1. Rentals In Paradise

0

Marathon, FL

Cancel

Open app

Search

Rentals In Paradise

5.0 (1 review)
Open • Open 24 hours
Updated over 3 months ago

Rentals In Paradise Photos

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Rentals In Paradise

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

11 years ago

I personally know the property manager and know that you will nothing but the best from her, hard honest work!

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Ask the Community - Rentals In Paradise

Verify this business for free

Get access to customer & competitor insights.

Verify this business

Seabird Key - Sombrero Reef is just a 30 minute boat ride from Seabird.

Seabird Key

5.0(3 reviews)
2.1 mi

We have stayed at Seabird key 2 of the past 3 years and it has been absolutely amazing each time…read more Deborah is a joy to work with. The grounds keeper has retired but I can't imagine they would hire anyone any less amazing. This property was frequented by Jimmy Buffet back years ago. All the photos of him at the island are pretty neat. This 10 acre paradise is a once in a lifetime thing and we have been fortunate to visit more often. This year unfortunately the dates just didn't work out but we will be back!

We took a chance and stayed here based off of a small ad in a travel magazine, with no photos or…read morecomprehensive description, over 30 years ago. We flew into Marathon airport from Alabama and South Carolina, and got picked up by one of the hosts, and we loaded onto a boat to the island. We were floored by how amazing the place was, how well thought out and well built it was, and the outstanding views, beaches and other amenities. Everything was solar powered, and there was plenty of power for our needs. We have been back three more times over the years, and each time it is even better than before. Seabird Key is a vacation experience that you will never forget. Great restaurants nearby, a seafood market if you want to cook at the island, and the fishing is great. Snorkeling and diving are as good as anywhere. Now there are very fine photos of the place to help people know what to expect, so there should be no hesitation in booking a stay there. We met the owners, and they are wonderful people who know how to put it all together for your enjoyment.

Photos
Seabird Key
Seabird Key
Seabird Key

See all

Coco Plum Vacation Rentals

Coco Plum Vacation Rentals

1.8(13 reviews)
2.2 mi

After receiving the full refund I would give them 5 stars. Everything else about the interaction…read morewas great.

I stayed in one of their rentals for a week in June of 2026. The rental was "My Beach Key" located…read morein Key Colony Beach. The property is a duplex with a shared backyard. The neighbor residing in the duplex next door (full time resident) was a problem since day 2 of our trip. Scott (the neighbor) complained that our dog was barking all day when we arrived back at the rental around 6pm. He said he couldnt hear his TV. My husband apologized and explained the dog needs to be crated while we're out and he gets anxious being in a strange place. My teenage daughter who was home all day confirmed the dog was not barking all day. I reached out to Coco Plum immediately and told them I didn't feel it was appropriate that the neighbor confronted us and they confirmed we had done absolutely nothing wrong. I asked them to reach out to the neighbor or owner and explain that we are following all the rules and the dog is approved. They declined to get involved but told me to tell him to reach out to them if he had a problem. My husband also witnessed Scott using drugs in the backyard. A couple days later Scott contacted the owner to make a complaint about our dog barking and confronted me and my daughter in the shared backyard. He came outside to confront us and was slurring his speech. I asked him if he was on drugs and he told me he was on prescriptions. My husband had to come out to get him to go back inside. When Scott made the complaint we had only been away from the rental for about 45 minutes having dinner. The next morning I contacted Coco Plum and let them know what happened. My husband had also spoken with them by phone the evening before about the complaint made to the owner. They offered me a very small partial refund but only if I signed a non disparagement agreement (gag clause) which is illegal and not enforceable in the state of FL. I didn't sign and declined the refund. I would steer clear of this company and particularly the above mentioned rental due to the full time neighbor. They don't care about customer service or your trip, they only care about covering up bad experiences and reviews.

Photos
Coco Plum Vacation Rentals
Coco Plum Vacation Rentals
Coco Plum Vacation Rentals

See all

Vacation Rentals of the Florida Keys - Wood damage in the upper deck area.

Vacation Rentals of the Florida Keys

1.1(7 reviews)
2.3 mi

Okay so here's the deal. I rented a very nice home from these people and everything went smoothly…read morein securing the property. They provided adequate communication and we arrived at the lovely home with no problems. I will tell you, as past owners of 2 beachfront properties on Pawleys Island, SC and know intimate in's and out's of renting, as we did rent them out from time to time, my wife and I took careful care of the house and property. When there were 2 small issues, the said company jumped on it and expressed appreciation for our help in reporting the issues and they dealt with it per mel. Because of their promptness, we will definitely will be doing business with these folks in the near future...or so we thought. I will tell you the price was not cheap and included a $1,000 safety deposit. But fine, we were initially happy with the experience. My daughter loves art and decided to do art on the painted carport, a 2'x4' area located towards the front of the carport. I want to report there were tire marks noted when we arrived, but, it's a carport after all. We came in a Yukon XL with a Yakima Rocket box on top, so we could not park in the carport, thus, we parked outside the whole week. No problem. But, the issue we had was the day we were leaving, One of the nice ladies who works at said company called and asked if we had a good stay, which I concurred and commented on how well they responded and how we were going to use them again. Unfortunately for me, I did NOT get her name as we were in the throws of packing to be out on time, which we were. I did tell her of the "artwork" done by my daughter and if she would like me to clean it off. I told her where it was and what my daughter used, which was colored chalk. I told her it would be no problem and in fact was going to scrub it off anyway, obviously, as I did not want to incur a charge. She ASSURED me it was fine and not to worry...see where I am going with this? So everything is good, or so I thought. Some days later I received an email, no call, and they informed me the "owner" was upset that there was paint on the carport. I knew exactly what was going to happen and kicked myself for not listening to my inner voice and cleaned it myself. I responded that the nice lady called and I told her specifically of the artwork and if I should go ahead and clean it off and how the lady told me "not to worry about it" and it would be "fine". I do need to point out our daughter used water to spread out the color, which gave it a "painted" look. But was in fact colored chalk. I emailed twice after their original email and stated she had used water which gave it a painted look. But No email was received, no communication from "Vacation Rentals of the Florida Keys" was ever sent to me. I knew we had a problem and I knew more than likely what they were going to do. And they did. I received my security check in the mail yesterday minus $250.00 "for repairs"! Are you freakin kidding me? Really? First off, they should have communicated with me via email, text or better yet a phone call. But no...just crickets on their end and a cold envelope with the check. No response, no personal small note or anything came with the check. Again, just the "for repairs" on the check stub. I had a reasonable expectation that they would have been honest and forthright in dealing with this but, sadly for them, their behavior speaks for itself. It was unfair to say the least and again they made NO attempt to contact me to rectify , other than the check minus the $250. They have shown "very poor" business acumen for sure. Had they been honest and fair and if in fact the water stained the paint at all, (which I find hard to believe). No pics were sent to me to show the issue and the "mystery woman" who I spoke with should have footed the bill. Heck, I would have have payed half, which is even more fair. So my advice in dealing with this company is to "beware". My story is completely factual and not embellished in anyway. We will not be renting with them, obviously. Hopefully, although I doubt they will learn from this. Hope this helps folks. In closing, I left a stellar and glowing review on some damned website and if I can find it, will make an addendum. Shame on "Vacation Rentals of the Florida Keys". Was $250 worth this honest review? They should have been professional and called me.But chose not to. And so it is.

The house we rented could use some TLC "Sun Daze" especially for the price they charged. The pool…read moreneeds work as well as the saltwater system for the pool needs repaired. The ceiling fans didn't work and we had to take time from our vacation to accommodate their maintenance crew.

Photos
Vacation Rentals of the Florida Keys - Garbage staked behind the shed.

Garbage staked behind the shed.

Vacation Rentals of the Florida Keys - There's water stains on the ceiling.

There's water stains on the ceiling.

Vacation Rentals of the Florida Keys - Paint is paling off the ceiling and this is only one of many areas.

See all

Paint is paling off the ceiling and this is only one of many areas.

Marlin Bay Resort & Marina - Marina had its own aquatic aeration curtain, set-up was sick. No bad smells, just a clean environment for your boat.

Marlin Bay Resort & Marina

4.2(12 reviews)
1.4 mi

This resort is top notch, it far exceeded all expectations.we rented a 4 bedroom house for a week…read moreand I don't think anything else on the island compares to this resor or mari. The spacious rental was over 3600 sq ft, had its own small private pool and just about everything you could think of needing for a good time in the keys (blender, two wine fridges, views for days... the list goes on and on). If you plan to bring a boat, this place is perfect! They rent boat slips by foot daily. The deck master was super helpful and even called us on our check in day to make sure we knew everything. There is a huge community pool on the grounds as well, with a pool table and ample seating. Due to Covid they didn't have the pool bar open, but all the other guests were very respectful of social distancing. I was super skeptical about staying anywhere with the pandemic, but honestly the house was cleaned in tip top shape which put me at ease. There is also an elevator that goes to each floor in the home. Yeah. AN ELEVATOR! We will 100% stay here again.

Why are there so few reviews on this place!!!! OMG, this will be my go to spot in Marathon. I have…read morestayed at Hawks Cay, Isla Bella, Tranquility Bay and others while in the Keys. Starting with the reservation process. Very cordial and informative. Check in couldn't have been easier. I was given an access code to enter the property and the keys were ready for me. Pulling into the lovely 4 bedroom home there was a welcome sign hanging with my name on it! Nice touch. 3 floors with an elevator and large and roomy. If you had friends and family staying, you definitely wouldn't be crowded. I know how it is being around family too long sometimes, lol. You are right on the Gulf of Mexico with beautiful views, amazing sunsets and sunrises (where can you do that!). Very clean and elegant. A walk in pool, hot tub, tiki bar, clubhouse with activities and other amenities! Incredible staff and amazing relaxing spot. PS, you can even get a private chef!!!! Say less. I'm not cooking on vacation

Photos
Marlin Bay Resort & Marina
Marlin Bay Resort & Marina - Master bedroom with deck,  great view. A walk in closet, own huge private bathroom. Small refrigerator and coffee maker area!

Master bedroom with deck, great view. A walk in closet, own huge private bathroom. Small refrigerator and coffee maker area!

Marlin Bay Resort & Marina

See all

Rentals In Paradise - vacation_rentals - Updated October 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...