I'm not sure why the reviews are so bad...we went for a garbage plate. The weather was snowy and cold so Sal's was close. I was craving the local delicacy. Ok the price has come up a bit...I think it was $44 for 2 plates. Two cheeseburger plates with mac salad, home fries, fresh onion and seasonings. It's a small place so if you're dining in seating is limited. We grab a table and open the Pepsis. Phone is ringing and people are picking up sandwiches, pizzas, plus other food. It's more of a takeout place. In a bit the plates arrive. Definitely what I was craving. Home fries are crispy, burgers (thick burgers) are cooked to perfection, mac salad and the rest is good. Not the original but going downtown was not practical with the snow covered roads and distance. Sal's is very good if you need your fix. read more

Salvatore's Old Fashioned Pizzeria - Two cheese burger plate with all the fixings. - Pizza Near Me - Honeoye Falls, New York

Not sure why this Salvatore's (Honeoye Falls) is so bad. Every time we've ordered, the food is overcooked and dry. Half the time they don't put the right toppings/sauces on the order. I just don't get it, I thought because it being a decent franchise it'd be better. We've really tried with this place but seeing the other reviews, I guess I'm not the only one. read more

Salvatore's Old Fashioned Pizzeria - Chicken cordon bleu is dry, overcooked and tasteless. - Pizza Near Me - Honeoye Falls, New York

See all

Purchased a large sheet pizza and it was baked to perfection with tons of pepperoni! Nice job and highly satisfied.

I was in the area and needed to grab a bite before heading back to NYC so I decided to get 2 slices. The staff was really friendly and recommended me a specialty pizza (I forgot the name of it.) I got the pizza she suggested and it was really good. I loved the crust, and the flavor was great. I sat in their outdoor seating area, located on their sidewalk, and I noticed that they have multiple delivery cars. They had so many deliveries during the time I was there, and I see why because their pizzas look so good and the one I had was yummy! I also loved their pink pizza boxes. read more

See all

My pizza and wings were delivered in a 40 minute window which was good but the cheese and pepperoni on the pizza was way over cooked and the chicken wings were dressed but very dry. I made up some wing sauce and dressed them myself. Somehow, their quality and quality control has really gone down hill. read more

I DIDNT LIKE AT ALL!!! I was there a few weeks ago and the kid on the phone was seriously rude to me! He straight up cussed me out over asking for a discount! I ordered some boneless wings and they came to $20+!!! And then they tasted TERRIBLE! Like rubber! And the store itself was far too loud. Never again. read more

I'd go with zero stars if it was at all possible. We waited over an hour for our pizza order (pick up), got home to find it was not what was ordered, called and the knucklehead that answered really could care less. Honestly Im thrilled- never particularly cared for their pizza but my wife always insisted...but now that's done. read more

Online website states that the superslice is 1/4 of a large pizza. I ordered it for myself and my husband come to find out they are two very small slices. Ended up going to another pizza place in town read more

Went in today and the girl making the pizzas was not wearing a mask over her nose. Several other employees (including one who seemed to be a manager) were chatting with her while I waited for my order and none of them told her to fix her mask. It was clear she wears it that way intentionally. They are putting their customers lives at risk. I wanted to support a local business by ordering take out but they are reckless and are going to kill someone! read more

Salvatore's has good pizza, and very good Buffalo style chicken wings. The best part is that the food is consistently good and almost always ready when they say. read more

Salvatore's Old Fashioned Pizzeria - the sign - Pizza Near Me - Honeoye Falls, New York

Sara Price We ordered from HONEOYE FALLS tonight and the pizza was burnt and the wings were like leather.Well Done does not mean BURNT. How about a little consistency. I love spending $30 for a pizza and wings and only being able to stomach 1 slice..... Like Reply 2 minutes ago read more

Great pizza place, I guess this is a chain. 4 or 5 other locations... Anyway, very small place, with very reasonable prices. 4 tables inside, but we ordered takeout. They had a TV which we watched while we waited. Service was respectful and took our order quickly upon arrival: 2 large pizzas, one plain, one with meat. They even had their own napkins. So different from a pizza place in NYC or on Long Island. The restaurant itself is plain and lacks decor. Needs to be more vibrant. After 15-20 minutes, which was a reasonable waiting time, we took out our pizzas. Great pizza with so much flavor. Very interesting look and slicing method, unlike any one I have ever seen. Meat was tender and delicious. The neighborhood spot for sure, despite no Yelp reviews... read more

the customer service is horrible, the younger people working seem really rude. every time i go there my food is either burned or just completely wrong. this is the only salvatores i've been to that messed up so much it's like the management simply does not care read more

Trashiest corporate pizza place I've ever been too! Food is so greasy and taste absolutely disgusting, order the cheddar broccoli soup, it was so thick and salty was like someone melted a block of cheese and added salt read more

Just had the soggiest pizza I ever ate. Called back to let them know and received a brief apology but nothing to make it right. Won't be back for a long time. read more

I had a steak sub the other night and again it looked like the meat is just shoved in the bread. There is no TLC when it comes to making subs. Also, I noticed that one of the workers did not wear gloves when she added onions to one of their plates. After the food is cooked, you should really wear gloves. I was really grossed out. She was the one who also cut my sub, presumably without gloves. I would not recommend this place. read more

Salvatore's in Honeoye Falls has inconsistent food quality and terrible service. We called for Pizza on Halloween night, got put on hold for five minues and then the line disconnected. So we called back and was put on hold again for five minutes and again the line disconnected. So we called back a third time, told the young, brainless girl who answered for the third time that we did not want to be put on hold again because we waited forever and kept getting disconnected, and she said "Duh, it Halloween, the busiest night of the year for us, so you are just going to have to hold again." Needless to say, we did not hold but instead hung up and called Guida's Pizzeria. They picked up on the second ring, took our order immediately and told us it would be ready in 20 minutes. Good-bye Salvatore's and Hello Guida's!! Never again will Salvatores get any business from us - good-bye and good riddance! read more