Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Simple Simon’s Pizza

    5.0 (2 reviews)
    Closed 11:00 am - 9:00 pm

    Order Simple Simon’s Pizza Takeout or Delivery

    Simple Simon’s Pizza Photos

    Business Info

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Simple Simon’s Pizza

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    4 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Great pizza. Was ready really fast. The staff was really nice! I would most definitely order from there again!

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - Simple Simon’s Pizza

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Pizza 174 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Pizza Hut

    Pizza Hut

    3.2
    (10 reviews)
    0.0 mi
    $

    Had to come WAY out of our way to finally experience one of these Pizza Hut Classic locations. And…read morebeing certified genXers, I've got far more heartfelt opinions than normal. But, the short of it is it's "classic status" is a nice extra, and while it's not really worth the distance we traveled (you don't wanna know how far, we're ridiculous) just to finally see one, it is worth coming a little extra distance, for what may otherwise seem like "just pizza." Obviously, it requires dining inside for the full experience. They have carry-out and a drive-thru, but the decor is made to replicate a location in the 70s/80s, and it's fairly effective. Sadly, this location doesn't have the red roof, but in fairness, even some of them in the day weren't either (hopefully they'll spring for it later). The interior is a lot nearer the full effect. The picnic tableclothes, the gorgeous stain glass light fixtures, the themed pictures, and red tumblers were all very nostalgic. The food itself was as good as any other typical location we've been in, generally. And the staff was nice, if a bit mystified why we came so far just for the "classic". This particular location is unusually large. It's actually a perfect square instead of the typical rectangular shape, because they've made room for a very large party enclosure. The only things this particular classic lacked that I would recommend is pitchers of beer on tap. THAT is a MAJOR nostalgic marker of actual Pizza Huts in the day. Another thing (that may actually exist, but we may have come at too slow of an hour) was the lack of table service. It was order at the counter and they brought to your table. I understand the ins & outs about that, but if we're talking classic, this was missing. In the day, they often had a counter to order, but only for carry-out, and designated wait seating (near the arcade). But dine in would seat and be brought menus, etc. Again, not a big deal at all, but authentic is authentic. What's funny is we have a great Pizza Hut location close to home we frequent that, while it's not officially "classic" has these two aspects in use. So, if I were to magically smoosh these two locations into one, I could make the total 70s/80s experience to a tee. Anyway, they had a contemporary arcade game "approximation", free to play, and fun, but (understandibly) not a true vintage game, and some retro tabletop activities to take to your table. One last petty thing I wish they had was some sort of souvenir-ish thing, like some stickers, or branded red tumblers to celebrate the visit. I know that's probably far more than the locals think anyone would care about, but I would have wanted something. Anyway, I plan to visit more of these classic locations and make comparisons, but this was a fun start and wife and I enjoyed coming, eating and taking a few Polaroids. Thanks!

    Literally drove out of our way for them to tell us the dining room is closed on Mondays. Not…read morementioned anywhere in their info.

    Photos
    Pizza Hut
    Pizza Hut
    Pizza Hut

    See all

    Nancy's On Main

    Nancy's On Main

    4.7
    (48 reviews)
    26.5 mi
    $$

    We enjoyed our first meal at Nancy's in Perkins. We had the "cheesy bites" which are basically a…read morechopped up small or medium pizza crust with cheeses and garlic plus dipping sauce. Nothing like what you are thinking from Pizza Hut, these were light and flavorful. The small was plenty for 2 people as an app. Yumm. My pasta Alfredo was ok. The sauce was fresh but thin and under seasoned. The lasagna with meat sauce was quite good. Unlike the Alfredo, this sauce was bursting with flavor. I dipped some cheesy bites in it.... Heaven. The layers of cheese and pasta were very good too. Very good meal. We will be back for more lasagna, for shore. We didn't try their pizza this trip, but it looked very good. Next time maybe. The layout was cozy and seasonally decorated. Very inviting. Hard wood seating was less inviting for my old a@@. The wait staff were young but professional. Great service with a team waiting approach. Nice to be in such good hands to enjoy a meal, plus we were sent home with a refill of our drinks. We don't get to stillwater much any more, but when we do, we will certainly zip over to Perkins for another good meal.

    Came in at 6pm on a Thursday night and the food took over an hour. We ordered one pizza and one…read moreorder of lasagna. I get that they are focused on quality, but that's ridiculous. Had such great reviews online it's a shame that the service is soooooo slow. The food finally arrived and it was good, but could not recommend because of the extraordinary wait to get it.

    Photos
    Nancy's On Main
    Nancy's On Main
    Nancy's On Main

    See all

    Old Magnolia Garage

    Old Magnolia Garage

    5.0
    (8 reviews)
    49.9 mi

    Awesome place to stop. They are always so kind and friendly. Have a great selection and have lots…read moreof local and made in Oklahoma selections. Plus the drive through is phenomenal! Their food and pizza is amazing too. Try their sandwiches fresh made and the salads are top notch!!

    Old Magnolia Garage is a cool name for this convenience store and gas station strategically located…read moreon Old 66. It is set up to serve the locals and capture Route 66 tourist business. Stocked with everything you would expect: sweet, savory salty snacks, soda, beer, fryer food, and a few Route 66 trinkets. Get there early in the day for their best and most famous offering, Arbuckle Fried Pies. Yes, those world famous crusty folded and fried pockets of fruit filled heaven. On an unwavering mission, we rounded the corner east bound on Route 66 late in the afternoon. Our destination in sight, the Old Magnolia Garage. In I go, straight to the big fried pie display case. I really wasn't expecting to find anything left at this time of the day, but there they were, two blackberry pies. Somehow, they survived the morning feeding frenzy. They were immediately adopted, along with a strawberry. Tomorrow's breakfast delight. Nope, not as good as if I had been there when they came from the fryer, but good just the same with a fresh cup of coffee the next morning. Get there early!

    Photos
    Fried Pies, Big Willies breakfast burritos (local favorite), tornado's and breakfast bars
    Fried Pies, Big Willies breakfast burritos (local favorite), tornado's and breakfast bars
    Now that is how to relax!
    Now that is how to relax!
    Old Magnolia Garage

    See all

    Simple Simon’s Pizza - pizza - Updated August 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...