I have been DYING to visit this place for years ! I am, after all, an ice cream fanatic ! The…read morelocation is definitely random - not what I expected on my hour and a half drive. The building looks super out of place in this small town. You go inside and you are instantly transported to a cute, roadside diner. The way you order gives it an old ice cream shoppe vibe. The decor is cute - a lot of ice cream signs ! I would say the prices are sort of high. I spent over $20 for a shake, a footlong hot dog, and fried mushrooms. Though pricey, it was all wonderfully delicious and worth it ! I had to get the shake of the month - because I wanted the trip to be extra special. From their Facebook post: "TAKE THE TRACTOR ANOTHER ROUND SHAKE OF THE MONTH (Only available September) Hot Fudge Shake with Chips Ahoy around the rim. Topped with a Bites and Blessings Barn Sugar Cookie, Rock Candy Lollipop, Green Tractor and Whipped Cream. 28oz. Shake in a SOUVENIR MUG"

Overall, this was everything I wanted/ expected. Food quality is comparable to DQ, what more would…read moreyou expect? Shakes are super fun, loaded with extras, and definitely make this a "destination ". The amount of soft serve flavors is astounding!! We want to keep coming back just to try more of those.

We enjoy stopping by for ice cream when we are out for a drive. They have many flavors and their…read moreportions are generous.

Visiting from California and I love ice cream! Checked out this place in Yelp and decided to make…read morethe drive out of Paris to try it. Becky, the owner, is fun to talk to, and makes delicious varieties of rich ice cream. I got Mill Creek Mud (chocolate ice cream with Oreos and hot fudge) and Guernsey Cookie (coffee ice cream with Oreos) in a small sundae. Next time I want to try the lemon and the blackberry with white chocolate chips. She sells pints, quarts, and half gallons, too. The little pink trailer by the side of the road is picturesque, and there are lots of seats and benches under shady trees to sit and enjoy your cool treat. The perfect way to cool off on a hot summer day!

I love this place, it's been here forever... really…read more It's tiny so they dont have burgers & many other big menu items but they have all the ice creams & other dairy products a full size DQ has. The staff is always super friendly & it's extra fun ordering at the window. There's seating out front & in the back at picnic tables in the grass

We got into the drive through at 8:45 wanting some amazing ice cream, and as we are pulling in we…read morewatch the worker (named Mason) walk to the back and hide from us so we decided to honk and let him know we were there. We waited for fifteen minutes straight, not taking out order and then once it hit 9 he walked out and turned the open sign off. Also on maps, the closing time is still until 10. This happened yesterday 11/3/25.

I know it is an ice cream location but they also have great smoothies if you're needing one. The…read moreice cream was 10 out of 10 however. The service was excellent! Super clean and friendly inside.

Checked out scoops during a work trip, it's a cute shop off of the court house square, the staff is…read morevery friendly and they have a great assortment of flavors! I had a hard time choosing but ended up getting the key lime pie, savory and perfect for the crazy hot weather we have been having here in Indiana! Check them out if you are in the area!

Ready for a delightful creamy sweet treat? Haul yourself to Ritters Frozen Custard! This is NOT…read moreyour run of the mill ice cream! This is creamy rich indulgence at its peak level! The freshest of strawberries with nothing spared. Vanilla is my favorite! I know it should be deeper than that but I cannot help loving vanilla! A Spring day offers even more enjoyment with the sunshine on your skin and glacier coolness in your mouth! Tables with umbrellas for shade so that you can enjoy your frozen custard outside. Nicely decorated with fresh and bright flowers in the area. The patio area offers a clean and well kept environment to add to your dining experience. Servers are polite and professional. Above all , they smile. Stop in for a moment of paradise! You'll be back I promise

Friendly fast service ... and delicious frozen custard!!! And the children love it! A go to when…read morewe're in town.

Three years later and we came back to Casey to re-live the experience, complete with the stop for…read moreice cream again! Didn't disappoint and the area under the giant mailbox is lovely with amazing landscaping.

Mary and I stopped in for a hand dipped sundae and banana split; anymore you rarely find hand…read moredipped banana splits in a banana split boat, like I remember as a kid! Delicious!!

Champaign staple! Our order came out quickly. I personally love the Coffee Oreo snowstorm. My wife…read morealways gets the lemon custard with cheesecake and strawberry.

This quaint little ice cream spot did not disappoint. Service was friendly and fast. The vanilla…read moreice cream with strawberry pieces and cheesecake bits made the perfect medley.

The ice cream is done the old way, old fashion the good way to do it. If you crave that "back in…read morethe day" good ol ice cream this is the place to go.

Always a hit!!! Great service, awesome ice cream!!!! The wife loved the Cheesecake Sunday!!!read more

Worth the drive to eat these delicious burgers. Cash only. Burgers are grilled while you wait…read more Seating outside on the picnic tables. The burgers are bigger than he bun. Condiments are sitting on the table and you help yourself. It was simple, tasty and fun.

Never would've found this place except that it was highly recommended by a friend. He didn't steer…read moreus wrong. Burgers are amazing. Prices are obscenely inexpensive. Service was provided by extremely friendly women. Grill closes at 12:30 and GPS showed we were set to get there at 12:33. We called from the middle of farmland while we were on our way because we were fearful we would miss the opportunity to eat here. But thankfully, the wonderful woman who answered the phone took our grill order and when we got there, it was waiting for us. We opted for burgers - me a double cheeseburger and my friend a triple hamburger - and the homemade potato salad. The burgers were huge. Honestly we each could've had a single burger and it would've been plenty. Lots of information, including their extensive menu, on their website. Be advised that they do not take cards. Cash only.

John is amazing the customer service is always so good and the ice cream is great…read moreI love getting the banana milk shake. everything is super customizable.

i got a brownie fantasy, and it was AMAZING!!!! the banana split was so good too. The service was…read moretop tear, especially the owner. hes so nice!! i hope everyone will get the chance to eat food/ice cream there because it's probably the best place i've ever had. i always go there everytime im in greencastle. 10/10 recommend and always 5/5 stars!!