Even after a complete remodel/renovation...the new staff can't seem to make MTO subs that are…read morephysically edible. A half sub with no extra condiments/addons should not look like a shotgun was used to apply the contents of said sub. What I received was an open faced MESS that I immediately returned. Get some training in there on how to make a normal sub.

Wrong orders, burnt food, missing food items when ordering , workers have no clue what they are…read moredoing , they are focused on distractions

Coming from an area with Wawa I expect a lot out of my convenience stores. However, this Turkey…read moreHill did not meet my expectations. When I came in I said hello to the clerk, but received no response. After that, I got a couple of granola bars and a drink. I found both of those items easily as the store was nicely spaced. However, the nice spacing does not make up for the limited food options. For example, they don't have any areas where you can order a fresh sandwich, but rather a selection of pre-made items. They also had an icee machine, but it did not look like it was frequently cleaned as dirty cups were lying around the machines. This Turkey Hill sells gas as well, but don't expect anything quick as it is usually packed with guests from Hershey Park.

I luv th in palmyra pa. Chase Angel Marc Holly Laurie Rob Mark are the BEST. The mgr Kevin I think…read moredoes a great job. Btw I love the new coffee machines. Better than SB. Going to miss Rob who just got promoted

This is what they call a legacy store. It is old, tired and smaller than the new shiny stores. It's…read morenot new and fancy. It's the kind of store you might drive by and never give a second thought. However, it would be shame to do so. I stopped here out of necessity, not necessarily choice, and I was amazed. This store is clean! Outside trash cans were clean and empty. Parking lot was picked up and well marked. The restrooms were shiny, clean and sanitary. The coffee bar was neatly and completely stocked with a great variety of options and flavors. Every coffee was fresh and selections were numerous. The coffee bar was clean. The coolers were clean, floors were clean, and shelves were fronted and well stocked. The manager was there and I complimented her on her hard work. She and another employee explained how they take pride in their store and in the safety of their food service. Their thoughts were genuine and borne out of a desire to provide quality food service to their customers. Though this store is a chain convenience store, it is run with the pride and care congruent with a family business. If you are a fan of Turkey Hill, this is one worth putting on your list of places to shop.

Those poor employees!They looked so frazzled with the manager. Reminds me of a micronarssacistread more

Every single time I come in here everyone is always welcoming. Never had a problem. Love the…read moreupdates to the store as well.

My mother was verbally assaulted there by a man blocking the gas pumps. She did not have her phone…read moreon her and ran into the store for help. The cashier refused to call the police or demand that the man leave the premise. The aggressive man eventually did leave, but returned as my mother was fueling her vehicle and continued his abuse. Ultimately, my mother stopped fueling out of fear and left.

waited 20 minutes for a hotdog that i ordered online. no sense of urgency with 5 other orders being…read morein queue.

Asked for street tacos and got sewer tacos i wanted cheese and onions on them mfs not cheese and…read morejalepenos are yall that fuckin incompetent???

store always clean, friendly staff, always running specials just ask the staff. Food fresh and…read morealways available. Great deals on cigarettes and OTP.

On 10/14/25, I ordered food totaling $28.87, mostly chicken, and the four pieces of chicken were…read moreseverely overcooked and bone dry and hard, and inedible. Very disappointed, won't be returning!

Great employee here should be recognized and rewarded I…read morethink her name tag said Marli Always helpful Always kind Always above and beyond treatment of customers She should be rewarded for her exemplary work

This Rutter's is right there on the main road between MD and York, and is a decent convenience…read morestore to pick up some snacks and some of that expensive PA gas. We were hoping to pick up some eggnog for the holidays but I did not even spot an empty slot in the case even though there was a sign on the door. Horrors, they were out of a standard item, which I guess makes them like every convenience store everywhere. They are pretty spacious with a decent selection of chips, soda, and hot sandwiches. I was pleased they had an M&T ATM inside, so, yeah, convenient.

This place has everything and the friendliest staff. Fantastic, hot food and alcohol selection as…read morewell. Crazy amount of moonshine that's all delicious.

I stop here twice a year at least on my trip from Richmond, VA to Duanesburg, NY and back again…read more You pulled me in with the deli. Now this year both going and coming the deli was not opened on time. When one is looking forward to fresh food it is disappointing to be told the deli worker said they would be late. And rather than sympathizing with me the clerk was short with me and said well that's life. I guess it is. I'll be finding another location to stop in the future. Weekend travelers need food too!