Tried Sicilian Pizza recently via delivery and overall it was a good experience. The cheese pizza -- one of their best sellers -- was solid and enjoyable, though not quite the best I've ever had. We also ordered the vegetarian pizza and cheese sticks; both were tasty, but I did feel the salt level was a bit on the higher side for my preference. Overall, it's good pizza and worth trying if you're in the area. For me, it's more of an occasional order rather than an every-week go-to, but still a positive experience. read more

Service: really fast Price: not bad for Arlington Taste: it's not bad but I don't think it's truly 'NY' pizza read more

My coworker mentioned about this place and we were on a craving hunt. We ordered here to give it a try. We ordered the pick up special to start off and mozzarella sticks. Honestly this place was really good and my coworker agreed as well. This is killed our craving really well, the pizza was delightful, the sauce to the mozz sticks was yummy. The gentleman who greeted me was sweet. For a hole in the wall pizza place, this was a really good pizza and we are planning to order here again. :) read more

Sicilian Pizza - Mozzarella Cheese Sticks - Pizza Near Me - Arlington, Virginia

See all

Best pizza in DC! Ordered delivery and they were quick. Food was hot and they threw in a complimentary salad. You got to try the calzone! read more

I've never eaten here, just ordered delivery, but I love this place. It's my new go-to. The pizza is good and the prices are very reasonable, which is harder and harder to find. I'm picky -- I think big-chain pizzas are gross and literally can't bring myself to eat it. I'm really happy to have found this place for when I can't bring myself to cook. Delivery is fast, too. read more

Great pizza! The cheese that they use is my fav. Ordered delivery from here many times and it's always good.

Good pizza, always a good experience. We order from here at least twice a month. We always get a large Sicilian and it's the right amount for the family of 4 read more

While staying at the Marriott, we placed an online order. Ordering was simple. Delivery was left at the front desk in about 30 mins. Two larges fed 5 adults with plenty left over (which was just as good the next morning while on the road). read more

Sicilian Pizza - a pizza in a pizza box - Pizza Near Me - Arlington, Virginia

This place is a family favorite. Whenever my in-laws come from Texas, they make sure to order the carry out special. I feel like that is a testament in of itself. Sicilian Pizza also offers a lot more than pizza! They have homemade hummus, pastas, salads, etc. It is quite an extensive menu. All of the items we've had from have been very solid. This place isn't a sit-in type of establishment, but it's perfect for when you're craving pizza and want quick service at a decent price. Perfect food for a movie or game night. read more

I've left a review of this place before. My takeaway has always been that it's better than a chain. Nothing crazy good, but nothing bad at all. You get consistent quality and the prices are fair. What I love about this place is customization. I can ask for extra toppings or omit toppings and they always get it right. I will say, if you order delivery, it will take a looooong time. They are popular and busy. Pickup is the way to go unless you're on ordering at 7pm on a Saturday and getting it at 9pm (although miraculously the food is still nice and hot). I think I can understand some of the delivery complaints. Pickup is the way to go. As for staff friendliness, I find the staff ridiculously friendly. During the height of Covid they'd even put the food in my trunk. I love this place and have been ordering consistently for 5 years now. read more

See all

Great drunk pizza for price point. Very friendly staff and the wings are the best I've ever had from a pizza place

Food is generally fine. It is the website that needs some improvement. The form validation is not quite right...had a situation where I submitted with the wrong credit card expiration date, fixed and resubmitted to see same error persisting (something about a valid key). Also, on first submit, with credit card details, you have to press and hold to confirm you are not a bot...you do..and then you are redirected and asked to submit the form again. Between this and the website presentation, I can't help but think this was the work of an amateur. read more

This was okay. The wings were very good and we would go back just for that. The Sicilian pizza seems to be exactly the same as the regular pizza but it is a square. read more

I always forget to take a picture of my favorite Arlington Special to update this review because I'm so impatient and just start nom-nom-noming away. As I mentioned in my previous review the Arlington Special is my favorite here which is also a "bad" thing coz I can't commit to try anything else lol. What I will say is whenever I order the Arlington Special it is always consistent with yummy in my tummy flavors! Don't forget to ask for extra ranch because it just completes this meal. Can't wait to come back! read more

Love their pizza! Best in Arlington. Calzones amazing too. My kids don't want to order anywhere else. So much betterthe franchise Pizza places ! read more

Just the worst. One of those instances where you can't believe that you just exchanged your hard earned money for what's being passed off as restaurant quality food. I ventured out of my comfort zone and ordered delivery from here the other night: grilled cheese w a side of fries and a baked feta marinara. The grilled cheese- what was supposed to be provolone and mozzarella I can only imagine was Kraft singles. The single slice of tomato had barely any color on it. I'm not sure that the sandwich was toasted or grilled as the bread was not at all crispy/had no grill marks. Definitely no mayo on the outside of the bread and a frying pan to really crisp it up. Grilled cheese is probably my most favorite thing to eat in the whole world. This wasn't worth the calories. Fries- pretty good actually. Crispier than I like but the best part of the meal. Baked feta marinara-- not sure what I expected here but it was certainly not a tinfoil tub of warmed up 99 cent marinara sauce from Wegman's plus maybe a cubic inch of feta cheese mixed in. Oh, and enough rosemary seasoning to feed the state of Rhode Island. The bread on the side was actually kind of nice-- crust was off but the soft inside definitely passed for focaccia. Not sure if they used the same stuff for the sandwich because it was just blah. I'd go elsewhere. read more

See all

Tried Sicilian Pizza for the first time and I am very satisfied! I ordered delivery through Slice. The delivery was very quick... they said it would take an hour but the pizza came 30 mins early. I got the 2 Gourmet Pizza special for 19.99. I tried the Arlington Special and Buffalo Chicken. Both were hot and very tasty. Buffalo is not super spicy either. Will definitely be ordering from them again! read more

Sicilian Pizza - Buffalo Chicken - Pizza Near Me - Arlington, Virginia

See all

I tried to order last weekend by placing my order through their online portal. The time estimate for a no-contact delivery was 50 minutes. After 1.5 hours I called the restaurant to see if the order left and to double check if I would be alerted when the food arrived. The lady who was answering the phones picked up the first time and didn't say a word, she sat the phone down so I could hear her helping the patrons in the restaurant. The second call, someone answered and hung up. Third attempt, she answered and immediately says "please hold" and repeated what she did on my first attempt. After 2 hours I wrote to them through their online contact form requesting a refund, no one got back to me. When the delivery guy finally came 2 hrs and 20 minutes after my initial order I told him I requested a refund. I was more than willing to wait for the order of you were swamped, but poor customer service, I will not tolerate. Aside from my initial email, I left feedback. I waited a week to leave this review and find it appalling that no one from their management team reached out regarding my experience. Oh, and no refund!! read more

After a long day of moving and not eating anything since a few bites at breakfast, I decided I "deserved" pizza. I saw this place on GrubHub and since Sicilian pizza is my favorite type of pizza, I couldn't resist. I'll begin with a spoiler alert: this is not Sicilian pizza, unless I have for my whole life suffered a fundamental misunderstanding of what Sicilian pizza is. Google Images was on my side, though, in confirming that Sicilian pizza is the super thick kind, typically cut into squares. This pizza was a LITTLE thicker than regular pizza, but not "Sicilian" by any stretch of the imagination. That being said, I still liked it. My margherita pizza was delicious, actually. They used whole basil leaves to ensure you got the flavor, and it made a world of difference. Fries were also on point. Nice and crispy. Nothing is worse than bad fries. Overall, I'd order from here again, but they should maybe change their name. read more

Sicilian Pizza - margherita - Pizza Near Me - Arlington, Virginia

Local business with great customer service and good pizza at a very reasonable price. My go to spot for my finicky teenager .

I'm not sure they actually make Sicilian--style pizza... at least not the type that anyone who has lived in or grew up in the tri-state area remembers. I've ordered their Sicilian twice now, and both times what was delivered was the same bland attempt at a round, thin crust pizza - same as almost any other place in NoVA. It wasn't Neapolitan thin, just thin in comparison to what one would expect when ordering Sicilian-style pizza... which I didn't think was going to be such an issue when ordering from a place literally named "Sicilian Pizza". Gave them the benefit of the doubt the first time around, but after receiving the same thing this time around, again, not toatally convinced "Sicilian Pizza" actually sells Sicilian-style pizza. Only bumped this review up from 1 star to 2 because my wife thought the pizza we received - regardless of what we ordered - was "actually not that bad". read more

Great food fast service and good price. Would recommend to others without a doubt. Would definitely go again

My pizza is always fresh, delicious and ready quickly. I always order the margherita pizza. The staff is great too.

We've ordered from here before and loved it. This time was not the best. We ordered the Sicilian Pizza which is supposed to be square but it wasn't. Not that big of deal for us. The thing that sucked was instead of proscuitto they used country ham. It was terrible. It was soooo salty. There's a big difference between the two. The cheesy bread is delicious. The Arlington Pizza was awesome. They also have an option to build your own calzone with sauce options like pesto, alfredo and garlic sauce which we love. Just do yourself a favor and don't order anything with proscuitto unless you want salty country ham. read more

Sicilian Pizza - Sicilan Pizza with country ham instead of proscuitto. So salty. - Pizza Near Me - Arlington, Virginia

See all

Great little spot. Perfect size pizzas and they do not skimp on the toppings. love the free parking in back!

Received inappropriate note in delivery regarding not ordering again because 15% tip is not worth their business and the 5 min delivery drive. I've been ordering from here for years and have always tipped appropriately. I would think that during these difficult times any business would be valued. Even if the order is not worth the restaurants time they are under not obligation to accept it. I will not be ever ordering from here again. If the note didn't come from the restaurant then it came from the delivery driver and he must be employed by the restaurant because he has been the same delivery person for the entire time I've ordered from this restaurant. read more

Sicilian Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Arlington, Virginia

The pizza is so good. Had a party next door and they basically catered the whole function. Everyone loved it! Super sweet employees will 100% go again when in the area! read more

Sicilian Pizza - One Large One Topping Pizza Small One Topping Pizza with a Bottle of Soda - Pizza Near Me - Arlington, Virginia

Everyone is nice and it tastes good! The only issue is that you have to wait a little bit.

My husband Zach and I found this pizzeria a few months ago and now it's the only pizzeria we'll go to. Growing up in NY and eating good pizza, our standards for pizza is pretty high. This place was up to the challenge. If you want delicious pizza go here. read more

We discovered this place after being seriously disappointed by pretty much every other pizza place in South Arlington. They have unique options, wonderful dough and fresh ingredients. Their sandwiches are especially good. I love the Italian Fest. We've had many of their pizzas... specialty and otherwise ... all delicious. The feta and spinach triangles are a house favorite along with the French fries. We've ordered from them at least 8 times .. orders are always correct and hot when they arrive. No complaints! read more

The best pizza I've had in some time! They do great white pizzas. The crust is spectacular. No dine in, but they do a very brisk business.

Great pizza, got the extra large with jalapeños for under $20. Small place but the pizza is definitely worth stopping by.

We order from here frequently because we live down the street and this is our go-to when we aren't in the mood for Ledo's (which is slightly better in our opinion). The prices are fairly reasonable, especially if they have specials. You can order online for pick-up, call to order, or get delivery. We generally opt to order online or call and then pick it up since we are in walking distance. They get backed up sometimes, particularly during Lent, but overall they are pretty efficient. A few times, the pizza has been overly greasy which took off a star. Also once we used an online coupon and paid before they called us to tell say they wouldn't honor that price. Sicilian is acceptable and good enough while not being overly special. If you aren't a Ledo's fan and want to go higher class than Domino's, this is your place. read more

Pizza order was wrong. Chicken parm was like chicken niblets with burnt cheese. See the most recent photos for a meatball sandwich. Where's the beef? you took 2 meatballs and chopped them up and called it an $8 sandwich. paid $64 for a Sicilian Xl.. Chicken parm and Alfredo and a sandwich. Disaster. I titled this Sicilian pizza because no matter how many times I called back to say my order was wrong (3 times) they kept sending a round pie. For some reason Sicilian to them only meant adding prosciutto. Where I come from a Sicilian pie is a square. Smh. read more

We ordered a large buffalo chicken pizza through Yelp. Delivery was sooner than the hour quoted. It arrived hot and intact. I really liked that they had ranch on the side. Sometimes I like to dip the buffalo chicken pizza in ranch and most of the time places don't offer it. The ingredients were dispersed proportionately. The buffalo sauce was a nice spice level. The large was more than enough to share. I would definitely order from Sicilian pizza again! read more

Pizza is decent, however, took an hour and forty five minutes to deliver and was stuck to the roof of the box and cold. Service can drastically improve read more

I live in Sedona | Slate and we order once a week. The food is always yummy and they deliver quickly and are super friendly read more

Sicilian Pizza - Philly cheesesteak pizza - Pizza Near Me - Arlington, Virginia

My fav pizza place in Seattle. The best Pizza in Seattle! Nice customer service the staff are friendly and nice. read more

2 good things about this place is caned soda and Uber Eats Delivery Person. I ordered Buffalo Chicken Pizza which was mad spicy, no one of us could eat it. Fries were tough and flavorless. $29 dinner is down the drain ( or should I say trash can) read more

Sicilian Pizza - French Fries - Pizza Near Me - Arlington, Virginia

I ordered in the last 30min they were open, so maybe that had something to do with the poor quality. But, I honestly can't say one positive thing about the pizza I ordered. Dough undercooked, layers of deli ham... pretty gross. Update: restaurant just replied to my review questioning if I was sure I ordered from them. Yes. I'm sure. Here are the screenshots of my receipt/order on Yelp from 2/7/18 and a pic of the pizza. Edges were cooked nicely (even charred), rest of the crust underneath toppings was doughy & uncooked. 2/12/18 - I appreciate your offer to give it another try with a free pizza, and I would select something different than the Sicilian. What is your most popular round pizza on regular crust? read more

See all