Congratulations on the new location! I was surprised I had not reviewed Moolicious before as it…read morehas been my go-to ice cream shop for a few years. Recently relocated from a busy retail street to now located nestled beside the Black River off of High Street has added a new level of summer to this ice cream shop. I love just sitting in their Muskoka chairs watching the river go by. Serving Kawartha Dairy Ice Cream, Moolicious has all of your classic flavours in a variety of sizes. Their serving are generous to say the least (they alone is worth a rare five stars), and the staff are super friendly. Offering ice cream and frozen yogurt there is something here for everyone. The next time I stop by I will need to check out the other store in the building - Georgina's local Board Shop. Next time you are up to the lake for a swim or camping at Sibbalds or simply out for a drive be sure to stop by Moolicious- you won't be disappointed.

They recently moved locations and I checked on their Facebook to see they were finally opened for…read morethe summer. A group of us went down to the location on High Street and it's honestly such a better location. They have a nice view of the water and more seating outfront as well as behind the building. They extended their business with a hot dog cart out front called "Wienielicious" which let me tell you is a VERY fitting name. It was one of the best hot dogs I've had from a vender and for only 3$ it was absolutely filling. But of course we couldn't pass on ice cream either!! If you are in the area you definitely need to visit this shop the owners are always so friendly and cheery. They have a variety of ice cream flavours which can also be turned into a good milkshake. And they have soft service option as well.

Came here to try some ice cream and get some for a party later…read more Service was fantastic, we got to try a flavor and ended up getting a scoop of that anyways.. should have gotten the kid sized scoop, because I was not expecting this monster. We prepaid for a tub to go, but asked if we can leave in the freezer until we finish our ice cream, and was allowed to do that, so that was nice. Inside is really inviting and just a chill space.

Always love coming here for classic Kawartha dairy flavours. My go-to flavour is mocha almond…read morefudge. Always check their instagram for deals! Ice cream scoops are always generous and expect a line during the summer months, but they move quick!

My family and I was in the area after an event and decided to stop by for some ice cream. You can…read morecertainly never go wrong with Kawartha ice cream! Not only do they have ice cream but they also have ice cream cakes. There aren't any tables or any seats available, it would've been so nice if they have it though. We tried the campfire s'mores this time, it was okay. I still prefer chocolate mint more though. We'll be back to try out other flavors next time.

Kids love stopping by to get their ice cream fix on. Ask…read morefor trial samples before committing to a huge scoop of your favourite flavour. But how to choose since there are so many delicious flavours! Tip: kids really struggle finishing one regular scoop....two scoops will either melt first or fall off. What's unique here is they carry all the flavours that cannot be found in most grocery stores. They sell tubs in the freezer at decent prices like Campfire S'mores for $5.99! They also carry local items like Neal Brothers products like bbq sauces, pretzels, and salsa. Coffee beans, maple syrup, butter tarts, dairy and butter. It's strictly take out, but there are benches under a few trees to enjoy it.

A cute little café on Main St in Newmarket! I got a cold brew and a delicious slice of pie with the…read morebest vanilla ice cream. I work close by and will definitely be coming back this summer for more drinks and ice cream. You will love this café!!

You know the warm weather is here when you start to see window service for your ice cream fix in…read morethose little gems around the city. Such is the case with The Pink Flamingo. While the ice cream may not be as good as that at the firehouse in Unionville, there are plenty of options to satisfy a fix. We ordered a banana and a separate pistachio ice cream after a refund line up. Standard fare at a reasonable cost. We headed across after splitting a few orders of fish and chips so definately a cheat day! Definately worth a try if you're in the area! -Zuk

A group of my friends and I were looking for the closest place to grab some Kawartha Dairy ice…read morecream while we were up at the cottage and this place came up. The place only has street parking and you have to enter and walk through a tiny alley to get to the entrance which is located at the back of the building. They had friendly staff and a variety of different ice cream flavours. Their regular 1 scoop ($4) cone was huge and you have the option of getting it in a cup. I got the butter pecan and it was delicious! Their seating is only outdoor and minimal (only 3 picnic tables) located at the entrance of the establishment. I would totally recommend if you're near by the area!

Great stuff! Tried this place for the first time while in the area and I really enjoyed the ice…read morecream. This place sells kawartha dairy ice cream in a variety of flavours and it is very fresh. You can buy the ice cream in a cup, regular cone, or waffle cone.. and you have the option of getting 1 scoop, 2 scoops, or 3 scoops. There is a nice seating area outside which is super hip looking with pink and grey painted walls. There is also adequate benches and chairs outside for you to sit and enjoy the ice cream with friends. In addition to selling ice cream, this place also has a small market inside where they sell what looks like merch and random nick nacks. We were not able to see or experience the market as we went here close to closing time, but it looks pretty cool. Definitely give this place a try if you're in the area and are craving for some kawartha dairy ice cream!

It is closed for the season in July! Insane! It is the…read moremiddle of the summer!!! Not secure why this is showing up in Yelp!

Wish I liked it more but if you are the only ice cream in the area, I guess you don't need to be…read moreamazing. Still, the staff is very friendly, but the prices and the ice cream flavours could get some improvement. The butter tarts are very good but also rather expensive. Was cash only.

It's my first time trying this popular local icecream shop…read more I first tried to sample some flavor I tried the pandan and the Hong Kong milk tea. The pandan isn't as strong as I expected so I didn't order it. I ended up getting the black sesame soft serve and a scoop of milk tea, both in cups. Cone are 25c more. Order more than $10 can also get a stamp and you get macaron once u get to 10 stamps. I think both the black sesame and milk tea had intense flavor but they aren't creamy enough and too sweet to my liking. And perhaps too many people order the milk tea so there wasn't too much left by night time and so it also accumulated some icy pieces. Mine got some icy bits. I still may go back to try other flavors. They have few seats both inside and outside and there's a little train table for kids to play too. Nice little spot to hang out during the summer time.

Another one of my favourite dessert spots in Newmarket. Their gelato flavours are exceptional and…read morealways rotating - offering lots of delicious fusion options such as Vietnamese Coffee and Hong Kong milk tea. Some days I crave something more decadent and strong, and other times I love something light and fruity. You can buy pints of their gelatos to take home as well. The owners are warm and welcoming. Staff are always helpful, making recommendations based off of what you like. Other than gelato, By Jacob offers lots of different desserts such as cakes, macarons, waffles and cheesecakes. I highly recommend this spot to anyone looking to try a new dessert spot - By Jacob is excellent.

Great selection of kawartha ice cream flavours including some sorbets for non-dairy options. All…read morethe flavours I've tried so far have been great. The bubble gum ice cream actually has little bubble gum bits in it! Since it's a take-out shop there is very very limited seating available. Around the corner of the shop you'll find a bench with 3 Scoops written on it. However it's near some garbage bins which makes for a terrible combination to enjoy your ice cream. Aside from that, the cashiers are always friendly and quick. They also have options to get cones, cups, banana splits or ice cream sandwiches. All forms of payment are accepted (except american express)

Got a cookie sandwich with Moose tracks ice cream (Kawartha Dairy). It was decent…read more It came with 2 large cookies which were decent: chewy & rich enough. There was too much cookie to the ice cream portion though.