Rhonda helped me find the perfect gloves to finish my costume. I was looking for black vintage…read morecotton day gloves, and she instead steered me toward a pair of kid leather that "fit like a glove", literally. I have small hands, but as most people know true vintage runs VERY small compared to current sizes. These gloves completed my costume and I went on to win "Best Overall Costume at the Clarke Very Victorian Tarot & Tea Party". This shop is hard to find, you can't see it from the street, so look for The Pub restaurant located in the Creamery building/ Arcata Play house. The store is behind the restaurant down a little alley. Amazingly low prices for the quality you get. Going there is like a treasure hunt!

Everytime I talked with the owner, Jane, and staff, I have had excellent service and great ideas…read morefrom them when I cannot make a choice of my own. They all are extremely helpful. I highly recommend this store based on the great customer service and awesome selection of clothing, shoes, and so much more!

A couple of weekends ago I, a mixed-race Black woman, went into the shop while wearing casual…read moreclothes. The employee that day asked me several times if I needed help, when I clearly didn't, and seemed to be hovering hear me as I went through the store. Their attitude was very suspicious of me, and made me extremely uncomfortable. I left when I could no longer stand the type of attention being paid to me. The other time I've been in this shop recently, I was with a white friend who was dressed quite well, and we were left to our own devices.

I always stop here when I visit Eureka. I love their merchandise with a caveat. I need to buy…read morenatural materials due to allergies especially to chemicals and yet all their natural high quality Aran wool are drenched with fragrances. Why? I can buy chemically crap anywhere. Please put these away from entrance and fitting rooms in a closed glass cabinet. They can be prominent without ruining the beauty of natural clean materials. I would love and appreciate seeing such a change.

Cool place to go if you need a costume or some costume jewelery. They have all kinds of novelty…read moreitems that you will never find anywhere else!

Good selection. But hours are wrong on Yelp (the sign on the door says closed on Wednesdays) so I…read moreencourage the business to update their hours for their customers.

Mermaids rejoice! Your creative sister opened this amazing gallery of ocean inspired art just for…read moreyou. From the ultimate sandal/flip flop "Third Oak" made of mostly recycled material, and the company will recycle or make you a new pair when you wear them out! To original marine inspired artwork sewn or silk screened onto the most comfortable and hip beach attire. This small artist boutique is artfully packed with original gems you will not find anywhere else. Driftwood earring holders, beautiful ceramic succulent bowls, and essential oils. Make sure you swing thru this place while visiting the creamery district.

We love marnie and all of her wonderful, local treasures! Her store has a very unique and lovely…read morefeel to enjoy while shopping.

Stoped in the other day and I did get an inexpensive gift for myself; It's a cute shop and they…read morehave an amazingly diverse selection with good prices. But as someone who is younger I felt judged based on the vocabulary she used when I asked to look at higher end pieces. I will say I dress quite nicely and have a background in minerals, faceting, and jewelry but felt discouraged and disrespected when trying to hold a conversation about products they sell.

Great variety of shoes and purses. Store is always freezing, though, so wear a coat. Mixed customer…read moreservice. Recently a clerk went to look for a shoe and didn't come back to tell me they didn't have. During sales the store gets very crowded but there are not enough clerks. Rewards program is a plus.

Pretty cute! Glad they hang show posters in the window, it…read moregot me to come in. They have a sweet $1 bin where i saw a $100 retail skirt! Wild. They also had some cool costume hats and leggings :) Also fancy novelty socks, misc jewelry, and glittery cat paintings!

Yesterday, 6/18/24, my daughter and I were wandering around old town Eureka & we stumbled upon this…read moreamazing shop. This is a place you could easily spend hours in discovering treasures. The selection is truly impressive, from literal Victorian clothing, to 1970's disco jumpsuits. My daughter found a gorgeous dress with a black tulle skirt and red satin rhinestone embellished sash for only ten bucks! But the real star of the show was the girl who worked there & I wish I'd gotten her name. She had short dark hair & was the sweetest, most wonderful young woman. She couldn't have known how much her kindness mattered, but it did. We have just moved here & my daughter is having a tough time, worrying about whether or not she'll fit in or be happy here. This salesperson was precisely the kind of person my daughter admires and we talked briefly about anime and video games and...maybe it didn't seem like much to her, but it meant a lot to us. We will certainly be back. Often.

Lady at the register was extremely rude when going through a consignment process. I tried to…read moreeither consign or donate. She was constantly rolling her eyes while looking through the merchandise and making groaning noises while doing so. I felt terrible for even bringing clothing in. Made comments about if I would bring winter clothes in, when it was actually winter, maybe she would consider. I took my clothes and donated them to Eco Groovy in Arcata. The people are very nice there and were willing to accept the huge bag of clothing, and entire bag of brand-new jeans for little girls with no issues what-so-ever, and didn't make me feel like a complete idiot for doing so!

Great selection and good location (right in town). I am partial to second hand stores and this one…read morehas a great selection of women and children's clothing (as well as kids toys) I was able to find some things for myself and the kids in my life and I didn't break the bank doing so. Everyone is always helpful and willing to assist if you have questions or need assistance.

Great vintage finds in great condition, great prices, great people working there. A super positive…read moreall-around experience. Plus, a beautiful sunshiny girl was tryin on a dress that was absolutely dynamite on her and all the women gathered to gas her up.

When to buy some more clothes and complemented the guy ringing me up since he was wearing a nice…read morecowboy hat and he gave me the most petty reply oof.