Kept hearing good things about Catusco's so i stopped in to try it. I ordered a margarita and my…read morefriend got the meatball with vodka sauce. I liked mine but they really overheated it! My friend said "meh" to his slice. I also got a few to take home to my kids. The Thai chicken chili was good as was the hot honey but the lasagna slice tasted like the sauce from a can of spaghettio's that I remember having when I was a kid. Well, you can't win them all! I was expecting better. People do love this place though, so try it for yourself, it's just not my favorite.

Greetings Fellow Yelpers, I had the urge for the Spinach…read moreArtichoke pizza and this is the best as I've stated in a previous review. James insisted that I try the hot honey pepperoni which is a Sicilian slice and even asked if I prefer a corner slice, absolutely delicious. Thanks guys, you're all always on point

I am telling you this was and is one of the best finds I've had. Thanks to Yelp because Paulie's…read morepopped up on a search one day when I was really craving solid pizza- this place did NOT disappoint. First of all service is pleasant and quick- I've gone when it wasn't busy so can't say anything about when it is. Ambiance wise, Inside there is a good amount of seating, it seems like you pay up front and sit down. They have pretty solid dessert options between the cannolis and gelato (haven't tried them yet but will definitely come around to doing so). They have the flour bags stacked up front and the ingredients they use- which I love to see because of the transparency of the business. I am surprised it hasn't been as busy when I've gone because this really is some solid thin crust, no flop, NY pizza. You can taste the freshness of the pizza sauce, cheese, dough, everything in every bite. I've had: -Buffalo Chicken slice: very decent and fresh buffalo chicken slice- packed with chicken and very generously dressed in a smooth blue cheese sauce. The only thing I will say is that it seemed a bit heavy on the sauce both buffalo and blue cheese sauce- felt it was a bit overwhelming. -Margherita Slice: wowwwwww!!! Such a SOLID margherita slice. The freshness of the tomato sauce was truly so apparent in every bite. And the balance of the fresh mozzarella and basil is a beauty. It feels light when you eat this and not heavy which to me speaks to the quality of the ingredients. -Grandma Vodka Slice: so delicious- I'm a sucker for a grandma vodka slice and this one was solid. Loved the ratio through and through. I've already been back multiple times since discovering this about a month ago- I hope this spot blows up and gets the recognition it truly deserves for its unique pizza. 5 stars!!

Sent the wrong order pizza wasn't good at all thanks for ruining our party not sure what everyone…read moreis getting here. Too doughy squares not enough sauce really not good. Four thumbs down. Two stars because we didn't get food poisoning.

Great Greek salad with chicken had generous portions. Served on a plate but I recommend they serve…read moreit in a bowl as it is but hard to manage on a plate. The tomato sauce on the pasta was fantastic. The meatballs although tender were not my favorite. Also calling a dish a meatball parm I expected it to be on a hero not meatballs with pasta. Maybe I didn't read the menu thoroughly I don't know. Anyway overall a good experience and would go back. Friendly staff. Small inside but clean and comfortable.

Great pizza at a great price. Just outside the Tanger outlets. My husband now looks forward to…read moreshopping. Wink wink!

I have read thru some of the reviews and I don't get it. Seems like the owner has had some issues…read morebut the food has never been In question. The food is incredible. I for one have never had any issue when I have gone here. I live down the road in deer park. There are many pizza spots by me but they do not even come close to Miseno. I never buy a pie we generally get the pre made slices they have and never been let down. The best thing outside of the food is my car smells like the pizza for my ride to worm the next day. I highly recommend the spot.

Pizza was average. garlic knots were below average. Price was above average. Experienced an…read moreattitude or she treats ALL customers that way..... No Smile... No Thank You... No change( had to ask for it).... No bag( had to ask for it). Walked out shaking my head..... "Kids" shouldnt be behind counter with attitudes serving the public spending good money.

Really solid pizza, nice people and very clean restaurant…read more We also got a chicken wrap with balsamic vinegar and it was great. Would definitely go back!

Amazing pizza, crispy and soft at the same time... insanely good prices too…read more The bbq chicken was my favorite aside from the pesto pizza... and I normally dislike pizza..

If I can give this place 0 stars, I would! First of all the staff is rude which is insane since our…read moreorder was almost $100. I also noticed at the restaurant that the guy making the pizza was touching money but never washed his hands. Then he proceeded to go back to playing with the dough! Anyway, we get home to find a piece of plastic and a hair in our pizza. When we called, the person on the phone acted shocked. This isn't the first incident we've had but we gave this place another shot since the pizza was somewhat decent. If my child would have gotten that plastic, we would've had bigger problems. I would never return or recommend anyone go here. Unsanitary practices in the front of the store, so I can't imagine what goes on in the back.

Had the pleasure to be able to stop and have an early dinner yesterday at Alitalia, we used to live…read morein West Babylon over 30 years ago and haven't been there since. We had a party of 4 and arrived at about 3pm, we didn't realize that the dining room didn't open till 4pm but they let us sit down in the dining room and we had to order from the counter which was no big deal. They did have a young lady in the dining room but she said she was not a waitress, this is just my opinion but they should let her wait on tables when something like this comes up so she can get the experience to become a waitress. Food was delicious, we all had different chicken dishes and all of us loved what we had. Prices were very fair. Definitely will be going back soon. They also do a pasta night and a chicken night the was very reasonable.

Pesto gnocchi is to die for, the spicy rigatoni sauce is so good it HAS to be mentioned, and their…read morecutlets are THE BEST in Huntington. It's hard to go wrong at a place like this the food is so damn good!

From 4 stars to 5. Best pizza around. Go get yourself some - too good!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!read more

They must have changed the sauce. Not that same, flavorless. The garlic knots look like they came…read morefrom a box. Not the same doughy homemade. Once loyal customer will not go back

Self proclaimed Pizza Snob here. Tried this place tonight for the first time. Been passing by for…read moremonths and finally stopped by. Firstly, the place is nice...neighborhood kind of place. Clean and well lit. The folks at the counter were friendly and helpful! Went against habit as I was craving a Tomato/cheese slice and glad I did. The slice was very warm, not blazing hot. I like it when it's very warm so I can enjoy it right away, which I did! The crust was crisp without being crunchy. The sauce, the most important part, was not overly sweet. The cheese was yummy without being salty. This was a very yummy slice indeed! Definitely going back and soon!