Birthday Girl loved her surprise cake! The taste was delicious and all the parameters were followed as expected! Best part no fondant! read more

Simply Caketastic - Sponge Bob Themed Cake! Big thank you! - Desserts Near Me - Marysville, Washington

Ordered a cake for son's 2nd birthday. Came out as the picture shown for what I was looking for. Lots of compliments on the cake, at the party. Will order from them again. read more

Simply Caketastic - a birthday cake with cartoon characters - Desserts Near Me - Marysville, Washington

Start of the design process about three weeks before I needed the cake for my son's 11th birthday. He's a huge friends fan, so I thought it would be cool to get him a custom cake. I let them know I wanted a boy's theme cake with more quotes from the guys than the gals. She knew I wanted the couch and the famous picture frame. What we got was handwritten quotes on edible backgrounds and a frame. The F.R.I.E.N.D.S wasn't even put on the cake like the examples I sent. I gave it two start because the cake itself tasted decently good read more

Simply Caketastic - What we got. It's cute but the top is so plain without the F.R.I.E.N.D.S - Desserts Near Me - Marysville, Washington

See all

Make great gluten free dairy free cupcakes and cakes! Yummy sugar cookies too! You need to order a head of time.

Cupcakes are on the slider size, need to step up and make them bigger for the price!!

This is the incredibly amazing cake they made for my birthday. It was delicious and impressive, and the filling and icing were frickin' perfect. This company has also been so amazing to work with. We had a snafu with our Mother's Day cake (our fault!!) and they were truly wonderful in getting it solved. We're gonna do more business with them in the future, for sure. read more

Simply Caketastic - Desserts Near Me - Marysville, Washington

Great service!! The bakery we had cancelled on us. They happily took our order at short notice without hesitation. We didn't have to compromise at all and it was $75 cheaper. read more

Simply Caketastic - Desserts Near Me - Marysville, Washington

See all

Time and time again I am thoroughly impressed with all the staff at this bakery. I go here for every cake I get now, and they have done an exceptional job every single time. The staff is all very friendly, thorough and precise. This is the latest cake I got (first pic is why I sent them, second pic a what I received!) and not only did it look AMAZING, it tasted amazing too. Thank you so much staff at simply caketastic for providing such a wonderful experience each and every time I visit! read more

See all

The cupcakes are to die. I even got a discount for 'day old'. Cupcakes stayed fresh a long time in the original box.

I went to these ladies with a vision of what I wanted for a birthday cake and boy oh boy did they deliver! It was as yummy as it looked! So delicious and so beautiful! You guys rock! I wish I could give you 500 Stars! read more

See all

Everything about this place was perfect. My fiancé and I needed a small cake for a simple engagement party. We walked in and were greeted like we were family. Super nice, helped us through the cake design process. Kept it simple for our cake. Vanilla with lemon curd filling and very clean looking. The finished product was absolutely stunning. Everyone loved it, and complimented on it. I could not be more happy with having our cake done here. read more

Simply Caketastic - Vanilla cake with lemon curd filling - Desserts Near Me - Marysville, Washington

We ordered a cake for a Gender Reveal and it was perfect! Not only was it adorable but it was so moist and delicious, I will definitely be a returning customer read more

Simply Caketastic - We ordered a cake for a gender reveal party and couldn't be more pleased. It was adorable and moist and delicious - Desserts Near Me - Marysville, Washington

I normally do all of my own baked goods, however, unable to do them myself this time I called here for a couple dozen cupcakes for a bridal shower. The staff were so pleasant, able to meet my needs and the cupcakes came out beautifully! They also tasted very good. I'm a baker myself so I'm super picky and these tasted and looked delicious. Wouldn't hesitate to use them again! read more

Our cake was perfection!!! It was everything we hoped for and then some! It turned out even better than the reference photo I sent, it was DELICIOUS, and Jessi was so helpful! I can't say enough good things! (First photo is reference, second is finished product) read more

Simply Caketastic - Reference photo - Desserts Near Me - Marysville, Washington

See all

Long overdue 5 star rating. I'm vegan and have rainbow hair. I wanted a unicorn cake for my birthday. She matched the mane to my hair! The cake was so delicious!! My co-workers devoured it, not even noticing it was vegan! I will be coming back for every family birthday now. read more

Simply Caketastic - Vegan Unicorn Cake - Desserts Near Me - Marysville, Washington

See all

Guys, boyfriends, husbands...need a Valentines gift that will make your lady gush, take a pic of it and brag to her friends how great you are while making her friends jealous on Facebook? Make this bakery your secret weapon! Also, on another note, These. Ladies. Can. Bake! I LOVE their edible art. Anytime I need a last minute birthday cake, or the oops-I-forgot-until-the-day-before-Valentine's treats for my wife, they ALWAYS come through and exceed any expectations, making me the hero at home. When I present their custom creations to my spouse for various occasions , she meets them with excitement and awe. The best part is the prices are really reasonable! I can't say enough positive things about the warm and friendly people who own and operate this small and mighty bakery. I will return again and again! read more

Simply Caketastic - Sailor Moon cake (backside) - Desserts Near Me - Marysville, Washington

See all

My son loved his Minecraft cupcake cake! They did an amazing job at decorating it and shaping it into the number "8". The taste was also incredible! They were very friendly and we also enjoyed some of their freshly baked cookies and cake pops that they also sell in their shop. Love the colorful decorations and everything was delicious! read more

See all

I got a birthday came custom made for a 2nd birthday party for my kid. The cake looked and tasted good, I got a lot of compliments. I placed my order a month in advance to make sure I gave enough notice. I would recommend. read more

Simply Caketastic - a ladybug themed cake - Desserts Near Me - Marysville, Washington

Super friendly. I knew exactly what I wanted and they made sure I got that. Not only was the cake beautiful it was delicious. I highly recommended worth every penny read more

See all

We LOVED our cake. The flavor combinations were just delicious, and the price was incredibly reasonable. We actually considered eating our top tier when we returned from our honeymoon instead of saving it! The owner's sister is a florist, and if you book the two together, you can get the sister discount. Very sweet people. I can't wait to have an excuse to order another cake from them! read more

Simply Caketastic - Desserts Near Me - Marysville, Washington

Hands down the best service we've ever had! I ordered 5 dozen cupcakes for my parents surprise 40th wedding anniversary, in the course of travel to the venue they were ruined. Simply Caketastic went above and beyond to help us out and get us replacement cupcakes in less than 24hrs, including delivery! The cupcakes tasted fantastic and the care they put into making sure everything went smoothly was spectacular. We learned 2 valuable lessons- no matter how safely you think you packed the cupcakes it probably wasn't enough and 2-Simply Caketastic has earned our business for life. read more

As a Yelp user I pay a lot attention to when reviews are posted because a lot can happen in between years. I reviewed this place back in 2012. After enjoying a lemon cake with lemon curd and lemon frosting I can tell you that 7 years later the cakes are just as moist and flavorful as ever. And you cannot beat the price or the customer service. read more

Simply Caketastic - Desserts Near Me - Marysville, Washington

The worst looking cake ever!! When we got home to look at it, I was extremely disappointed to say the least. I called them immediately but the worker said "the baker is gone for the day" even though I saw her working. I showed her photos of what I wanted and she took pics then said she can do it. The design is coming off and it was laid on top with a different color. See photos. She knew she messed up. I called 3 times but she won't take my calls. So I told them I will bring the cake back because I want a refund for this awful job. Safeway would have done a better job! What a waste of money. The cake is coming apart, doesn't have the bday hats, it has bad cursive writing, should have been printed, just bad design. If I had known it was going look this amateur, I would've made it myself. At least have the decency to own up to your mistake! This is my baby's first bday cake. You should be ashamed! read more

Simply Caketastic - Desserts Near Me - Marysville, Washington

See all

Can you tell which cupcake is gluten free? Because we know which they are but can't taste a difference. My husband eats gluten free and the kids and I don't have to, so when he saw she could make gluten free for the same price and timeframe as regular cupcakes, we knew we had to give it a shot. He actually surprised me with a trip to pick them up. Let's just say, I've never had a peach bourbon cupcake but I can't imagine it ever being better than the one I had today. Because i have zero self control I also tried the pink champagne cupcake that was amazing as well. Onto the gluten free: my husband called today and she was able to whip up his custom order of four different flavor gluten free cupcakes within a couple hours. He ordered a strawberry, a cookies and cream (one chocolate frosting, one white frosting) and one vanilla. This cupcake missed NOTHING. If you're craving a real cupcake, she can make them and you wouldn't know the difference! We will be forever customers from here on out! read more

Simply Caketastic - Yummmmm gluten free and traditional cupcakes. Can you tell which is which??? - Desserts Near Me - Marysville, Washington

I had Jessi do my cake for my daughters birthday party and it was amazing! The decoration was perfect and the cake itself was delicious. You cannot go wrong with Oreo or cookie dough mousse. I currently have her working on my wedding cake and I'm beyond excited to see it! The cake tasting was a simple process and delicious. Highly recommend her crew! read more

Simply Caketastic - Dinosaur Cake - Desserts Near Me - Marysville, Washington

Our request for my baby girl first Birthday cake was all granted!.. It was beautifully made, it matches our theme and the taste was delicious and very moist. The sweetness was perfect!.. read more

Simply Caketastic - Unicorn Birthday cake for my baby girl 1st Birthday!.. Taste delicious, moist and perfect sweetness!.. - Desserts Near Me - Marysville, Washington

See all

I adore this place. Always delicious and creative. I've used her for all my special moments. She nails it every time.

Just came home from here. Ordered treats from the window. The macarons were hard/crunchy. A huge disappointment in texture. Flavor was yummy but who wants a hard crunchy macaron? My daughters cupcakes tasted pretty stale. Both the frosting and the cupcake were hard. Not sure if the cooler they were in was just too cold or if they were old. The whole experience was a bummer. And I love bakeries. First time there but I won't be back. It's Christmas Eve so maybe they're overwhelmed...? I dunno. I wouldn't mind 2 free macarons and cupcakes to see if I could change my mind. read more

Loved my daughters 1st birthday cupcakes! Did it 3 days in advance and tasted great!! read more

Simply Caketastic - Desserts Near Me - Marysville, Washington

See all

They perfected my son's birthday cake. I sent them multiple birthdaY cake ideas and they told me they could came any of tthe examples but this one would be the best because of the details in it. They gave me bids on each cake so I could decide which one worked with my budget. They even told me where I could buy the Toy Story figurines. The cake was exactly lIke the sample I sent them and it taste amazing. It was tthe center piece of the birthday party and everybody was complimenting it. I would have paid double the price for this beautiful cake. read more

Simply Caketastic - Birthday Cake - Desserts Near Me - Marysville, Washington

TL:dr, the owner was rude and hurried us along and the cupcakes were no better than a grocery store. We were so excited to discover a cake shop in town and spent time on their website looking at all the gorgeous cupcakes and cookies. Our kid's birthdays were coming up and we wanted to let them get whatever flavor they wanted. We took the time to go try the flavors and that was where the fun ended. We walked into the tiny shop and it looked great. Crowded, but you could see the center of the shop was for watching them bake. Two ladies were there, a younger woman mixing what looked like frosting. The other lady was older and looked irritated. I said we wanted to try some and then order two dozen for two days away. From the moment I said that, we all felt like we were putting her out, we weren't welcomed or anything. They had only a few types of cupcakes ready to buy, none of the specialty ones they sell online. When we still put in our order, you could tell she was hurrying us along so we'd get out, even though we were the only people there. You'd think spending over $60 on 2 dozen cupcakes would buy you a smile. The lady making frosting was giving us sympathetic smiles and looked embarrassed by the owner's attitude. When we left my son commented on how that wasn't how he pictured it going. Yeah, same here. Our fun jaunt to a surprise little cake shop was uncomfortable, hurried, and unsatisfying. The cupcakes weren't any better. The frosting was falling off of all of them, some were dry and none of them were any better than what you could get at the grocery store for a fraction of the price. When we went and picked them up, a kind lady and her daughter were there and they were very welcoming and had our order ready to go. The 2 stars are for the lady making frosting and the kind lady and daughter who were there when we picked them up. I'd give the owner and the cupcakes zero stars. We won't be going back. read more

New bakery in a town w/ not a lot of bakery competition. I've been looking for a place to get a really nice, gourmet cupcake in Marysville... I don't have much selection to choose from in this town, so I went around to some of the grocery stores tried Haggens (they had a large cupcake, but was nothing special), and Safeway (smaller cupcake but icing was great), and then I tried this place... The owner was very nice and cheery, she had a plate of very small bite sized chocolate w/ white icing cupcakes as samples. I tired one, and they were good, but that flavor wasn't available to purchase that day. I scanned the display case, trying to figure out what cupcake I wanted to take home with me. A lot of her cupcakes seemed to be made with a "buttercream/ cream cheese" frosting combo. Honestly, as a cupcake/ cake fan, and a baker myself I can't even imagine mixing those two, and personally I cannot stand the taste of cream cheese icing so that left me with a "Chocolate Chip Cupcake (vanilla cake w/ choc chips & choc buttercream w/ choc chips on top), and my mom got a Lemon Cupcake to go. Each cupcake was $2.75 (+ tax), and seemed slightly smaller than even a regular size cupcake which was kinda disappointing for the hefty price -- but I wanted to try this new place out, and was hoping to me wowed & amazed by the cupcake. My Chocolate Chip Cupcake was OK. I had good flavor, was moist, the choc buttercream was good, fresh, but there was hardly any on the cupcake. I give it a B- because I love icing.My mom's Lemon Cupcake must have been good because she keeps saying how great the icing was. Makes me wish I was a lemon fan. Place is a cake shop. Just that. No coffee or tea or anything to drink. No where to sit. I'm guessing she's counting on just being a special order cake shop, the cupcakes are there so people can stop in and buy a few to take home? Not sure how any business could service on that, especially a new, unestablished business. This is not the type of place where you'd get a cupcake, a coffee, and sit with a friend to visit. Hours seem really short & inconsistent. I drive past this place often, and more than 2/3rds of the time its not open. I saw they had a booth at Marysville Strawberry Festival. On Friday I was at the Festival, it was 3pm and they were just then setting up their booth. Pretty sloppy & unprofessional in my book. All in all, I can't say I would go back when I get my cupcake cravings, but if they hit and I happen to be nearby, I might stop & give a second chance, although Safeway can better satisfy my cravings for less and they are just a couple of blocks away.... Really wish Caketastic's cupcakes were bigger (especially for the price), and had more icing, like Cupcake Royale in Seattle, Bite Me at the Everett Mall, Gigi's Cupcakes in Las Vegas, ect. read more

I Have been waiting for Marysville to have a decent bakery so I was exited to stop in and try this place. My first impression when I walked through the door was that it looked dirty and cluttered. Still I figured maybe it's like one of those divy breakfast places that has the best breakfasts ever! So I settled on a couple of cupcakes for our dessert (not much of a choice) and a cookie for me on the way home. The cookie wasn't much to look at, I can decorate better than that and I don't run a bakery. On top of the crude decoration the cookie tasted stale. As far as the cupcakes go, the actual cupcake itself was really good but the butter cream frosting wasn't that great (Butter cream is usually my favorite). The chocolate frosting was pretty good though. There is still 1/2 of each cupcake sitting on my kitchen counter and 2/3 of the cookie (my husband and I shared bites to try them). I don't know about you but still having 1/2 a cup cake on my counter almost 24 hours later speaks volumes in my house. Plus the $3.00 each cupcake was really steep for amount and quality. Did I mention that they really need to clean this place up :/ read more

My family and I went to Simply Caketastic for cake tasting for my sisters wedding. If there were more than 5 stars I easily give it to them! Jessi and her daughter were the sweetest! Not only personable and accommodating, but the cakes we tasted with filling and frosting was mouth watering amazing! Jessi was very thorough, up front and honest about pricing. We were amazed by all the different dessert items she offered as well. This family owned business is a hidden gem! She let us try her edible cookie dough.. the chocolate chip w Oreo.. I'm a huge chocolate chip fan and it truly did not disappoint! We will be going back there for years to come! Thank you girls for being so kind and so accommodating! read more

Great experience! All I did was email them with what I wanted for my baby shower and they replicated the picture EXACTLY. They even found real jewelry for the embellishments, since we were having a tea party-baby shower. Tons of flavors to choose from and the cake was delicious (: read more

Simply Caketastic - Baby Shower | Baby Bump Cake | Boy | 5/22/16 - Desserts Near Me - Marysville, Washington

See all

Some of the best cupcakes I have ever had, and they were vegan. I can imagine the regular ones. Definitely need to try this place.

Designed a super cute cake for my daughter and it was ready in 30 minutes ! My baby loved it!

I work at a nearby health clinic and wanted to treat the doctors and staff I work with to a really nice cake. It was spur of the moment so I just stopped in and bought the 2 cakes they had for sale in the case and I grabbed a couple of business cards because we are a cake loving bunch and I figured it would be good for this small business as well. I wish I had gone to Safeway. Both cakes were dry, and tasted like they had been in the case awhile. The roses on one of the cakes looked discolored and wilted, as one of my coworkers pointed out to all. Everyone was disappointed and both cakes went in the trash. read more

Ordered cake for my son, wasn't good at all. Specifically asked for it to be not sweet, it was really really sweet. My family didn't like it. read more

Terrible customer service, they make you feel like you are putting them out by placing an order. This was my second time going and I got the same service, I will never go back nor refer anyone to go there. read more