Absolutely wonderful food! Great place for date night! Very classy feel. Appetizers were on point…read more Steaks were mouthwatering. Dessert was delicious! Drinks were perfect. We highly recommend

Service was good, and our server was friendly and attentive. Unfortunately, the food didn't live up…read moreto the recommendation. I ordered the walleye, and it was very average--nothing memorable or worth the price. It felt like a run-of-the-mill dish that I could get at many other restaurants. The first thing we noticed when we walked in was a strong sewer/trap smell near the entrance, which wasn't the best first impression. While the odor didn't seem to carry throughout the entire restaurant, it was noticeable enough to stand out. The tap beer was also served much warmer than expected, which was disappointing for a steakhouse of this caliber. Overall, the service was the highlight of the evening, but the food, warm beer, and less-than-ideal first impression left us underwhelmed and feeling that the experience didn't justify the price.

Seriously, like stepping back in time to the days where you could go to your local steakhouse for a…read morephenomenal meal, friendly service, and a cozy home like atmosphere. Well, look no further. This no-frills steakhouse specializes in dry aged beef, is James Beard award winning, has great cocktails, and still serves you a relish tray while you wait for your meal. For those of you under the age of 35, a relish tray, often consisted of carrots, celery, pickles, and cubed cheddar cheese like this one. They also will bring you some bread and butter if you would like. In my opinion, you should definitely opt for the tenderloin, but I'm not sure there is a bad steak option on the menu. They also have seafood and even sandwich sandwiches including a burger so there's something for everyone! It's family friendly and although the decor will remind you of your grandma's house, no grandparent I have ever met could put out steaks like this. Visit the ice cream capital of the world and make sure to save room for a steak!

- House salad - delicious - Tenderloin (filet) - I would…read morehave loved a crust on it. Was cooked to the right temp but I'd order something other than beef next trip. - Waeside Old Fashioned - no thank you :) Overall, I'd go back to try it again and order different things, maybe some chicken. The service was lovely and the whole place is quirky / cool.

Big thumbs up for this establishment on my visits! I have…read moredined here on numerous occasions and they do what's necessary to keep me coming back (consistency in the kitchen and service). There's not a large menu for an obvious reason and that's to be sure you receive an excellent meal served by always attentive staff at a reasonable price. It's always worth the hour long round trip drive for me I'll be back for more

Waited in a line for 40 min, was only spoken to one time. Someone greeted us but after that…read morenothing, have seen people come and go and no one has filled us in on what's going on. Unprofessional.

I ate there tonight (8-17-19) with a friend. We were both impressed with the atmosphere, and wait…read morestaff. The food was good too. I ordered the onion rings, and pork belly appetizers. We both liked the onion rings, we got a small order and couldn't finish them, as the entrees came to our table sooner than expected. The pork belly appetizer was meaty and flavorful, though it was tough to cut even with a steak knife. It had a toothsome level of tenderness, it really needed to be cooked for a longer period of time at a lower temp. The fat still had an elastic stretch too it, which was kind of off putting. The pork belly was flavorful but would've tasted better with more of a smoke element to it. Our steaks, were delicious. I got the large cut Ribeye, he got the Sirloin. I struggled to finish mine, it's just that I got filled up with my salad, potato, pork belly, & onion rings first. It's a bit of a drive from Cherokee, Ia. a little over an hour, but worth the drive if you're looking for a new place to dine at. Nice decor, attentive wait staff, good food over all.

Excellent food, great service and always consistent! A small town venue with a robust menu. We…read morehave never been disappointed!!

Fast & friendly staff. The prime rib sandwich I had was wonderful. One in our party stated the…read moresirloin was a little tough but still a good steak, possibly due to being medium rare As for ambiance nice to be able to check on the football score & enjoy a beverage before getting our food.

This was really great! The steak was delicious, soup side tasty, and cheese balls are awesome…read more Cheap drinks here too.

Every trip to the Black Hills, we stop at Hartford Steak Co. always the best food and greatest…read moreservice of our trip. I highly recommend this out of the way hidden gem!

I was starved to death traveling jumped off the interstate and found this place. It's about three…read moremiles from i90 but well worth the trip. I was greeted quickly and sat immediately. Waitress was very friendly and efficient. Menu and hours are limited but what they do they do well. I had twelve ounce filet mignon. It was two 6 ounce filets but they were cooked perfectly. Came with a lettuce wedge, loaded potatoe and fresh bread. Quality was top notch. This is a local place and it's priced accordingly. $29 covered my entire meal. Decor was nice and the noise level was very acceptable.

We specifically traveled to the roadhouse with another couple this last Thursday (Ribs night). We…read morelove these small town gems and found everything about it to our liking. The service, food and atmosphere was top shelf with a wonderful small town vibe. Three of us ordered a full rack and one ordered a half-rack. Tender, fall off the bone with a mellow BBQ sauce that complimented the smokiness nicely. $3 draft beers sweetened the deal! We'll go back to sample other items on the everyday menu. Make a reservation for rib night so they know how many to make and not run short (which we understand happens often) and arrive early most any other night. Highly recommend this roadhouse!

Great steak and caprese. Brianna is great as is the chef. Never a bad meal for a little caferead more

This family run joint was tasty. I had the french dip, my husband and the brisket sandwich. We…read moregobbled it right up. Loved seeing the family there helping out pitching in, each person had a job. We were stopped over at Dakota Sunsets RV park and this was a perfect quick dinner.

Unfortunately this business was severely damaged in a storm May 11, 2022. It has been closed since…read morethen. I spoke to someone from the business and she confirmed they have not reopened. They are preparing lunch meals for delivery to senior citizens.

A nice place. Service was some of the best I've ever had. Food was solid, but not the best. I will…read moresay that I think it is as good as I expected it to be, but I always hope it'll be better thus I am not leaving a 5-star review. Fried pickles spears with the rock n roll sauce were great. I wouldn't have ordered these except my server recommended them out of all the apps, so I went with that. Fried things at places like this usually lack flavor and are just salty, fried bar food. These had some kick. The rock n roll sauce was like a Mayo with Frito's Chili Cheese Twists, so they were yummy. Tilapia on wild rice was ok, but it's tilapia, so how amazing can it be, right? Broccoli wasn't too over cooked and it still had a healthy green color, so I was happy with that. And the fries were a tad greasy, but they came out hot and crunchy. I think if they let the oil drain off them a bit more under a heat lamp, they'd hold their crispness a bit longer. Oh, and it was an entire plate of fries, so portions were generous. Lastly, everything was served very quickly. The place wasn't super-busy, but it wasn't dead and I was happy about the timeliness. I ordered an app first then placed an order for my entree after munching on that. And I was out done in 45 minutes. Granted, I was eating alone, but still. If you enjoy meat, I highly recommend giving this place a shot. I am a pescatarian (mostly vegetarian) and I have a sneaking suspicion that their beef and chicken options have much more developed flavors.

Great food great drinks, great owner, great service! Will be making it our "go to" place when…read morewe're in Sheldon!@

There tonight for the wings, all u can eat...lots of sauce but terrible wings, heard a lot about…read morewhimps....I'll try it again but if I'm eating wings I'll probably NOT EVER go back.... C'mon man Wooooo d-

Again a small tucked away place that has the best ribeyes…read more Great taste cooked right ( they know what rare means ) Salt and pepper is all you need with a good cut of meat and they have a great cut Cold beer doesn't hurt either