Second time visiting the place. Ordered the ribeye with a side order of salad and sweet potato. salad came first without asking. Quick service and the place was packed full when I arrived. Food was good. Recommend. read more

Don't let the appearance fool you, the staff is top notch as well as the food!! You never leave there hungry, always taking home to go boxes for 2 more days if your a moderate eater. The prices are well worth the visit, you can't go to McDonalds for 2 for less than here. I HIGHLY n STRONGLY recommend the seafood Alfredo!! The shrimp n scallops are the size of the palm of your hand...pretty close. Just give it a try, you won't be disappointed!! read more

Cozy, friendly & the food is fantastic. Reasonably priced given the quality of the food/atmosphere. Would go back at the drop of a hat.

We always get great food and service at Rustic Tavern! The crabcake is a must! Desserts are scrumptious. A little pricey but then everything is now days. They keep the lights down and if you tell them it's a special occasion, you might get a seat by the fireplace if it's not taken! read more

Not sure how I missed this place. I've been in Carlisle for 3 years and had my first experience at the Tavern. Clearly it is a crowd favorite as it was very crowded. They started us off with what most restaurants provide...rolls. These rolls were not special at all and tasted akin to what one would buy at the local grocery store. I suggest you skip these useless carbs. I was also not overwhelmed with the very berry lemonade. This alcoholic beverage was indeed very berry, but seemed to have very little liquor in it. I ordered a regular lemonade next since this wasn't worth it. For my meal I ordered what they proclaimed to be award winning crab cakes. These were actually pretty good. I enjoyed the texture and flavor, but they would have been excellent had I received some remoulade drizzled on top or even on the side. They provided some tartar sauce on the side but I'm not a fan of that, so what could have been great ended up as pretty good instead. I also enjoyed the baked sweet potato with the brown sugar. All things considered, I'll be back. read more

Excellent local restaurant. Loved the ambiance and the food. Steaks were great, drinks were great. Service was great. Friendly people. We sat at the bar for dinner. read more

Such yummy food passing through town and heard about this restaurant glad we stopped!

Always a great meal and a good time. Wait staff and bar tenders seem to have a genuine desire to give you the best experience.

This place was fantastic. Our waitress was friendly and attentive even though it was the dinner rush and the place was packed. I ordered a Sam Adams on tap and it was delicious. For my meal, I got the western burger which had cheese, bacon, onion rings and spicy bbq sauce on top with onion rings on the side. The atmosphere was pub like but brighter with more lights. Highly recommend this place. read more

Food was abundant and well prepared. Best server ever!!!! Very nice inside, quite enough to talk. Well kepy read more

First off we went there and the parking lot was packed. We walked in and was seated immediately. The place is huge inside. Food was great, huge portions I ordered off the appetizer menu and was surprised how big the fish tacos were. Fresh iced tea and the glass was filled constantly. Nice seating area and great waitress. read more

I had stuffed shrimp and sauce was dry up ..just 2 stuffed shrimp And crab cake .. it was not big portion ..waitress acted friendly but a little attitude .. Prob a good place for area ..but from nj and looking for a little better quality .. My husband had haddock and it was just OK ... Mayb we ordered wrong dishes ..fettuccine dish looked good and decent portion ..mayb next time .. read more

Improvement recommendations: Offer food allergy alternatives. Make the French fries gluten free! Get some allergy free bread! It makes a difference! Ambiance is great! read more

Went to the tavern with two others couples for dinner. I had a seafood pasta dish, which was good and the others had ribs, crab and a mushroom dish that they said was good. However two in the party ordered NY strip steak - one was done nice, the other was nothing but fat. It's hard to believe they were the same cut of steak. It was a bit disappointing to say the least. The server was nice and did a nice job. The prices are okay for what you get. The one big downfall is the noise. It was so loud that you couldn't hear the folks sitting at the same table with you. People need to learn to talk with indoor voices so that the entire restaurant doesn't have to listen to their conversations, and you can actually talk with those sitting at the same table. read more

Hands down the best steaks in Central PA. Cooked to a perfect medium rare and seasoned wonderfully. The table shared many of the seafood, fish, and ribs and everything was outstanding. Service was superb. Irish Old Fashion was amazing. Will definitely make this a regular dining option in our rotation. read more

We found this charming place off the beaten path while driving on Newville Road in Carlisle. It didn't look like much from the outside and normally I would drive on by places like this, except my wife was curious to try it. So, I pulled over and checked reviews and to my surprise, it had a lot of favorable ones. So, we decided to check them out for lunch. After walking inside, we were seated next to a fireplace. The place is somewhat cozy with a dining area and a bar. My wife ordered the 1/2 lb of wings and mild BBQ sauce for $8.99 and said they were very good. I had the Deluxe Cheese Burger with lettuce, tomato and sauteed onions for $9.99, along with A1 sauce on the side. It was very delicious! The burger was made to my liking and lightly seasoned. The chips and pickle slices tasted fresh too. Excellent service! We plan to return again in the near future. read more

Great spot to have a nice meal or drink after a long day. I was in town for work and one of my coworkers suggested we stop by for dinner. I had the seafood bisque along with the stuffed shrimp. The seafood bisque was amazing. It was so good I had to go back the next night to have another bowl. read more

Rustic Tavern - Seafood Near Me - Carlisle, Pennsylvania

See all

Can't go wrong!! Great staff and good food with plenty of options for all! Nice down home feel!!

Food was great and service was awesome. Our waitress was 5 stars and really made you feel good about eating there. Definitely be back.

We bring a group of 20-25 people to Rustic Tavern every year. We've been doing this for several years now, and this restaurant never disappoints. The food is excellent. We are usually there on a night with a packed house, yet the service is still top-notch. Friendly, attentive, and efficient. We will continue our tradition well into the future. read more

Great food great atmosphere the wings are really good salads are very good and huge staff is very friendly always fresh food very clean I come here at least once a month for some grub. Keep an eye out on their web page they run specials every week and their prime rib here is top notch as well. read more

Had to let this one resinate for a while. But this was one of the worst dining experiences we've had in years! If it wasn't for this place having sentimental value to a late family member. I'd be much harsher. The flies/bugs in the cocktails were a nice touch. Each order of the same cocktail were made diffidently or had different ratios of contents. Interesting stuff. The cake cakes were an abomination with no or very little crab. All filer. We should have known better to order cake cakes with crab being out of season. But nothing "award winning" about the crab cakes. They used salted butter or a butter substitute for the seafood mixed grilled and the scollops/seafood were borderline inedible. Now the prime rib did look good and was a healthy portion. So there's that. For the price of seafood and beef in todays market, This place is a no fly zone and we will not be returning. Order plenty of cold lagers to drown out the aforementioned. read more

The food and service is very very good. The place is very nice as well. The portions are big. Prices are fair. My cheese tortellini with crab Alfredo was super amazing. The GF had chicken Alfredo. Her chicken was well prepared. Had the scallops. They are imitation but very good. I will def go again and enjoy another dish. One of my new favorites. read more

Cozy/romantic atmosphere. Great food and service! They take reservations as well. Great for a date night.

Rustic Tavern is usually busy most lunch times the parking lot seems full. However the Rustic Taverns is not the place for a small group reception. Our group of about 50 had the rear end of the dining room with just a divider so all the noise from the front of restaurant came through so difficult to hear when we had a speaker talk. For 3 tables of 10 and 1 table of 14, there were only TWO servers, and no bus boy. Each serve had two tables. They were great and worked their buns off but this was not fair to them or the customers. Food came out based on the order, not getting the food to each table. Food delivery took so long some people got their meal others had to wait more than 5 minutes on both tables. The food was good although some went cold as some of us waited for rest of table to receive their plate, and plentiful, the desserts were very good. Their house dressing could use little more acid, perhaps a splash of balsamic vinegar. I realize restaurants are having a tough time finding servers but it is not right to take the business if you can not feed them in a timely manner. The meal took about 2 5 hours. If you do book a group then negotiate how many servers for the size of your group. read more

This place was wonderful. The ambience of an old fashioned tavern is the decor of the inside. Our server was very helpful and friendly. Huge portions of food were served quickly, hot and for a reasonable price. Would highly recommend if you're in the area. read more

I'm going to title this review.as " if it walks like a duck and quacks like a duck then it must be a duck" My husband and I entered the restaurant which was nearly empty and I was asked if we had a reservation. My answer was no we had not made a reservation! I was then told the restaurant would be full in about 40 minutes for guests that had previously made reservations. In 40 minutes we could have been served and on our way. I must admit there were no people of color present. I was humiliated and hurt and felt we were not welcome because of our color of our skin we are Afro-American. Shame shame on the management and the woman that said I was rude because I made the remark that this felt biased based on race. I hope that she considers how hurtful the experience was for us. Thank you read more

Everything you could ever want in a restaurant. Great, friendly service. Hot, delicious food. Atmosphere was like I was back home. A great spot and I will be back. read more

We came on a Saturday at 3:30 in the afternoon, in the middle of January. The restaurant was just about empty but for two tables. We were met with "Do you have a reservation?" No. "There's going to be at least an hour wait." Huh? It's 3:30 in the afternoon and there are only TWO tables being served. "You can sit at the bar." Now, this exact scenario happened once before when we tried to eat here about a year and a half before. We are from out of state and there was an event going on in town at that time. We blamed it on the event. We figured we'd try this place once more when no event was going on. I was shocked that we were met with the same thing. Normally, I would have left, but out of curiosity, we went off to the bar. I hate sitting at a bar, but I wanted to see how this played out. Fortunately, at that time, it wasn't busy at the bar, but it got a bit busy while we were there. We were there for one hour. Our bill was 175. We ordered appetizers and a couple of drinks. The food was good. The bartender was great. She was friendly and efficient and the drinks were good. During the hour that we were there, we watched 8 parties walk in and turn back around and walk out of the bar entrance. They were a mix of 2 to 4 people in each party. We didn't see how many groups came through the restaurant entrance. Now, if each party averaged 175. Each, they let about $1400 walk out the door in one hour, while tables sat empty. Do that every weekend over the course of the year and that's a huge loss. At 4:30, when we left, I poked my head into the main restaurant and only 3 more tables had been sat. The remaining tables were still empty. I don't know if this is restaurant policy or employees, but this kind of arrogance astounds me. The food is good, but it's not that good. I will not be returning here again. read more

Always great service and food. The bar tenders will remember you and pay attention to drink levels even when not sitting at the bar.

We have been here several times. We went there for lunch and they were not very busy. We were seated and the waitress provided menus. Three other couples arrived after us and were seated. The waitress proceeded to wait on them. We waited over 20 minutes and when another couple arrived and she attended to them, it was enough. I spoke to her and identified since she was not wanting to talk to us we were leaving. She identified she would be with us next but it was clear our business was not wanted. read more

This was a wonderful family friendly restaurant with great food and service. They offered great seafood and American classic selections. We'll definitely return! read more

Quaint local establishment serving good food and drink. My wife and I just got into town after a long drive and tried Rustic Tavern based on the good reviews. Although it was very busy we were able to get a nice seat in the bar area after a minor wait (we could've been seated in the dining room right away). My wife enjoyed the fish tacos which she described as "delicious". I had the crab cakes based on the good reviews. While they were also delicious and loaded with lump crab meat, I did find them a little dry. Our server, Meghan, should have an "S" on her chest. She was hopping all night but didn't leave anyone waiting; she was amazing. I'd definitely return, but likely get my crab cakes in Maryland from now on. read more

Great friendly family restaurant and bar. Reservation are recommended, especially the day before for Friday and Saturday. Crab cakes/sea food is the speciality but the pasta dishes and steaks are great, too! Got the Greek salad this time with the grilled chicken added. Salad was very large with about 50 olives and lots of feta cheese!!!!! Loved it! Other at the table ordered Chicken Parm, crab cakes and a steak. All was very good. Diving room recently renovated to a more modern feel. Have been here many times and will return!! read more

Rustic Tavern - House Greek Salad with grilled chicken added. - Seafood Near Me - Carlisle, Pennsylvania

The food is very good. They have wide menu with plenty of selections. The staff all seem genuinely friendly. They have a bar area, two dining rooms and an outdoor patio section. Plenty of room to spread out. read more

Found this on yelp. Very glad I did! Yelp reviews were right on. My wife and I had the crab cake sandwich with onion rings. First, the onion rings were superb. Quite a generous serving, hot and fresh. The crab cakes were perfectly seasoned and you could taste the back fin crabmeat without a ton of filler. Even the lettuce and tomato was super fresh. Our waitress was courteous and efficient and the atmosphere was very pleasant. It was a short hop off of I-81. read more

Second favorite spot in Carlisle. Great food (ribs are amazing and fall off the bone). Combo meals allow you to try more than one entree at a reasonable price. Pork chop is another excellent dish. Prices are reasonable and some creative craft beverages for the holidays. read more

No matter what I order here I'm very happy. The staff is friendly and helpful. Last I was there I ordered the steak wrap and sweet potato fries and they were delicious. The fish tacos are also very good. read more

We had a rehearsal dinner at this quaint little spot. The place reminds you of a local bar, but the food is anything but. The crab cakes were deliciously prepared and the sauce was on point. The service was exceptional. It was a great way to round out the day. read more

We came to Carlisle for a medical appointment and we were happy that it was scheduled for late afternoon because we then had to look for dinner before a 2 hr drive home. What a great little find! The specials were interesting, and the portions were generous. Our server, Kristen, was eager to make sure that we had a pleasant dining experience. Shortly after we were seated, the place really started to fill up...on a Tuesday! A good sign! We each ordered the mixed grille selection from the menu which consisted of two entree' selections and two sides for each of us. No wonder the place is packed on Tuesday! I can't say that I'm looking to forward to driving 2 hours for a doctor's appointment in the future, but I am looking forward to dinner! read more