I stayed in a house with four other students from 2010 to 2011 rented through Scott Fraser, and overall have had a very bad experience.
Through the year, while they did respond to maintainance queries, the response could often be slow, and in my cases the contractor didn't manage to fix the problem anyway. Of course, no-one else was sent to follow this up.
I felt we were treated without much respect at times. For example they came to inspect the house a few times through the year. The house was certainly clean, especially for a student house, yet they complained it was unacceptable because a couple of the rooms were messy (i.e. there was stuff on the floor). We had to tidy it all away, and the first we heard was when we received an angry letter from them. It's not nice, or necessary, to have how you live dictated to you. When I rang them to ask why the house was declared unacceptable their tone was very confrontational, and I wasn't offered much useful advice.
The worst part was at the end of the tenancy. After 5 people spending a good 2 days cleaning we were initially charged about £600 in fees. Some of this was for an inflated inventory fee (£198) for someone to come round and take pictures of cracked paint etc. We were also charged some money for compensation fees for apparent damage we had caused (3 blu-tac marks, a small damp stain on 1 carpet and an almost invisible mark on a matress). After lengthy and tedious discussion these were taken off meaning we paid £500 in total. This is about £300 on cleaning fees, which is frankly shocking. The landlord was unwilling to compromise, despite our efforts at cleaning.
On top of this, we were told to pay to get the carpets cleaned (£90) ourselves, then they cleaned them again (£82) and charged us.
I blame Scott Fraser for using such expensive services, and sending a bewildering and self-conflicting amount of information about how the house should be cleaned.
In summary, they are just about acceptable to deal with through the tenancy, but can be quite underhand and will almost certainly take a lot of your money at the end of the tenancy. read more