We wanted to try this new restaurant and overall, the experience was great! The layout is open and welcoming with fun splashes of color. The cooking staff all wear red hats with black bands - I'm sure there's a meaning for this but I couldn't locate it. Otherwise, it looks cool. Everyone was friendly. Our appetizer was the Garlic & Melted Mozzarella Bread. We waited longer than expected to receive this and when it arrived it had cooled. A little cracked red pepper and it was pretty good. We went with the pep to share because if a pizza joint can't produce a good pep... The crust was thin and although a single pizza is intended for one person, two slices each was enough for us. The pepperoni was rich and it was a delish za. Best of all, there's plenty of choices and you build your own. Just know that there's one size and you have lots of options with fresh Italian ingredients. Thus, you'll pay a little more. read more

A pizza place in an repurposed Pizza Hut, that works! They have personalized the space and it's fairly fun. Sitting at the bar you can view a varying loop of pretty places in Italy. We really love the authentic Italian pizza they serve. So much better than we've become accustomed to in the US. Wide selection of topping, some not typical but very good. And every month or so a seasonal offering that has been fun and tasty. Servers and Management have been quite friendly and helpful. They have various special offers posted on social media that frequently tempt us. They also have a rewards program that is fairly generous as well. They had a very good Happy Hour, however they just recently changed it and it's not so good. They did not post the change of social media, so the change was an unwelcomed surprise change. Still, ask about HH M-F 3-6. (Nov25) read more

Overall: kind service, casual ambiance, fun bar menu, fine pizza, prices on the higher side, inclusive restrooms We got there early on a weeknight and were able to be seated right away, but the place was surprisingly hopping for having just opened. The servers were kind and attentive. Drinks and appetizers came out fast. I wasn't allowed to add anything to my pizza which was a little upsetting. The drink menu had lots of fun options- even a flight! My partner and I enjoyed our spritzers and they came in nice wine glasses. The meatballs were pretty lame. The pizzas were okay. Flavors were good, but they were super flimsy and required two hands to eat. It might have helped if they were cut into more than 4 pieces. I wish they had a smaller and cheaper kids pizza option. The music they played was fun. Overall, we enjoyed our evening, but it was more than I like to spend on a night out eating pizza. read more

Expect a little bit of a wait. They just recently opened. Try going during the week if you can! Weekends are super busy with long wait times. The place is cute, it has the aesthetic of an old Pizza Hut. The staff were fantastic, very attentive. The pizza omg. I will be back. SO good. Nothing else to say. Pizza was incredible. read more

See all

I've eaten a lot of pizza and I would give this place a solid b. I got two different pizzas as part of their lunch special. The crust was good, but a smidge floppy. The sauce and cheese had zippo flavor. Like nothing. I won't be back. I think coal fire is better. read more

Pupatella - Pizza Near Me - Columbia, Maryland

See all

I really enjoyed my lunch here. I had the prosciutto and arugula pizza, and it was delicious. The dough had the perfect texture -- soft with a nice bite -- and it was topped generously with fresh arugula, prosciutto, and shaved Parmesan. I also liked the inviting, bright dining room, and the service was kind and helpful. They offer a variety of specialty pizzas cooked in a brick oven, plus appetizers and desserts. I'd love to come back and try another pizza flavor next time! read more

Ok they are newly opened ....but...all the more reason to get it right! 1. They don't do half and half? Huh? What pizza place doesn't do half this half that! 2. Only one size. Huh? And it's only 11 inches. Huh? 3. And they're pricey! Very pricey for what you get. 4. And the dough is soft...like cotton not crispy enough for my taste. Crumbled bacon, not slices - somebody should've told me. White cheese dominated the whole damn pie - what a let down!! 5. Need more experienced workers to show the novices how it's done...you know like talking to customers, answering questions ...etc 6. They took the place of another pizza place. Pizza Hut left. as they should have - horrific pizza but I thought in its place would be something far superior. I was wrong! read more

Pupatella - Pizza from Pupatella's in Ellicott City Md - Pizza Near Me - Columbia, Maryland

I tried the lunch combo individual pizza with bacon as a topping. It came with a salad. I was greeted by a very friendly server who had my order ready and waiting. The pizza was very tasty and I could tell the ingredients were fresh. The dining room was clean and probably a third full. I think the total was a little less $13 and was totally worth it. I'll definitely be back. read more

Pupatella - Bacon and cheese 10". - Pizza Near Me - Columbia, Maryland

Meatball Starter was excellent Pizza was good Atmosphere was good - converted from a former Pizza Hut. Service was great - very friendly. BUT - had a very musty / damp odor. Most likely from the exposed roofing rafters. Bad enough that we will never return. read more

We picked up take out from Pupatella on a rainy Sunday. The pizza was very good and I would definitely have it again. The appetizer sampler was good but not worth $19. Overall, the price was a steep for what it was, but the food was good. read more

Pupatella - Frittura sampler - Pizza Near Me - Columbia, Maryland

Pizza was good, but small and not crispy on the bottom. Very floppy. I did order carryout, so maybe eat in would be better. The cost is premium for a pizza as well. I assume because they advertise better ingredients. I may give them another try. read more

Amazing!!! Went to Pupatella last night for the 1st time and it was so good I can't wait to go back. They do a true Neapolitan pizza right! I felt like I was right back in Napoli, Italy. We started with the zucchini fries and the seasonal water melon salad. So refreshing! We then had a Margarita DOC pizza and a Pepperoni pizza. So good. We ended with a flight of Gelato. So cute! Service was awesome as well. Shout out to Amanda and the rest of the staff that checked on us. read more

Pupatella - Flight of Gelato - Pizza Near Me - Columbia, Maryland

I will not return. Similar to MOD pizza size and overpriced. Dough was too chewy like a leather. Panini sandwich was below average and it was kid size portions. I had high hopes and realized you can't trust yelp reviews. read more

There is really nice ambience. The service was really good and the waiters were very kind. Pizza was tasty and fresh. Little expensive for 11" tho I would recommend them 100 percent read more

This isn't a good or bad review, just my honest review. The pizza is small, expensive and the crust is just okay, it's a good pizza for probably most people, but something was missing. The sauce was just plain and nothing special. If you e ever visited nyc and had johns or Lombardi, and really enjoyed them, you'd like it. If you're more of a Grimaldi guy, the. You will be disappointed. Recommendation: either bring down the price or sell us a bigger pie. Make that crust more charred and crispy. Overall, it's a better and imbibed quality pizza than rest of the pizza joints in the area. read more

I was really looking forward to trying this new restaurant, but I was very disappointed. Very very expensive for what you get. Pizza was nothing special. read more

Great pizza, perfectly baked crust with the right crunch to it, and deciding which pizza was the best at our table was nearly impossible because they were all 10/10. Pretty neat to know the earth is healing too... old pizza huts turning back into pizza places. Can't wait for warmer weather to sit on their patio and enjoy a beer! read more

Excellent Neapolitan style pizza, wines by the glass, beers and gelato. Service was attentive. I appreciated that the manager checked in on our experience. The ambience is modern and fun. They have a great kids menu. Can't wait to come back to try some of their appetizers and salads. read more

I was very excited for the Columbia location to open, but I was disappointed. First, I felt that it was expensive for a pretty small pizza ($19). Second, the dough was soggy and seemed undercooked. Flavor overall was ok. In addition, we ordered the Frittura Platter and everything was fried, and seemed like it was probably made from frozen, not fresh. It seemed quite small for $18.5. read more

I've been to this location on several different occasions. Compared to the Mosaic Fairfax, VA location, the Columbia location has staff that does not know how to properly get the pizza crust right. Everytime I've gone, they serve the pizza with a slightly raw dough crust. The portions are smaller compared to Fairfax location, such as the Arancini appetizer. Arancini at Columbia location as so tiny, that the price of the item is not justified. I've lived in Napoli, I know what they should taste like, and I know good Napoletano style pizza. read more

I have been waiting for this Pupatella to open up near me as I used to go to the Arlington location when worked in DC. I got the Filetti and while it was good it was pretty wet. The crust was just amazing but the middle of the pizza that sort of suffered under the liquid of the tomatoes. The taste however was great so lesson learned to stick to mainly just cheese. We also got the Brussels Sprout appetizer and it was fantastic. My husband enjoyed the house made mango lemonade. I found the seating in the restaurant to be a little uncomfortable and lacking in something I cannot put my finger on. It's not someplace you would linger. I guess I felt very exposed the entire time. That said, our server was super sweet and the other servers all seemed to work as a team. It was a little pricey also, but what is not these days. I will definitely be back to try different pizzas and some of the drinks, which sound great. read more

It's a family oriented good old fashioned pizza parlor but the other food is really good too. Great appetizer and wonderful ambiance. Nice Friday night hangout. Service is excellent. The staff is friendly and helpful read more

Haven't been back since older guy manager was in charge. He was a mess. Went in today and was glad to see a new manager Sara. She was great and so was the bartender. Had some drinks while waiting for my take out order. Food and service were great. I am glad to be back. Great social hour. read more

Nothing special except expensive pizza. The $8.75 side salad is a rip off. They need lunch specials or they are in trouble. $25 for a personal pizza and a soda is crazy for lunch. Service needs to be better. read more

This location recently opened and we've dined takeout and in several times. Hands down one of the best places to grab a quick authentic and absolutely delicious meal. From the apps, to the salads, sandwiches, pizzas, desserts, and wine! We will be dining here often. My wife is gluten sensitive and she can eat literally everything on the menu. read more

I had the best Margherita pizza I've had in a loooong time! You have to try one to understand - I have no words than can adequately describe the incredible goodness of this pie! The arugula salad was top-notch as well. My server, Chelsea, was super friendly and efficient and made the experience there 5 stars! I can't say enough about the welcoming and helpful demeanor of everyone working there. It's a cute interior (used to be Pizza Hut) with a nice vibe - plus genuine Italian music playing at just the right volume! I'll be back! :) read more

Tried Pupatella for lunch today. Ordered a pizza and side salad for about $16 (lunch special). The dough is soft and chewy, delish (5 stars). The pizza itself was basic. Would I pay $16 for it again? No way. The sauce, cheese, basil did not start a party in my mouth and it was a little greasy. Salad was good. read more

Pupatella - Margarita pizza and side salad - Pizza Near Me - Columbia, Maryland

See all

Recently went to Naples and got spoiled with the great local pizza. Pupatella pizza is almost as good as the Napoli pizza!!! read more

Tried Pupatella for the first time and was very pleased with everything! Came on a Monday evening before 5pm, not busy at all. Katie was our very friendly server who gave us her truthful opinions on the pizzas and desserts. We had the meatball red pizza and the mushroom white pizza, both very yummy. Then took home the "funnel cake" type Nutella dessert (forgot the name, a Kate recommendation) and shared a double scoop of pistachio gelato that wasn't too pistachio flavorful and no nuts. Will be back to try the other pizzas. read more

I was excited to try this place and tried to order online for carry out, but the website ordering was down. I then tried to call and order 2 pizzas to go and they said they can't accept over the phone orders. I was surprised an exception wasn't made since they were well aware their online ordering was down. I know they are just opening, so I hope the kinks are worked out soon. read more

Servers were attentive but the pizza dough was tough and sauce salty. In fact the Cesar salad with deep fried pancetta or pork belly (hard to tell) made the salad super salty. Huge portion of salad but way too much salt. Plastic plates is a turn off when going to a sit down restaurant and expecting a solid experience. read more

Amazing place! We had a great time with my family. The atmosphere was friendly, my kid had a bunch of stickers and she loved it.

Bottom line - tremendous pizza and attentive (without being over-bearing) service. I would compare this pizza favorably with pizza I have had in Naples, Italy. The crust is perfectly chewy, and all ingredients are fresh. I had the regular sized Neapolitan, while those with me enjoyed their "pizza flight" selections. The wine list had a few good selections, but I went for the Sangiovese red. Perfection. This place uses an old Pizza Hut building shell, so don't expect much atmosphere. The restaurant does not take reservations, but we didn't seem to need them for Sunday afternoon lunch. read more

Been coming regularly since we discovered Pupatella and Pizza has always been so consistent! However this afternoon, it appeared quite runny (Like chef had put too much sauce on).........my toppings actually slid of the pizza! Let waitress Amandah know but she either didn't hear me or didn't want to hear me b/c I got no response. First ever meh experience in 3 months so cannot complain! read more

Been here a couple times now and it's been the best pizza in the area, even with some pretty stiff competition. Perfectly done brick oven crust and great ingredients. Service and accommodations have been pleasant each time. Try the dessert sampler, while you're at it. read more

Pizza is absolutely delicious! Will definitely return soon and often. Only did take out but will try dining in

Best pizza in the US! Closest flavor I have found to pizza on the Amalfi Coast. Great indoor and outdoor seating options.

The pizzas were bland and just ok. It was cooked well but lacked the flavors.We were a large group of 12 so we ordered 6 different types and nothing really stood out. I enjoyed the atmosphere and we were able to get a table outside the patio for our large group. Our waitress wasn't the friendliness and we had to ask for things like water and utensils. The crowds definitely diminished after a month of their soft opening. We went on a Tuesday night and got a table right away. I would say maybe a third of the tables were full around 6pm. They have a pretty good reward system based on how much you spend, so maybe I'll come back for that, but puptella is not my first choice for pizzas. read more

Overpriced pizza . River House Pizza is 100% better for wood fired pizza. Need to say more !

Good food but expensive, I'm from Mexico but is so nice to see that there is an Italian person in an Italian restaurant, was really nice to see that real Italian pizza place... Great place read more