"One bite, everyone knows the rules!!!" Looking for something to eat while I watch Thursday night football. I see this little establishment in the strip mall just north of Washington St. & Rt.45. I'm a huge pizza enthusiast & love to try any pizza that's near me. The funny part is I've never heard of this place. So I walk in & the place looks presentable & clean. I'm met with a worker named Ton who answers my questions & takes my order. I couldn't really see any examples of how the pizza really looks from the menu. I ordered a 12 inch half & half pepperoni/ sausage. While I'm waiting there, I think to myself let me see how the reviews are which is too late at this point if they are bad since I already ordered lol. The reviews are horrible. So I ask Ton questions about the place. He tells me it's by new owners. That was a sign of relief for the most part. My pizza is finished finally & I take it home. When I opened the box, I was really shocked. It looked amazing. The edges were crispy but not too much. The perfect touch. The crust was crispy & crunchy but not too hard. The sauce & cheese was a perfect blend for all the flavors exploding! Now mind you some of their reviews were late or delivery complains so maybe they could work on that if that's their only problem. The taste & quality of the food is definitely not a complaint at all. "One bite, everyone knows the rules!!!" I would have to say with scoring it with surrounding pizza places, I'm giving it a 7.9, which is high compared to the other places in the area. The best part is Ton didn't know my feelings on the bad reviews until after he already had my pizza cooking so if you're reading this I don't want you to think my questions influenced him to make it with extra care. It was all made normal. Give this place a try!! Ton gives off the energy that if you had a problem, they would fix it. He's respectful & seems like he likes what he does. For the record, I ate the whole pizza lol! read more

Sarpino’s Pizzeria - Cheese, pepperoni, sausage pizza. Half & half. It was fire!!! - Pizza Near Me - Third Lake, Illinois

I am happy I discovered Sarpino's not too far from my house using the Slice app. They're not on Slice anymore, but they do have their own app now that is quite handy, with a good rewards program. I really love the marinara sauce at Sarpino's. Everything seems so fresh and top quality. I continue to spread the word and have had several friends who have also taken a liking to Sarpino's. read more

Sarpino’s Pizzeria - Margherita Pizza Margarita - Pizza Near Me - Third Lake, Illinois

The food is great! But I can't ever seem to order online or ever get a hold of anyone on the phone!!! Is anyone else having this same issue! This has been an ongoing thing for a few months now! They have a number ending in 5000 and another on 5009 and none give me anyone that answer! read more

I loved their hot honey pepperoni pizza! Perfect Thank you for the great pizza and service, and promptness! read more

Ordered at 7:00pm and it finally got delivered at 9:30 on a Monday night. . All three Pizza's came way over done, their bread was also overdone. Prices have become out of hand . We did receive a $3 coupon, but may be the last time we order from here. They were one of our go to places, but not anymore. Kids would rather have Little Caesar. read more

This guy doesn't pay his employees. Busted in 2015. Busted in 2021. An investigation conducted by the U.S. Department of Labor found Sarpino's Pizzeria owner, Julius Jokimas, owed $188,628 to 104 employees at three locations in Chicago, the agency said in a press release Monday. After Jokimas refused to cooperate, investigators with the agency's Wage and Hour Division obtained a subpoena to look at employees' pay records. In addition to the back wages that were recovered, Jokimas also received $75,504 in penalties for violating the Fair Labor Standards Act for the second time in six years, the agency said. The pizzeria was previously found to be in violation of the act in 2015. The investigation also determined Jokimas failed to maintain accurate payroll records. read more

Arguing with a customer over pizza he "prepared himself" This is not light baked, nor light on sauce and skimped on pineapples and onions itself tasted too well done. Definitely not using this place again. read more

See all

Ordered here three time so far. Perfect every time! I noticed the delivery was faster than the expected time, no complaints there! Ingredients had great flavor and the crust is perfectly crispy and buttery. They also have decent specials on their website...worth checking out if your ordering for a group. read more

Sarpino’s Pizzeria - Pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Third Lake, Illinois

AMAZING PIZZA 10/10, this was me and my familys first time ordering and i am NOT disappointed! We got a 16 inch Pepperoni and Mushroom pizza with a side of breadsticks and i gotta say.... BEST pizza joint in town, i recommend everyone go and at least try once because youll never regret it. Also had very good customer service! They really sold that smile! read more

The best thing I like about Sarpino's is that it's open super late and offers great substitutes when you aren't craving pizza. It also helps that they don't require a delivery fee , Even so TIP your Delivery drivers well !!!! read more

Sarpino’s Pizzeria - Hot and Spicy Buffalo Chicken Wings - Pizza Near Me - Third Lake, Illinois

Stayed at a friend's place in Gurnee after attending a football game at Northwestern. Didn't get back to the Gurnee area until after 11, so had an idea that food options would be limited. Searched by what pizza places were open and Sarpinos showed up. With good reviews backing them, I utilized the easy online ordering and headed their way for late night take out. Our pies were done and waiting. The pizzas were very good and hit the spot to feed 4 people. read more

I've had their wings and their pizza and both are very good! They tend to quote delivery times high, so if it says an hour, you can expect it faster :). On top of that, they have FANTASTIC customer service. A pizza got delivered and we thought we got the wrong order - turns out I had ordered the completely wrong thing. They delivered the pizza I meant to order within a half hour at no charge - and it was totally my mistake! We have been, and will continue to be, fans of Sarpinos! read more

This place isn't good, ordered a pizza at 11:40ish. App said delivery time between 12:50-1. Ended up not getting it till after 1:15. The pizza came cold and the breadsticks weren't even cut properly. I won't give my business to this place ever again read more

Waiting for Pizza and their employee wasn't even wearing a mask. I thought it was mandatory, when operating a business.

First time ordering delivery and it was a fail. Food is always great when dining in, that experience should also be the same when carrying out. read more

Sarpino’s Pizzeria - The entire sandwich had 2 pieces of meat, ridiculous! - Pizza Near Me - Third Lake, Illinois

See all

They have a wide variety of yummy looking pizzas to choose from (though I was slightly disappointed that some I wanted to try weren't available at this location). Super easy online ordering. Love the pizza tracker. Pizza was ready on time. We had a slight issue with a deal site coupon we tried to use - the worker had no idea how to handle it (my husband had to walk him through it) but it ended up fine. We got four pizzas - and they were all tasty, though we were disappointed with the Grecian Gyro which should have had Tzatsiki on/with it but came with marinara (?!). Overall we were happy with the taste and quality of the pizzas. I submitted online feedback about the two small issues...and was surprised when I received a personal response from the General Manager, apologizing for the confusion on both counts and offering me a free pizza for our inconvenience. It's customer service like this that makes me want to go back to a business...so we will be back. read more

I will never order again from here. This is the WORST pizza I have ever gotten... cheap frozen pizza would be better. Got a deep dish sausage pizza which was awful...the crust was overdone and burnt in places, there was barely enough cheese to cover the crust, the Italian sausage was not round little balls but looked like a different color bologna, and there was more marinara sauce than anything which interestingly enough was cold.it was not cut so make sure to ask for it to be cut as well. The tiramisu was frozen to point that I had to wait 20 minutes to eat it as a fork would not go through it. The only reason for the one star was the driver who messaged consistently and the person who refunded my money no questions asked... door dash did the same. if you want to throw your money away go here otherwise steer clear. Avoid at all costs. read more

I didn't receive parts of my order. The pizza had a few animal pepperoni mixed in when I ordered vegan pepperoni. So I couldn't eat it. The ranch and creamy garlic sauces were missing. The order was delivered to the wrong address. read more

Quick delivery, great pizza, sauce, and toppings. The crust is like my Nonna used to make! I will order from them again.

My friends and I wanted a pizza and the reviews on here were great. This is the worst pizza I've had in a really long time. I ordered a sausage and onion. The sausage looked very strange. Like flat footballs curled up. Very spicy. There were hardly any onions and the sauce is just nasty. Save your money, go to Lou Malnati's. This was like a Dominos or Papa John's but expensive. read more

Sarpino’s Pizzeria - Look at the nasty sausage! - Pizza Near Me - Third Lake, Illinois

I love their calzones! One of the best I've had. There pizza is okay. There cheesy bread isn't cheesy. It's just pizza dough baked with light over cooked cheese on top. All there "app" are just oven bake and have no flavor. Same with there chicken fingers. But they are always really nice when I call. There delivery is fairly fast. And 24/7. Which is awesome. read more

Sarpino’s Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Third Lake, Illinois

ROUNDEST pepperonis I've ever seen. Very symmetrical. Nice. Napkins were also soft and plentiful. Keep up the great work!

Love the pizza. I will always choose to eat here over y'all other pizza places in the area. A must have pizza

I love the pizza! I had struggled to find a "regular" pizza delivery place that we liked, but we finally did! I love how easy it is to order online and their delivery service is awesome! When you request "ASAP," it says it will take 45+ minutes, but we often get ours within 20. If you request a specific delivery time, they are within a couple minutes of that time! My whole family enjoys the food and have become regular customers! read more

We ordered 2 thin crust medium pizza's and the signature salad. The food was great and exceeded our expectations. The only complaint was the cost was a little high but nonetheless we will definitely be returning. read more

Easy online ordering and free delivery. Really tasty cheese and sauce, and the toppings seem very fresh. I like the breadsticks, especially with the garlic butter. The salads are super fresh and better than you would think coming from a pickup pizza place. I've found my new go to pizza in the area. read more

The pizza was fantastic. Great toppings well worth the money. Quick delivery also. FYI when ordering if you need silverware let them know. Would highly recommend read more

I like sarpino's gourmet pizza over any franchise pizza.Freshly made with fresh ingredients.Customer service is also good.Been to 30-40 different pizza places and this will be in my top 10. read more

Didn't appreciate the dry rub hot wings, no breading is awesome but I prefer liquid hot sauce. Not impressed with the garlic breadsticks, the seasoning is great but the breads as flat as a pancake and crispy like a McDonald's hashbrown. read more

I always order delivery and although it might take a while to recieve it never makes me question why ....the food is always hot and delicious ... I love the wings they are perfect . Great job sarpinos read more

This place is awful. Better off with DiGiorno! Honestly, don't waste your money...unless you want overpriced frozen pizza. Slow service. "Authentic Italian" pizza, made by Indians. Really??!! read more

Good pizza at a conparable price. Been here several times and the value is good, especially as order more food. Ordering online is easy.

Decided to try Sarpino's delivery. That part was great. It arrived early and the driver found my place without calling me. Everything was hot. Ordered a personal pizza, plain chicken wings, and mozzarella sticks. Rundown on the food, mozzarella sticks, wouldn't order again. Chicken wings are decent for the most part, they are moist (slightly greasy but not terrible). Was surprised by the pizza...ordered sausage, mushroom and olive. Didn't know the sausage was sliced (I prefer the other kind...wish I'd known that). I don't really eat a lot of pizza but when I do, I can be particular about it. The sauce on the pizza was very good. All in all, really decent. Now for the one bad thing I couldn't get past...the ranch dressing was terrible. Horribly thin, horribly acidic (was it really old & just completely broke down?) Make it fresh please or get a different vendor. Didn't like it one bit. If I'm going to order all of these things, they better have one amazing ranch dressing! read more

Amazing pizza! I got the primo capicollo and it was so good I couldn't stop eating it until it was all gone! The overall mix of seasoning was addictive. The cheesecake was worth it too. Also have to say their customer service was top notch. read more

The food was great! I love the hours we are on vacation it was a great choice very clean shop and the guys were very helpful and nice. Great service thanks read more

The pizza is tasty, and the delivery service is fast, but the drivers continue signing for my orders without my knowledge. I get an email confirmation with a signature that does not belong to me. This has never happened with other pizza places in the area-- I am always asked to sign. It's odd to receive an email thanking you for an order with a signature that does not belong to you! While the manager is quick to respond, this has happened several times, so I feel like my concerns aren't being taken seriously. I consider myself a very loyal customer, but we will be looking elsewhere for pizza because my concerns appear to just be getting shrugged off. read more

I must admit tho I like most dishes from Sarpinos their pizza was not my fav. I tried a new twist yesterday and loved it! Instead of ordering the standard pizza sauce I substituted marinara - YAY! So much better! Service, prices and an incredible rewards program continue to make Sarpinos a great choice (plus FREE delivery!) now, if they could make the "thin crust" just a little thinner . . . read more

Soooo good! It actually reminds me of the pizza from when I was in Italy! Another big plus is their HOURS! Thank you so much for always providing that 1am munch :) Get 25% off when you go check in there! Not bad at all, can't wait to get more! read more

Have ordered several times and picked up from restaurant. Really good for the price. Lots of good toppings. Be sure you use coupons!

Fast service, intriguing specials, and delicious pizza. I'll definitely be ordering from here again.