Cancel

Open app

Search

Shake Shack West Midtown

3.5 (33 reviews)
Open • 10:00 am - 11:00 pm
Updated 1 week ago

About Shake Shack West Midtown

Loading...

Read the full summary in the app

Order Shake Shack West Midtown Takeout or Delivery

Shake Shack West Midtown Photos

Business Info

SHAKE SHACK WEST MIDTOWN ATMOSPHERE

What's the vibe?
Outdoor seating
Dogs allowed

You might also consider

More like Shake Shack West Midtown

Recommended Reviews - Shake Shack West Midtown

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

Reviews With Photos

Oreo Cookie Funnel Cake and Banana Pudding limited-time shakes. $6.49 each plus $0.50 each for limited-time sprinkles. Pride.
Daniel B.

We went to Shake Shack West Midtown this past Sunday. The burgers and shakes were delicious. These are still some of the best burgers around anywhere, not just Atlanta. Having gone to several locations inside and outside of Georgia over the years, the brand has done a good job with quality and consistency across locations, in my opinion. A few things that set this location apart, from my experience: 1. Better presentation. Whoever prepared our burgers on Sunday did a terrific job with the presentation. Shake Shack burgers are already, by design, supposed to be presented nicely. However, the burgers that we got here looked extra nice; a bit more care and detail went into their presentation. I appreciated that. Take a look at my pictures to see what I'm talking about. 2. Temperature. We dined in. Our burgers were freshly cooked and quickly served. They came out very hot, off the flat-top griddle. I actually had to wait and let the burgers cool off a bit, at first, before continuing to bite into them. 3. Greasier. I could just be misremembering or it's what I ordered (the Carolina BBQ Burger with Fried Pickles), but the burgers here were greasier than I remember the burgers at the other locations being. I also had some of my wife's ShackBurger to compare to the other locations. Anyway, we all generally enjoyed the food and service was good too. This is a solid Shake Shack location. For more details, keep reading. This Shake Shack replaced Yeah! Burger at Westside Provisions District (WSPD). Yeah! Burger was a fixture on the Westside for 12 years; it opened on June 10, 2010 and closed on June 11, 2022. Shake Shack then opened in this spot about six months later, on December 20, 2022. There are eight Shake Shack locations in metro Atlanta at the time of writing this review, in late June 2025. We parked in the nearby WSPD garage and paid $4.50 to park. Currently, the self-parking rates are: 0-2 hours $4.50, 2-4 hours $6.50, 4-8 hours $11.50, and up. Unfortunately, Shake Shack does not validate unlike other businesses at WSPD (e.g., lululemon validates). If you've never been to a Shake Shack before, the restaurant style is American fast-casual. Like other locations, this one has self-serve ordering tablets (4). If you dine in, you take a number and your order is served to your table on a tray. The West Midtown restaurant space is contemporary in design and aesthetically appealing. The storefront, patio, and outdoor step seating look nice and blend in stylistically with the higher-end WSPD look. The dining room inside and the patio outside are sizable. The patio is covered and has fans and string lights. Here's what three of us had: Burgers * ShackBurger (Double $9.99) - cheese, lettuce, tomato, ShackSauce * SmokeShack (Double $11.49) - cheese, bacon, cherry peppers, ShackSauce * Carolina BBQ Burger with Fried Pickles (Double $11.99) - pepper jack cheese, applewood-smoked bacon, tangy-sweet Carolina-style BBQ sauce Sides * Fries ($4.49) with a side of ShackSauce * Fried Pickles with Buttermilk Ranch ($4.99) Shakes * Oreo Cookie Funnel Cake ($6.49 plus $0.50 for sprinkles) * Banana Pudding ($6.49 plus $0.50 for sprinkles) The ShackBurger was terrific as ever. It's perhaps the quintessential cheeseburger to me. The ShackSauce differentiates it. Shake Shack's ShackSauce is like McDonald's Big Mac sauce or In-N-Out's spread. All are mayo-based, creamy, sweet, and tangy. In comparison, I believe ShackSauce is slightly less sweet and slightly more tangy. It's good and also perfect for dipping Shake Shack's crinkle-cut fries in, which is why we got a side of it. Shake Shack's fries are pretty standard. This was my first time having the Carolina BBQ Burger with Fried Pickles. I thought it was good, but not great. I prefer the traditional ShackBurger. The Carolina BBQ Burger had a lot going on with the bacon, barbecue sauce, and Fried Pickles which, while I don't mind them, I'm not the biggest fan of. The burger was too rich and intense for me. So, I'm not knocking the burger or the person who made it because objectively, I think it was executed well; it's just a personal preference. This is only the second time the Carolina BBQ Burger has been made available by Shake Shack. It's part of the company's 2025 Summer BBQ Menu. They debuted the burger as part of the Summer BBQ Menu last year (2024). The Fried Pickles side is new as of this year. My wife liked them, but they were just alright for me. The portion size here was underwhelming and disappointing. I don't think they gave us enough. The Banana Pudding shake was excellent. Both it and the Oreo Cookie Funnel Cake shake are also part of the limited-time summer menu. The shakes were hand-made/hand-spun (I caught a glimpse of the staff making the shakes). The 50-cent rainbow sprinkles are also only available for a limited time: June and July 2025. The ingredients are better quality than typical fast food (e.g., 100% Angus beef, cage-free eggs).

a person's feet on the counter
Christina A.

Perfect location, delicious food, awesome service. Clean restaurant and restrooms! We stopped in on a Saturday afternoon and grabbed some shack burgers and chicken sandwiches with shack lemonade. It hits the spot every time! The restaurant is super cute and trendy. I love all of the tile detail on the walls and neon signs. Plenty of tables and seating inside. There was some parking available directly outside but we chose to park in the public parking garage across the street using Park Mobile.

Shack burger
Cassandra Tia H.

Pulled up here to meet my cousins for a fun Saturday Burger and Shakes. We were excited about the Peach Milkshakes. Located off Howell Mill I opted for the Valet parking. Right across from the Shake Shack. Ordering was easy. They have kiosks.. but because the Peach Milkshakes were out we couldn't complete our order on the kiosks..We had our hearts set on that Peach milkshake .We ordered at the counter. I got Strawberry shake instead. I ordered the Shack burger with cheese and bacon.. it was nothing to brag about, it had a ok flavor. Strawberry shake tasted like Vanilla and they threw a strawberry in. We sat outside on the patio. It was cool until I felt the bugs biting. I probably was just being paranoid. One of the managers came out and asked how everything was. We voiced our opinion about the Peach shakes. He offered apologies.. they didn't think they would sell out like that . Insert my twisted lip and sarcastic remark.. " Peach Shakes . In the Peach State of Georgia .. you didn't think they'd sell that quickly, REALLY" They do allow your fur babies (dog) on the patio. I probably won't be back anytime soon. You go and judge for yourself.

Zoe S.

We came here to grab frozen custard. I initially got chocolate because it's my favorite but it was very grainy ( not smooth) so I asked to switch it to plain vanilla, which was much creamier. I'll return to try out the food.

Signage
Huie N.

New (at the time of the review) to west midtown is shake shack. Located right beside brash coffee and across from ornsbys is this burger spot, perfect after drinks at holiday or other spots around the area. There's inside and outdoor seating, and they have self ordering kiosk inside located to the far right of the counter. Food was pretty good.

Hot Dog
Christopher R.

Check your food y'all...got served a moldy hotdog last time I went. Love shake shack but this location never fails to mess up or forget some part of my order.

Over cooked burger.
Eric L.

Shame on you! My burger was thin, over cooked and not satisfying. You've got too big and lost your quality!

Nuggets

See all

1 month ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

3 months ago

Business owner information

Photo of Ellie K.

Ellie K.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

4 months ago

Business owner information

Photo of Ellie K.

Ellie K.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

1 year ago

Helpful 3
Thanks 1
Love this 3
Oh no 0

2 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

10 months ago

Business owner information

Photo of Ellie K.

Ellie K.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

3 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0
Photo of Alex P.
953
1478
4831

3 years ago

Helpful 8
Thanks 3
Love this 5
Oh no 0

2 years ago

Business owner information

Photo of Ellie K.

Ellie K.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

2 years ago

Food is always made to order and hot. Usually pretty busy but they roll out the orders quickly. Shakes are amazing!!

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Zoe S.
226
376
1181

4 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

3 years ago

Helpful 2
Thanks 0
Love this 2
Oh no 0

2 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

2 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

4 years ago

Helpful 3
Thanks 0
Love this 2
Oh no 0

2 years ago

Business owner information

Photo of Ellie K.

Ellie K.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

2 years ago

Business owner information

Photo of Ellie K.

Ellie K.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

3 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

2 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

3 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

2 years ago

Business owner information

Photo of Ellie K.

Ellie K.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

3 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 1
Love this 1
Oh no 0

2 years ago

Business owner information

Photo of Ellie K.

Ellie K.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Serena S.
80
112
89

2 years ago

Business owner information

Photo of Ellie K.

Ellie K.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Anne S.
102
279
1202

4 years ago

Helpful 3
Thanks 0
Love this 2
Oh no 0
Photo of Corri M.
340
63
41

4 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Adrian F.
122
10
13

3 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

3 years ago

Wonderful service and food obviously! Even though this location is not one I'll recommend to work at, the service is top-tier!

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 1
Photo of James R.
146
14
66

3 years ago

Delicious burger bashing fries fast service and polite highly recommend if you want a good affordable meal

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

3 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Jasmine M.
55
102
30

3 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of T S.
0
20
3

3 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of John S.
31
53
0

3 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Ask the Community - Shake Shack West Midtown

You might also consider

Verify this business for free

People searched for Burgers 15,333 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

Verify this business

Grindhouse Killer Burgers - Grind house burger & sweet potato fries

Grindhouse Killer Burgers

4.0(1.4k reviews)
2.9 mi•Piedmont Heights
•$$

Heard great reviews of this place and decided to check it out. It did not disappoint. I've been on…read morea health plan and trying to eat better and so I had the avocado salad with a burger patty. It was really delicious. Everyone with me had a burger and loved it. The sweet potato fries looked awesome. And the key lime pie shake that my daughter had was really good (she highly recommends it). Service is amazing. They bring your food out to you. And the atmosphere is nice and quiet and relaxing. Easy to talk to others and enjoy the time

I've been on a bit of a burger quest in Atlanta lately. And this has been on my list for a while…read morenow. Went on a Saturday night and this place was packed out. The small parking lot was full and lucked out with a spot on the street. I opted to order at the bar so I could enjoy a beer and where it is full service - otherwise it is ordering at the register when you walk in. Service at the bar was friendly, efficient and attentive. I ended up with a double beef burger (each patty is 1/4 pound) at $9, pimento cheese (.75 cents) and Grindhouse Sauce which was in the 1000 island / Mac sauce territory. I was undecided on a side so lucky for me there is a "Frings" option of 1/2 onion rings and fries ($5.75). The burger was a little on the dry side even with the toppings but the potato roll made it a little more interesting. The onion rings were great and can't go wrong with crinkle cut fries. Cold Tropicalia on draft ($8) served by friendly bar staff made it a really great experience. Even though this is not my favorite burger, the sides, the drink options and the overall vibe of the place with excellent service still will make this a place I could visit again. Maybe giving a different burger a try instead of a BYO like I did the first time out.

Photos
Grindhouse Killer Burgers - Interior

Interior

Grindhouse Killer Burgers - Grindhouse style burger and fries

Grindhouse style burger and fries

Grindhouse Killer Burgers - Interior

See all

Interior

NFA Burger - Dunwoody - Burger Benefit Burger

NFA Burger - Dunwoody

4.6(625 reviews)
12.1 mi
•$$

Best smashburger ever!…read more And yes, it's located inside a gas station--but don't let that fool you. You order inside, and they'll bring your food out to your car or to the picnic tables out back under the shade. I got a single smashburger with extra bacon and grilled onions, plus an order of tater tots. Everything was SO good! I could eat this "gas station burger" any time. Definitely one of those hidden gems worth stopping for!

Not gonna lie, I almost looped NFA Burger in with all the other questionable fast food options…read moreattached to gas stations. You know the type. And the standards for this type of business concept are normally belooow the basement. But I figured we'd stop in while running errands in the area and grab something to munch on. I saw that they fry with tallow and I'm always on the hunt for some beef fat fried goodness. Now it's a rarity to spend less than $10 on a good burger these days in ATL, and even more of a rarity to feel that said burger was worth your coins. I side-eyed their $6 single but figured I'd give it a shot. Man, NFA proves that a burger doesn't have to be "gourmet" to still be damn good. The sauces, mustard, juices from the beef, slight sweetness from the potato roll, the crunch of the pickle... it all combines into something simplistic in nature yet magical. I usually expect this level of good (and inexpensive) in South GA but they brought that small town flair to the suburbs of Dunwoody. I hate crinkle fries normally but the decision to fry them in tallow makes me a believer. Simple, classic menu. No frills. Hot and fast. Great customer service, too. Just wait in your car and an amicable young adult (of which they seem to largely employ) will bring your order out to your car or to their picnic tables in the back. $17 for two to eat... in this day and age?!?! This place puts fast food burger chains to SHAME.

Photos
NFA Burger - Dunwoody - Menu

Menu

NFA Burger - Dunwoody - The double - added bacon and grilled onions

The double - added bacon and grilled onions

NFA Burger - Dunwoody - Burger with Tater Tots

See all

Burger with Tater Tots

Fred's Meat & Bread - Primo Cheese pull

Fred's Meat & Bread

4.1(903 reviews)
3.4 mi•Inman Park
•$$

Craving a great classic burger!? Fred's got it!…read more Mine was delicious, perfect combo, classic ingredients, amazing flavor. You're inside Krog Street Market, so the ambiance is already nice, me and my friends got lucky to find at spot at their table, but there's plenty of room at the market. Service was fast, friendly and helpful.

Fred's is widely known to be the "best" cheesesteak in Atlanta. It has many accolades including…read morebeing on the Michelin guide. 1) Korean Ribeye Cheesesteak: - PROS: It was packed and filled to the brim with ribeye that was nicely cut with an even cheese dispersion. I loved the caramelized jalepeno slices since they added it beautiful hint of spicy sweetness to the dish. The bread has a nice chew and it does not get soggy fast. - CONS: Not that special. I dont know why it's "korean" since it tasted like a normal cheesesteak but with a few jalapenos. I also wish they added in more jalapenos (I got like 3). 2) Garlic Fries with Ranch: - PROS: Very nice texture with a crispy outside and fluffy inside that is not too dense. The flavor comes from the garlic mince that is on top. The ranch is like a mixture of an aioli and tartar sauce (I think they make it in house, correct me if I'm wrong). - CONS: Inconsistent texture as some of the fries were dense but a few had that good hollow crisp bite. Quite oily too. Overall, I enjoyed the cheesesteak but would probably skip the fries next time. I do believe it is good especially the bread. I don't think it is worth all the hype it gets, but it is good.

Photos
Fred's Meat & Bread - The counter at Krog St.

The counter at Krog St.

Fred's Meat & Bread - Italian Grinder

Italian Grinder

Fred's Meat & Bread

See all

Hopdoddy Burger Bar

Hopdoddy Burger Bar

3.8(216 reviews)
5.4 mi
•$$

If you are looking for a good hamburger, Hopdoddy is the place! It's easy to get to off of I-85,…read morewith a lovely outdoor patio area to sit outside, plenty of seating inside, and seating at the bar! This hamburger is one of the best I've had! The French fries are also delicious, and they have a great selection of beer if you're in the mood for one. I definitely recommend it and will be back!

This location falls far below my expectations for the Hopdoddy brand. I'm a huge fan of Hopdoddy…read moreand frequented the original California location two to three times a week when I lived there, so I was really disappointed by how different the experience was at this location. The "sauce bar" is essentially just a ketchup dispenser, and the bar won't allow you to run a tab--even when you offer to leave a credit card. Unfortunately, the burger I ordered was cooked well beyond well-done, which was a major disappointment. On top of that, nearly everyone working seemed to be counting down the seconds until they could leave. Honestly, I couldn't blame them; the overall atmosphere made it seem like the staff wasn't enjoying their work environment. One positive: the fries were hot, fresh, and actually very good. I really hope management takes a serious look at this location. Improving the work environment for employees and having stronger management and oversight could make a huge difference in the customer experience. Otherwise, I'm afraid this location will continue to sit half-empty, as it was during my visit today.

Photos
Hopdoddy Burger Bar
Hopdoddy Burger Bar
Hopdoddy Burger Bar - The Classic

See all

The Classic

Stockyard Burgers & Bones - Certified Angus Beef Burgers

Stockyard Burgers & Bones

4.1(746 reviews)
6.4 mi
•$$

Stockyard Burgers & Bones was PHENOMENAL…read more Let's start with the star of the show: the bacon burger. Juicy. Flavorful. Cooked just right. The bacon didn't just show up , it showed out. Crispy, savory, and perfectly paired with the burger. Then came the garlic parm fries... listen... those alone deserve their own review. Dangerous. Everything tasted fresh and made to order, which always hits different. You can tell care went into every plate. The vibe? Perfect for any moment ; casual lunch, date night, family outing, or just treating yourself after a long day. Definitely a hidden gem, and I'll absolutely be back ASAP. Hands down one of the best burgers I've had in a while. The D-Tay Yay or Nay?! Order the bacon burger + garlic parm fries combo and thank me later. Eat it fresh while it's hot , that's when the magic happens. Approved.

My wife and I stopped by for a late lunch and grabbed a seat on the patio to enjoy a beautiful…read moreSaturday. We'd been here once before and remembered it being good and it didn't disappoint. I had the Cobb salad (no bacon) with green goddess dressing, which was fresh and really flavorful, plus the smoked chicken was a nice touch. My wife ordered the haddock with a Caesar salad and it was fried perfectly with a generous portion. I had to taste a piece of fish and it was really good! We also took the bread pudding to go huge slice, homemade taste, and a great way to end the meal. If we're on this side of town again, we'd definitely come back. Our waitress did a good job very helpful snd friendly!

Photos
Stockyard Burgers & Bones
Stockyard Burgers & Bones - Stockyard Frites

Stockyard Frites

Stockyard Burgers & Bones - Stockyard Bloody Mary

See all

Stockyard Bloody Mary

The Vortex Bar And Grill - Midtown - Retro Diner Burger

The Vortex Bar And Grill - Midtown

3.9(2.1k reviews)
1.6 mi•Midtown
•$$

Whew, I hadn't been to the Vortex since my college days 5-6 years ago. For nostalgia's sake, this…read morewas the second stop I made on the "Atlanta Streets Alive" stroll. I didn't feel like drinking before walking in but the service once I sat down at the bar made it hard not to partake... twas excellent! They had hella specials on a Sunday evening, many of which I can't remember currently but were expertly recited by our main bartender. Now I DO remember that their well drinks were on special for $6 because that's the deal that I thoroughly enjoyed for my 2-ish hour stay ;) The ambience is very grown (21+ thank GOD) but also quirky af! I didn't notice the giant lucky pen*s for a minute even though I was seated directly in front of it at the bar LOL. They host a shot challenge at its base that requires "no hands" and they really go out of the way to get everyone involved when folks are proving their.... skills. It's fun to watch but also nerve-wracking! The environment is lively (but not loud) and dive-y and the playlist was SOOO good with great song diversity, from My Chemical Romance to T-Pain to the Isley Brothers. It was the perfect nightcap. Now the food that we ordered this night was not overwhelmingly good but certainly not bad. To be fair, this spot is known for their burgers and neither of my party got one this time around. But the half salad I got was GIANT, so big that I had to double check with the food runner that it was indeed a half. Filled me right up for the low-low. The husband wanted to opt for something lighter too and got their Cuban sandwich with plantain... nowhere near authentic, but good enough for the moment. He's a certified Caribbean and thought the plantain was actually not bad, so there's that. The prices are reasonable. What takes this place up a notch is the clear organization to their operations, the way the team works and communicates together to strive for efficiency in service, and the neighborhood familiarity that this Atlanta institution emanates. I previously only when to the Vortex in L5P which has now shuttered I believe. It was a completely different vibe. But I have a feeling this spot is immovable. It is truly a neighborhood gem to meet up and have strong, affordable drinks and bomb ass burgers... next time I'll be sure to dabble in the latter. Sidenote: bathrooms were pretty decent and clean for a busy bar environment... I was surprised!

Has lots of seating available outside and inside…read more Decorations are unique and fun! Definitely has character! Staff were friendly and service was quick. The Hell's Fury burger is full and has a very nice kick. The tater tots are nice and crispy.

Photos
The Vortex Bar And Grill - Midtown - Entry and Ambience

Entry and Ambience

The Vortex Bar And Grill - Midtown
The Vortex Bar And Grill - Midtown - Vibe

See all

Vibe

Holeman and Finch Public House - THEE Burger.

Holeman and Finch Public House

4.2(169 reviews)
1.7 mi•Midtown
•$$$

Holman and Fitch is such a wonderful restaurant. I've had their cheeseburgers in the past and love…read morethem from the days when H & F would only serve 24 cheeseburgers in the evening as well as had their cheeseburgers at the Braves ballpark too but this was my first visit and H & F's new location and our group came for brunch and they had our reservation and were ready to serve us. I ordered the insanely great fried chicken and it came with coleslaw and a biscuit. I also had the potato hash on the side that was killer. We ordered some shareable plates of food including the deviled eggs trio, and the scrumptious cornbread covered in butter. The mixed drinks looked amazing although they didn't have bloody Mary's on a Sunday g brunch afternoon for some reason but I just ordered a Guinness to go with my food anyway it's a beautiful restaurant just like the old location and the service was impeccable.

We had brunch at Holeman and Finch Public House yesterday (Saturday). Everything was outstanding…read more This restaurant continues to be an Atlanta institution and one of the best in the city. Holeman and Finch is known for its burger, and deservedly so, but I can't stress enough how good the other food and drink are here. Looking at the current list of Atlanta restaurants in the Michelin Guide, I think Holeman and Finch deserves to be included. I wonder why they got snubbed. Holeman and Finch relocated to Colony Square in Midtown in February 2023. The restaurant validates parking in the Colony Square garage for two hours. We stayed just over two hours and ended up paying $6. I like to enter and exit the garage via Peachtree St NE. There's also an entrance/exit on 14th St NE, next to The Starling hotel. We used to go to the original location in Brookwood/South Buckhead circa 2010 when only 24 burgers were made per night and released at 10pm. Holeman and Finch existed in that location from 2008 to 2020. It was quite the Yelp hot spot: https://www.yelp.com/biz/holeman-and-finch-atlanta-2 This new location at Colony Square is way more spacious and looks great. There's indoor and outdoor (covered and uncovered) seating. The atmosphere is that of a modern, upscale pub. It's nice. Reservations can be booked on OpenTable, so get those dining points. Our server said the brunch menu was served until 4pm. Here's what my wife and I had: Drinks: * H&F Bloody Mary ($14) * Iced Tea - half sweet, half unsweet ($5) Graze: * Naturally Served Oysters ($5 each) - cocktail sauce, mignonette, buttered saltines, horseradish - Lowcountry Cups - Charleston, SC - Dukes of Topsail - Topsail Sound, NC - Dixon Point - New Brunswick, Canada * Deviled Egg Trio ($9) - classic, country ham, and Pickapeppa mayo * Hand Chopped Sirloin Steak Tartare ($20) - capers, horseradish, egg yolk, chips * Simple Lettuces ($15) - citrus vinaigrette, crisp shallots, fromage blanc, pecans Sandwiches: * H+F Cheeseburger ($28) - certified Angus and Hereford beef, onions, Kraft, fries Plates: * Housemade Scottish Gravlax ($18) - toasted brioche, fried Pantelleria capers, lemon dill clabber * Holeman + Finch Vegetable Plate ($32) - "all that is best from our Southern farms" Dessert: * Sticky Toffee Pudding ($14) - vanilla ice cream Everything, down to the sweet tea, was fantastic. The Bloody Mary was strong and so delicious that I gulped it down. All of the dishes were beautifully plated and finished. The oysters were fresh, superb quality, and cleanly shucked. They forgot the crackers, but that's okay. I highly recommend the deviled eggs. They were perhaps the best we've ever had anywhere. If you're unfamiliar with Pickapeppa, it's a sweet and savory Jamaican brown sauce that is used to make the mayo for this dish. There was nothing "simple" about the Simple Lettuces salad. It was pretty much a perfect, tasty, and refreshing salad. As for the H+F Cheeseburger, it's a classic and continues to be one of the best burgers around. Every bite is just so good, and the ketchup and mustard remain distinct. If you've never had the burger before, get it here or at H&F Burger at Ponce City Market. The Truist Park version isn't the same and I've never tried the Mercedes-Benz Stadium version (the old Turner Field version was legit, though). If you like gravlax, wow - the gravlax here is amazing and really well made. The Vegetable Plate was terrific as well. It featured potatoes, okra, beans, succotash, mushrooms, onions, peppers, tomatoes, and more with a fried onion ring on top. It's a great dish to share. The Sticky Toffee Pudding was top-notch - exceptional texture and flavor, and perfectly paired with a scoop of dense vanilla ice cream. Our server was Jonathan R. He was friendly and took great care of us. A manager checked on us too.

Photos
Holeman and Finch Public House - Rabbit/hare tabletop decor and centerpiece flowers in our booth. Nice little touches here.

Rabbit/hare tabletop decor and centerpiece flowers in our booth. Nice little touches here.

Holeman and Finch Public House - Complimentary roll, butter, pickles

Complimentary roll, butter, pickles

Holeman and Finch Public House - Inside. Dining room. Host stand. Facing the front of house and patio.

See all

Inside. Dining room. Host stand. Facing the front of house and patio.

Shake Shack West Midtown - burgers - Updated October 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...