I never skip a chance to visit a thrift store, and Amvets is one of our favorites…read more We are still school shopping, and we found more Buffalo Bills team logo clothing for the children. Their elementary school celebrates Buffalo Bills team every Friday during the football season. Why buy brand new when you can find almost for significantly less money! The men's department yielded up a dozen brand new basketball shorts with the tag still on for only $4.99. We grabbed a good handful of those. All in all another, very successful trip to the Amvets Thrift Store.

I'm writing about ALL their locations:…read more Buffalo location - it's near the art store named Hyatt's and is the biggest AMVETS I've been too. Lots of selection but prices were high. It also smelled dirty like all amvets do but it also smelled like weed too. I left with nothing and wasn't sad about it either. The people were nice and let you shop, but maybe it's cause of the weed smell, who knows. I was there once and won't be back due to travel distance. West Seneca Location - they have a nice assortment of stuff but it always smells dirty and the floors are dirty. You come out smelling like the store. I hate going in it but my mom likes to thrift. I only donate items. I typically haven't had any issue with donating to this location. The old man with the long hair is REALLY NICE! He's the nicest employee across all their locations. Deal with him only if you go inside. He will let you take the tote out to your car for donation items to bring in. My mom has never had an issue donating here either - he always lets us take the tote. Last time I tried to donate, he was there and said i could take the tote as i always ask. Well, last time when i did that, a younger employee came out and caught me midway taking it to my car and told me i couldn't take the tote because they're very expensive and apparently the policy is it remains in the store and you have to bring your items in and place them in the tote. I told him the long haired man said it was okay and that I've never had issues, and that i had heavy items and needed help getting them in. Nothing i said mattered to him. He did NOT offer to help me and ended up taking the empty tote inside before i could get my stuff into it. I should have left but i honestly wanted to get rid of my items, so i chose to donate. They have the heaviest of doors and they never leave them open. It took me several trips to get my items inside. The long haired man saw me making the trips and asked why i didn't take the tote. I told him what had happened, and he shook his head. The long haired man ended up helping me. I never went back after that experience. I will NOT be donating to AMVETS anymore. Cheektowaga location: This is the location my mom likes to visit the most. This one smells dirty as well, floors are dirty and you come out smelling dirty. For donating items, you have to pull up in the back of the building. You have to bring your items to the door and they do NOT help you. There's no totes either. I went to donate in November or December of 2025. They don't salt or clear a pathway to the door so it's easy to slip/fall on their property and maybe that's what they are waiting for lol. Thankfully i didn't fall, but i nearly did. An adult and her small child were waiting at the door to take my things. The adult was on her phone the WHOLE time! The adult NEVER helped take my stuff. She had her small daughter take everything! The daughter looked like she was maybe 5 years old max age. 3-5 years old. The adult was barefoot! The adult at least had a jacket on at the door but the child didn't have a jacket on, not even a sweatshirt and she was the one taking my items. I even offered to help take them inside because i couldn't believe what i was seeing. I even asked numerous times if the lil girl 'had it' and 'do you need help?' loud enough for her mom to hear me. I felt so bad, this lil girl was doing everything while her parent was too busy on her phone. The parent never looked up! I feel so bad for this child. We've donated lots in the past and never encountered this! Based on this experience, I've never donated again. I will not go back to AMVETS nor donate. We've instead been donating to other places that act more professionally and actually help you and they don't smell!

My boys needed a few things for back to school, so we took a quick trip to Goodwill at The…read moreSouthgate Plaza. So glad he came here! Found a great pair of sneakers for my little guy that are absolutely brand new, and discounted all the way down to ten bucks! This is a great place to get some Buffalo Bills T-shirts for the kids, because our school celebrates the Bills every single Friday. They found a very beautiful frosted glass flower vase. I'd like to take cuttings from my flower beds, and this vase is a nice addition to my collection.

I was really pleasantly surprised by this Goodwill location because they had a very organized and…read moreclean store. There was a really nice selection of glassware and home decor. I didn't look through the clause but everything looked very organized and in good shape. There is ample parking in the shared parking lot.

I don't know how I never reviewed the store before, but it's been open perhaps three years now? Or…read moreI've been aware of it anyway for about that long. It's on Sheridan, it's much smaller than Savers, Amvets or Goodwill or any of those kinds of stores, making it a very easy place to stop and do a quick run in if you're looking for something or a quick run in just to check it out. Easy parking out front.

I am a woman on a mission. In an attempt to find the replacement thrift store (RIP Payne ave…read moreSalval) I flailed my way across Sheridan on foot in search of new, well old, pants. It's close to my regular grocery stores, so I was really hoping this was going to be the place. All I can say is that it's not not the place. Walking in, I immediately came to face a large security footage screen, as if to deter me from theft. The proceeds of the sales go towards feeding and clothing the underprivileged (they say they even give some donations to the people in need, which explains where all the clothes I throw in those red boxes around town go) which you would hope would make anyone with a conscience pay up, though at the prices they charge, I could see why one wouldn't want to. The prices are more comparable to a low end clothing retailer like Walmart than second hand stores I have grown accustomed to. They also had the colored tags, and I looked unsuccessfully for signage to see if it meant any deals. Their website explains the color would make something half off, which must not have been the case today. I combed through the racks, which are sorted by type and size instead of color. I was able to find one cheaper pair of pants to try on, so I headed to the back, where there were two massive unlocked fitting rooms. They were super clean and spacious with a wall sized mirror, a bench and a rack for returns. I could comfortably kick my legs about (yes, kick, as I was testing the durability) and squat down (butt crack coverage) without worrying about hitting the wall. Side quest accomplished. I had also looked through the rest of the store: furniture, housewares, toys and books. I was disturbed to find a used bottle of mouthwash for sale on the shelf, which is mostly the reason why when deciding between a three and a four for this review, I knocked it down. The cashier asked if I wanted to join the loyalty program, to which I declined, watching my total pop up on a screen in front of me. They're rounding pennies now for those paying cash. Which in the grand scheme of things hopefully means that an extra two cents is helping those they serve. I might come back at some point, with more money in my wallet to poke around, but for a place called Heart, this isn't my new love.

These ladies have become FAMILY to my kids and I! Seriously. They always have MOREEEE then fair…read morepricing and a very crazy, and insanely lucky selection! I am not exaggerating when I say every single article of clothing my kids have is from here. They have daily sales and are very helpful. My mom passed a little over a year and a half ago, and these ladies have become a sense of comfort for me and my family. These gals help with anything from explaining daily household items and their uses, to helping calm and entertain my kiddos while mommy can look and find the incredible deals I do! As always, THANK YOU LADDS LADIES! For literally everything I have and come to have!

It's a small but mighty thrift shop with a set of cute ladies working. You can tell this store is…read moreincredibly beloved by their community. Prices were great and extremely affordable, they don't seem to have the same price increase bug as some of the other corporate thrift stores.

it was nice selection of things. the prices of things were kinda expensive for a thrift howeverread more

Amazing experience overall. Everything felt well handled, the staff was friendly, and the place…read moremade a strong positive impression. I would be happy to come back again.

I moved to Alden in April of 2025 and somehow I have managed to become a regular at Under One Roof…read morein what can only be described as record-breaking time. Honestly, I think I'm in there more than anywhere else in town... okay, maybe second only to the coffee shop -- but still. Priorities. Recently one of the girls who works there asked, "Were you in here recently?" My response: "Yes... but you're going to have to be more specific." At this point I'm basically on a first-name basis with the clearance rack. This place is truly a magical hybrid of boutique, consignment shop, and small-town treasure hunt. They have clothes for kids, teens, and adults -- some new, some consignment -- and the consignment pieces are so pristine you'd swear the previous owner bought them, lovingly removed the tags, whispered affirmations over them, and then never wore them once. And it doesn't stop at clothing. Oh no. There's furniture, small appliances, baby items, exercise gear, bedding, health and beauty goodies (from really good brands, too). You name it, they probably have it. And if they don't today... check back next week, because the inventory changes constantly. One of my favorite things is how active they are on Facebook -- posting new arrivals, sale alerts, and little contests so you can plan your visit like a highly strategic shopping mission. If you live in or anywhere near Alden and you haven't been here yet, I don't know what you're doing with your life -- but I gently and lovingly suggest you redirect yourself to Under One Roof immediately. I'll probably see you there. I'll be the one pretending I'm "just browsing."

consigning for a couple years, no problems. This January, I dropped two new winter coats with them…read moreand some other household items. This week I called to retrieve only the new winter coats and they tell me there is no balance on my account - and they do not have them. They further went on to state, they had nothing "tagged" for me since last December.... you literally cannot randomly drop off items, you need an appointment which I had January 26, 2026! The owner had her manager call me, who I had spoke to about these coats twice. Since they take your items and you get no ticket, ...they win! Bad business practice. Whoever took these coats has some nice winter wear.

Love the mission of this place. I always leave with my arms full of items, and donate my items with…read moregood conscience!

I like this little place. The prices are reasonable, the selection is good, and it's nicely…read moreorganized even as stuffed full of merchandise as it is. The dressing rooms are cute, too. I knocked off a star for the Jesus music (which another reviewer accurately described as loud and distracting) and the smell. Most every time I've gone there it smells like someone just took a big stinky dump in the bathroom. If you can get past those things, it's really a great little store.

First time there today and it was a great experience! The store is kept nice and warm, clean and…read moresmells good as you enter. The man working was so nice and welcoming. This store had a lot of cool stuff. Much better of a collection and variety of things than ive seen at other antique stores. Will definitely come again!

Very cool antique stop in Tonawanda. They feature some great items for every kind of collector…read more Quality furniture is sprinkled throughout the store with a lot of diversity in terms of style and age. The upstairs area is a little sparse but has a few cool items as well. Take your time in this small shop for you will definitely find something worth taking home.