This place is fine, but they're not always the friendliest. Recently got an inspection done where…read morethey had to do a thousand dollars of work on my car and somehow missed that there was a nail in my tire. There are better places in Oneonta.

STAY AWAY! I recently took my car into Monsers to fix the…read more"Check Engine Soon" light. After having them work on it for THREE different occasions, it still wasn't fixed, and they charged me $987 dollars for repair parts and labor, that never solved the problem. On my fourth trip back to find out what exactly was going on, John Bogart, the manager, said to me, "Well leave it here again and we'll see what we can do." NO! NO! NO! I then took it to Susquehanna Auto Repair and had it repaired for $78 dollars. The light has never come on since. MONSER BROTHERS is the epitome of a RIPOFF!

Hit or miss with this place. Got to get em in a good mood. They will bend over backwards to help…read moreyou and the next they can't be bothered. I've been here several times and never consistent.

Awesome customer service and polite staff. Highly recommendedread more

I'm a first timer after trying numerous other places. They swapped out summer tires for snows,…read morechanged oil. Super fast, reasonably priced, and I'm hoping they're my new go-to place for car repair.

McCarthy is absolutely the best place around for tires and service. These guys are great! They've…read morealways taken amazing care of me and all of my vehicles. It's rare to find this level of customer service these days. The work is great, price is right, and service is awesome.

Top notch mechanic. Honest and fair. Gene cares about the…read morepeople in this community. For the last five years I brought my car to a place in Oneonta and realized they were total crooks. Always tacking on extra things they said were wrong with the car and overcharging for what actually did need to be done. The last time I brought it in they gave me an insane estimate and a list of things that were detrimental. I decided to find someone to give me a second opinion and I'm so happy I did. I spoke with Gene and brought my car in and was given an honest assessment. This is my new guy. Highly recommend.

Last month I drove up from Brooklyn for a wedding and my car started experiencing a random…read morescreeching noise whenever the wheel moved. It was a Sunday morning and all mechanics and repair shops were closed. I was essentially stranded until Gene showed up to tow my car, and when I described the issue to him, he decided to check it out for himself before towing me away. He fixed my wheel in 5 seconds and found that my splash shield was bent and was grinding on the rotor. He bent it right back with his hand and saved me hundreds, maybe thousands of dollars and an incredible amount of stress. Thank you Gene!

Scott was one of the best managers around would always get our trucks in and repair timely and for…read morea great price. Unfortunately this review is not about Scott it's about the Mccarthy corporation as a whole. They got some bad news from the code enforcement officer that they actually had to put some money into the building, and instead of fixing the building and saving the jobs of all the employees, they decided to fire them and not even give them a full weeks notice or a severance package, Mccarthy prize itself I'll be family, owned and caring about their employees , but actions speak louder than words. as a small business owner myself, I could not imagine doing that to any of our employees. They should be ashamed of themselves.

Oil change and inspection. Excellent service and very fast turn around! Reasonably priced.read more

Great staff! High quality service and wonderful customer experience (waiting room is VERY nice)…read more Would highly recommend. While on the thruway our tire started thumping, luckily this shop was right off the freeway. They were efficient and quick to help.

My trailer tire blew on the Thruway, at night. My trailer was towed and dropped off outside the…read moreshop. I arrived the next day, just before they opened. They replaced my tires quickly and then tightened up my minivan luggage nuts for me too. I couldn't be happier with the service!

This is a very nice, locally-owned Firestone dealership and specialty tire shop. Shelly (the office…read moremanager) is very efficient and accommodating, and the tire technicians do great work. I live a considerable distance away, and Shelly was happy to schedule the mounting, balancing, and delivery of my new winter tires around my schedule so I could drop off the wheels and pick up the mounted and balanced tires when I was in that neck of the woods anyway. All told, she saved me about 150 miles of driving. Another thing I like is that this is a specialty tire shop, meaning that they don't do general auto repairs. That means that they know tires because it's all that they do. It also means they're not going to pad the bill by selling you unnecessary parts and repairs (unlike the shop I used to use). All in all, this is a very good tire shop that I use and highly recommend. I always try to support local business whenever I can, and Rick's Tire makes that easy to do.

The Very Best for your Tractor Tire Repairs. Came right to my house and installed two new tires on…read moremy John Deere. Thanks!

We've had them mount the snow tires on our truck, which was a super-quick job, but they were…read moreresponsive and kind when we called, and their pricing was really fair for the amount of time it took. We have no reservations about using them the next time we have any tire-related issues, and I'm hoping to return to this review and add that fifth star.

Easter weekend. Huge screw embedded in my tire. Shop closing in 20 minutes!!! 3 hour drive ahead of…read moreme. Their response? Come on right down. Fixed tire & back in the road in no time flat (no pun intended!). Courteous polite efficient and great customer service. Wonderful people. Wonderful work ethics. Gotta love these people! Thank you so much! John S.

Alex and his crew have treated our grandson and his 2006 Honda Civic with real TLC for over a year…read morenow. Thank you, Alex! It's refreshing to see a business that's been around since 1940 still holding true to old-style family values in today's world. Their expertise and deep knowledge are immediately obvious, and just as important, they are genuinely nice people to do business with. Highly recommended. Tony & Lindy Colón Utica, NY

My go to place for any car service I need. Tires, brakes, inspection, oil changes, and anything in…read morebetween. Always fast, accommodating, and reliable. Alex is the owner and he's super knowledgable and trustworthy with any car needs I've ever had. I Legit thought I completely tore apart my tires/brakes after smashing into a few potholes over the winter, brought my car to Alex and it was just some debris that got stuck between the brakes. Got out cheap this time. lol BUT I honestly wouldn't take my car anywhere else. Always a good experience. Support local businesses!!