The quality of the seafood at Scale is superior. I have purchased seafood to cook at home and have also dined at Scale. The team there is knowledgeable and friendly. The service they provide is top notch. We live in a time when we need to be careful about what we consume and I am happy that Scale is in my neighborhood. To feel comfortable with a wide selection of seafood relative to sourcing and origin is priceless. read more

I stopped by for lunch today and was a cool fish market to have lunch at. The service was great. I ordered the catch of the day, which was a Pollock fish sandwich, and when I opened the box, I had high hopes. The bread was good, and the tartar sauce was excellent. Unfortunately, the star of the sandwich--the fish--was where it fell short. The Pollock had absolutely no flavor and appeared to have no seasoning at all. It was very disappointing. The atmosphere and presentation were promising, but the sandwich itself missed the mark. With better seasoning and more flavor in the fish, this could have been a much better experience. read more

Scale Fish Market - Inside - Seafood Markets Near Me - Jersey City, New Jersey

See all

Food (4/5): We ordered the catch of the day sandwich, truffle fries, and crab cake sandwich. The food was quite delicious and fish fresh. My favorite was the crab cake sandwich. The catch of the day was solid but could be more flavorful. The fries weren't my favorite as you couldn't really taste the truffle. I also generally prefer thin cut fries. Service (4/5): The staff were nice and friendly. The place was very busy when we went on Sunday late afternoon around 530pm. Some of the items like the fish and chips weren't available because the shop was short staffed. The food took around 25 min to come out due to the short staff. Ambiance (5/5): Chill fish shop ambiance with indoor and outdoor seating. Nice relaxing music playing and cool fishing decor. Tables inside are a bit cramped while outdoor tables have more space. Spot is pretty busy. read more

See all

Quick stop on the way to dinner so we didn't enjoy many options but the food that did come out to other tables looked amazing. The oysters were excellent and the vibe overall is great. A must for anyone liking fresh seafood. read more

See all

Super fun place with the best seafood around hands-down. Both to take home and to eat right there. Many tables outside, and great service and knowledge about seafood. I don't buy anywhere except Scale. A great people watching spot as well. This is the only fishmonger you will ever need. read more

See all

Scale has a very nice and friendly staff. The selection of fish are mostly seasonal fish. Everything I've purchased there has been of excellent quality. read more

Stopped by on my way to the airport heading back to LA since it was close to my hotel -- and wow, what a find. Their lobster roll easily beat the ones I've tried at those 1K+ review spots in Chelsea Market. Honestly, best I've ever had. I got the brown butter version, and the combination of the savory butter sauce and sweet, meaty lobster--served warm--was just perfection down to the last bite of their huge portion. Paired it with their citrusy green tea from the fridge, and the balance was amazing. The shop itself is cozy, spotless, and full of interesting seasonings to browse. There's even a grab-and-go section with seafood dips and salads; the staff kindly advised against buying since I had a long flight, but next time I'm bringing an insulated bag so I can take some home! Everyone was super welcoming and friendly, and I loved seeing locals casually drop by to pick up fresh fish -- clearly their selection and quality are top-notch. Makes me wish we had a place like this near my home. Tip: The kitchen opens at noon. I arrived early and waited it out to fully enjoy the lobster roll, but there's smoked salmon dip, and crackers you can enjoy while you wait. There's even an outlet by the seating area if you need to charge your phone. Definitely a spot I'll return to every time I'm back in NY/NJ. read more

See all

Scale Fish Market is the location to get fresh seafood and prepared foods. We regularly buy tuna from here to make poke and uni to make pasta. We also regularly eat here. The crudo, oysters, lobster roll, and frito miso are our favorites. The owner/chef is always tweaking the flavors to keep things fresh and seasonal. The entire staff is friendly and knowledgeable and will never steer you wrong. read more

Wow. Finally got to try this place and it was fantastic! Originally, I didn't know they served cooked and prepared food. I stopped by and got the shrimp po'boy, fries and fried calamari special and they all were amazing. The best food I had in the area in a long time. Prices are not super cheap, but the portions and quality are worth it. This is now my official restaurant for po'boys: so flavorful, filling, abdundant, and presented so well. Nowhere in town to get a po'boy of this quality. Same for the fries: delicious. And the staff was friendly, to boot! I will definitely be going back time and time again! read more

We were thrilled when Scale opened a store in our neighborhood where we can buy fresh fish at any time. We used to buy fish from Citarella in Manhattan, but now we're glad to have a local store that sells top-quality fish. We often buy their salmon to make oven-baked salmon with red bell peppers and onions over jasmine rice. Their salmon is always incredibly fresh, moist, and tasty. I also love their oyster po' boy and 'fish of the day' sandwiches. I highly recommend Scale's fish to anyone who lives in or visits Jersey City. read more

See all

Amazing service! rogolfo I believe is his name the man working behind the counter was so hospitable and very inviting. We got the brown butter lobster rolls and they were fresh, buttery, and warm. The place is small and there's outdoor seating if you want to dine in they'll set you up after you order at the counter. I think I found my new spot in the neighborhood ! read more

Scale Fish Market - Brown butter lobster rolls - Seafood Markets Near Me - Jersey City, New Jersey

See all

Lunch review only, as I have yet to actually purchase fresh seafood from this fishmonger: Get the Ahi Tuna Crudo if you want plump juicy pieces marinated in a lightly sweetened soy sauce. I would've preferred no sugar, but the quality of everything else was on point. The Lobster Roll was loaded with plump chunks of lobster, tons of fresh dill, and just enough mayo to lubricate everything without drowning it. But the Crab Cake Sandwich. Jimminy wow-lickers! Easily one of the best crab cakes I've ever had: loaded with fresh crab meat and very little filler (our server said it was ~80% vs. 20%), perfectly baked so that it was lightly crispy on the outside, and sandwiched between two pillowy soft brioche buns. This is the sandwich to get. The only drawback of this place is how high the prices are. A lobster roll, for example, is $32. As a former Bostonian who lived there during the heyday of $15 lobster rolls, the prices make me want to wither and die. But my desire for seafood is too strong, so I will (begrudgingly) pay these prices when it's time for a treat. read more

See all

This is a fish market with a few counter seats. A friend and I came here for lunch and got the crab and lobster bisque and browned butter lobster roll. Both were delicious. The bisque was tomato-based and had a decent amount of crab and lobster meat. It's not all cream, unlike many other bisques. The hot soup felt very good on a cold winter day. The browned butter lobster roll was also served hot, in contrast to the New England lobster roll that uses cold mayo. The lobster meat was seasoned with a little Cajun seasoning to give it a slight kick. We had the option to add more lobster meat, but thought the 4 oz. standard size was enough with the bisque. We both left with full stomaches and warm hearts. read more

See all

The shrimp po boy, lobster roll, and fish and chips were the best I've had in the US. Service was really great and the interior gives off a seafood vibe. 10/10 for everything read more

Scale Fish Market - Lobster roll and fish and chips - Seafood Markets Near Me - Jersey City, New Jersey

See all

Amazing food. Warm buttered lobster po'boy and a plate of very fresh PEI oysters. Topped it off with fries. Small quaint sitting area. Some of the best seafood I've had recently. Friendly staff. read more

See all

Food is always fresh and delicious and the staff is friendly and knowledgeable. Great all the way around!

Had an amazing lobster role here, incredible flavor. Will definitely be back to try other items! read more

Scale Fish Market - Lobster roll - Seafood Markets Near Me - Jersey City, New Jersey

The best local seafood ever! The menu is extensive and the staff is super knowledgeable. Seafood and specials are always fresh and heaping portions. Their Caesar salad is to die for and their cocktail sauce is delectable. read more

See all

I am never in this part of JC so it took me a while to finally visit Scale Fish Market, and I'm so gad i did! I got two salmon fillets for $20 to cook at home and a $20 shrimp po'boy sandwich. $20 is a bit high in my opinion, but this po'boy was worth the extra few bucks. Served New Orleans style (aka crammed with shrimp to the point of overflowing) the shrimp were lightly fried and all the flavors of the sandwich came together well. The bread was not the right kind of bread for the sandwich, and that's the only bad thing I can say about it. I'm looking forward to coming back to try the fish and chips. read more

Scale Fish Market - Half of the shrimp po boy - Seafood Markets Near Me - Jersey City, New Jersey

Stopped in here on a whim and the lobster roll was delicious and the service was great will deff be back!

Meh. My first time there for takeout. 1- it took FOREVER to get a cup of clam chowder (20 minutes..were they still fishing them out of the sea?!?) 2- the small size is NOT worth the hefty $13!!! 3- also it was thin (not thick) and with no potatoes. I make a much better chowder at home, so I will not be back for this. The dip (trout) was Ok, but I should've gotten the crab instead. The fresh fish to cook at home looked good but way too expensive for my budget. read more

Scale Fish Market - the size of their cup of soup. - Seafood Markets Near Me - Jersey City, New Jersey

My relatives are huge seafood lovers and insisted on taking me here during my visit. I ordered the blackened fish sandwich and it was SO GOOD! The fish was cooked perfectly and not even a little bit dry. Loved how the fish was larger than the bun. Warning- a little messy to eat but worth every napkin! We also ordered the west coast oysters and fish and chips which was equally delicious. read more

Scale Fish Market - Blackened fish sandwich - Seafood Markets Near Me - Jersey City, New Jersey

Best fresh seafood in Jersey City! Always a great selection of fish, shellfish and great service. read more

This little gem of a seafood market really exceeded my expectations. I went on a Sunday afternoon and it was a little crowded. It's very small inside. I like the fact that it is both a seafood market and they make food there as well. Very limited seating but I recommend eating the food right there as it's fresh. I saw everyone with bowls of lobster bisque so I followed suit. Best lobster bisque I've ever had. The bowl was filled both lobster and crab. The base wasn't too milky or creamy, it was just right. I also shared some east coast oysters. My partner got the fish and chips and that was perfect. The fish was in abundance, nice and fluffy under the batter. The fries were nice and golden. The dish was great. I also had the grilled Mackerel which was seasoned very well with a green chimi like sauce . I was so full and pleased, I took the rest of my food and rolled home. I'm definitely coming back. I did not get any raw fish but they seemed to have a pretty good selection. The staff were friendly and attentive also. read more

See all

Got the shrimp po' boy for my first visit and it was spectacular. They did not skimp on the shrimp at all and the shrimp had a great size and meatiness to them and the batter they were fried in was seasoned well. I will say the dine-in service wasn't great but being that they are primarily a fish market, the guys had their hands full dealing with that side of things so I won't hold it against them. The staff was still very nice and I enjoyed my meal. Will be back to try more. read more

Scale Fish Market - Shrimp po'boy - Seafood Markets Near Me - Jersey City, New Jersey

This place is wonderful. We were looking for some well prepared quality fish.... Scales did disappoint. Our fish of the day was some excellent Flounder. But the outdoor BBQ kept tantalising our tastebuds. Some dishes were being BBQed right there street side for the customers, and it smelled and looked great. We had to have a chat with man operating the BBQ, and we discovered that this was "Tony".....the owner of Scales. Tony and his staff don't just serve you food. They make sure doing well with the offering on the table. Tony understands and delivers on his "neighbourhood presence". Go to Scales and you'll truely feel like a part of the neighbourhood. Thanks Tony. Chatting to you tonight was awesome. read more

Amazing food best fried oysters I ever tasted & great customer service. And a truly unique experience I've told EVERYONE I know about this hidden gem read more

See all

I recently started going to Scale Fish Market at 45 Coles Street, Jersey City, NJ. After looking for a real good fresh fish store in Jersey City, I found one only a few blocks from where I live. Scale's fish is fresh and enticing. I recently bought cod fish and baked it and it was light and heavenly (See photo). The fish assortment is quite good. Scale's indoor decor is contemporary and inviting. The manager was helpful and knew about the fish selection on their varied fish menu. I like Scale and will definitely plan on shopping there for my fresh fish needs. read more

Scale Fish Market - Seafood Markets Near Me - Jersey City, New Jersey

See all

We came to scale and tried their lobster rolls. One month in Maine trying many versions and I got to say, this one not only holds up..... its probably at the top!! Can't wait to try the butter version they also do next time. Was simply blown away. You also can't beat their delicious and very fresh oysters... a only $1 on Thursday!! read more

Scale Fish Market - Lobster roll on lettuce. Fantastic! - Seafood Markets Near Me - Jersey City, New Jersey

Hello all... In my neighbourhood... there is not one fishy spot worth going too and then i found Scale spot... it was when they opened up but now they have blossomed and wow they are good. Fresh scallops to all kinds of fish to shrimp and what not. Huge Oyester selection !!! And thursday happy hour oysters.... BYOB tooo are kidding me !!! Its a wife and husband operation... awesome couple. They work hard and treat there customers like family. I always have an amazing time there. They are raising the bar in Jersey city for fresh seafood gig. nothing fancy just honest fresh seafood. Mad respect. I usually dont give 5 stars but its worth it. Fresh fish ! Smoked fish Spreads Sauces Oyesters Its a beautiful place with an amazing service... Its a neighbourhood spot come with your family or friends or date or mrs or pet or by yourself. Phenom atmosphere. Enjoy ! BYOB read more

See all

Everything is so overwhelmingly good I can't stop coming back. The fish is so fresh that it feels like I'm having some of these fish for the first time. Don't sleep on the sandwiches and raw bar either. read more

Scale Fish Market - Available fish - Seafood Markets Near Me - Jersey City, New Jersey

This is a fresh fish market. Very clean. More than just fresh fish, they also make a few made to order food items. There's a couple of high tops outside where I stood and ate my to-go box, I couldn't wait. I had the crab sandwich ($18). It was thick. It was also wide enough to fill out to the end of the circular bun. It was about 1/3 larger than any crab sandwich I've ever had. It was tasty. I would have enjoyed a spicier seasoning. But the great thing about the mild crab cake seasoning was that it still allowed me to taste the cream itself. Seems to make sense. This place is very clean. They also have sushi grade fish, which we will come back and try later. They also have a soft shell crab sandwich that I did not try. My wife enjoyed her Connecticut lobster roll($26), she said she enjoyed the roll. It looked like it had about 1/5 more lobster than the last one I had elsewhere. read more

Solid fresh finds at the Scale Fish Market. I went in looking for crab to cook at home, and amazingly they had rock crab ! Apparently this was a highly anticipated item at the shop. I also got a pound of fresh shrimp. You can pick the size of shrimp you want : small, medium, large . The staff was friendly and helpful in giving recommendations. If you can't find what you're looking for, they have recommendations for something similar . The packaging of my items was good and I was able to happily enjoy my crab and shrimp at home . They were delicious. If you also want to eat a meal here, they have a whole menu for that. They've got crab cakes, lobster rolls, and the like. There is a bar on the opposite site from the fish stand, where you can eat but there are not tables to sit down and eat at. read more

The fish is always fresh Need I say more But I Wii He goes every night to the fish market Tony and his wife work very hard and they hired a fantastic knowledgeable staff If you have not tried , I urge you to go read more

Great neighborhood spot for fresh fish and prepared seafood. Typically I'll just pick up high quality fish to cook at home or dollar oysters on Thursdays, but they also have a great lobster/crab bisque and small kitchen that hasn't let me down. read more

Scale Fish Market - Seafood Markets Near Me - Jersey City, New Jersey

See all

It's a cute place, small, there are only a few tables. BYOB. My mistake to come on a Friday evening, so oysters selection is limited and that's all I ordered. Oysters were fresh but not impressed. It satisfied my cravings, that's all I came for. I heard Thursday night is $1 oysters special, not sure it's the same ones they served tonight. Based on the price of the menus, they already charged $1extra for each oyster shucked and served. There isn't much service other that, so I didn't leave extra tip. Overall I would say it's a great value if your bring your own bottle here and order some oysters. I was surprised that they sell paella pan here with the right kind of Spanish rice for paella. I am a paella snob, so in my opinion this is the only rice one should use for legit paella. I didn't see paella on the menu but I definitely would have tried that if it was offered. read more

See all

Had Connecticut style lobster rolls and a few oysters with my wife and sister. It was their first time having oysters and lobster rolls. We all thought they were phenomenal. I've had lobster rolls all over New England and these are up with the best. Highly recommended! Staff is incredible as well. read more

Scale Fish Market - Pink Oysters. Delicious with cocktail, lemon, and vinegar. - Seafood Markets Near Me - Jersey City, New Jersey

Amazing fish sandwich with the best tartar sauce and buns! Planning on coming back for sure no matter how far away i live! read more

scale is a small little fish market that opened up in spring 2021. they sell a variety of fresh seafoods, and also some seafood dishes like lobster rolls, ceviche, and oysters. it's BYOB as well! seafood fridges are on one side of the store to buy fish like salmon, shrimp, and uni. the other side of the store has little wall standing tables for customers to enjoy their seafood dishes. in the back, there are some small shelves with fun products like fancy olive oil, canned fishes, and sauces to purchase. the only thing i will note about the lobster rolls are that they are somewhat small. however, they are packed full of lobster so do with that information what you will! what we got: 1. connecticut lobster roll ($26) - not my favorite. usually connecticut-style lobster rolls use a lot of butter and has cooked, warm lobster. the lobster that we got was somewhat dry (so sad - i think they were overcooked) and did not taste like butter overload (can be good or bad, depending on how you see it). maybe i'm just more of a fan of the new england style? 2. new england lobster roll ($25) - sooo good, i really liked the mayo on here and the flavor was delish. 3. loaded fries with crab meat ($17) - my favorite of the three. surprisingly very tasty and there was a lot of crab! we ended up having to use a fork to get the crab meat and fries together, and had to line the bottom of the fries container with a napkin so we didn't make a mess. so much crab. so much goodness. read more

See all

Had some excellent bluefin tuna sashimi as well as fantastic fish n' chips (fresh cod, a light batter that complemented the fish well, and a distinctive tartar sauce that added the perfect zing). Everything here is fresh, the space is cozy and welcoming, and everyone is friendly. Five stars across the board! read more