The Bay continues to be an A-OK spot, in my opinion. Your classic pub food can be found here, but…read morealso a few elevated options like unique pasta dishes, salmon cakes, and tofu peanut satay. Came here recently with a group of six, and good thing we made a rez because it was full! Our server wasn't the friendliest guy around but still made sure we were taken care of. I personally stuck with water but half the table went with old fashioned. Everyone had the same note as to how very sweet they were. My husband and I shared the cubano sandwich and the buffalo cauliflower bites. Those cauli bites were fire, I could order those everytime and be happy! Wasn't the biggest fan of the cubano though. There was way more bread than there was fillings. Oh and I tried my brother's pizza! That was very good. I'll look forward to returning for patio season - great outdoor space here!

Pretty good! Really cute spot, my only issue is that the tables are so packed tight in there it is…read moreso loud. Food was good, I had the lasagna and spinach dip. Spinach dip you barely got any. Lasagna was a good portion. Overall I'd go back.

This "hole in the wall" bar is a must stop. I love visiting bars like this because of the community…read morethey provide. I was welcomed by the locals and had great conversation through my visit. The area is out in the country and can be tricky to find in Google maps. Once I arrived, there was plenty of street parking as well as a lot in the back The inside was charming with a vintage vibe. Drinks were strong and their menu is lengthy. I ordered a cup of the soup which was styled after the Reuben sandwich. The corned beef was excellent. The soup is creamy and flavorful. I have tried to stop by again but they are only open Tuesday through Thursday. I wish I had checked the menu it because the reviews online show a fish fry but I'm not sure if that's available daily since they're closed on Friday? I hope you find out soon!

Finally got in here. Wanted to go here for a while. Fish fry is great. Are at the bar and had…read morelovely service. The old fashions were awesome ( not weak) and the fish fries we got were great too. Love the charming Wisconsin feel to the place. We will be coming back.

We came here after learning from some locals that it's the nicest and most consistent restaurant in…read moreWhitefish Bay. Another big determining factor was that they're very gluten free friendly and items are marked on the menu (gluten free or can be made gluten free). They also have non-alcoholic options if you or anyone in your party does not imbibe. We made a same day reservation for a party of 4 for a Saturday night dinner. Our table was ready for us when we arrived. The dining area was pretty small and it was almost full at 8 PM. They do have tables outside when the weather allows, and a bar, so that could be an option if you can't book a table inside. What we ordered, and our thoughts: Drinks: Cherry Spritzer (NA) , French 75 Food: Salmon , Blackened Tuna , Niçoise Salad with Blackened Tuna , Caesar Salad with Anchovies , Clam Chowder I would get the Niçoise Salad with the Salmon because it's much easier to break down with a fork to eat. The bathroom was clean and spacious, too. :)

Had a lovely time back in Moxie! It's been few years for us, but the food, drinks, and service…read moreremains really great. My husband and I came in on a whim, and given that it was a Friday night we got very lucky being able to snag two seats at the bar. I love bar seating honestly, especially where bartenders are friendly, as they were. These guys knew what they were doing too, because they wiped up our craft cocktails in a flash. Moxie is kind of known for their martinis, and have a whole section on their menu for them, so naturally that's what I gravitated towards. I can't recall the name of the one I chose, but essentially it was Hendrick Gin, cucumber, and mint. So refreshing. My husband had a bourbon cocktail of sorts and really enjoyed it too. We weren't in the mood for full-dinner so instead shared the short rib medallions from the apps list. Those were tasty! Perfectly cooked braised short rib on top polenta medallions with bourbon-marinated peaches and cambozola cheese... what's not to love? We also had the caesar salad with chicken, which was crispy and hit the spot. Plan to spend a decent amount of $$ dining here, but you get what you pay for. All in all, a nice night!

Best I've ever had and I've been around the world. Please visit while you're in MKE! So worth it!read more

I have had their Ruben sandwich before it was not the best I ever had but it was good. On October…read more23, 2025 I was driving by the restaurant and decided to stop and get another Ruben sandwich. There was a lady at the door getting ready to lock the door. I asked her why was she locking the door? She said they close at 10 PM I said good it's 9:44 PM I still have time. She let me in while I was waiting for someone to take my order I was ignored. Some of the stuff was hanging around doing nothing. Then I seen the lady who let me in say something to another lady and she came and told me the store was closed. I had been waiting for someone to take my order for 5 minutes and then I'm told the store is closed when I finally get some help. Oh and that is not it she walked away and never came back. I'm still there waiting so I wave for the lady who let me in to come over because I standing here in shock. I asked her what just happened are you going to take my order or what? It doesn't take long to make another sandwich. She told me they were closed and walked away also. I have never been treated this bad in my life that I can remember, I was ignored and they just walk away. Is it part of their job description to ignore people when they don't want to do the work? The place looks really nice on the outside well light and that was the reason it caught my eye. But I will not be going back, I'll try Mae Velma's I might get better customer service there.

Really good jerk chicken egg roll! The jerk chicken platter is also very good with the rice.read more

I was in Milwaukee working and had extremely limited options food wise. They were giving us Papa…read moreJohn's pizza and I was in the mood to eat something a bit healthier, so I ordered from Jamerican. I got the large jerk chicken, extra spicy ($12.67). The first thing that I noticed was how extremely small the portion of chicken was. There was one wing and then what would have been one breast (medium at best sized), but it was chopped up into three pieces, so who knows if it even came from the same piece of chicken? To top it off, there were no plantains and the sauce wasn't hot at all. Ultimately, I wound up filling up on rice and beans (which they did give a massive portion of). With a solid amount of legit Jamaican spots in MKE, this is one that I will not be returning to.

We visited here recently for our first time. We were a little skeptical after reading some of the…read morereviews from about a year ago, however, we were pleasantly surprised with the entire meal. The servers were attentive and friendly and the food was really good. We ordered wine/beer (decent pricing and pour), kids meals, a ruben, salad, and cheeseburger with jalepeno bacon. All of the food was really good. They served locally made pretzel bread before the meal with flavored butter which tasted like honey mustard. Based on previous reviews, it seems like the place is working to improve their food and service. I am holding off on the 5th star to see the menu expand over time. Perhaps they are focusing on improving from where they were a year ago. I would suggest adding a wider/more unique selection of foods for people that want something a little different, such as the honey mustard butter they serve. Ambiance is great and the kids enjoyed their meals (kid and adult menu items) as well. It certainly didn't hurt that the kids were able to leave the dining room and walk out to their giant playdium with a huge selection of video games, basketball shoot hoops, pinball machines, and other fun games for kids. Depending on the evening, this room is staffed by an adult and you can pay for unlimited play for your children to play in the room while you dine. Or they can have their own meal served in there if you prefer to have them play while you dine alone. The options are pretty wide, but it's close enough that your children aren't far, but not so close that you hear the noise of kids/video games. I also appreciated that the room looked and felt clean. Definitely a far cry from some of those other 'kid game pizza places' where the rooms are sweaty and germy feeling. This is very different, in that it's clean, well staffed, and all the games are included after paying a low fee to get unlimited play. I would suggest this for couples that want to go out and let their kids play while they dine/socialize with their friends. We are looking forward to returning.

We are looking at the river club for our wedding venue and were told the same chef handles nines…read moreand the banquet. To get a feel for his style, we tried nines for date night. It was perfection and we will be hosting our wedding there! We started with the duck confit risotto and honestly, I could eat that every day for the rest of my life. My fiancé ordered the lamb chops and I got a beef dish I don't remember the name of. Food tasted as good as it looked, but we did wish the chops had more of the veggies or something more filling added to the plate. My fiancé was still hungry after he finished, but my meal was so large I split it with him and I was still full. The desserts looked a little sketchy to me in that they seemed to have a lot of components but ORDER THEM! The banana dessert really didn't have a strong banana flavor, but it was mouth watering. Get it. Don't share! All in all, we were so happy with the excellent service and delicious food that we aren't even knocking a star.

Close to the Marcus North Shore Theater, The Chancery is a great place to grab a bite before a…read moremovie. Family friendly, beautiful bar, good service and good food. I ordered the Chicken Fajitas. The chicken, peppers and onions were all tender and very flavorful. The toppings were fresh, with the tortillas wrapped tight to keep them warm. The Chancery was a classic place to eat for a long time, but now this is the only one that remains. Stop in, and grab a tasty bite of history.

My first time trying the Chancery! My husband and I both had the BBQ bacon burger! Very tasty but…read morevery saucy! I had mine with sweet potato fries! My favorite item though was the cheese curds! Very cheesy, very crispy! I also really enjoyed my cup of decaf coffee (not pictured)! Interior of the restaurant was clean and nicely decorated! Plus we had a kind, fantastic waitress! We will be back!