Love this place so much! The new owners are friendly and happy to answer any questions about the menu. The menu has something for everyone and it's all great and reheats great the next day. read more

Very good food! Portion size is large. We tried two pasta dishes which were excrement. The pizzas sounded good and we'll have those another time. Service was fast and friendly! The inside dining is cute. Lots of seating which can accommodate couples and bigger groups. We will be back for sure. Love supporting local! read more

Sicilia Pizza - Manicotti - Pizza Near Me - Oak Ridge, Tennessee

See all

First time I ate here, the pizza was great. Second time, it was the worst pizza i ever had.

Hole in the wall, incredible pizza! Tried the Gyro, so good! Yall seriously need to eat here, currently the best pizza in Oak Ridge (yes, including Big Ed's, which has gone downhill since covid). You will love this pizza when you are craving GOOD pizza and dont wanna settle for cheap chain pizza read more

Sicilia Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Oak Ridge, Tennessee

We picked up 3 pies tonight. The Supreme, Hawaiian and gyro. All were cooked perfectly and tasted great!! One of the best in oak ridge

My wife and I went to eat here last week and it was good. We have been one other time since new management took over. We decided this would be our pizza spot from now on. We think the pizza is good and decent priced. The only thing that happened was last week when we visited, we walked in and ordered our pizza and never had a server. 30 mins in and another party walks in and a server (owner) came out to wait on them. We felt ignored. But, other than that it's a good little spot for pizza. We will be back. read more

Everything was awesome. The place doesn't look like much but you should give it a try. The Lyla bites were amazing. I loved the Alfredo sauce with mine very garlicky. The marinara sauce is a little chunky so if that isn't your thing stay away. We also got cheesecake which was perfect. Creamy and not too sweet. read more

Sicilia Pizza - Lyla Bites and Fried Cheese Ravioli. - Pizza Near Me - Oak Ridge, Tennessee

Love the personal touch!! Nothing like being in Tennessee and getting at O-H inside you pizza!! Love it and also delicious

Was good but not great. The baked spaghetti was really good and the gyros was average. Sort of hard to find the place but thanks to directions on my phone I finally found it. In other words, a larger sign would have helped. read more

Very good pizza. Reasonable prices. And nice folks. Our veggie pizza was great. As was the fried ravioli appetizer. Would visit again. read more

Best pizza, calzones, etc in town. Doesn't make my sensitive stomach hurt or my daughters ;) yay!

If you cant make your own dough, you shouldnt be making "pizza" at all. This was a slap in the face to Sicilian culture and could honestly push us into WW3. I hope nobody else ever has to eat this 3rd world middle school cafeteria pizza again. Next time I consider this, ill just burn $100 bill instead. read more

Sicilia Pizza - BBQ Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Oak Ridge, Tennessee

Horrible crust! Just bad. Definitely not like any you get in Italy, New York, or Chicago

Wow this place was a big surprise to me and my co workers! We decided to try a new place and this place had a very diverse menu. They ordered baked spaghetti and Alfredo. They said it was amazing!! The portions here are insane. I ordered a calzone, Buffalo chicken and added jalapeños to it. It was so bug I only ate 1/3 of it this place def needs more reviews and more people to try it. You won't be disappointed! read more

Sicilia Pizza - Buffalo chicken calzone - Pizza Near Me - Oak Ridge, Tennessee

Good food . I had baked ziti and a medium Stromboli. 36 bucks was I thought a little expensive. Will I go back , sure just be a once every now and then thing.Cannot afford to eat there on a regular basis. read more

Called an 45 minutes before closing and was told they were closed. Laziness and apathy is why small businesses fail!

DO NOT GO HERE! We order pizza here for deliver to our hotel. I waited outside for the delivery to come for 1 and a half hours. I called several times. First they said they had to remake the pizza. Second time they said they would be there in a few minutes. No show. our pizza was than delivered the next day at the hotel!!!! unacceptable. We asked for our refund and they tried to keep our delivery fee! I will never do business here again. read more

We stopped for a quick bite. Cute little place. The jalapeño poppers were great! The pizza had fresh toppings but the crust was disappointing because it's frozen not fresh. read more

Ordered online for office lunch. Received a phone call that they had some "technical difficulties " and order would be delayed. Received another call from the restaurant telling me I needed to call their third party vendor they use to handle orders, to ask them to send a fax with the order or they couldn't process our order. I called Slice (vendor) and they said the fax machine at restaurant wouldn't work, and the restaurant refused to take the order over the phone, so the only thing they could do was cancel the order. What a joke. Why did I have to call THEIR vendor??? The restaurant said they didn't have a phone number for Slice. What?? You do business with them and don't have their phone number?? Won't be ordering from here anymore. I shouldn't have had to fix their problem. read more

I ordered baked ziti with meatballs and it was extremely disappointing. The sauce on it was basically just chunky tomatoes and onions and the rest was just liquid. And none of it was sticking to the pasta at all. There was a very strange taste that I honestly could not put my finger on. Kind of sour? Possibly thr cheese. Will not be ordering again as I couldn't bring myself to eat more than a few bites. Waste of money. read more

This place is an absolute gem! Delicious pasta! My family had the spinach ravioli, baked ziti and baked spaghetti. We were greeting by a very polite young man who was very patient with us since we had never been there. Later, the manager on duty also came out and was very friendly with the customers. We will definitely return. read more

Wow! Can't believe the menu choice at this place! I ordered the all meat pizza and a pesto and basil pizza. I've also had their calzones. The pizzas have a great taste and are pretty standard sizes. Their baklava is pretty tasty too! Can't wait to try the other items on their menu. The eat in is pretty small but I think everyone just orders carry out so it's ok. read more

Customer service is great! Food is amazing!! The authentic flavors, and ingredients make the food taste amazing! read more

Sicilia Pizza - The Chicken Shawarma is amazing!! This was my first! The food and ingredients are amazing! Great customer service! - Pizza Near Me - Oak Ridge, Tennessee

The Mediterranean food here is spot on! It's been hard to find good Mediterranean around here. This place always hits the mark. Even the delivered food is always hot and delicious! Keep up the great work! read more

When we walked in the smell of mold and stinky cleaners made me take my order to go. They weee very busy with to go orders and a little disorganized. The Greeks alas was average and the pizza was as well read more

The best pizza in town. Very reminiscent of new york/ new jersey style. The white pizza is absolutely fantastic! I can't recommend this place enough. read more

New ownership! Awesome very nice family and awesome food! Go check it out! We had cheese bread(highly recommend), all meat pizza and Hawaiian calzone! All delicious! read more

Doesn't look big from the outside, just a small corner of pizza heaven The Pizza was so delicious and fresh! We are originally fromNY and we are fussy about pizza; this is so much like NY pizza!! read more

First time customer. Ive never had to post a bad review since living here 1 1/2 years, but our food was not good. Ordered delivery and even though we live less than a mile away, the bread was cold and hard. The pizza was overbaked and the bottom was hard. Tasted like a frozen pizza from the grocery store. The chicken alfredo looked great, but had no taste whatsoever. Ordered fries because they are a "favorite"... they were soggy and undercooked. Very disappointed on this $35 order. Highly doubt I'll give a second chance. read more

We have tried this place three times and have yet to enjoy our meal. I ordered a pizza the week they opened and it was undercooked and extremely bland, and I instantly regretted not going elsewhere. I decided once they'd had time to work out the new restaurant kinks to try again. I got a cheesesteak that was short on cheese, came with peppers when I requested for them to leave them off, the sandwich bread was tasteless and chewy, verging on stale, and the meat was crispy from being burned on the griddle. Today I ordered some pasta hoping that would be okay. Nope. The baked spaghetti (which was listed a customer favorite) was watery and bland and the sauce was weirdly sweet. The chicken Alfredo was sticky and thick and had a bad flavor--obviously from a jar or can--and honestly the Prego bottled Alfredo my husband refuses to eat tastes less artificial. I cannot image the people who work here care two licks about the food. $25 spent for a delivered lunch for food that was picked at (rejected by the kid as well) and then 80% of the food was scraped into the garbage can. With the dearth of Italian food in Oak Ridge, I was hoping that this would be at least similar to the passable Cisco food truck type stuff from the now closed Gondolier, but it's not even that level. I should have learned my lesson the first time, but three strikes and you are out. read more

Sicilia Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Oak Ridge, Tennessee

See all

Decided I was in the mood for something different and this place was a fantastic choice! I had chicken vindaloo and my husband chicken Alfredo. Both dishes were hot, fresh and delicious! read more

Have had two great takeouts from here. Both have been fresh, hot, delicious, and bountiful. What a great find! David Day read more

Sicilia offers a great low-key environment to take the family and enjoy some pizza. It's good, and not pretentious or showy about it. I haven't strayed past pizza on the menu, and looking at other peoples dishes, I'm not sure I will. But the pizza is delicious. read more

I love this place! Everything we've ordered from them has been fantastic. The pizza reminds me of the great pizza you get in new York and new Jersey. The sides have all been tasty. I love the fried mushrooms. Their white pizza is everyone's favorite. read more

The absolute worst pizza that I have ever had. No flavor. Hardly any cheese. Asked for bacon topping. Might have had 1 slice on an extra large. Found no mushrooms. Red onions, where white unions. Soft and slightly soggy crust. Yeah, I really bad pizza. read more

Been driving by this place for a few years finally drop in and got a pizza and a calzone. Been looking for a north east ( ny-nj) type pizza it's the closest thing I found to it . The calzone was the size of the box and it was big read more

I've now tried this place 5 times, and every time the food is excellent. The pizza has a firm, non-soggy crust, with a robust sauce, and not-your-everyday toppings. I like the meatball and chicken parmesan pizzas. Then I tried several items from the mediterranean menu and was shocked at how good they were. This has become my go-to place, where I tell everyone to find good food. The only weakness I've found has been the non-mediterranean appetizers. They're just okay. Where this place really shines is the pizza and the mediterranean food. read more

Pizza tasted great, some of the better pizza in oak ridge. Portions are large and prices are very reasonable. The hostess was very friendly.