Tried this place on a Tuesday night when our favorite local pizza place was closed. Three XL pizzas fed 6 teenagers and 2 adults with about half a pizza leftover. The Sir Nicks specialty pizza was fantastic. The other 2 were a sausage and a pepperoni. The single topping pizzas were good, not great. The pizzas were ordered for pickup and the gentleman on the phone was nice enough... during the call, he made sure I understood what location I was calling at least 3 times. Maybe one time for each pizza? Either way, the pizzas were ready in a half hour, as promised. Seen on the menu that an XL pizza is $22. The toppings must be obnoxiously expensive as my 3 pizzas came out to a total bill of $110. Shame on me for not keeping the receipt. Would definitely get that Specialty pizza again if I didn't think that was the wallet buster. I'm certain it was. read more

Great Pizza Best in Bartlett. The Problem I go to lesser pizza places because they have coupons and I save money instead of always paying full price for a large pizza which is almost 30.00 at Sir Nicks. Too expensive. I was a fan but not anymore because they are gouging people with full price and no coupons. When they give deals and coupons my large family will support them again. They are losing 20 pizzas a month from my family. read more

I had a big order for a party, and they came through. The pizza was really good, and it was ready on time as promised.

Overpriced unless you get the slice or specials, I ordered the medium pizza and it ended up being about $24 but you can order the slices or the lunch specials and it's gonna be a lot better deal read more

I came here looking for a quick "snack" as it was later at night and I just wanted something quick and easy. I knew they were here for a long time and I never been this location before but I pass by all the time. The price for a slice of pizza and a drink was standard but the pizza was great. I really didnt look at the menu besides looking for a quick slice of pizza and a drink to be honest. But still great pizza. read more

You can't beat the prices and the pizza is great, thick crust, and very filling. Customer service needs a little help.

Pizza was good but the man upfront could be a bit more respectful. I would come back to get more

Wow just wow. Rosati's was closed as was most other pizza places at ten. See the photo. Every inch of pizza was covered in cheese, meat and vegies and all high quality. Absolutely stupendous way better than the other pizza places around us. From now on this is our pizza go to. They did not scrip on anything. Tons of fresh good quality stuff. 5 Stars easily. read more

SIR Nick's Pizza - Sir Nicks loaded pizza best I have ever had - Pizza Near Me - Bartlett, Illinois

I can't remember the last time I had Sir Nicks pizza, but let me tell you. Their pizza slices are amazing and delicious! The man at the counter told me they were out of pepperoni and cheese slices, but within a matter of minutes, fresh pizzas came out! You'll definitely won't have pizza that has been sitting out! Highly recommend for great service and great pizza! read more

Great pizza in Bartlett. I have been coming here for 15 years and I love the pizza so much. I order over the phone and its always ready within 20 minutes. I love sir nicks pizza. Best pizza in my area read more

Pizza was so good, and the garlic bread was fire too. The front counter guy had great customer service. The chef made the pizza fast and fresh. Great chill vibe inside.Definitely gonna be my go to spot moving forward! read more

I order from here alot and i ordered cheeseburgers for my daughter and i, after about and hour and a half i called to find out what happened, they called the wrong number and had the wrong name, it was messed up because at 9:45 central, we had no dinner and now im stuck in a 7-10 day refund, what pissed me off was there was nothing done or offered, i mentioned that food is cold and they would have to cook and deliver it a 2nd time and to just give me the refund, but i just feel like there should have been some effort to appease the situation other than sorry i can have my manager refund it when they get a chance, read more

Of the many great places to get pizza in Bartlett, Sir Nick's is the greatest! Their family trays are great for those nights you just don't want to cook, too. Sandwiches are great to have while watching the game, too. I wish that they would make online ordering available again. I have become accustomed to not having to talk to people. read more

Rando stop in for lunch on the go. Took maybe 5-7 minutes for anyone to appear at the counter to take an order, when he did show up there was a single slice in the display heat box thing and I asked if he had any more pizzas coming out. He said not that's it for the day. I said ok and ordered that crusty slice and something else fried that was going to take 10 minutes to make. When I came back, magically there was 1 new pizza in the box and another being loaded in! My other item was sitting on the counter behind the register, dude was in no hurry just sort of took his time and eventually reached over and got it and served the slice. Idk what's happened but businesses have just seemed to remove any sense of customer service now. Btw food was a 4/10 tops. read more

Not bad at all. A jumbo slice of sausge pizza with a drink for $4. Sir Nick's gets total brownie points for having Valentina Hot Sauce on deck for my slice. If I happen to be in the area since this is way out of the way from where I live, I would definitely stop in again. Friendly counter staff and a clean eating area. I was pleased with my order and experience. read more

SIR Nick's Pizza - Pizza By the Slice (Sausage) with Drink - Pizza Near Me - Bartlett, Illinois

I've ordered before.. so it was very cool this evening.. I ordered. Hung up.. added grilled onion/ green pepper. What did I get ?? Awesomeness... Sandwich weighed about 2# before I took the picture Why can't i post this picture ?? After it was delivered..I called right back & said it was ¡ Muy Pinche Bueno !... And got dead silence. Doesn't understand Spanish. Or a Compliment. And I'm still pissed i can't load a picture for you to see.. read more

This is good quality pizza and closer than Lou Malnatis. The fries are amazing too. Can't wait to order more pizza.

One of the best cheesy beefs I've ever had. I had the Cheef which is a cheesy beef on garlic bread. Amazing taste, tender beef and perfect bread. read more

So far this is the only pizza place (besides Giordano's) in the area that we like. We got an XL thin crust cheese, with two orders of the curly fries. Our order was delivered within a half hour of ordering. We'll be ordering from here again. read more

SIR Nick's Pizza - a plate of pizza and onion rings - Pizza Near Me - Bartlett, Illinois

I get wings here and they're consistently good quality. Not overly breaded like most places have. Good Buffalo sauce. Hard to find decent wings like this. I approve. read more

This restaurant is horrible,my friend ordered wings and it was 8 dollars for like 5 wings and they were smaller than an atom. Fix your service. Also they never have cheese pizza. My friend also didn't even get his sause that he asked for. Also the pizza is dryer than my dryer. Fix your restaurant. Thank you Karen Smith read more

Sir Nick's is our family's go to place for takeout. The service and food are awesome and there is something for everyone on the menu from pizza to salads to cheese fries and hot dogs! read more

Quick and easy! Very tasty pizza! Picked this up and ate it at my friend's place in Bartlett. Cheese is fresh, and the thin crust contains just the right amount of sauce. Looking forward to trying their deep dish in the future! read more

One of the better pizza joints in the area. They have other options on the menu too. Give them a try, not a bad pie.

The Ribs are the Best! We also ordered the pizza! Very good.We have been ordering from this location for many years since my kids were little. read more

Great greek salad and amazing pizza. Very clean, kind workers and fast. One of my favorite local pizza places!

By my parent's house in North Hoffman, the pickins are pretty slim by way of good food fast. There is a Subway and, ummmm, that's about it. So when they got a Sir Nick's off of Palatine Road when I was about 14, that was pretty darn exciting!! ALMOST as excited as I was to find out via Grubhub that there was one within delivery distance of my new house. SCORE FOR ME. They are pretty consistent between the two restaurants based on what I have ordered, and that's a good thing. They were consistently delicious!! This particular time, I ordered a gyro w/ extra sauce, chicken noodle soup, and curly fries. My husband ordered a meat lovers pizza, which I stole a slice of and enjoyed immensely! As for their soup--YUM! The next time I am sick, I am going to remember Sir Nick's and their Chicken Noodle Soup. This stuff is homemade, and it really soothes the soul! Delicious! My gyro was chocked full of thick-cut meat and the sauce is amazing. Very flavorful. Plus, on the gyro, there are diced tomatoes rather than two large slices that I have had in the past. This was really good and helped to ensure a tomato in each bite!! The fries are pretty solid. I really enjoy a curly fry, so this was right up my alley! I will definitely be trying more and more as time goes on! And my husband already wants more for tonight. Who am I to argue?! ;) read more

See all

I've been a loyal customer here for over 15 years. The food has always been good and plentiful. Tonight, my opinion changed, and not for the better. We ordered a big order and I got a gyro. In the past, their gyro was always stuffed with meat to the point where it wasn't even foldable. You'd need to eat a bunch of meat before even attempting to pick it up. Tonight's sandwich was laughable. There was literally 8 or 9 slices of meat on it. I actually laughed out loud at the amount of meat. Calling places like this to complain does no good. First, they give you a canned apology that they don't mean, then they offer to bring you another sandwich that they probably spit on. The driver is surly because he's not getting two tips from you and he probably spits on it too. Thanks, Sir Nick's. This is the last time I order from you. Nobody likes cheap business practices where rooking the customer is par for the course. read more

Best go to slice in town. I had a pie last night and hit the spot, with just enough crunch and great sauce. Very clean, bathrooms could have been cleaner. read more

Amazing customer service. Great pizza. Got one of their specialty pizza and it was absolutely delicious. Highly recommend it. read more

SIR Nick's Pizza - I smell deliciousness. Amazing customer service. - Pizza Near Me - Bartlett, Illinois

This is my favorite quick grab pizza place! It is awesome and very clean! My first observation always. & not only having a choice of pizza but many more sides/meals/appetizers. The staff there is always nice, and quick service. Their pizza is always so fresh and warm fulfilling! read more

This is my FAVORITE spot for pizza. I especially LOVE the crust. it tastes soooo good! If you are looking for a place to get a pizza slice to go, sir nicks is the place! read more

Great staff, fast service, amazing food and pizza is excellent and very reasonably priced. Top notch spot

Best pizza but the wings you can taste the whole freezer on each and every one of those wings/ horrible

Ordered slice of pizza don't know how long it was sitting there but it upset my stomach and ended getting diarrhea. So basically I just ended shitting out my money! read more

Ive tried this place a few times. Unfortunately for them, there's way better pizza for way cheaper. I'd say it was less than mediocre :/ And super expensive. read more

Shout out to Sir Nick's! You guys came through in a hurry! When another local pizza shop failed you guys stepped in and made it happen! Thank you thank you thank you! read more

Great thin crust pizza. Good flavor and the crust is very crunchy!! Great place for apps!!

Had a hotdog with everything on it and the bun was super stale, and there was sliced red onion vs diced which I found odd. Would recommend trying something other than a hotdog. read more

Sir Nick's has consistently been a great place for pizza and sandwiches, and there is unquestionably something for everyone on the menu. Their slices are a great value (i.e., huge and filling) and are representative of their double dough pizza. If you are not a fan of double dough pizza, please know that they also make a delicious thin crust pizza (and nice pan and stuffed pizzas). Although Bartlett has some tough competition in the pizzeria market, Sir Nick's always stands out as a great option. The one particularly unique pizza offering that they have is the Gyros pizza, which is absolutely delicious on a thin crust or double dough pizza. For sandwiches, the Italian Beef, Gyros, and Maxwell Polish all offer great value for the money, but I would recommend getting The Chief grinder sandwich -- Italian Beef and broiled cheese on toasted garlic French bread -- if you want something really special for lunch (or dinner). The owners of this Sir Nick's location are always very nice, and they definitely deserve your business! read more