varied options. The waitress was courteous and efficient. My only complaint is the beer selection was very limited. I know the average American beer drinker thinks Bud Lite, Bush Lite, Cours Lite and Michelob Ultra are great. Sad when there are so many real beers and so many breweries in Wisconsin!

The service was excellent and the gluten free cod was very good (but overpriced)…read more We also had the tenderloin tips, they were okay and extremely overpriced based on the portion size. The salad bar was depressing- end of life salad (starting to turn brown) and the soup had separated in the pot and even with mixing, was not coming back together. On the good side the dining room atmosphere is nice and was clean.

Teeny bits of lobster and not stuffed shrimp

Lobster stuffed shrimp

See all

Triple Decker BLT

Pizza Hut

3.2(20 reviews)

5.3 mi

This place is not the old Pizza Hut. I stayed away for a few years but now it is the best pizza…read moreplace in Tomah! Great service and the cheese bread is now cheesier than ever before!

This pizza hut goes above and beyond and is super friendly. I placed my order via online and upon…read morearrival as noted my normal was ready and hot. Upon entering is promptly greeted. I additionally was able to receive plates, napkins, Parmesan and red pepper flakes. Upon getting to my hotel my order was accurate super hot still and filled with the new chicken sausage which is amazing. They weren't skippy on toppings and I'd highly recommend the chicken sausage. This was by far one of the best Pizza Hut experiences I've had recently and I'd highly recommend them. PS they have a drive up option too.

See all

Laughing Larry's Lunch Room

4.4(118 reviews)

6.5 mi

Food is good service is good. There is nothing fancy about this place The ambiance is quirky…read morealmost funny. If you want fancy this any your place Just a bunch of truck drivers stories and maybe a few lies and laughing. They never make my wife feel uncomfortable When ever in in the area we try to stop by and Larry seems to remember us

Went here with the wife for breakfast. Service was good, waitress and cook were super friendly!…read moreMenu was super cheap and gave more portions than advertised which is a huge plus, but the dinner is situated between two wash bays and the smell was absolutely disgusting. I couldn't hardly stand to eat while smelling such a fowl smell. Cool concept, but needs better ventilation to not smell so terrible. Cannot recommend at this time on that alone unfortunately.

More Ambiance

Denver omelette!

See all

Old time pictures and history.

Papa Murphy's

3.2(5 reviews)

5.3 mi

I placed my online order at 7:30 am for a 2pm pick up. At 2:45 they were just starting them. I had…read moreto stand and wait while they made 4 family size pizzas. I was incredibly disappointed. NEVER happened before and we order often!

So much bad in such a short time! Ordered on line. I paid and asked to have put on my rewards…read more The girl stated I must tell her that before the sale. Of course I asked why, she says that's the way it is, and most people know this! I said cancel order and we'll start again, She says that can't be done. I held my frustration, especially since I already had given a tip using a credit card. As I waited, another person in to order something with lettuce, which her reply was that they were out of lettuce. Really? While waiting, I also noticed that as the pizza is waiting to be completed, the order paper sits atop the pizza. Pick up was for 11:45, I left at 12:05. Finally, I believe the girl was offended that I was unhappy, never have I got a pizza with so little toppings. This place needs help, or an experienced manager!!!

Taphouse Twenty

2.8(60 reviews)

5.4 mi

My family is in town for a military event and this restaurant was conveniently located near our…read morehotel. That's where the good kinda stops. Kids shared a pizza and side of fries. The pizza was thin crust and kids gave it 3/5. It was filling but nothing extraordinary. The side of fries could fit in my teen son's hand. Disappointing! I had the buffalo chicken wrap. I couldn't finish it, barely begin. It was served ice cold. Sauce was oozing everywhere which may have been fine if the food was warm. Only positive, beer was cold and a good selection. I would not return and certainly not recommend.

I stopped here every time on the way to Minnesota to charge mu car and it's a decent place to eat…read morewith good service

Chocolate milk shake

See all

Full pound of wings, spicy honey and sweet chili

The Pines

4.5(20 reviews)

7.8 mi

Right off the highway, Giant German Pretzel was delish!! Food was excellent, ambiance is perfect.read more

Food was fantastic. Portions were large and the salad bar was great. Brandy ole fashioned sweet…read morewas great. Salad bar was tasty. No pic of the Philly and patty Melt. They were yummy!

Salad dressing

See all

Casey's

1.9(9 reviews)

6.3 mi

I placed the order over the phone for a large sausage green pepper mushroom and tomato pizza. They…read moresaid it would be 50 minutes. When I arrived they indicated that they have no record of any order being placed for either my name or my phone number. They also stated that they're out of tomatoes. It would be nice if they would inform you of such at the time of ordering. They apologized and are putting a pizza together while I wait. If I order from here again I'm going to demand a confirmation number.

Just went and bought diesel. The pump started churning at about $10. I had put $15 in. It started…read moreto give me air. I went into complain they told me they didn't know that it was happening. They are pretty careless about their customers. Casey's is screwing people over every few dollars at the gas station.

See all

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

3 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Eric D.

9 years ago

I don't know why I keep trying this place, I guess it's because of a lack of options. So this time I ordered the salmon, menu says comes with rice and asparagus, waitress says the asparagus is extra?? not sure how that works....Anyways I think I am done with this place, the ground round sucks but at least what is listed on the menu is what you get. read more

Angelina B.

594

10 years ago

I love this place. I just moved to the area. Great friendly staff. Plus the food us great. Not just bar food. They have everything you need. Plus the place is clean. But I highly recommend it. Can't wait to go back again for steak dinner. read more

Rebecca T.

13 years ago

Great place for steaks- come early (or there could be a wait). It's very casual and a bit out of the way, but the food and service are good. If you're looking for a break from chain restaurants, try Smitty's. read more

Smitty's Overtime Inn - bars - Updated October 2026

People who viewed Smitty's Overtime Inn also viewed

The Break Room Sports Bar & Grill

3.7

(102 reviews)

Idk about Amy because she wasn't working when we stopped but Brandy has the best attitude! Food…read morewas amazing and great service! Will definitely stop again next time I'm near Tomah!

Food took a long time, fries were room temp not enough pickles to cover burger all in all not…read moresatisfied.

Re-Pete's Saloon & Grill

4.4

(99 reviews)

Fantastic food as always!! Great bartender/server in Jason. Fast efficient and darn good food.read more

Great food & service. We stop whenever we're in town & it's great when we're riding on the local…read moreUTV trails. Also love that they have a gluten free menu!

T.K.'s 400 Club

3.8

(22 reviews)

Clearly a local favorite. We were there in the middle of the afternoon and bar was full of people…read morehaving fun. A group of UTV riders came in and elevated the already happy mood. Everyone was having a good time. Our waitress, Sara, was very attentive and quite friendly. I ordered the BLT but asked if I could have it on 2 pieces of white toast rather than the 3 pieces of Texas toast they advertised. It was perfect! Fries were some of the best I have ever had. My husband had a mushroom Swiss burger. It looked large and yummy! He agreed!! To top off this meal they had Yuengling Lager on tap!! We will stop in again next time we drive up to Minnesota.

Always delicious! Burgers are big and done perfectly! Lots of UTV traffic. People having fun!!read more

Evergreens Supper Club

3.4

(41 reviews)

Great experience, went here with my parents and family and we were greeted as we walked in and…read morepromptly seated. Most of us had the Friday fish ($8.95 acye with salad bar) My wife ordered the chicken and youngest son ordered the blt. Food came quickly and the fish pieces were decent sized although the fryer oil could have used a change. Blt was a good size for a 9 year old but maybe a tad small for an adult. Wife's chicken was cooked through and done. For dessert I ordered the grasshopper and my wife and daughter got pie slices, you can't go wrong on any of those choices! Those were a 10 star! Waitstaff took care of us and checked on us several times. A gratuity is added to all parties seven people or larger so fyi. The place is pretty rustic and in the woods, but then that's the experience I guess, they had a hummingbird feeder up and there was things of birds feeding off it. For those that snowmobile the trail comes right nearby and the owner is a big supporter.

Planned on dinner at the Evergreen. Went on-line and chose the dinner I wanted - see attached…read morephoto. I showed the picture to the waitress, and she asked if I wanted the scallops and I said of course, just like the picture. The steak was not $26.99 as shown on the site. It was tough to say the least and a little over-cooked, never had a NY strip like that before. Instead of the 6 scallops as shown in the picture on their site, I received 3 scallops and was charged $15 for them. The owner said, "JFK Jr. wants us to eat roadkill and walked away." I paid my bill, left a nice tip as it wasn't the waitress's fault and then I walked away too. They have lost 2 customers and any future recommendations.

Laughing Larry's Lunch Room

4.4

(118 reviews)

HWY 71 Taphouse & Eatery

4.3

(4 reviews)

We were looking for a place for Friday night fish fry. We came here and are very glad we did. My…read morewife kept saying how good her cod was and the walleye I had was some of the best I have eaten in the Monroe county area! It's an older building so the ambiance is not that great, but the food made up for it. I went there for a fish fry not to look at the building and I receive a very good fish fry.

Service was good. The prime rib was ok but most of it was over done and there was a huge chunk of…read moregristle / fat that was a significant amount of the piece. The mashed potatoes were very dry.

Crow Bar

3.4

(7 reviews)

I originally didn't even know this bar was there. I'd like to start with the Crow Bar is…read moreawesome--great food, great drinks, and the service was spot on. Friendly staff that make you feel welcome especially if you are out of town. Definitely will come back if i'm in town again!

Legit little dive bar in Tomah. They have a few slot machines and a pool table. Our bartender was…read morevery attentive considering the amount of people that were there. Seems like a lot of locals come to this place. Although they do sell food items, I didn't get a chance to try any but I heard their burgers are food. I'll have to try and come back.

Backwater Bar & Grill

5.0

(3 reviews)

This place is an absolute classic dive bar. If you are looking for pull tabs, cold beer and frozen…read morepizzas this is the place for you!

Great fish Fry, awesome reuban's and nice staff. Great log cabin atmosphere with bottled…read moreLeinenkugels Original! Winner!!!!

Brenda's Bar & Grill

5.0

(3 reviews)

Great food and service Serves the locals very well…read more Small and quaint but serves its customers very well.

Great little bar with a fun little menu. We stopped in for a couple of drinks and appetizers and it…read morehit the spot! Would love to go back and try their fish fry! Staff was super friendly also!

Pine Cove Bar & Grill

3.5

(18 reviews)