Beautiful front room, but not as fancy as expected. Most patrons are seated in the side room. Excellent pasta, mediocre pizza. Shrimp was not fully pink/cooked. No olive oil on our table for our bread. Pasta was delicious; but everything else fell flat. read more

Cool spot in Telluride - excellent service and nice dining room. The food was overall good (margarita pizza was top-notch), but on the pricey end of the scale for what you get. Probably to be expected for a remote mountain town. read more

My daughter and he fiancee had dinner here on Friday last week. The place we chose was closed do to a private event, so we went here. They were quite busy, but we were seated in about 2 minutes. Did the soups; minestrone and red lentil soup for the wife. Ordered a pizza and 2 glasses of an Italian red to drink with the margarita pizza. Was stellar. Decided to do desert as well. It was over the top. Meal was SO good, we got a pizza to snack on later that evening. Was not cheap, but also not expensive. Great value IMO. It capped off a GREAT day! A wine list to literally die for. This entrepreneur is doing EVERYTHING right. read more

Service was good and attentive, beef carpaccio was average but good and I had the veal carciofi for my main which appeared close to Piccata but has artichoke hearts and didn't mention lemon. One of my favorite dishes is veal piccata which is not on menu but most good Italian restaurants that already have veal on menu will accommodate but I was told no. So, I got creative and I had artichoke hearts held off asked for a little extra lemon and ended up with a good piccata. Would have given 5 stars if they would have just said no problem rather than not accommodating from the start. read more

This was our favorite meal in Telluride! We ordered the Risotto with shrimp and veal. Not a bite was left ! They brought out one wrong entree but fixed it quickly! And didn't charge us for one glass of wine! 10 stars!!! read more

See all

Best bread and pizza ever! Pasta was good but not tons of flavor. Cozy vibe and great fireplace.

My wife and I sat at the bar and split the mushroom risotto and the tiramisu which were both authentic and fantastic. The risotto was 10/10 even for the mushroom haters in the world (trust me I was one for most of my life). The service was impeccable with a knowledgeable bartender/server. Oh and all of this takes place is one of the coolest looking restaurants in Telluride. And it's right next to my favorite place in the city. read more

Best thing of the was the bread we had to ask for and received half way thru the meal. mushroom veal was Basic simple gravy with mashed potatoes. Chicken was surprisingly dry. Cheese pizza for the kids was large but lacked flavor. Very disappointed!! Service was better than the meal. read more

The food is outstanding, always! We are locals and this restaurant has never let us down. The service is authentic and fast, they know how to please!! I wish I could give more than 5 stars! read more

the service was great but the food so bad. extremely , abourdely expensive. I really felt angry leaving the place for the bill we paid. 18 dollars to add chicken to a salad... read more

This place is much bigger than I thought it was. Service was decent but I would highly recommend the cream sauce with the fettuccine and mushrooms and add the chicken. Very delicious. Would not recommend the calamari. They tasted like rubber bands. I would still give it for a star is because of the pasta with cream sauce. read more

See all

Look s like a high end Italian restaurant! Great bartender with an Irish accent.. the food was average and my wife's $55/$59 fish entree had a old fish smell across the table The tomato salad was skimpy read more

Great food and reasonable price in telluride. We sat at the bar and the bartender was very attentive. Delicious espresso martini read more

Terrible. Food is insanely overpriced for pasta that is store bought, not fresh and served lukewarm. Pasta sauce is from a jar at best. $37 for 10 plain cheese ravioli's for a kids meal! And when I say plain they were not even salted. Save your money and go Clark's or the village market... We love the national, kanazhaba, Floradora, etc... so plenty of great spots this was just a big expensive disappointment! Really sad for being in a great location in telluride... read more

Dinner was excellent from beginning to end. Calamari crispy with tentacles, yummy Caesar Salad with big pieces of parm. The pasta was on point. Dessert perfect. Will be back. read more

Yum! My husband and I ate at Rustico for our 1st wedding anniversary when we were visiting and it was delicious. We got the rigatoni alla montanara and rigatoni alla grappa, both were delicious. We were seated outside and it was beautiful. Adam was our server and made the dinner all the more enjoyable. He has a fun personality, was respectful and prompt. He also treated us to bruschetta and limoncello for our anniversary - so thoughtful! Thank you, Adam! We had the tiramisu for dessert and it was delicious! We will return next time we visit! read more

Mediocre food at outrageous prices. They've got the ambience down but that's the extent of a real Italian experience. The restaurant looks the part and it sounds like the part as a lot of their staff are Italian. Once the food comes out, the gig is up. The cream of mushroom soup tasted like NOTHING. No hint of any kind of seasoning. I got the arugula salad with grilled shrimp and it was a bed of arugula with three overly cooked shrimp and a lump of goat cheese. Creme Brûlée was the worst I've ever had. The caramelized layer wasn't even crispy. Jaw dropped when we got the bill. read more

food took forever. 1hr before we got an appetizer. we had to ask for it. food wasn't good and was cold. manager said they'd comp the meal for the wait and they didn't comp even one item. in fact, they double charged us for something. read more

In Telluride for a few days and wanted a nice dinner on a Wed night. Didn't want to walk too far and didn't want bar food. Had a nice dinner at Rustico. Solid Italian food, the veal my wife had was amazing. My pizza was good (but I am a massive pizza person and make 9 out of 10 Neapolitan pizza at home, so I am a super tough judge.) Definitely good Italian food. Service was outstanding. read more

See all

We were very lucky to get a table on July 4th! The atmosphere was relaxing and the service fantastic. We ordered the bruschetta as a starter and 4 tiny pieces came out. At a cost of $14.50, I expected both a larger portion and a more flavorful dish. It was just tomatoes with EVOO on toast. I was not very hungry so I ordered the caprese salad as an entree and it was the same thing. No flavor at all. It did come with balsamic on the side but this would have been better with a balsamic reduction. I don't recommend ordering this. My friends all had pasta and raved about it. I guess I ordered poorly but they were blown away by the rigatoni, sea food pasta and how perfect they were. The desserts were also baller. The Tiramisu was light, fluffy and perfect. The apple tart with gelatos was also a hit. If you come here, stick to the Italian staples and go for pasta and desserts! read more

See all

Personally I think this is the best place to eat in telluride but definitely the best Italian around. I have family here and have been visiting for years and we always come here. For some reason locals never recommend rustico to tourists but it's so amazing. Marat the waiter is so incredibly kind. I love the pizza, mushroom pasta but any pasta really. All their wines are amazing. I've never had anything I didn't love here. Such a nice ambience very romantic. Love dining outside in the summertime. read more

Rustico Ristorante - a plate of pasta and a pizza - Italian Near Me - Telluride, Colorado

See all

Coming from an Italian background I would give the food a 0 out of 10. Food was very bland and the sauce tasted very watered down and from a can. Not authentic. Very disappointing. The restaurant was very well designed and staff was friendly. read more

Service is amazing however... The food is very bland I had the Caesar salad, Veal Ossobuco, Calamari and the Rigatoni. No flavor and small portion sizes for Italian food. Wouldn't recommend read more

B-/C+. Don't always judge a book by its cover. Italian workers, cool mountain vide mixed with authentic Italian, Italian owner, Italian food and menu with Italian language. But food came out too quick which was a red flag. But presentation was good. Food tasted sub-par from expectations. Could have made it just as good at home with quality ingredients. Had sausage rigatoni. read more

I love how amazing the flowers look hanging outside of the restaurant. It is picture worthy. If you eat there for lunch the patio looks like a lovely place to eat! We stopped in after 8 PM to grab dinner because it wasn't too crowded inside. I know they have heaters outside but it was still a little chilly for us. We opted to sit at a booth near the bar since that was the warmest area. We shared a bunch of food. Calamari- I loved that they have the tentacles in here. I didn't taste the citrus vinaigrette but it was still very tasty and we enjoyed it. Cesar Salad- It was good but left a little something to be desired. Maybe more dressing or a bit for garlic. Still very good. Caprese Salad- I think that was the least tasty dish we ordered. IT just lacked flavor. The tomatoes were ripe and the cheese was good but it needed more flavor to it. Maybe we should have added more balsamic dressing to it but it wasn't the tastiest. Mushroom Risotto- Excellent flavor throughout the entire dish! I loved how the truffle oil was present but didn't take over the dish! There were a good amount of mushrooms in the dish as well. Even though we were sharing the dish I may have eaten the majority of the dish! :) Chocolate Espresso Mousse- Really delicious! I wish it was bigger since we were sharing it! (I tend to like my mousse a bit thicker but that is just me it is a great dessert!) Service- Fast! There were many servers who brought dishes and if we needed anything extra! read more

See all

Oh boy, what a disappointment this place turned out to be for our family to spend one of our few precious evenings together! Of all the restaurants we ate at (breakfast, lunch and dinner) in Telluride, this restaurant was our least favorite and the biggest disappointment during our Christmas vacation there.. Why, sub-par food, especially the pastas, cold and lumpy, (pizza was quite good) and ridiculously poor service, after the waiter realized we only had 4 alcohol drinkers on a table of 8. I must say the 4 who did drink ordered an $80 bottle of wine and several beers thereafter. The place was 60% full (a clue? during the holidays?) and we noticed our server switched off when we declined the second bottle of wine he was recommending. Thereafter he did not inquire about our food, our table was not cleared for 20-25 minutes after we completed our dinner (again the place was not full and there were plenty of wait staff) and I had to ask the maitre d to please clear the table so we could order desert. The desert menus came another 10-15 minutes after the request from our waiter, and were tossed on the table! we were somewhat perplexed as to what his problem was except greed, we really felt all he cared about was the final tab and his tip! when he finally came to ask for our order in another 10-15 minutes (we had two young adults with us 12, 15), we declined and here's the clincher, which has prompted me to write this very specific review, despite our host reaching out for the bill, he gave the bill to one of our younger female guests. Again, poor etiquette from a greedy waiter. Never again will we go to this terrible establishment. Our most amazing experiences were at The butcher & the baker (lunch, coffee & deserts) Allred's -Gondola Station, (lunch, spectacular ambiance, views & service), Timber Room, Brown Dog Pizza, to name a few. read more

Best restaurant I have ever experienced in Telluride. I've been coming to this town for 7 years and finally tried this place. ABSOLUTELY AMAZING. Adam, our server, made the best recommendations. He coursed our meal out perfectly and just brought the best energy. The pasta is in my top 5, even competing with 5 star places in Europe. I will be coming back here every time I visit moving forward. So happy this place exists in Telluride. 10/10. Amazing. read more

Who is giving all these 5 star reviews? We decided to eat here because we did not have reservations and got into town late and wanted a quick bite. Started with the bruschetta appetizer. As you can see on the picture this was barely a sampling. While the tomatoes had a nice freshness to them, the bread was not toasted and the juice made it mushy like a wet sponge. It also lacked seasoning as the garlic and basil were imperceptible. So basically chopped tomatoes on white bread for $14.50. Main course was pasta. My wife had the mushroom fettuccine. Pasta cooked properly, nicely al dente but where are the mushrooms?! As you can see there was about 5 slivers in the whole dish. Pasta and sauce for $27. I made the mistake of ordering the pasta "special"; spinach ravioli stuffed with chicken. I had about 10 ravioli and I swear that it was salmon and not chicken. "Stuffed" was a loose description since there was such a small amount I cannot tell you what meat was in there. The real kicker was that when the bill came I saw that the "special" was $38. The only thing special was the rip-off. With our cocktails our bill came to $168 after standard tip (service was fine, not the waiters fault we got ripped off). If you like paying $30 for $2 in food costs this is the place for you, otherwise just get a pizza at Brown Dog next door. read more

Rustico Ristorante - Italian Near Me - Telluride, Colorado

See all

We didn't have a reservation but the host indicated they had an hour and 15 min opening. We took it. Service was excellent and fast and food was delightful. Hubby had the veal on the bone and I had the thinly sliced veal with artichoke. The meat was so tender and had a very pleasurable experience. read more

See all

This place is great! Atmosphere is chill and the staff is also really friendly. They know what they're doing and what they're talking about. The food was tasty. I had the sea bass & my son had the margarita pizza. They were also very accommodating to my friend who is vegan. We enjoyed our dinner and will definitely come back on our next visit! read more

Rustico Ristorante - Pizza Margherita - Italian Near Me - Telluride, Colorado

Loved this restaurant. They are easy to reach. A live person promptly answers the phone. Service was very good and the food was delicious! Their signature rigatoni was exceptional. We were glad we sampled their gelato with a side of their almond cookies. We enjoyed their spacious covered outside seating. There is plentiful indoor seating for those that prefer the indoors. Would recommend a dinner at Rustico's. read more

What happened?? I remember the food being so good but tonight, I was so disappointed. My pasta had such little sauce, I would say, dry. I asked for more sauce and I was brought some marinara that could not have had less flavor. I made reservations so far in advance because I was so excited to eat here but will likely not return. I would suggest getting the elk bolognese at Smuggler's, so much better and lots of flavor. read more

Rustico is always on our list of restaurants to visit when in Telluride. They have fresh, tasty Italian food, good wines, and gelato! What else could you want? I absolutely love their patio when the weather is nice - and they're even dog friendly! My husband and I came in with our pup for lunch on our visit and had a tasty experience. I had their cabbage and mushroom salad to start and it was simple, yet so flavorful. I loved how fresh is tasted. For my entree, I ordered their pizza with ricotta, pepperoncinis, and mushrooms. It was so tasty and had just the right amount of spice. It normally comes with prosciutto as well but I opted out of the meat. The restaurant is HUGE and would be a great place for a large party or private event. Most places in Telluride are on the smaller side so this is truly a gem if you're looking to host a lot of guests. When we were there, it looked like they may have been setting up for a wedding reception on their patio. How cool is that? Anyways, if you're looking for fresh, authentic Italian food while visiting Telluride, this is your spot! It doesn't disappoint. read more

See all

First rate Italian restaurant with high end traditional fare. Pricey for Italian but worth it. So popular they added a large tent covered patio, very pleasant on a rainy night. Reservations a must. We had an excellent veal, over pounded but scrumptious taste. The accompanying spinach had a tangy vinaigrette coating, a very welcome upgrade from the usual over saturated garlic that's typically served in Italian spots. We also had the shrimp risotto with three very large prawns. Everything was served very hot which was a nice bonus. read more

Absolutely amazing. This is a MUST-GO in Telluride. Each time I come here I order something new and have yet to be disappointed. The staff are incredible and almost all are Italian. The atmosphere is amazing. I have ordered almost everything on the menu at this point... my favorites would have to be Rotisserie Chicken White Pizza & Fettuccini Mare. read more

Rustico Ristorante - Fettuccine Mare - Italian Near Me - Telluride, Colorado

Read the reviews...we jumped in with both feet and enjoyed a great meal here. We made reservation the same day, and were seated right away for our 7:00 time slot. When we arrived at 6:45, others walk in's were being quoted 7:45 seating times...so even in off season on a Wednesday night, plan accordingly or expect to wait. We were sat in the dining room below the main entrance, tables were spaced appropriately and staff wore masks and gloves. Fresh bread was delivered immediately, and water was offered. Be careful here, and specify "tap" or you will be paying for expensive bottled options as others have noted. My wife ordered a nice glass of red wine, and I had my signature Arnold Palmer. The wait staff and bus staff were very attentive during our visit, and the dining room and patio area were fairly well seated. We had carpese salads to start, and they were exceptional...fresh tomatoes, perfect portions of mozarella, and basil. We drizzled the dish with viangrette and enjoyed. Our server explained the specials of the day, we placed our order, which was pleasantly served just about 10 minutes later. My wife had a ravioli dish in a light pink sauce (forget the name) which was light and buttery...very well prepared. My Rigatoni Alla Montanaro was also delicious, with a tangy tomato based sauce, and zesty sausage slices. We both accepted the offer of sprinkled parmesan cheese. Yes, the entrees here are 20+ dollars per plate, but this is Telluride and if you expect to pay less for more...I'm sure there is an Olive Garden in Montrose and hour away?? Following dinner we ordered Tiramisu, which was light, spongy, and dusted with cinammon and powdered sugar. This washed down perfectly with my dark and rich cappucino. We enjoyed the food, atmosphere, and service at Rustico. We will definitely be back. read more

See all

To say that we were absolutely blown away would be an understatement. We knew we were craving Italian and wanted to splurge on our last night in Telluride, and Rustico just happened to be about two blocks from where we were staying. From the moment we walked in the doors, we were treated like the most important dinner guests they'd ever seen. Our waiter was extremely friendly and talked through the whole menu and how they prepare the food. There were also a few younger male employees who were on top of everything whether it be refilling drinks, supplying bread, presenting cheese, etc without feeling overbearing. The wine list was a little over my head, but I was given beer recommendations and it did not disappoint. From the time we made our decisions on the meal, I think our dishes were brought out in under 10 minutes, it was incredible. The Rigatoni Alla Montanara was fantastic and just the right portion. The blend of premium sausage mixed with a spicy marinara and rigatoni with ricotta cheese was impeccable. I was in food coma for the next hour. If you are in Telluride for a few nights and enjoy nice dining, then there is no reason not to stop in here for a meal you won't forget read more

See all

Incredible dinner. Beautiful outside space. Really stellar wine list - it was so good. Started with Capresse - entrees were House Ravioli and Risotto with mushrooms and truffle oil - dessert was lemon gelato and pistachio gelato read more

See all

Delicious, authentic Italian food in downtown telluride! The food is delicious - our favorites were the Ceasar salad, ravioli, and mushroom risotto. The ambiance is a bit lacking (it feels a little like a cafeteria inside), but the food is worth it. read more

Rustico Ristorante - Mushroom Fettuccine Ai Funghi Di Bosco - Italian Near Me - Telluride, Colorado

This has been our go-to nice place to eat restaurant. They were running their $35 entrée and app deal. Cesar salad...perfect. Sausage and pasta....Took an hour to receive. And when I asked about it....it appeared in a few minutes....Pasta was not cooked properly. Real bummer. This would be a lower rating but due to coming here tons, I guess they were busy, and waiter was over worked? I hate paying for something I do not receive. read more