A treasure hunt with charm and value…read more Penny Wise Consignment is one of those places where you walk in "just to browse" and somehow leave with a bag full of finds you didn't know you needed. The shop is well‑organized without losing that fun, treasure‑hunt energy that makes consignment shopping so addictive. Clothing, accessories, home goods--everything feels curated enough to be worth your time, but still priced like a true local gem. What really sets Penny Wise apart is the staff. They're friendly, patient, and genuinely invested in helping you find something that fits your style or your home. There's a sense of loyalty and community here--you can tell regulars come back not just for the deals, but for the people. Inventory rotates often, which keeps things fresh, though it also means you've got to be quick if you spot something great. A little more space or updated displays would push this place into five‑star territory, but honestly, the charm is part of the appeal. If you love good value, unique pieces, and a shop that feels like it's run with heart, Penny Wise is absolutely worth the stop. Enjoy

The best thrift store in this town, with lots of clothes, handbags, THE SHOES OMG (got a pair)…read more Lots of named brands items like Michael Kors, Kate Spade, and entire table of Tory Burch, I spent $100 & came home with lots of summer attire. Loved this place

This store is great! They may not have exactly what you were looking for if at all. If your looking…read morefor that weird screw, bilge fitting, light fixture, this is your spot! Want actual nautical decor for your patio or beach house? This is also your spot. Set aside some time go in and poke around. You will be surprised.

Cool cool store with all things water related. There are used and new items, boating paraphernalia,…read moredecorations, lanterns, fishing gear and lots lots more! Relatively small space lacking any real organization, but so fun to maneuver and move things and discover something you never knew you needed or wanted. Went with a friend you said she so wished she had known about this in her boating and fishing heydays. It is worth a stop!

This shop is the go-to for denim and cashmere! The owner/buyer has carefully selected the best…read moredesigner denim (KUT, Big Star, AG, Etienne Marcel) in a multitude of styles and stocks the largest inventory of alluring cashmere I've seen in one spot, ever. Her antique displays are filled with soft tees, leather belts, vegan handbags, artisan jewelry, tasteful baby/kid wear and so much more. She also carries a Massachusetts painter's truly inspired work - which she can't keep from selling off the walls. Keep an eye on their faceboook page for the launch of their shoppable website.

I've been meaning to post this for a while now but decided after a recent shopping visit to Hope…read moreand Stetson, it was time! Mystic has been in dire need of a store like Hope and Stetson. They sell high end denim, such as Seven, Miss Me, Hudson, True Religion, Joes, Citizens of Humanity, Paige and more. I always visit them for my jeans needs but end up finding much more. There are great dresses for summer time and amazing cashmere year round. I recently got a cute dress for a wedding and received so many compliments on it. I always go there for baby shower and children's gifts, too. It's a perfect place to pick up a gift for a friend, of any age. The accessories (artisan jewelry, scarves, vintage looking belts, and bags) is awesome. The people that work there are friendly, helpful, and I'm so happy Mystic FINALLY has such a great store!

When you first walk in, you are greeted by Pigeon, the friendly shop dog. The clothing is organized…read moreby size ranges, type of clothing, and color. Each item has a personally scripted price tag that tell you about the article of clothing. It lists the decade it originates from and the designer. It also tell you the size it actual fits, even if the original clothing tag disagrees, and a bust size which is so helpful since vintage clothing doesn't usually have the same stretch as modern pieces. She carries pieces in all sizes. I saw XS through 5X in the store with more than one each. the prices seemed very reasonable for what you were purchasing. The store smelled and appeared clean. the owner welcome me in and then let me shop- no hounding or frequent inquiries. I don't find anything for myself today, but I was charmed by her shop and mission. I wish I was local so I could peruse regularly.

Let me set the scene, it's a super cute and small building. You see a pride flag and a pun on the…read moresign. Already two green flags. You walk in with a jingle-jangle and a you see large windows on the right. Lined with vintage shoes and boots from the 50's to the 00's. Colored coded clothes; rainbow satisfaction on left. Long dresses, blouses, and skirts arranged together. You see Punk Masc or Rock Masc on a little chalkboard sign and see 60's and 80's dresses, pants, blazers, and patterned button ups galore underneath. Everything is organized very well. The back has a clothing rack with sale items on it. Great choices. So pretty. Right next to it is a maker bin, it's a bin of items that need a little love and TLC. You wanna practice adding buttons, sewing or wanna find some awesome fabric? This is your place. Such a good vibe and the person working was so kind and patient.

What a unique store! Perfect for Christmas gifts!! The customer service and gift wrapping was…read moreamazing. DEFINITELY make this a stop on your way to Mystic.

Not my kind of place, but my wife liked it. We spotted it on Yelp and decided to stop. Lots of…read moreinteresting and unique items. Would recommend only for women or perhaps men who like to decorate (ahem). We bought a dried out starfish and some silver tea lights for my mother in law. See my profile for more information on how I rate stores. A 3.5 to 4 star establishment.

Not really sure Not really that much of a selection. But very cute store but if you have…read moresomething in mind you might find something to interest you

Thank God for this place right before Christmas. picked up some novelty items that made think of…read morecertain people & helped me wrap up the rest of my shopping. but even better both my children are into record players & vinyl records & i was able to pickup some 70's/80's artists. right next to Rose Dairy & a pub across from yhe old Everybodys. prices reasonable.

I had been searching for a Georgian Giardinetti Ring for some time…read more After some strange goings on with Ebay uk, I decided to google Giardinetti Ring. A beautiful example came up on the Petra Star website. I called Dimitria and had a great conversation with her about the ring. She let me know if I wasn't happy, she would gladly accept a return. I agreed to buy the ring, and she let me know if she sent it by fedex, I wouldn't have to pay the sales tax. How great! I received the ring which is amazing and beautiful. I am a very happy customer. Dimitria made it so easy and pleasant.

Extremely professional. It's been such a please to have been working with Dimitria. I have…read moretrusted her with my estate pieces and with updating the designs. I look forward to continue working with her.