Rodeo Grill

It's a tourist restaurant so don't expect good service because the staff knows even if they're nice…read moreyou'll never come back anyway. (They were rude) The bathroom had no lock and they never greet or acknowledge you when you enter but the food was good, that is why I give it 2 stars instead of 1 star.

Decent Mexican food if you're traveling through Fort Sumner. Nice little place!…read more People were friendly the food was good and reasonably priced.

Storefront

Dine in closed, but drive-thru open

See all

Sadie's Menu

Melrose Tire

4.4(22 reviews)

36.2 mi

Super friendly service. Very clean Ladies Room. Good selection of drinks and snacks. Neat and tidy…read morestore. So much better than the Allsups down the road.

Stopped for lunch and had a chopped brisket sandwich and a ham & cheese. Both good. The battered…read morefries were exceptional. No ambiance, but a good quick lunch when you're in a hurry.

Dining room and order window.

From the parking lot- RESTUARANT is the only sign

See all

Dining room

Del's Restaurant

4.1(622 reviews)

57.1 mi

Dining here was Recommended by the hotel staff. We were Seated quickly, and staff were attentive…read moreand friendly, Decor gives a very vintage, hometown feel, just like one would have expected traveling Rt 66 "back in the day". Pretty extensive menu, focus on simple, filling and delicious. The chicken fried steak is a huge portion, well seasoned and fried without overcooking, The chopped sirloin was equally delicious. Would highly recommend!

Greeted almost immediately. Seated and received drinks really quickly. Waitress was helpful and…read morefriendly. (LA H sorry she mentioned her name, I don't remember it.) Dan wanted Chicken Fried Chicken Steak with Baked Potato and Onion Rings. A reasonable/ Good amount were served. Waitress verified he wanted White Gravy on the steak. It was really good. I asked about the Shrimp & Fish Tacos and Waitress said, many customers rave about them. I chose the Hatch Green Chile Relleno. This was delicious. Since I eat so small meals, half was left, but with 2.5-3 hr drive home, I chose to say "it was great but time in the car unrefrigerated probably not a good idea." Cute Gift shop and diner. Food was reasonably priced. Nice to be out of the car for a duration on the way back home.

All Decked Out for Halloween

See all

A view of Del's

Lalos

4.5(2 reviews)

54.0 mi

Good place to stop on a dull trip along 285. Special food, good popcorn and other snacks to break…read moremonotony. Clean restrooms

Great food! Who would have known. I had the cheese burger (large and tasty), crinkle-cut fries,…read moreand soft drink for 8 bucks.

Red Door Brewing

3.8(59 reviews)

60.6 mi

Daphne was our wonderful server, the food was excellent we had the turkey melt and patty melt…read more with onion rings and by far the best cheese curds we have had in a very long time. The Red Door Amber beer was extremely tasty! Passing through from Albuquerque to Corpus Christi! I would definitely recommend! Live music an a bowling alley attached what more could you ask for! Met a local named Jack and he was such a wonderful person. Absolutely loved conversing with him! Sorry I don't have take pictures of food! Trust me it was great! Thanks for making it this location such a pleasant stop! Happy Birthday to Daphne tomorrow! 6/27

Well... when it's the only game in town.... *yeah Clovis is a smaaaaalll town. We were looking…read morefor a brewery after our visit to the zoo. The brewery is located in a bowling alley. The bar itself is small, but clean. Best part about the place was the bartender. She was friendly and attentive. Food was ok. We had some fried pickles and mozzarella sticks... typical bar food. Not a bad experience, but again, there's not much in Clovis.

Lumpy cheese, no flavor

See all

Beer menu March

SideKix on 66

4.3(496 reviews)

56.8 mi

The owner's husband didn't know that the dish he made (the Heart Attack) was actually a dish made…read morefamous in Springfield, IL. Texas Toast with a burger patty, grilled onions, fries, cheese and (here is where it changes) a choice of white gravy, brown gravy, Red Sauce or Green Sauce. Also known as Horseshoes! I chose the red sauce and it was delicious. Perfectly medium Rare. My only complaint was the onions. When I hear "grilled onions" I think soft and caramelized. The onions I recieved didn't even seem to touch the pan. But it was still a delicious dish. The waitress was great! Wonderful sense of humor. Did everything she could to make us feel comfortable and happy. Well done! The diner was just that...a typical Route 66 Roadside Diner ... but elevated. I would definitely go again to try their breakfast and/or dinner. I would recommend this diner to anyone!

Since my dog was waiting in the air-conditioned Jeep, I decided on SideKix on 66 for a takeout…read moredinner. This little diner in Tucumcari, NM has extensive menus for breakfast, lunch, and dinner. The service was very friendly and hospitable... encouraging me to take a seat while I waited back on August 2, 2026. It was one of the waitress's birthday which made me super happy but simultaneously sad because it was also my youngest daughter's birthday - she was in Cali at the time visiting her dad before school started. I DIGRESS... There was a variety of seating arrangements. The chairs had really cool upholstery beckoning to the 50s era in the area. One dish in particular caught my eyes: Southwest chicken fried steak ($19.49). I had it with green sauce. I almost chose Christmas style - red and green sauce. The green beans and mashed potatoes with cream gravy were just fine. So was the roll. The steak was mostly tender, savory, and hearty. I was able to take the sauce and breading off to share with my canine. They also sold souvenirs. They still seem to be recovering from a fire from the previous year especially with their prices - a bit high in my opinion. I'm a fan nonetheless. RATING BREAKDOWN Food: 4 | Service: 5 | Ambiance: 4 | Price: 3

Inside

See all

08.02.2026

La Cita

3.9(195 reviews)

56.7 mi

Every time I visit Tucumcari, I eat at Dells, which is very good. But this time I'm trying…read moresomething different. I decided to try La Cita. I'm glad I did! I visited on a Monday evening, around 5pm. That's usually the time us old folks eat. I had no issue getting a table. Promptly seated, I ordered a beer and my dinner. The menu is a good mix, something for everyone. I ordered the Chili Rellenos. Of course I ordered that. Hey, when in Rome..... My meal was served quick and hot. Waiting a minute to cool was definitely in the cards. No problem, I had my beer, salsa and chips to occupy me while the steam settled. After a bit, I dug in. First fork was the rice. Oh, was that rice ever good! The only problem was that there wasn't enough. I suggest that you order a side of that glorious grain. Fantastic! The refried beans, well, were ok, but just ok. The Hatch greenies, as you'd expect, were outstanding and very flavorful. I ordered them Christmas style, with green and red sauce. Both of those condiments were tasty, but of the two, the green sauce stood out. Boy did it ever. I'll be dreaming of that sauce later tonight. Hopefully my girlfriend doesn't pop into the picture.....OR, maybe she should! LoL, now that would be a dream! Don't worry about parking, as there is more than ample. You can park in the front, the back, either side, and if you're driving a big rig, pulling a trailer, or driving a tank, they've got you covered. Across the street is special parking for those vehicles. More parking outside than tables inside. Pay La Cita a visit for a romantic dinner, or as I did, by yourself....my dream trend may have helped with that. Hey, I may be old, but certainly not dead! Quick Tip: I parked in the back, and when leaving, I took the dirt alley. It was a fun adventure. I'd suggest that you do it during daylight hours though. You never know who you'll run into, or for that matter, over! Let's hope it isn't Skinny Pete or Badger.

For a small town this place is a vibe! Fresh food and friendly service. Always a treat when in…read moretown.

Outside front entrance

Chile Relleno New Mexico Style

See all

Mom's Home Cooking

4.4(36 reviews)

59.0 mi

First of all such a cute little spot, food is so Delicious…read moreand a lot of food for the price. The two Women serving were so sweet and attentive despite the constant flow of guests coming in. Overall an amazing experience will definitely be back if we past through

Ordered the burger and fried okra, good eats! The women working there are gems! Diner type of place.read more

Dining room

Western omelette

See all

Sign

Penny's Diner

3.7(125 reviews)

54.1 mi

If you're making the drive between Santa Fe and Roswell, this is realistically the only stop--and…read morehonestly, it's a pretty solid one. Penny's has that classic roadside diner charm, complete with the shiny silver exterior and that satisfying old-school diner door. It leans into nostalgia in the best way, like you accidentally pulled into a time capsule somewhere along a desert highway. Inside was clean and well-kept, and the staff were attentive and friendly without being over the top--exactly what you want when you're road-weary and hungry. Food-wise, the burger hit the spot and the tots were crispy (always a win). Simple, classic diner food done right. A couple of knocks: the bathroom was just okay, nothing terrible but not great either. And the soda... not good. It had a strange flavor, almost like the lines hadn't been changed in a while--definitely stick with water or something bottled. Overall, it's not a destination restaurant, but for where it's at, it absolutely delivers. A reliable, nostalgic pit stop that does the job well. Worth the stop? Yes. Just skip the soda.

Finding Penny's is like striking gold (note: this review applies to their Yampa, Colorado, location…read moretoo). Either stretch of road is remote and food options are few and far between. When you see the lights are on, it's a relief. From what I understand, they're able to stay open 24 hours because of a contract with Big Rail, which keeps train crews fed and honestly, the rest of us travelers benefit too. I love that the choo-choos take care of their people while providing a service to anyone passing through. It's a cozy, welcoming stop when you need it most. The kind of place that makes a long drive feel less lonely. In the instance I'm in those parts of New Mexico or Colorado, Penny's is my go-to. Five stars!

Things to do in Fort Sumner

Penny's Diner. Metal signs and photos.

See all

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

6 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Joseph C.

0

5

1

2 years ago

Nestled in the historic town of Fort Sumner, New Mexico, home of the famous outlaw Billy the Kid, Rodeo Grill is the hidden gem you've been searching for. This charming eatery offers a unique blend of history and culinary excellence that makes it a must-visit destination. From the moment you walk in, you're greeted by a warm and inviting atmosphere that perfectly reflects the rich heritage of its location. Rodeo Grill stands out with its commitment to delivering fresh and flavorful food, and it truly shines in every aspect of its menu. Their freshly made sandwiches are a revelation. Each sandwich is a masterpiece, crafted with the freshest bread and high-quality ingredients that burst with flavor. Whether you're a fan of classic combinations or adventurous options, you'll find something to love. The smoked meats are the star of the show at Rodeo Grill. The depth of flavor achieved through their meticulous smoking process is unparalleled. Every bite is a perfect balance of smoky richness and tender, juicy meat that will keep you coming back for more. Don't miss out on their fresh-cut fries, which are the perfect side to any meal. These fries are always served hot and crispy, with the ideal seasoning to make them utterly addictive. They are the perfect complement to the rest of the menu. What sets Rodeo Grill apart is their unwavering dedication to using fresh produce. Every dish is vibrant and full of life, thanks to the crisp and flavorful vegetables that are sourced with care. It's clear that quality and freshness are top priorities here. And then there's the homemade salsa. This delightful concoction is the perfect blend of flavors, offering just the right amount of spice to enhance your meal without overwhelming it. It's a testament to the thought and creativity that goes into every dish at Rodeo Grill. Beyond the core offerings, Rodeo Grill boasts a variety of delicious sides and creative specials that keep the menu exciting and diverse. There's always something new to try, ensuring that each visit is a unique experience. In conclusion, Rodeo Grill in Fort Sumner, New Mexico, is a true hidden gem. With its fresh sandwiches, delectable smoked meats, crispy fresh-cut fries, vibrant produce, and incredible homemade salsa, it's a dining experience that you won't want to miss. This place is a testament to the rich history and culinary artistry of the region. Highly recommended! read more

Stephanie S.

6

3

0

4 years ago

Awesome place for great food and friendly service! We really enjoyed the food and if we are ever in the area again, we'll definitely come back! read more

Tamara E.

85

131

168

7 years ago

Very good breakfast would come back and I would highly recommend this restaurant Everything was good on the menu read more

Marvin M.

25

98

8

10 years ago

Almost 35 bucks for two Billy the Kid burgers and two teas?? Won't be back. But the burgers were good.

Paul A.

0

35

2

4 years ago

Food was very good and fresh. Cook to order so it takes a little while but well worth the wait.

Eric E.

0

2

1

8 years ago

Stopped by for breakfast driving through. They have lots of choices and our food was great.

Rodeo Grill - tradamerican - Updated September 2026

Best of Fort Sumner

People found Rodeo Grill by searching for…

People who viewed Rodeo Grill also viewed

Esther's Family Diner

4.7

(37 reviews)

absolutely wonderful place! people are so nice. I had the spaghetti dinner. That was excellent…read more Next time I come, I'll be sure to stop again

Esther's was a recommendation by the hotel we were staying at in Sumner. Definitely a diner type…read morerestaurant small and quaint one of few in town open for a decent dinner. Menu was simple for all meal times- breakfast, lunch and dinner. Our waitress was very sweet and we had a great conversation with the "chef" about how they made the Taco Burger that I had. Speaking of that it's a cool concept and very tasty I loved the crunch of the taco shell, burger cooked exactly how I like mine done. I had the green chili on just one of them to try probably definitely going to add this idea to our burgers at home. My husband said his burger was good too. Hand cut french fries I could have kept eating those until I burst. Now we are Texas Southern people and when we had this diners version of sweet tea well the sugar my husband added to his did not help it. But it quince the thirst we had do to the only flaw this little diner had and that was it was super hot in there. I believe they have a AC issue. That's the only flaw this place has. It's a nice place to get a simple meal. Stop in make your own opinion

Mitchell's Coffee Shop

3.7

(3 reviews)

I am drinking a perfectly creamy latte paired with a Salted Carmel Pecan Oatmeal cookie. This is a…read morequaint little shop in Fort Sumner, NM. I think it's the only coffee shop in town, other that the gas station. But this place is definitely good. And they have antiques to look at in the back of the shop.

Cute little coffee place. Excellent for those of us too spoiled for gas station coffee pit-stops…read more The barista was very friendly. They offer light fare as well, cookies and muffins and things like that. We passed it at first on account of not being able to find a street address online. It's on 84 across from the windmill place and definitely worth a stop if you're looking for coffee.

Allsup's Convenience Store

4.0

(6 reviews)