It was horrible, had to ask another patron if they even had menus. We ordered simple food thinking it was going to be good, it took about 25 minutes to cook a pancake, when we walked in - they had huge bags of potatoes on the floor so we were like "Oh this will be good" ... Not - my husband received frozen hash browns rather than fresh. His food was burnt and then the waitress gave us the wrong bill, I didn't notice until after we left - I always take a picture of my bill. Also, by the time we arrived home both of us were sick. I do not recommend this place, and all we wanted to do was to support our local businesses - but were treated like we didn't belong. Sad - Oh and the health inspector should pay a visit. read more

The very definition of a hole-in-the-wall greasy-spoon diner. 1. Limited counter seating? Check. 2. Locals-only regulars? Check. 3. Outdated décor? Check. 4. Sassy server? Check. 5. Huge portions? Check. 6. Great food cooked expertly? Check. 7. Absurdly low prices? Check. Setting foot in Scottie's is like stepping back in time...in the best way possible. Finding a seat is pure luck; show up early or be prepared to wait, but know that you will be waiting outside, because there isn't an inch of spare room inside. If you do find a coveted spot, grab it because it won't be there long - and be prepared to rub shoulders and knees with the person next to you. Don't worry; that's all part of the experience. You might not know them when you first arrive, but you'll be best friends by the time you leave. Pro tip: the cook is not Scottie. There is no Scottie anymore. Presumably there was a Scottie once, but his whereabouts are unknown. At least to me. Jackie is amazing. If you've seen "Alice," she is the embodiment of Flo. I'm kinda shocked I haven't heard her tell someone to "Kiss my grits!" yet. She delivers good-natured sass just as frequently as plates of steaming hot food. Again, all part of the experience. Your food is cooked to order in front of you, so you know it's fresh. Even if the place is packed it won't take long, because there are only a handful of seats. And about that food: it's damn good. You can't go wrong with any of the skillets. The biscuits and gravy are wonderful. The toast, slathered with melted butter? Heavenly. The pancakes are enormous and awesome. The coffee, hot and delicious. Best of all, when you're handed your check, you will invariably mutter out loud, "That's it?!" The prices are insanely low. They're what you might have paid for breakfast in the 1980s. Two people can easily walk out of there stuffed and only $15 poorer. Tip Jackie well. She deserves it. It may be hot in there. It will definitely be cramped in there. You might see a fly or two. You'll leave smelling like grease. But you will be happy and satisfied and already planning your next visit. Besides, like I said... All part of the experience. read more

Small mom and pop. The food is great. Need different coffee. Meet great people and get very hot in there in the Summer. The price is very reasonable read more

Good food, engaged staff, neat setting. You sit at the counter and watch the chef. It's what our family of 5 were looking for in this neat small midwestern town. The price was perfect so we are going back again today. They even gave my kids a candy gift at the end of breakfast and my kids are all practically adults. read more

Atmosphere brings you back in time! Amazing home cooked food. Only counter seats with approximately 20 seats. It's a must if you want great quality home cooked food and friendly waitress and cook this place is for you! (we'll be back when we're in town again) read more

Good home cooking style place. Small with only seating for about 10-12 but a great hidden gym. Friendly service. We were stopping for a bite to eat driving through and decided to try it out. Cool layout as they cook the food on a grill just behind the counter. You won't be disappointed! We all ordered breakfast items. read more

Excellent food. Sassy server with a big heart. Prices are very good. You might need to wait because the place only had 15 or 16 stools. But well worth it. read more

I wish I could give this place ten stars for service, quality and taste of the food. The wife had chicken fried steak and promptly declared it some of the best she's ever had. She is a fanatic about chicken fried steak. She also said this place was right up there with our, till now only, favorite breakfast place Manny's Snack Shack. I had the biscuits and sausage gravy with hash browns and an over medium egg. Some of the best, if not the best I have ever had. Let's talk about that over medium egg. It seems to be nye on impossible to get one that is cooked right. The egg that can with meal was done to perfection - lots of runny yolk with a firm white. Heavenly. Service: We called for curb side pickup when we were 20 min away. The gentleman who took our order was very friendly. No sooner than we pulled up out front he came out with our order. We didn't even have to call. Talk about service. WE WILL BE BACK!!!! ps: Now I am off to mark this as one of my favorites on Google maps! read more

Classic small town diner - 15 stools at the counter, with Scottie and Jackie running things. Cash only - so check your wallet before ordering! Menu is what you expect, with well prepared food and diner coffee. Just a great local place - a sure stop when I am in town read more

Scottie's Eat Mor - At the grill. Did I tell you this place is small? - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Fort Atkinson, Wisconsin

This little hole in the wall is one of the best places to eat at. Everything made to eat fresh right in front of you. Not much seating so get in where you fit in. Definitely worth it. read more

A classic counter diner of the 1950s-1960s. That means limited counter seating and the world's smallest restroom. But do stick around, it's worth the wait! Scottie's stock in trade is cooked breakfast to order-- eggs any way, bacon, hash browns, toast and good coffee. I've eaten here many times-- never disappointed with either the service or the clientele. read more

It's like walking into 1950's America. No tables only a counter complete with a sassy waitress who knows all the gossip in town. You can watch the cook make your breakfast fast as he chats with the regulars. Can't beat the prices and the food is excellent and the coffee cup is never empty. Great Saturday morning date place for sure. read more

Small town, greasy spoon, counter diner. Smart talking patrons and staff made the meal an event. The counter looks over the small kitchen and you can watch each meal being prepared. If you are looking for a place for large groups or a fancy brunch, best move along as this is not the place for you. read more

Awesome for breakfast! Pancake is amazing and a small is certainly shareable. They are very generous with their portions! Diner breakfast and lunch at its finest. Scottie's is a place loved by the locals. Comforting, yummy and a bang for your buck! read more

Scottie's Eat Mor - Less than $10 - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Fort Atkinson, Wisconsin

All I can say is hope you can find a seat because you're taste buds are in for a treat. Small town mom n pop dinner from the 50s style, been enjoying the food here at this location for 48 years. Awesome food, great prices, cooked right in front of you. Humorous staff, friendly atmosphere. Parking can be tricky because it's on mainstreet, but it is worth the hassle. Not one thing on the breakfast or lunch menu that isn't 100% delicious! They also do lunch specials, get there early so you can get a seat ! And enjoy their food because it is a taste bud treat! read more

This little dinner is great! Jackie is a funny , down to earth counter staff that makes you laugh and feel at home. Randy is a excellent grill cook, and Scotty gave us a free blueberry pancake! Definitely stop by this little dinner Eat More Yum Yum! Thanks ! Steve and Kathy read more

This is a genuinely retro hole in the wall diner with 15 or so stools around the counter. My "Mounds" skillet (sausage, mushrooms, cheese and 2 eggs) came on top of what seemed like a pound of hashbrowns. The skillet and coffee was $8.20 tax included. The food and service were excellent. Highly recommended. read more

A little hole in the wall. An old fashioned diner restaurant in Fort Atkinson, WI. ( minus the old train car) But don't be deterred by the Main Street location; just look for the little Coke sign outside. Step on in the door and it's like "CHEERS" from the '80's! Everyone looks and seems friendlier than one might expect. Belly on up to the counter; there's 9 stools around the counter and the show is in the center. That's where the magic happens. Scottie is grilling up world class hash browns for some of his famous skillets like the veggie (peppers, onions, mushrooms, tomatoes, two eggs any style and topped with cheese if your choice. (There's Swiss, cheddar, Colby Jack, American) there's an all meat skillet and a create your own...they're all humongous and delicious. Scottie keeps his "regulars" special extras on hand like one patron had his own bottle of flavored coffee creamer, my guy loves Heinz 57 and though it wasn't one of the regular condiments found on our first visit, the next time we went back it was there and we didn't even have to ask; Jackie (Scotties sis) remembers everything and it's quite a special feel when you realize they got something just for you and remember your favs. Scottie is also famous for his pancakes... (I'll post a picture next visit) The regular is larger than the plate it's served on and two can easily share and be more than satisfied. Their flavor is light, fluffy, vanilla-ish with the perfect brown color and of course real butter and maple syrup; so "sasifying". There's bottomless cups of coffee, coke-a-cola products and did I mention the decor is all classic Coke motif...from the clock to the original 8oz bottles on a shelf, every Coke gadget you can think of. The menu has all your traditional breakfast foods; bacon, eggs, sausage, cereal, juice, toast of many choices including Raisin (my fav) , and there's a Half skillet available too because the regular size is so big you can have the rest for your midnight snack if your eyes are bigger than your stomach like mine. Scottie has specials of the day for lunch like the reuben sandwich, soups du jour, chili, classic diner food changes daily. Sad part is they are only open 5am until 1pm Monday through Saturday and closed Sunday's. If you find yourself passing through Fort Atkinson, WI, try to catch a seat at Scotties Eat More....you'll want to eat more...& more, & more & more &.... read more

See all

Husband and I stopped here with 2 other couples for breakfast. We watched the cook make our breakfast. We all enjoyed the food. It took a little longer considering there is only one cook but he was friendly along with his sister who was the waitress. Small place with only approximately 20 seats. Pancakes were huge and good. Would highly recommend. read more

Scottie's Eat Mor - Medium pancake on a platter. - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Fort Atkinson, Wisconsin

Came to town a couple of years ago and Scottie's Eat-Mor was the first place we stopped in while looking for a Fort home. They were very welcoming. A family business with very good food. I'm a regular now. Wouldn't think of having breakfast anywhere else. You will not be disappointed. Jackie is the best and Scottie never stops caring about pleasing his customers. read more

My first visit I gave it a 5 star, this time, not so good. The eggs were not as I requested and half the potatoes were almost burnt and the other half, barely cooked. There were only 2 customers while last time the counter was full. Although Jackie (the server was not in) I think she keeps Randy, the cook, in line. It is small and only has counter service so it's not for everybody. When the place is full, everybody is 'family' and we have a good time. I will try it again. read more

Fort Atkinson's best breakfast: friendly service and meals cooked to order-- all in a late 1950s stool and counter setting. Lots of locals eat here, and no wonder! Don't worry about a short wait-- believe me it will be worth it! Cash only; leave your credit card at home. On - street parking. read more

Always friendly and welcoming, true Midwest hospitality! Portions are generous, food is delightful, and it's all made to order right in front of you. With 79 years in business, Eat-Mor is a great small town spot for visitors and locals alike. read more

See all

Stopped here because of Yelp reviews and we were not disappointed. Nothing fancy. Just good food served at a long counter facing the grill. Reasonable prices. Large portions. A step back in time! read more

My boi Randy is a master chief, that man must be half cook half God. The pancakes are without a doubt the best and biggest cakes I've ever seen. I'm pretty sure this is the only place unicorns would eat if they were real. read more

Tiny tiny space. Great food. Amazingly huge pancakes. Always leftovers. Limited Hours.

Nice Surprise! We walked in and luckily someone was leaving and it was completely packed. Here is the reason why, Great Food! Cooked perfectly! Eggs, Hashbrowns cook right in front of you! For breakfast and lunch, this place is perfect! read more

Homemade burgers and very old style. I loved it and you can watch them make your food.

Most delicious biscuits and gravy on the planet. Be ready to wait for your meal but it's worth it. Be willing to rub elbows with whomever you sit next to, as well. It is as old school as it gets but it's also the best meal you will eat. We stopped in by chance and nearly left but an older gentleman offered his seat and we are so glad. Thank you Scottie and Jackie for the great breakfast and conversation!!! read more

GREAT FOOD nice people very tiny place like 12 seats but huge portions I got the Philadelphia cheese steak gives two huge sandwiches soup is the best part. I would say to go there if in the area read more

This is a true American, hole in the wall diner. Can be greasy, like diner food is. If you want healthy, or green food, go someplace else. Sit on a stool and eavesdrop on the small town locals. Walk to Riverfront or Farmers Market, Antique Shop. Nice, friendly service. Get EVERYTHING with onions. read more

Scottie's Eat Mor Part 2... If your in Fort Atkinson and you don't stop at Scotties your missing out on a true Wisconsin tradition...Walk in, eat too much, bitch about it, and then dream about going back for more... How cool is it that you stop back for your second visit and the waitress Jackie remembered me. How was the food??? "DON"T ORDER ONE LARGE PANCAKE" My God one pancake was overflowing on a large platter. Scottie said to me as he set the platter down, HUNGRY?, as he said it with a sly smile. I ate 1/2 of the pancake along with 2 huge sausage patties. What a great experience and the food was amazing. Next time your at Scottie's, TIP JACKIE BIG TIME and tell her I told you to do so and wait for that sweet little smile. PRICELESS. Thank you, you guys are the best. read more

Very cool place and the food was awesome and plenty of it. Small place with about 12 -14 seats at a bar type seating area. Was busy this day (Friday) but you can watch him cook your food and be entertained. Friendly people and a great atmosphere. read more

Stopped in after a morning at Aztalan State Park looking for some good food at a local eatery. Scotties was welcoming and accommodating. We had the soup of the day which was authentic and yummy then split a burger, cheese of course, with hash browns. Done perfectly with generous portions. We definitely return when in the area. read more