We're eaten here several times, and just ate here earlier this week for my husband's birthday. The staff is wonderful and the food is absolutely delicious! The supply' is so delicious as an appetizer and I dream about Ravioli Al Pistacchio E Filet dish as it is incredible. Definitely check out this restaurant if you haven't been!!! read more

When the Indianapolis location of Catellos closed I was devastated but this restaurant quickly replaced it as my favorite Italian restaurant. You will want to get a reservation because they are always full. Finding parking in downtown carmel in the evenings can be challenging but the restraint does offer valet parking for 10 dollars. The restaurant is pretty and clean. The place is pricy but you get what you pay for. Everything I've had at that place was delicious. My favorite dish is the vodka pasta, I'm addicted to whatever sauce they put in it. The photo I provided is a steak with honey glaze that was a special they were offering when I went for my birthday and it was also incredibly good. The first time I went there, I didn't like the first thing that I ordered and had to order something else. They removed the price of the thing I didn't like from the bill, which was an incredibly kind gesture that I would never normally expect a restaurant to do. The staff in general are so nice and very knowledgeable about their menu so you can trust their recommendations about things. read more

Ristorante Roma - Steak - Italian Near Me - Carmel, Indiana

This is my all time favorite Italian restaurant in the general Indy area! I suggested it for my book club's monthly restaurant meet up! I ordered the Genovese Di Mare and it was as phenomenal as always! You can also switch out the pasta noodle with almost any dish! For dessert I got the tiramisu which is the best tiramisu I've ever had! It was balanced and light! Many times when I've had tiramisu other places the coffee flavor is overpowering or the something is overpowers the other flavors. Here that's not the case! In my opinion. I'd never had their tiramisu as I always get the pistachio pannacotta. However, they were not serving the pistachio pannacotta at the time of my visit. I recommend both the pistachio pannacotta and the tiramisu! Service was lovely as always! And the ambiance was as cozy as usual! read more

Ristorante Roma - Tiramisu - Italian Near Me - Carmel, Indiana

See all

Craving Italian, we decided to try a new spot and landed on Ristorante Roma. The interior was very nice - dark and moody with exposed brick that gave it a cozy atmosphere. We ordered the meatballs as an appetizer, which came out surprisingly fast, even before our first glass of wine. You get 3 meatballs and they were very good! Maybe just slow down how fast they come out compared to being served our first drinks. For mains, we had the Cacio e Pepe and the Bolognese. Both dishes were good - just not a standout for us. One note: The restaurant prides itself on cooking pasta the authentic Italian way, served al dente. Personally, I found it a little too al dente (a bit more chewy), though that may come down to preference. If you're used to softer pasta, you might want to try a different dish. Our server was very nice. read more

See all

Roma is a true staple for me for date nights, girls nights, and any night when I want a great meal. The Vongole al Pistacchio e Pancetta is the dish I order every single time. It is rich, memorable, and easily one of the best pasta dishes in Carmel. The service is always great and the staff consistently makes the experience smooth and enjoyable. The drinks are excellent with a strong mix of classics and seasonal cocktails that are consistently delicious. Their tiramisu is absolute perfection and the ideal way to end the meal. Roma delivers every single time. read more

See all

I heard a lot of good reviews about this place and decided to try it for my birthday for some authentic Italian cuisine. Parking is not ideal for getting here as they have a very small parking lot but some street parking available. The restaurant is a good size but still cozy. We were were seated near the front in the evening so it the sun was blinding every now and again from where is was setting but not the worst thing. I enjoyed my food I just didn't love it. I did enjoy the complimentary bread with olive oil/balsamic dipping sauce. We had some fried brussel sprouts that were good and some deep fried rice/mozzarella bites (suppli) that i felt were too cheesy/fried to enjoy. I ordered the Gamberi E Pomodori Secchi (fettuccini with shrimp and sun dried tomato sauce) but it was too heavy on the sauce/not my taste preference. I did leave here disappointed that it did not seem to live up to the standards my friends set. However, there were a lot of other dishes and positive reviews from others that I would be willing to give it another shot but would definitely try other things on the menu. We had a nice server and everyone we interact with was kind! read more

Ristorante Roma - Italian Near Me - Carmel, Indiana

See all

Maybe my fifth visit here and a fine restaurant, and my bad for accidentally getting the La Bolognese twice in a row (forgot I got it six months and didn't care for the sweet marina). Great service and food (my friend did have to send back mash potatoes that were cold), next time I will pick something different. They did cram the six of us on to a very small table, but I think they just are tight on space there. Good lighting and ambiance for a dinner with friends, not too noisy. read more

Excellent food and service. We went to Ristorante Roma for Easter dinner and it was great. The waiter was attentive without pestering. My wife and I shared an appetizer and a dessert, both were excellent. read more

First time back since they moved to the new spot and it did not disappoint. Beth our server was awesome. Great recommendations by her. Atmosphere was great. Decor fits a classy Italian restaurant. The food was amazing. I had the lobster ravioli and it was so good. Prices are very reasonable for such a great meal. Oh and they have valet parking. You want a classy Italian meal in Carmel this is the place. read more

See all

I wanted to love it, but was more underwhelmed than not. The meatballs were pretty good - a mixture of different proteins. Would've loved to see more sauce and a crusty bread to support the heaviness of the dish. The pasta was... just pasta. Not a lot of flavor. The sprouts were good. The tiramisu lacked texture. I asked about it and they said that's how it's supposed to be. My experience is that it was soggy. Lots of flies were around (I sat at the bar), so that took away from my experience, as well. read more

The food was very tasty but the clams were so tiny there were basically nothing in there, it was just shells . The server took our orders which was two pasta dishes and we only received one plate of food bc he did not put in it which was odd bc we only ordered 2 plates of food so was not a big order . Overall the food was delicious read more

Ristorante Roma - Italian Near Me - Carmel, Indiana

Food was excellent! This is my second time there! Recommend the Genovese di mare! The pasta is made in house and it is a family business and they are from Rome! Not too loud. Parking can be difficult on busier days! Service is excellent! read more

we went as a family and it was a good family friendly restaurant. i do feel like there was too much of a hype for what we got . the food was okay , not bad but just not something to truly be impressed. The service was good , the waitress was attentive and answered all of our questions when we were trying to choose read more

We enjoyed yet another delicious dinner at Ristorante Roma. On this visit, Lisa took great care of us at the high top table in the bar area. Our menu choices on this visit were: Bruschettine di Carne starter, Italianissima salad, Gamberi e Pomosori Secchi entrée, and Genovese di Mare Spaghetti entrée. We also opted for the bottle of Alpataco Malbec. We were quite pleased with each of our choices and took home plenty of leftovers to enjoy. Definitely recommend! read more

My friend and I decided to meet up on a Thursday night. We both were craving pasta so decided to stop by here. We ordered the Italianissima (salad), Genovese Di Mare, and Spaghetti Alle Vongole. Everything was okay, but the Genovese Di Mare - something about the noodles just wasn't to our tasting. I'd like to come again to try their other dishes because my friends really enjoyed the lamb chops and ravioli. Our server offered to split our salad into two dishes so that we can easily share, which was nice. She was also very attentive and made sure we had everything. It's a perfect ambience for date night as well - will bring my husband next time since he loved pasta. read more

See all

Enjoyed a date night here. Quant peaceful interior with a large bar for cocktails. Outdoor seating available but not always in use. Our waiter was wonderful and we enjoyed our server very much. He was knowledgeable about all the restaurant had to offer and clearly very pationate about his job, some of the best service we've had in a while. Food was great, highlight was definitely the bruschetta de carne. Pasta is all made fresh daily and you can certainly tell. Sauces were also great amd so we're drinks. They were pretty crowded on a Sunday night so I would expect a wait on a weekend at normal business hours. read more

See all

We got a carryout order and food was just bad. The only redeeming thing was the host was super friendly and personable and fun. I get wine added to ragu but man- it literally smelled so bad of wine and nothing else. Caesar salad was so bland also. read more

If you're looking for authentic Italian; then this is the place for you. However, understand that authentic Italian is not like "American authentic Italian" if you know what I mean. Nonetheless, the appetizer meat balls were phenomenal, but the bruschettine di carne looked good but did not execute well. That app needed something more than just steak and bread. The entrees were good, but nothing over the top. And to be fair; in my opinion that's just how authentic Italian tastes (it had flavor but not as much as you would think). The service was absolutely fantastic and we couldn't have enjoyed our time there anymore than we did. Check this place out! read more

See all

Maybe they were having an off night during our visit, as our food was served cold and the pasta cooked unevenly. My husband and I both ordered the Genovese Di Mare. You could tell the pasta was homemade, but parts of the dish were undercooked and chewy (beyond al dente.). The seafood did not have much flavor, but may have been because it was cold. We ordered a Caesar salad which was ok. Whole anchovies on top of the salad were a little overwhelming, we were expecting a little more subtle introduction of the anchovies. There was also a small charge for the anchovies on the bill. Destiny, our server, was friendly and attentive. A manager did check on us, but we did not want to complain as we were with friends and didn't want to spoil the holiday mood. The dining room is upscale, nice and cozy. There is a small dedicated parking lot. They have such great reviews. Maybe this was just an off night. read more

Ristorante Roma - New winter menu. - Italian Near Me - Carmel, Indiana

See all

This restaurant is amazing!! We arrived early (4:30) and were promptly seated. Landon was our waiter, and he was exceptional! He explained the owner was from Italy and based the menu largely on the food he grew up with, that his mother made for him. Every bit of our supper was handmade, and you could tell it was made with the freshest of ingredients. My husband and I shared the meatball appetizer (Heavenly!!), then had salads - Caesar & Caprese. We both had pasta entrees (made fresh to order) and finished with tiramisu for dessert. Landon was very helpful in helping us select a wine we each liked, even bringing samples for us to try. I highly recommend this restaurant for a night out. We will definitely be back!! read more

Fabulous dinner a few weeks ago. Lovely atmosphere and great food. Our server Jasmine really made the night however with her perfect blend of friendliness and professionalism. The tiramisu was very different than any we'd ever had, more cake-like, frosting etc. read more

We dined here for National Pasta Day last night and loved every bite. The salads are incredible, the service has always been wonderful (shout out to our lovely server Destiny!), and the pasta combinations are delicious and interesting. We love how you can choose the homemade sauce and protein and then pair it was the type of pasta you prefer. I ordered the... + Ortolana salad: Seasoned romaine lettuce tossed in extra virgin olive oil topped with seasoned heirloom tomatoes, finished with our balsamic reduction. + Genovese di Mare on pappardelle pasta: Sautéed shrimp and bay scallops married with our fire-roasted tomato sauce and Genovese basil pesto. Topped with extra virgin olive oil and parsley. Tomato sauce and pesto?! I couldn't resist it. The portion sizes are great and the ambience inside is so relaxing. My parents love that you can hear each other talk, so this is a great spot for both an intimate date night or a family gathering. We'll be back soon! read more

See all

Riley, our server, made this meal a 10/10 experience. We'd honestly give it 12/10. This was a top 3 experience on the northside. The service and greeting were personal as soon as we walked it. We were seated immediately and loved the romantic ambiance of the restaurant. It feels tiny and intimate inside. The food was fantastic. Every bite was so so delicious. They even had gluten free tortellini which I'd never been offered before. We would recommend Ristorante Roma for any occasion, a celebration, occasion, or date night. read more

See all

Our most recent visit to Roma was nothing short of disastrous. I ordered the salmon; my wife chose a pasta dish. The salmon arrived pallid and lifeless, a gray apparition on the plate--more reminiscent of something exhumed than caught fresh from the sea. It was, without exaggeration, the least appetizing preparation of salmon I've ever encountered, in both presentation and flavor. My wife's pasta offered no redemption. Overcooked to the point of stracotto collapse and cloaked in a sauce that tasted as though it had been siphoned directly from a can of Chef Boyardee, it managed to offend both texture and taste. Suffice it to say, we won't be returning. read more

For a special occasion (birthday), we decided to try Roma Ristorante (plus we had a gift certificate). The restaurant did not disappoint! The food was wonderful (homemade pasta ~ yummy!) and the service was outstanding. We were able to get a 4:45 pm reservation as the other times were booked to larger party groups. We were actually seated next to one of the large groups which was fine with us. They were not loud or disruptive to our meal. However, as we were checking out, the manager came to our table to let us know that he had given us a discount on our meal since we were seated next to the large party. We did not expect this, but it definitely made our evening dining out even better. We would highly recommend this local Italian restaurant and we will return!! read more

Fantastic evening! We are very picky about our Italian food and this place was money! We will be back. read more

This place ROCKSSS. We tried to go to the Christmas market + it was closed, so we decided to try one of the restaurants near by. Our waiter, whom I forget their name, was seriously amazing. Older man with a giant personality, fun jokes, and amazing service. He seriously made our night. He gave perfect recommendations from their menu and he made the best aperol spritz for me... so obviously this place is just awesome. It was dimly lit which was so nice and cozy + the only thing you could hear in there was all the conversations from the rest of the guests which honestly just added to the vibe. Loveeee this spot. read more

The service was great, the ambiance was perfect for a date. And the food turned out good.

The food was very good, I had the crab stuffed shrimp special in a garlic sauce. Wife had the flat bread and it was very good.

Lucky Carmel!!! Freshly made pasta daily. Delicious sauces Reasonable prices. Delicious specials. Perfect size portions. Excellent bread. Knowledgeable & accommodating staff. Well done read more

There was a great wine selection, staff were helpful and informative. This tasted like real Italian food.. it will not be like Olive Garden but that is a good thing! They are able to accommodate larger parties of people which is nice. I would definitely return. read more

First visit since they've moved. Love the building. So much bigger and nicer than the plaza location. Our server Savanna was great. Caesar salad. The dressing didn't have an abundance of flavor but it was good. I got La DELICATA with Pappardelle, Crushed walnuts, and hand crafted delicate cream sauce. The sauce was lovely. The pasta had quite the toothsome bite. Really could have been cooked a bit more. I don't like soft pasta at all, but super firm isn't great either. I'm a big fan of walnuts and cream sauce. Husband got FILETTO AL GORGONZOLA Filet mignon grilled. Served with house made gorgonzola sauce and rotating seasonal vegetables. The steak great, the gorgonzola sauce awesome, the seasonal veg bad. Neither of us like zucchini. Dessert. Tiramisu and Chocolate Mousse both really good. Really great location and surprisingly not very busy. read more

See all

Ristorante Roma is located in downtown Carmel, In. The parking is not the best but the food is good. We all came here for a group gathering and the accommodations were just what we needed. We had a large group of approximately 13 people and the service remained flawless. We all had several dishes that we all enjoyed. The is a small restaurant that is worth a try. I tried a seafood pasta by the name of Genovese Di Mare. At this location they will allow you to chose the pasta of your liking from there selection. The dish was fresh and seasoned well. The bread was also fresh and had a delightful oil accompaniment. I can say Ristorante Roma has the BEST Old Fashioned cocktail that I've tried at any restaurant. This restaurant is definitely work a try and the cocktails are just as good. I also recommend the lemon drop martini. read more

Ristorante Roma - Old Fashion - Italian Near Me - Carmel, Indiana

See all

My food was good but my wife's tortellini was amazing. The price of food was fair and we had very very enjoyable service. We will definitely go back. The atmosphere was cozy read more

The food, the service, the ambience ... 5/5. Located in the heart of Downtown Carmel. We can't wait to return!

Amazing place. Out of all the places I tried in Indy, Seattle, Chicago, NYC, and Europe - this is one of my favorite restaurants now. It is owned by an Italian family and they make all of their ingredients from scratch (pasta, sauces, even powdered sugar). We ordered Bocconcini Di Prugne (dates wrapped in bacon) to start followed by a few pasta dishes - La Delicata Spaghetti, A'Sorrentina Gnocci, and a special papardelle pasta with steak strips and a pistachio sauce. To say that all of them tasted incredible would be an understatement. The appetizer was 10/10 and so were all the pastas - fresh, perfectly cooked, and presented nicely. To finish it off, I ordered a strawberry panna cotta dessert and absolutely loved it. It had that really strawberry flavor, not just a hint of it. Great texture. Last but not least, our server Jasmine was fantastic. Very friendly, attentive, and quick. She explained the menu and offered some wine recommendations (we tried one and it was spot on). Ask for her if you're dining in! To sum up - I'm happy we finally came here and can't wait to try out other dishes on the menu next time. The place also has a free parking nearby and a terrace outside! read more

Ristorante Roma - Panna cotta (strawberry) - Italian Near Me - Carmel, Indiana

This restaurant had been recently recommended to us and since we were in Carmel at the CAT theater for a show we decided to have dinner here. It was a great choice. We got seated almost immediately with a reservation and I'm glad we did have a reservation as the traffic coming into the restaurant after we were seated was almost steady. Our servers did a great job of advising us on menu items which were spot on. We started with complimentary crusty bread and olive oil dip. We shared an appetizer of baked baby Brussels sprouts that were amazing. I had the bolognese pasta as my entree and it was tasty and plentiful. We shared a dessert of tiramisu that was delicious. The atmosphere was quiet and casual. read more

See all

I had an awesome meal tonight with some of the most fantastic service. I met someone for a work dinner with the hopes of having a good meal. This place exceeded my expectations. The host staff was extremely polite and accommodating. Gave us the option of a table or in the bar and we were fine with sitting at a table in the bar. The service was spot on throughout the entire night. You would almost say too fast. The recommendation for the wine was not the most expensive, showing that they were not just trying to upsell when they recommended something. The salads were fresh and delicious, and great bread as well. We had the meatball appetizer, and they were so delicious. We could have just eaten them for dinner. We both ordered a salad and they were both fresh and expertly prepared. I was surprised at how delicious the cherry tomatoes were. We went with the stuffed ravioli, and my guest inhaled it, and said it was one of the best he'd ever had. We had dessert and my guest had the tiramisu. He was pleased that it was not too heavy on the coffee flavor. I had some type of chocolate dessert with espresso poured over the top, which was a real treat. Service was always on point and they brought out the next course as soon as they had cleared the plates for the previous one. You didn't have to wait for it or wonder where anyone was. Multiple people helped with bringing dishes and clearing dishes. It was like a smooth orchestrated event and we both commented on how excellent the service was, especially given the service at most restaurants these days. I think it's rare these days that you find this level of service at a reasonably priced restaurant, with excellent food. I will be back. read more

I have been here a few times, but always at the older location. I stopped in on a whim for a Sunday dinner at the new location right off of Main Street and it wasn't crowded when I came in, but was packed by the time I left. I love the story behind this place and the service has always been great. One of the main reasons I keep returning is because of the experience itself, but the food this time was lacking. I had the Pasta Genovese Di Mare again - as I always have since it's so good - but this time it wasn't as flavorful. The most prominent flavor in the dish wasn't the most appealing and sadly I didn't finish it. My friend had a specialty mushroom and truffle carbonara and she was not super pleased with hers either and said she'd try a different dish if she returns. Overall the experience is great and the new location is superb. Plenty of tables, dim lighting, and an catered to experience, but I'm slightly bummed about the actual meal. read more

See all

Our entire party agreed the food was amazing. I had the Ravioli Al Pistacchio E Filet. It was incredibly delicious and rich. Highly recommend. read more