Here's the deal: Giovanni's is a staple for Great sandwiches and salads!…read more Service is friendly and always consistent! It's my go to spot when I'm Sea Isle!

TLDR: Future customers be warned that your preferences are not respected here…read more I love the sandwiches here. HOWEVER today we experienced 100% unacceptable behavior by the chef (I believe the owner) in the back. My friend, who unfortunately lost her voice, ordered a sandwich through the notes app on her phone to the girl at the desk. Her order was an Italian with diablo and liverwurst. The girl understood it fine, asked some questions but they understood the order. He came to the front and asked to confirm the sandwich with salami, pepperoni, and capicola, PLUS the liverwurst. He told us that's not something he had heard of before but we confirmed we wanted it all on one sandwich and he went back. Seemed fine and understood. When we got to the counter, they had two sandwiches ready for us. We informed her it was liverwurst and she just handed over the one sandwich. Paid and then checked the sandwiches after the confusion. We realized they just put liverwurst and peppers into the sandwich and nothing from the Italian. We went back into explain, talked to the first girl at the counter. She asked "did we write the order wrong?" And I confirmed for my friend, we just wanted to add liverwurst and peppers to the Italian sandwich. She said okay and that they would remake it. Then the owner came back. He gave us a serious attitude and said "I'm not making it that," openly insulted her order by saying "those meats don't go together" and that he wouldn't honor the order despite her already paying for it. I told him "It's what she ORDERED, that's what she wants." He replied "I don't care, I'm not doing it." (A simple "we don't do modifications" would have been totally understandable by us instead of this.) Thankfully, his entire wonderful staff heard. I asked about just paying for the other sandwich so we could combine it at home. The amazing woman at checkout gave us the other sandwich for free. The second star is purely for the generosity and understanding of the staff. We understand it was busy and sometimes things get overlooked, but the behavior from this guy was extremely unprofessional. Their only saving grace was their extremely kind and apologetic staff. Future customers be warned that your preferences are not respected here. A quote from my friend when we were home: "I was half-hoping that when I added the two sandwiches together, it would be disgusting and he might have been justifiable. But it was delicious just as I ordered it." We brought our friend to visit Sea Isle City to show her the best it has to offer, and it's a shame the owner's behavior ruined this experience.

So happy I found this place when I was in town…read more Friendly local family deli. I got the Italian and it was everything I expected it to be. Delicious. Fresh. O ate the first half at 5 and will save the other for 10pm.

Amazing fresh foods and delicious deli sandwiches.Would definitely recommend to anyone looking for…read moregood food and fresh sandwiches. 5

Not my first visit and won't be my last! Today I had a craving for a meatball sub. It was good…read more But I would like to point out that it was the least delicious thing I've had here. I'm going to give my review based on my visits as a whole. Not this sandwich. Like I stared, it wasn't bad. It just wasn't quite hot enough. The cheese wasn't melted. The sauce was room temperature. We also got pasta salad that was overly drenched in dressing. Typically my go to orders are an Italian or a corned beef sandwich which they knock out of the park here. The staff is excellent and friendly. They get food done quickly with fresh ingredients, made to order and nothing typically goes wrong. Some reviews state negative comments regarding the bread. I personally love the rolls. A softer roll and a hoagie don't mix. I highly recommend Sugar Hill Subs. Just maybe not the meatball sandwich. And let it be done they only have port o john in the parking lot. No restrooms.

Recently moved to the Mays Landing area and tried Sugar Hill on August 22nd. Ordered a half a…read moreRegular Italian and a half Super Italian. These were delicious. Super Italian was gigantic!!! Both subs were fresh and delicious. Staff was very kind and courteous as well. Check out my pics. Highly recommended.

If you know, you know! We love coming to Bagliani's and have been going here since I was a kid…read more This place is an Italian deli on steroids, with plenty of great food and that old-school Italian deli feel. This time, I went with the ribeye steak sandwich with fried onions and melted cheese on an Atlantic City seeded semolina roll. It normally comes with provolone, but we opted for Cooper Sharp, and it was an excellent choice. The steak was tasty, the fried onions added the perfect touch, and the Cooper Sharp brought that creamy, sharp flavor that makes a great steak sandwich even better. The seeded semolina roll helped bring everything together. The sandwich was delicious, hearty, and filling. You definitely won't walk away hungry!

Super friendly staff and great variety! One of the best markets around! Came to visit cape May from…read moreDC (which has no good Italian anything) and loved this cute little market, it had everything we wanted! Great pit stop!

Very fresh hoagie with thin sliced meats and sharp provolone. Touchscreens were easy to use and…read moreservice was quick and friendly. Store has many different snacks and an excellent selection of fresh meats at the deli/butcher counter.

My husband and I have lived on the peninsula for 2 years now and just today ordered lunch for pick…read moreup! Ordered online and picked up. Food was made fast and well! Just walked right up to the lady behind the computer and told her I was here for pick up. She stared at me like I had 14 heads and proceeded to say "name!?" In an incredibly condescending way. She then tossed my bag of food on the counter and said nothing else. I told her to have a great day. She was an older lady probably late 60s with short hair. She is the only downside to my experience. Food was fantastic though

This shop has specialty items like imported pasta, aged balsamics, marinated lupinis, italian tuna,…read moreetc. I bought some orecchiette there when they had just opened and it was SO good with sausage, broccoli rabe, garlic, and asiago I mixed it with. It was an italian brand I had never purchased before. I have also bought really nice wedges of parmigiano reggiano and asiago there for appetizers I made. The cheese was fresh, cut off a huge wheel and at a reasonable price given the inferior product I could have purchased at a Shoprite for nearly the same amount. Recently, I bought sub platters for a family event. I ordered just regular turkey, the julzy, and the calabrese. The calabreses went SO fast. They make a good italian sub. I received so many compliments on the sandwiches. People really liked them. Definitely check this place out. They are new, and unfortunately, have a restaurant that opened up in their complex recently that also serves subs, sandwiches. What they have to offer is a different matter though. Every time I have been in there I have been treated well and taken care of. Friendly service.

My mother first told me about this deli several months ago. I was skeptical and thought could it be…read moreany worse than several others in the area, both of which are about 1 mile from my home or workplace. The one closest to my residence is okay. I'll swear by the sandwiches for the most part but not the salads - we'll leave it at the owner uses his/her fingers NOT a spoon to taste the salad product and goes on mixing BEFORE washing her hands. The other place closest to my residence used to be a really good place to go. Anymore, you tell them what you want on your sandwich, they put on what they want. Well the heck w/both of those places. NOW FOR GAETANO'S! This place is great. The lunch meat used to make the sandwiches are great. The place is neat, clean, and uncluttered. Bread is always fresh! What you order is exactly what you get! - They follow Burger King - Have it your way! Gaetano's is about 5 miles from my home and a bit further from my workplace. I'll travel the extra distance, it's worth it. As for customer service, the employees have always been extremely nice. If you have never been to Gaetano's RUN don't walk and skip the place up front! Once you have tried Gaetano's I'm sure you will agree with me!

I've been wanting to try this place for years since I pass through Vineland regularly...and I'm SO…read moreglad that I did! Totally unassuming exterior..but don't let that fool you. This is a family run business doing everything right. Stopped in at noon on a Thursday and they were busy...always a good sign. The girls up fromt were super sweet and very attentive. Every customer was greeted amd asked if they needed help the second they walked in the door, but in no means a pushy or trying to rush you type of way - more like they genuinely wanted to serve their customers. That's old school, real, and hard to find these days. Nice job ladies! So, inside they have all sorts of pre packaged and frozen pastas...including some homemade frozen Italian dishes that I haven't tried yet, but definitely will. Good feeling they're amazing just off my gut. Also they have a cool selection of chips you don't see everywhere. On to what I got: Canoli donut & the mini Sicilian (daily special). People rave about this canoli donut...and now I totally get why. This is world's colliding here. Amazing fresh donuts with house made canoli cream in between covered in powered sugar? INCREDIBLE. I'd never eat another regular canoli over this again. Just wow. On to the mini sicilian. This was a daily special and I'm not a guy with a mini appetite, but this thing was the perfect size to tackle in one sitting for lunch. I know my way around an Italian hoagie and this thing was BUILT DIFFERENT. Assembled with love/fresh as can be/good bite and chew on the roll/top quality italiqn meats/fresh veggies/and even the oil was seasoned. Just wow. Top 5 hoagie of my life and I've literally eaten thousands. I took one bite and realized why they were busy on a Thursday at noon. This thing was so good I felt like having chips on the side was disrespectful. Not kidding. This is a small business doing BIG flavors. Everything I had was great, and everything I didn't have I want to go back for. Get here yesterday and support an absolute gem of a mom & pop!!

Authentic Italian cuisine. Great for any occasion and enjoy…read morethe to go freezer items for convenience.

Now you can walk in and order your sandwich, and get it right away ! No more calling in days,…read moreweeks, or months ahead of time. Absolutely delicious. Can't wait to go back soon!!

What a horrible experience.....I took a break from making dinner and ordered 2 sandwiches…read more #6,Madie's Caddy, one with eggplant and one with chicken cutlet....both came with mozzarella, basil and roasted red peppers. The bread was a disaster....Need to get better bread....Tasted almost stale....and for $34 for 2 sandwiches you expect better. The chicken one the bottom bread was actually wet (it was really bad)...Never again ....Avoid, and save your money...The eggplant was dry as well. It was better years ago....don't know what happened.

Subtract this one from a short group of places in OC that I had driven by for years but had never…read morestopped at until two weeks ago around lunch on a Thursday. Upon entering everybody is warmly greeted by someone who works there and while there are certainly shoobies who show up at least when we were there it was far more locals than anything else. The store part has a little bit of everything in terms of dry goods, dairy items, multiple drink coolers, frozen food items and bags of ice outside but the star of the show is the deli half of the store. All I can say is that it's good and by good I mean like really good. The guy working the grill knows how to make a cheesesteak and the rolls they buy are righteous. Past that aforementioned cheesesteak options (there are multiple) you also have a full line of hot/cold hoagies, all D&W products, several salads by the pound and even a few breakfast sandwich options along with coffee/ donuts from when they open at seven. A few noteworthy quirks to help your experience: * When they're open (in season only) it's from 7am-8pm. * The grill does not start until 11 and it stops around 30 minutes before they close. * They do not accept debit/credit although there is an ATM on site. * Their large hoagie is a 19 inch monster. (It's well worth the investment) * Speaking of investment, prices are definitely on the high side but I suppose that comes with the turf of being open seasonally along with being on the island in general. * Check out the picture frame on the wall with all of the prayer cards as it's very impressive as is the sign on the deli warning you of their ten dollar surcharge. Overall Berenatos is really a neat place with a bunch of character and everything we got from the grill was fantastic and next time we're in town especially if we stay as close as we did last time, we'll definitely be back for more.

No online or phone order option. I've had good sandwiches in the past from here, but I went in a…read morecouple weeks ago and waited on a line of many people for 15 or more mins to order sandwiches and just as I was next , I thought it would be my turn... I hear a woman criticizing an young employee who was supposed to take my order. I waited and waited and no one said "I'll be right with you" or anything. I ultimately left as I didn't feel good about the way the person was speaking to another young man employee and it was going to be a very long wait for 2 sandwiches. I went to Wawa.