Great friendly staff. Food was pretty good except for the battered fish which was a very heavy batter on it.

Great food, service and atmosphere! While traveling on business I found this dive bar hidden gem. Fabulous grilled chicken sandwich and an eclectic neighborhood vibe! Thanks for a great evening- I'll be back when my travels bring me back this way. read more

If you like the smell of stale cigarettes and a room temperature, approximately 80°. This is the place for you. What a complete shit hole I walked in, turned around, and walked right back out. SMH read more

After over 7 hours of driving, I needed an alcoholic beverage. We decided to visit this place since it was so close to our hotel. Sheffield is semi hidden but still a gem. Smoking is allowed so you must be 21 and up to enter the bar. I don't know if it applies to dining area. This place gives the the dive bar vibe. If you are looking for something to do, they have 2 pool tables, juke box, and live sports. read more

This establishment is frequently visited by my family. The food is good for a bar. The bar allows smoking, but yesterday we were there celebrating 2 birthdays. There were many people smoking besides our group of 8. The owner only said our group smoking was too much others. This was very odd 90% of the restaurant was smoking. We are sad that we were asked to leave as we patronize them weekly. We won't be supporting them again, of course he waited until we ordered plenty of food and drinks. Never again!!!!! read more

The day bartenders are blow you away fantastic. Love this bar for an afterwork cool down. Love love love it!!!

I only went here because a friend invited me, otherwise I would not have gone! We went someone was having a party at the back which made the restaurant close the other side where there were pool tables. The whole bar was limited to only 2 pool tables that's in the front. Not cool! Then on top of that who had to pay for the pool table and the people who were playing were hogging the pool table. Drinks were too prices for a bar night. Just not my type of crowd. O and they smoke in their, if you are not a smoker avoid this location! read more

Food was good Italian Beef. Service was very slow. Drinks was even worse. Had Top shelf Long Islands came in a small Plastic cup maybe 10 - 12oz. Tasted like flavored water. 12.00 for 1 drink. Outrages We will never return to this place ever.... read more

Comfortable place to meet and eat. I've found the food to be very good. The drinks are reasonably priced and a strong pour. The service is generally good. The do get busy in the afternoon and service can get a little spotty. Overall I really like this place and will return often read more

This is the one of the few places that still allows smoking in the bar in NW Indiana When I leave i smell like a ashtray. It's a fun time, the chicken is good but the question remains: is it worth smelling like an ashtray to hang out? Nope...it's the cigarette smoke for me dawg! read more

Very unprofessional. After being told my food would take 20 minutes. I wait 50 minutes and still left without food. Customer was poor

They are the Bomb. The wings are number 1. I'm always getting food from here. I love Sheffield's. From Ms. Nay Nay (First Lady) read more

The Ancient One and I disobeyed a cardinal rule of restaurant dining - we went to a self-proclaimed sports bar for a weekday breakfast. Now you and I both know, Gentle Reader, that a sports bar is not usually the place you think of when you say "Wow! That's where I want to be at 10:00am!" Unless, of course, you've been out all night - then, you probably want to have breakfast at a sports bar, because you know you can get a little hair of the dog along with your greasy eggs. But The Ancient One and I (mainly me) couldn't find the restaurant I was looking for, amidst all the twists and turns of strip mall hell, and so I figured, it's Bob Evans again. But then we passed Sheffield's, and there was one sign that said "open" and another sign that said "Breakfast and Lunch Served," and the car pulled into the lot. Inside, we saw that the sports bar area is to the right, and the restaurant area is to the left. The Ancient One commented right away that the decor was very nice - not too fancy, but pleasant and neat. We were greeted by a friendly, but not too friendly, hostess, who told us that our waitress would be right with us. And, lo and behold, she was, bearing menus. We asked for coffee and had it within a minute. I was favorably impressed. Sheffield's already had the lunch salad bar up, but I was told that breakfast was still available. I ordered a vegetarian skillet - potatoes at the base, with mushrooms, broccoli, onions, green pepper, topped with two eggs. I requested sunnyside and wheat toast. The waitress asked if I wanted the toast buttered or not. I said not. The Ancient One ordered crepes with cherries. Since T.A.O. is actually trying to gain weight, she requested the whipped cream on top instead of powdered sugar. The waitress promised to give her LOTS of whipped cream. The food came in less than 10 minutes. The Ancient One had three large crepes, with artfully-arranged whipped cream on top. I had a couple bites. It was really good. I was also very pleasantly surprised with my skillet. Sometimes, you just get a lot of potatoes with very few vegetables. Not this time. There was a very good ratio of potatoes to vegetables. Everything was cooked just right. The skillet wasn't humongous, but for me, it was still a lot. And my wheat toast was dry, as requested. We each took the remainders of our meals home. I just had mine for dinner with a little extra cheese on top. Still very good. All in all, a very pleasant experience. I would definitely go to Sheffields for breakfast again. And it wasn't crowded at all, unlike the Bob Evans and Bakers Square across the street. Who knows, I might even have dinner and drinks there sometime! But not with The Ancient One along. read more

I'm never going to be THAT big of a fan of any place that still allows people to smoke inside the establishment. My insides were killing me that night. Minus trying to breathe, I had to deal with the awful stench that was left in my clothes and hair after being there for only a couple hours. The food on the other hand wasn't too bad. Typical bar food. We ordered a bunch of apps. I remember being fond of the wings. read more

I have been a regular patron for about a year now hitting up the bar for lunch. Mikell and Crystal are two of the best bartenders out there. The only down side to the bar is that the tv's don't have HD. come on now, its 2011, get on that shit. Hot Turkey open faced sammich was delish and a hefty portion for a small price. read more

I was very excited to see this place. It looked like a great alternative to the chains. The food was not anything special, tasted just like the chains. I had pancakes and bacon. Bacon was depressingly thin. Pancakes were unimpressive. This place isn't worthy the extra steps to get there. Maybe the connected sports bar is better. read more

When I walked up I noticed the empty dining room, not a good sign, explained by the sign on the door- This is a smoking establishment. I opened the door, bad idea. read more

Welp. The food is colder than the beer but warmer than the service. And the bathroom has no hot water which isn't surprising considering how cold everything else is. Today will be our last visit. My husband ordered the pulled pork "nachos" with cold pork, unmelted cheese and a salad on top that took 30 mins and we only had one beer since the bartender was missing in action when we would have had probably 3 each by the time the "food" came. read more

Disgusting meal. Presentation is awful and they don't know what a caesar salad is. Ordered a steak and got a slab of undercooked fat.

Quick review. Stopped here on a drive from O'Hare to Indianapolis on a Sunday morning. The Bob Evans' close by had an hour wait so as I headed back out to US 30 I saw Sheffield's, a sports bar pub on the frontage road. Was served by Hillary who allowed me to order a lunch special even though it wasn't lunchtime. Thanks Hillary! Had a grilled cheese sandwich with bacon, great home made potato chips and tea and I was out the door for around 10 bucks. I'd still be waiting to be seated at Bob Evan's. Why, when such good alternatives are available, do people wait an hour to get served factory food? On my way back, if time allows, I'll try having dinner here. Warning, no kids are allowed here, due in part to the fact that this is a smoking establishment on the bar side. read more

can you say one pound cheeseburger? that's just the meat. before all the other grilled and fresh toppings are added. before you count the giant bun that is truly bigger than your head. bacon. grilled onion, mushrooms, peppers. tomato, lettuce, cheese. i ordered it once by pointing at the picture, it looked good and i had not read the description. yeah when it came out on a platter, i was stunned. it fed three of us at the table, well we all had had quite a few drinks by then, and i think i took half of it home for leftovers. their hot wings are good. the other items i have had there have always been good. get your friends, get the burger. have fun trying to get it in your mouth. read more

The two stars are for the bartenders and (sometimes) the music. Do not EVER visit the bar on a Thursday...ask around and you'll understand why. If you want to chill, go early in the week. read more

Ive been to Sheffield's 3 time now and I always have a good time. I went on Thursdays where they have $2.00 domestic beers and on a Saturday where they had $3 buck you call it. Its really a mixed group of people which makes it a comfortable place to hang out. They also have a DJ at 10pm on Saturdays, I would not go just for the "DJ" auto play MP3 player. Food was not bad and the wait staff is always fun, Sandy was very attentive to my table. read more

Ate there with some family while we were visiting. The Lemon Chicken soup was good, but the Perch I ordered left quite a bit to be desired. The perch was cold, rubbery, and really had no taste and at 14.95 the portion was overpriced. My wife's Pot Roast was dry. read more

Good food, great service phenomenal prices. Just had a thick cheesburger bowl of clam chowder 7 bucks !

I'll come back here when I visit Indiana again this place be lit and drinks mad cheap I like a lot haha!!

The food is good and the drink specials are awesome...and that's it! The service is horrible. The bartenders are so mean to pretty female customers. The attitude from the bartenders alone makes this place less desirable to visit. They allow smoking on the inside which is a complete turn off when you're just trying to hang out. read more

Good food, just and ok beer selection! Cheap though which is always a plus!

Tonight I went to Sheffield's in Dyer. The meal and the service were excellent. The food came quickly, was hot and tasted great. Mt waitress Bree was outstanding. She was pleasant and spent a little time talking with me as I was the only customer in the restaurant. Excellent service. The best. Definitely going back. read more

Amazing people. Amazing food. Especially the wings and salads.. big t.v.s to watch all sporting events. All and all a great place to sit relax eat and drink read more

We all ate here the other day and we enjoyed our dinners very much, it is a nice place to eat and we will return again soon I hope. My Nephew and brother in law ate there yesterday & they loved it. 25 % off is a wonderfull deal for us old people. Try it if you can. The bread is great and honey butter to. Yum read more

This is a strange set up. Non-smoking family restaurant side, where there are seldom any customers sitting and the "ok to smoke" sports bar side of the restaurant. The interior design of the restaurant is out dated and I wouldn't think of Sheffield's when taking the family out. We go to Sheffield's to watch sports in the bar and for the BEST wings around. They are plump and moist even though we ask for them to be cooked extra crispy. They also have a good selection of sauces. The salads are good too. We do not go very often though because it is a smoking establishment. Well I guess we could sit in the no-smoking, boring restaurant side where there are no other customers but we want the TV, sports bar experience. Just wish it could be without the smoke. The great wings warrant 5 stars, but the smokey environment knocks a couple off. But that is just my "non-smoker" opinion. My friends who smoke love that they don't have to leave the restaurant for a smoke. read more

Half family restaurant and half bar...the place is huge. Bloody Mary's not so good but breakfast was delicious! Hearty portions and great hospitality. We stopped in about 8:00 a.m. And thought they were closed. Only 3 others there -I think they were regulars -not busy at all. We will stop in again but will trade the Bloody Mary for Coffee with Baileys. read more

Smoking is allowed in this establishment. Sorry, but I'm not interested!! I won't eat in a restaurant that allows smoking! I'm sure the would have been good, but I wouldn't have enjoyed it because I would have been coughing too much! read more

Disgusted. I watched as a server in the bar approached my clearly over served girlfriend and asked her if she wanted another drink while the one she had was still half full. She said, "yes" and then the server asked her, "top shelf?" Yes again. She brings back a drink in plastic f'ing cup and says, "$12". My girl gives 15 and says keep it. That was all but a couple of dollars she had left. 5 minutes later I had to help her out of the bar staggering and stumbling not having taken a single sip out of that $12 plastic cup. She was clearly being over served and then hustled for her remaining dollars. Here comes the sarcasm... nice training program. Where do you recruit your managers from? The county work release program? For those wondering, she was there ahead of me. By the time I arrived she was already several shots chased with Long Islands into her night. A $12 drink in a plastic cup, seriously? If it was crowded I might understand but it was dead that night. No excuse for it for plastic cups and certainly no excuse for taking advantage of someone that drunk. If this is how you operate, you're in the wrong business. read more

The spinach dip is delicious. They have decent drink specials and usually have a DJ on the weeken

Food was good. Service was good also Been their a couple of times and had fun this is a smoking bar. Will go back

the BEST spinach dip ever, great hot wings and burger!!!