Okay so this is just another convenience store as far as I'm concerned, I drive by this place twice…read morea day 4 days a week and it's about 3 and 1/2 hours from my house so I never really stop here. My job as a medical courier has me out this way and a few nurses in Gowanda New York told me that Crosby's has really good breakfast pizza. So now I got to stop and find out. The building itself is really small in fact I never would have thought to even stop here as even though it says Pizza on the sign out front typically it didn't look like a large enough building to even have a kitchen but... I went inside and grabbed a couple of slices of breakfast pizza anyways. Holy crap it was good. First thing I noticed was there's about a half inch of egg on it which was considerably more than other places I have purchased breakfast pizza. I ate two slices and I'm pretty full. I also couldn't help but notice the crust when I picked up the first piece was firm enough that the pizza slice itself didn't droop down so all of the toppings fall off. I didn't really have to fold it in half to get it to stay out straight and even with that being said the crust itself was very soft. And I didn't really notice until I got down to the end pieces of crust where there's no longer any toppings, but there's a really good buttery flavor which I'm pretty certain is why the whole slice tasted incredible. The only thing that kind of bummed me out which isn't a bad thing but in my case it kind of did, these peaches are not frozen solid and just warmed up in an oven on site. The nice lady behind the counter said the dough is frozen but they put the rest of the toppings on it before they cook it. The reason this bummed me out is because if it had any frozen product in its entirety, The option would exist I could buy a couple of them right out of the freezer and being that it's currently averaging around 20° here in New York, I could get home with it still frozen and cook it when I arrive. But anyway, I definitely recommend stopping into any Crosby's location if you have one nearby and try a slice.

i bought the pizza deal 2 for $22, taste was phenomenal, explosion of italiano herbs & spices a…read morelong with an incredible wait time less than 10 mins. ~ have to try!!!

Horrid customer service, paid for four subs which were all wrong, called and staff was very…read moreargumentative. I would not recommend this establishment to anyone.

This is my favorite sub shop/lotto shop/last minute everything including delivery meats shop!…read moreGinger the owner is amazing! She is friendly, contributes to the community and truly cares for her customers. Her staff is outstanding, especially Gabi and Brandon. They both always have a smile and are willing to help!

I get all my platters for parties from here. The owners serve perfect portion sizes. They are…read morefriendly with good prices and great to do business with,

Most products at this store are expired and management will put stickers over the expiration date…read more All deli meat is bought at discount stores because it's going bad and then once it's turning colors they will use it for "ham" salad. Do not shop here. The owners are truly horrific people who lie cheat and steal and then act like prophets of god afterwards.

single worst phone system anywhere. new pharmacy customers, quit before you start- system won't let…read moreyou through without varifying you d.o.b. which it can't possibly varify because you're not yet a customer. clearly set up by a moron.

worst pharmacy. medicine gotten regularly is never stocked causing life threatening situationsread more

I stopped here really late in the day. After driving for 15 hours. I was hungry and tired. And…read moreneeded to use the restroom. There was a huge snow storm that I was traveling through. This place has a small cafe that serves deli style sandwiches and wraps. There is also numerous gas station store items for purchase as well. I ordered a simple turkey sub and bought a 20 ounce bottle of soda. After I ate I decided to go to my car and try and sleep for a half hour. Just to get some energy to continue driving. The weather was just too much. This place was clean and the staff was friendly and helpful. Thank you.

The weather was getting bad so stopped here to see if the snow would lighten up…read more Got an Italian half sub which was good. The bread was really soft so I should have had it toasted. I wanted to get a drink from the fountain since they had blueberry lemonade. I was going to taste some then I realized the smell was awful. Like a port a potty so I passed. They had tables to sit at to eat there which was perfect. The staff was very friendly.

As the price of gas rises everywhere during the March Iran conflict, on the Irving Seneca…read moreReservation, gas prices continue to be 40 cents cheaper than national average. 03/11/2026 a gallon of gas is $3.19. Inside the bathrooms are spotless and handicapped accessible. If you're a cigar smoker, look for the glass containers of Central American rolled cigar "seconds" sold individually, as well as Native Pride brand cigarettes by the pack or carton.

Great place for gas! Price is right and always friendly when I interact with any of the employees!read more

Single restrooms. So if you have to GO... like, really really bad. Good luck. Luckily, bathroom was…read moreclean. Gas super expensive.

Small store, parking lot, and only a few pumps. They have full service on 1 pump with limited…read morehours. Garbage cans over flowing and I was going to use the bathroom once...no thanks... I held it until I got to Tim Horton's down the street. I'm weird about public bathrooms. They have to be very clean or I'm not using them. Theirs was beyond using. It's very convenient on your way from Buffalo to Jamestown if you need gas and an energy drink. That's about it.

I went in yesterday to your store and only spent 200$ to have a older gentleman come to me to say…read morethat I shouldn't leave my truck at the pump when I was pumping my gas and buying 70$ in gas . This guy is a complete dick!!l

Really clean well stocked shop with great prices and very helpful staff to assist you with your…read morepurchase The restaurant diner looks really cute - might have to try it out on a future visit!

I love Crosbys pizza special. Every Tuesday and Thursday you can get two large pizzas for $14.99…read more These are cheese with one topping Pizza's They are very good, they give a lot of pepperoni but are skimpy on the mushrooms. My husband would like a little more sauce on the pizza but they charge extra for that so we usually get the regular amount. Crosbys has a lot to offer for a convenience store. Snacks, lottery tickets, gas etc. There is enough parking and several locations to choose from.

Nicholas at the Fredonia Crosby's made me the best pizza I have ever had at a Crosby's! He killed itread more