Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Rustic Cafe

    3.8 (243 reviews)
    Closed 11:30 am - 10:00 pm
    Updated a few days ago

    Rustic Cafe Photos

    RUSTIC CAFE ATMOSPHERE

    What's the vibe?
    Moderate noise
    Casual
    Good for kids
    Good for groups

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Rustic Cafe

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    Scallop Sandwich.
    Tracey H.

    Delicious food and beers. As a starter the fried pickles are a must. I had a great burger, lots of flavor and cooked perfectly. My wife has a scallop sandwich, with I have never seen on a menu. She loved it! Definitely recommend this little gem!

    a car parked in front of a rustic cafe
    Steven H.

    A diamond in the rough. So glad we didn't drive away. Tiny place with a wonderful bar (and bar tender). Delicious burger (sorry forget to take a picture) and spicy fries pickles. Bartender was also server and was friendly, attentive, and proud of the establishment. What a great surprise this place was.

    Caragh B.

    Had lunch here after kayaking and I could not love the ambiance more. There's an attached greenhouse that is such a cozy vibe I cannot wait to go back. Cute outdoor area w fire pit as well and I hear they have great karaoke. We got malt fries and they were a perfect start! Salty and malty and still crispy! I got raspberry jalapeño burger. Came with bacon, grilled jalapeños and strawberry jam. Burger was cooked perfectly on a toasty roll. Bacon was crispy and salty and put against spicy jalapeños and sweet raspberry jam there was nowhere to go but flavor town after one bite. We tried the malt salt wings and they were crispy and full of flavor too. Bartender was on his own and took a triple seating when we arrived and he handled it perfectly! Food was quick and hot and we didn't want for anything. A great find and we will def be back to try more of their huge burger menu

    a double rainbow in the sky
    Doreen J.

    So when you come to the rustic café understand the name of the restaurant! If you like a rustic atmosphere and a great outdoor spot then this is your place! We were looking for a nice place to go for a drink and a casual atmosphere outside and we found it at the rustic café. Definitely a hometown feeling and the best burgers we've had in a long time with some fabulous toppings! Don't miss it

    The Rustic famous Pickle Back
    Sheila D.

    Great food, wonderful drinks and the service is top notch. If you love pickles, this is the place to go. Pickle backs, fried pickles, and pickle martinis. Do you love burgers? Chocolate burgers with/without bacon, burgers with caramel, Gorgonzola and all the above. You will not be disappointed, tons to choose from!

    Picked up a super-filling buttered lobster roll. Won't be the last. Yummy beers on tap; watched a couple enjoy their pickle whisky.
    Kelly H.

    Covid-19 era: because of distancing this small place is even smaller, but call ahead orders and outdoor dining means you can still try their glorious seafood if the few indoor tables are already in use. I suggest getting it to-go for one awesome beach picnic like we did. We arrived early and had time to enjoy a pint/popcorn. Seasonal and local beers were on tap, and Spatan went well with the autumn day. The couple in the corner was enjoying their pickle back whiskeys ("I usually never like whiskey, ooh!"), so pickle back's on my to-do list for our next visit despite the curious-and-or-icky name. Our food was neatly packed, and the generous amount of buttered lobster packed separately from the toasted roll. Consider getting bubbly with your seafood since it's that good. The small but stocked bar is too cozy and clean to be called a dive bar, and the bar tender/host was super friendly. For now I can only enjoy reading drink specials and their commentary on the Rustic Cafe website, and the I'll be dreaming about everything on their seasonal dinner menu specials, but I can't wait to return!

    Scallop Roll

    See all

    11 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    11 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    10 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Page 7 of 7

    Ask the Community - Rustic Cafe

    Review Highlights - Rustic Cafe

    Dined inside on monster burger, Rhode Island clam chowder and corn bread I was wowed by the food and service.

    Mentioned in 6 reviews

    Read more highlights

    You might also consider

    The Black Sheep - Skillet chicken thighs and this is to die for

    The Black Sheep

    3.2(225 reviews)
    3.8 mi
    $$

    This is one of our local faves. The pub was for many years a family owned pharmacy honored by the…read morequote for the back room. The owner brought over the wood and decor from an Irish Pub so when you walk through the door you have magically been transported to Dublin. Creative cocktails and many beers on tap along with traditional Irish food complete the scene. The food is a awesome mix of Irish and American dishes. Guinness Beef Stew, Bangers and Mash, PEI Mussels, Steak Frites, and seafood dishes are sure to make this a pub favorite. They also have live music on the weekends and trivia nights. Hats off to the staff who make this place a local Cheers favorite.

    I stopped in with a friend late afternoon on the Saturday of the Niantic Oyster Festival. It was…read morebefore dinner, it was calm and plenty of seats available. We sat at the bar which is our preferred spot and were greeted immediately and handed menus. I ordered wine and my date had a Guinness draft beer. Next we ordered mussels to share. They were delicious. The toasted bread used to soak up the broth. As we enjoyed our conversation and he had soup the restaurant started to fill up and it became much more lively with conversations and laughter. Next we ordered dinner. I had the pasta primavera and he ordered the shepherd pie. We were both pleased with our choices. Staff was very attentive even as the place filled. I would definitely go back.

    Photos
    The Black Sheep - Bartender too busy to help the customer on her phone texting.

    Bartender too busy to help the customer on her phone texting.

    The Black Sheep - Strawberry Spinach Salad

    Strawberry Spinach Salad

    The Black Sheep

    See all

    La Llorona Progressive Mexican Cuisine - Chimichanga de Pollo a la Parrilla

    La Llorona Progressive Mexican Cuisine

    4.1(135 reviews)
    3.7 mi
    $$

    I love La Llorona!! I frequent this restaurant often and I've always really enjoyed my meal and the…read moreambiance. The Cabos tacos in shrimp or cod are both amazing. I love Mexican food and there's definitely a time and place for Tex Mex food smothered in cheese and sauce, but La Llorona really stands out for the freshness and colors of its food. The margaritas are also very good and there are always some super interesting flavors on the special weekly menu. In my experiences, the service has always been fantastic. I typically go with smaller groups and we always receive our food pretty fast. I went for a work dinner with a group of 14 and the service was still very fast and our waiter was super funny and attentive. I have also never had to wait for a seat here due to the large number of tables, but the restaurant doesn't feel cramped. This is a great place near the beach and there is always ample parking.

    I came here on a weekday evening and it was moderately busy. I got the guacamole and chorizo ($16)…read morefor an appetizer and chimichangas ($26). The guacamole and chorizo was solid! Chips were very crispy. The chimichanga was stuffed with chicken, rice, bean and smothered over some Cajun queso. The food was solid, but nowhere near mind blowing according to the achievement and recognition on the wall. It also is way higher then other spots and for there price I would expect a lot more flavor and even complimentary chips. Staff and service was fair. Overall the food was fair and given the area there aren't many other Mexican restaurants to provide competition, won't be my first choice to eat within this area but I wouldn't be mad either. Food(50%): 6.0 Staff/service(25%): 7.0 Value(25%): 5.0 Overall: 6.0/10

    Photos
    La Llorona Progressive Mexican Cuisine
    La Llorona Progressive Mexican Cuisine - Guacamole y Chorizo (GF)

    Guacamole y Chorizo (GF)

    La Llorona Progressive Mexican Cuisine

    See all

    Lady Katharine Cruises - Flyer for Boat Ride aboard the Lady Katherine

    Lady Katharine Cruises

    2.7(14 reviews)
    5.2 mi

    Much more than brunch!…read more I wanted to treat my parents to brunch and I found this truly unique venue where you can dine on a yacht on the CT River and dance/listen to music! It is the 2-hour fall foliage brunch cruise on the Lady Katharine yacht called the Mystique. You arrive by 10:30am at Eagle Landing State Park in Haddam, and everyone (I'd estimate about 150 people, tops) begins the boarding process. You have pre-assigned tables and can request to sit together with family/friends ahead of time. The buffet brunch is hot and ready as soon as you board which is great because there are literally no lines - it's a gradual process. Also, the food is out and replenished for a long time, so you don't have to worry about not getting any, e.g. if you decide to partake in the music and view on the top deck first, you can eat when you are ready. The buffet consisted of salad, rolls, salmon, stuffed chicken with a delicious cranberry stuffing, tortellini, tender beef tips with gravy, carved ham with a delicious sauce, Belgian waffles with fruit and cream toppings, eggs, bacon, sausage, potatoes, raw salmon w/capers and several desserts... I'm probably forgetting something. There is a cash bar but coffee, juice and tea are free ($3 for a fountain beverage which I thought was strange). The staff members were all incredibly friendly and attentive. There was a 3-piece band playing a variety of music on the top deck and people were having fun dancing. The views were amazing, especially seeing Gillette's Castle from the water. For only $50-ish dollars per person, this was an awesome alternative to your usual brunch buffet!

    First I would like to say Donna the promoter for the ALL WHITE Cruise intentions were good!!!! Who…read moregoes on a $5k+ boat ride and the boat cannot sail. Absolutely, unacceptable LK. You charge a lot of money for?? Boat didn't move IJS... The Lady Katherine staff were so nice and pleasant to the guests EXCEPT the contact, She was unapologetic & awful. So back to the boat the venue. I was so disappointed there was no silverware just paper plates, plastic forks and rolls of paper towels on the tables. The bar was limited not sure if the promoter had an opinion. Anyone who rents from them please read the fine print and have insurance... their boats needs repair... this was not a cruise more like a tugboat PARTY

    Photos
    Lady Katharine Cruises - Scenic Hartford skyline from the beautiful Connecticut River

    Scenic Hartford skyline from the beautiful Connecticut River

    Lady Katharine Cruises - Charter a private event!

    Charter a private event!

    Lady Katharine Cruises - Fall Foliage Cruise leaving from Goodspeed in Haddam

    See all

    Fall Foliage Cruise leaving from Goodspeed in Haddam

    Rustic Cafe - musicvenues - Updated May 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...