We've lived near New Market for two years. We love going to the Vintage, and have gone to the Five West Coffee shop many times. But we didn't even know Prospect Pantry was there. Tiny sign outside, great food inside! It is more of a pickup and take home kinda place, or possibly when it is back walk down to the New Market park and have a picnic. 1. The foot is fantastic. 2. The parking is reasonable (off the street and on the street). Overall a gem! Wait, perhaps i shouldn't post this so that it can be my gem (mine, all mine). I don't like lines afterall... read more

Love the vibe of this place. Cozy seating for two or ample seating for 6-8. Very sweet decor, feels welcoming. There are a few steps to get in the door, I'm not sure if there is a handicap entrance. I had the raspberry oatmeal, thinking it would just have rasberries in it. I should have read the menu better, it actually had some sort of fruit syrup mixed in it, made it a less healthy choice than I wanted. Still, very yummy and I practically licked the bowl clean. The person at the counter could not be more hospitable, kind and helpful. I didn't catch his name, I would love to give him a shoutout. My friend had toast with a cheese and tomatoes and said it was very good and filling. Great little coffee/breakfast spot. Beautiful large windows looking out onto Main Street, a nice view. read more

Prospect Pantry - Raspberry oatmeal - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - New Market, Maryland

See all

I don't normally leave reviews, but I had to this time! If I could give more than 5 stars, I would. From the moment you walk in, you get that clean, welcoming hometown atmosphere that instantly makes you feel comfortable. But the best part is the food! This was our third time there and everything we tried has been absolutely delicious! My personal favorite is the homemade butternut squash soup. I'm very particular about butternut squash soup, and this is hands down the best I've ever had! You can truly taste the care and quality in every bite. Highly recommend! read more

What went well? Everything. New Neighbor and I went to pickup clams at Lighthouse Seafood (the absolute best place in town for fish, thank you!) in New Market, but stopped at Prospect Pantry on the way. Glad we did. I had an excellent Reuben (not as much corned beef as you'd get at Katz's in NYC but the price was not $33.95 either). He had smoked salmon on an everything bagel (and since they get bagels delivered several times a week from a mysterious source on Long Island) the sandwich was legit. Icing on the cake: they make an excellent Irish Coffee using Tullamore Dew Irish whiskey. Very warming on a cold day. Total price with tip was about what the Katz's Reuben costs and New Market is a much closer drive. The Guy At The Counter was personable and knowledgeable and he delivered food promptly. Great food, knowledgeable staff, excellent ambiance, great value. I've already staked a claim to one of their outdoor seats once this Wretched Winter is done. Woo hoo! read more

Stopped into Prospect Pantry for a quick bite with my in-laws on the way back to Frederick from the airport. What a delightful experience! It was a bit crowded with lots of locals and bikers (their beautiful bikes were lined up outside) but by the time we ordered our food, a table opened up and we were able to sit and enjoy our sandwiches. I was delighted to see they offered several gluten-free options, and I ended up getting a BLT on a GF everything bagel. Kendall recommended the salted caramel cold brew and both the sandwich and coffee did not disappoint! My in-laws split the Reuben and were impressed with the amount of meat on the sandwich. The BLT was piled high with bacon and the tomatoes were beautiful... none of those sad little colorless ones here. MIL is self-professed "picky" about restrooms and she gave theirs the gold star of approval "it's nice and clean!" she said. Overall, a 5-star experience. read more

Everything always goes well at Prospect Pantry. The food and service is excellent. I'm not too sure about ambiance, but it quaint.

Adorable little spot in New Market! I tried the Chicken Ceasar. It was an ample portion, romaine, parmesan, croutons, all beautifully dressed with just the right amount of tasty dressing. It came topped with what seemed like pulled roasted chicken, which was also a generous portion. Looking back at the menu, thats exactly what they described. The only feedback I have, is that the chicken while tender and plentiful, was bland. There's no salt and pepper on the tables, so there was no immediate way to add seasoning without bothering the staff. So the cold shredded chicken, in my opinion, took away from the salad. So just keep that in mind. Maybe ask for a little more dressing, or scope out the condiment choices when you stop in. But it was a good salad that with better planning on my part could have been a great salad, and a good portion for the price. Staff was lovely and attentive. The rest of the food coming out all looked good too. read more

It was our first time here and certainly won't be our last. Breakfast was delicious, super friendly staff, and loved the decor and overall ambiance. read more

Prospect Pantry - Chocolate peanut butter iced coffee, salted caramel cold brew, bacon egg and cheese on a croissant and everything bagel - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - New Market, Maryland

Delicious veggie panini and a large selection of drinks and chips. Downtown New Market in an historic building. Will definitely return!

Nicely decorated interior, very friendly and helpful staff. Went for lunch, I had the Ruben it was delicious. It was busy, but service was prompt. I'll definitely be back to try one of the many other menu items. read more

Close to frederick about a 12-13 minute drive in the middle of their new market shopping strip. Very pleasant cashiers/hostesses, a variety of items to choose off the menu. They even have mimosas available for those interested! Would definitely be back to explore the menu a bit more. Very cute atmosphere! read more

See all

Order at the bar, get a really good sandwich. Ruben was nice crabcake was good. Lots of drinks to choose from. Very good stop for lunch. read more

Prospect Pantry - Order at the bar, get a really good sandwich. Ruben was nice crabcake was good. Lots of drinks to choose from. Very good stop for lunch. - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - New Market, Maryland

Prospect Pantry is easy to overlook, right along Main Street (MD Route 144), amid a long row of similar-appearing historic houses-turned-antique-stores-turned-maybe-houses-again. There is a colorful flag out front but driver's need a passenger to spot the business before just zooming by (desite the zealously enforced 25 mph limit). We found our way to PP on President's Day for lunch. Upon our 1130 arrival we learned that PP usually is closed Monday's but opened on this day because of school's being closed and the weather being weirdly warm for February. The engaging person behind the counter (we only saw two employees the whole time there) explained it was somewhat of a business experiment to be open on a day when usually they are closed. The experiment seems to have been a rousing success - PP was crowded with many Moms and little kids by the time we left shortly after noon. (Barney videos on a big screen would have held the attention of many patrons!). The 5-year-old contingent was present in full force! There is a fairly diverse menu of sandwiches and paninis and breakfast foods, from which one orders at the counter. Food is brought to you; you can wait at one of several little tables (Note: its easy to imagine PP filled to capacity on a busy weekend in warmer weather). Services is competent but no-frills - your sandwich will be packed to go in a little cardboard box. The PP business model appears not to entail doing dishes, which is fine but would be better with outdoor seating options (there appear to be none). What we got was tasty enough, but one might envision some chips or something to be poured into that little box next to the sandwich (there were none). What they do at PP they do well. Clearly this is a business still in its development stage - it will be interesting to see what passes with more time and business experience for the owners. read more

Stopped in for second breakfast of the morning (hehe); it was much better than my first breakfast! NY bagel and cream cheese was spot on NY delicious! Egg and cheese croissant was buttery gooood! Hubby ordered the butter rum cold brew--he is not a fancy coffee guy yet he said it was amazingly good! The guy running things from the front is always sooo nice, very courteous. Parking lot on the side street closest to the door, if you can't find parking out front. You really should make this a regular stop; you won't be disappointed! read more

Love this place! They have a great selection that is continuously updated! The Baltimore Peppermint Stick Lemonade brought me back to my childhood, and the wasabi vinaigrette on the Smoked Salmon Bagel is an incredible addition to the classic sandwich! We will definitely continue to visit! read more

See all

While I rarely share my dining experiences, I couldn't resist praising Prospect Pantry. I've had both breakfast and lunch there, and on both occasions, the experience was truly exceptional. Not only are the portions generous, but the food was amazing. I had the best Ruben sandwich I have ever had there. The service was stellar, adding to the overall enjoyment of the dining experience. Without a doubt, I found immense pleasure in both of my visits, and it's safe to say that this eatery has secured a spot on my list of go-to places. I'm eagerly looking forward to many more delightful meals at Prospect Pantry. read more

The service was great and really good food a lot to chose from and it is such a great place for family's

My husband and I are new to the area and decided to check this place out for lunch and coffee of course. We've tried it two times now and we are in love!!! So many awesome cold brew flavors (pictured is the peanut butter cup) and the ones we have tried are so good!! I definitely recommend getting a coffee when stopping by! We have tried 4 different sandwiches and all were amazing. Great flavor and creative combinations. It's also super cute in there and amazing service!! Highly recommend. This will be our new neighborhood spot for coffee and sammies! read more

Prospect Pantry - Peanut butter cup cold brew - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - New Market, Maryland

Great ambiance. Awesome food and delicious coffee. Definitely will visit again when Iam in the neighborhood.

Great food, great service, always worth the drive from downtown Frederick. Highly recommend trying.

What a wonderful place to spend a wintery morning! We came in for breakfast to wait while our dog was at the groomer, and loved the service, ambience and food! The hash and greens sandwich with ham was perfect for my husband, and my raspberry oatmeal and bagel were to die for. Service is exemplary and the server is incredibly attentive and polite. We love this gem and will come back again and again! read more

Extremely friendly service. Food was excellent. Went in for breakfast and loved it so much that we ordered lunch to go.

Food was great love the roast beef with has on sesame bagel. The servers are knowledgeable and informative, gives you a home town feel. Wish they had more local pastries and less plastic wear if your eating in would have been great, but overall lively place to have breakfast or lunch. Will come again read more

Prospect Pantry - Outside view - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - New Market, Maryland

See all

I really wanted to find reason to give a higher score, but... Ambience nails it. Cute without being cutesy. Love the bathroom floor finished with pennies. Be sure to read the article on the wall. 4 Star. Service: friendly and prompt. 4 Star. Food, iffy. The chicken salad croissant- chicken salad a tad dry, croissant oddly non-flaky. Lemonade- watery, too sweet, not tart enough. 3 Star. Spouse rated her chicken mozzarella panini 3.5 Star. Based on the other reviews, I will try them again. read more

My favorite local go to local sandwich shop!! The absolute best. I love the beet salad, the Patrick sandwich and the chicken salad sandwich. The place is cute inside. Curbside is my go to. They're prompt in brining out my order. read more

We decided that the puppy needed to be left at home for some quality separation and anxiety quelling time so I decided that we finally needed to check out prospect pantry. We came for some coffee and breakfast. The breakfast sandwiches (i got the avocado toast and the boy got a breakfast sandwich) was good. We both wished that they have an espresso machine since we both wanted lattes but the boy ended up with a cold brew, and I ended up with a hot coffee with one of the specialty syrups in. While these were good, I still wish there was the option of lattes. We will be back for sure, maybe in the summer more than the winter time since both of us are fans of steamed milk + espresso when its cooler out and cold brew when its warmer. Food wise, we def will be back. read more

What a WONDERFUL little find! We do a yearly family event to cut down our Christmas tree. We were all pretty hungry, thirsty and looking for a local place to grab a bite to eat. We called first because they were close to closing time and did not want to inconvenience the staff. The person on the phone was very kind and said it would not be a problem... as soon as we pulled up we loved the ambience both outside and in. The gentleman behind the counter (believe his name is Kelvin) was so welcoming despite the time. A very well rounded menu with multiple great options. Darling decor and had a nice big table for all of us. Between the sandwiches, açaí bowls and coffee we were very pleased with the high quality of their food. Definitely added this to our must go back list. And thanks for hiring such great staff ...we felt so well taken care of! 5 stars read more

This is the only place in Frederick that both my partner and I can have food that fits our diet without bending over backwards. This place is adorable, the turkey & apple panini was to die for and the hash and greens panini was the best thing my girlfriend had ever eaten. The service was polite, fast and friendly. I loved the old feel with the new modern pops of the building. Will be coming back likely more than I can afford. Try the smoothies, try the juice, try everything! Excited to try out the rest of the menu (: read more

Prospect Pantry - Turkey and apple panini and hash and greens panini with a strawberry banana smoothie. - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - New Market, Maryland

Excellent food, service and athnosphere. While I have been delayed in leaving a review, I owed this review due to the amazing service provided by Kendall and the cafes management. I stopped in a few weeks ago on my way home to Frederick from Baltimore and I was amazed on the cafes quaint and cozy atmosphere. I had a ham and cheese panini and it was sublime. It came wrapped up in the this nice little box and it was perfectly completed My deepest gratitude and appreciation to the staff as I will be returning in the near future when I am in route to Baltimore once again. Definitely worth the trip to read more

Loved the decor! The food filled my craving!! Bagel sandwiches were packed full of goodness. My only critique was the Açaí bowl needed more thickness, otherwise the flavor was great! I will be returning!!!! read more

I'm so grateful this place opened! They have awesome food- breakfast and lunch available all day. The salmon bagel and the turkey panini are my favorite. I hope this place lasts a long time in New Market read more

Prospect Pantry - Inside - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - New Market, Maryland

See all

Was blown away. We walked down there for the first time because we saw they get their bagels from Long Island and we wanted to try it out. Ended up getting "The Reuben", which was so good I was having childhood flashbacks a la Ratatouille. Cold brew was excellent as well, and fairly priced. Will be going again in the future to try out the rest of their menu. read more

Very good quality food, Just wish their hours were a bit different to accommodate people in the afternoon after work has let off. Have you guys thought about adding Crepes to the menu? read more

Great new small business in New Market serving fresh made sandwiches and fresh squeezed juices. Had the turkey and gouda panini and it was very good... can't wait to try something else on the menu. read more

Such a cute little spot! Food was great. My party really enjoyed the paninis and bagel sandwiches. I am still thinking about the Italian panini cause it was so good. Smoothies and açaí bowl were lacking in flavor, so I wouldn't recommend those. But everything else we had was delicious! read more