FAN GIRL ALERT!
This was the first real Broadway show for my two friends. I freely admit that I was the one that was shamelessly promoting this show to them. Partly because I knew the plot (both the Jimmy Stewart/Margaret Sullavan version and the Judy Garland/Van Johnson version), but mostly - and I'm being honest now - because Zac Levi. What can I say...I'm a nerdy fan girl.
I'm going to try to steer clear of my OMG's, and squees of joy, and my giddy hand clapping. I'm going to try to keep this review as sane as I can.
But OMG, I do love me some Zac Levi!
I was interested to see how they had changed this from the two classic films (one dramatic, one also a musical.) I was more interested, though, in Zac's performance. You see, I'd seen him in "First Date" on Broadway a few years earlier, and was eager to see how he'd adapted to being back on stage.
Phenomenal!
One of the things I adore about him is his sweet sense of humor. Seeing him in person during Comic Con and at Nerd HQ, you get to understand that he's truly humble, fun and intelligent, with a quirky, strange, geeky sense of humor.
All of that came out on stage through his character. He made us laugh with his dialogue, facial expressions, and physical antics.
In short, he was on point that night, and increased our enjoyment level to 11.
I expected that.
What I did not expect was to be blown away by every other member of the cast.
Laura Benanti is beautiful, with a gorgeous and strong singing voice. She also has a knack for comedic timing, and her facial expressions rivaled those that Zac was pulling.
Jane Krakowski (who will always be Elaine to me) was stunning in her portrayal of Ilona. Dancing, singing, laughing her way across the stage, she was fun to watch. And the splits! TWICE a night, sometimes more during matinees. Damn!
Gavin Creel was incredible. Playing the character you love to hate to a tee, he elicited laughs from the audience and sang and danced his heart out.
Nicholas Barasch, who played Arpad, really impressed me. He was the youngest cast member, that was obvious, but he looked and sounded like a seasoned pro.
I could go on, but I'm well aware of the fact that I'm approaching fan-girl squee status. So, let me just say that the score was great (looking forward to the cast album, myself). And while I went specifically for Zac Levi, I left in awe of the whole cast. They were all giving out their best that night (though, at stage door, Zac did say that he felt off, after I'd complimented him. Man, if THAT was an off night, I can't even imagine what an on night would be like!)
It's a fun, funny, sweet show. The actors work well together, and the plot isn't hard to follow. If you're looking for a treat, this might be the treat for you.
Try me! (You'll get it after seeing the show, trust me!) read more