Sausage and mushroom pizza. Really, really good! Definitely one of the best pizzas we've had since moving to the Eastern Shore of Maryland, 4 years ago. And a left over slice heated up in the air fryer, delicious! Nice place, nice staff and quick service. Can't go wrong. Try it, if you're in the area. read more

Procolino’s Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Chestertown, Maryland

Came for lunch, order to go. we waited nearly 30 mins for our pizza. I think they forgot, and turned out our food was sitting on top of the oven read more

Procolino’s Pizza - Large pizza. Like $16. Slices have already been removed lol - Pizza Near Me - Chestertown, Maryland

I really love the food here. The hot wings are delicious, the salad is yummy, and the eggplant parm sandwich is fantastic! I really can't complain about anything we have had at this little restaurant. It is fast and delicious. The staff is friendly and helpful. read more

Came here with my school orientation and we were all disappointed. When we got our pizzas, all of the toppings fell off and when the waiter kept telling us to wait, we would wait for 15ish minutes and it would still fall off so we basically ate pizza with just tomato sauce. Most likely won't come here again read more

Literally impossible to eat. Not cut all the way. The cheese was falling off into the box before you could pick it up . read more

Procolino’s Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Chestertown, Maryland

Got a cheese steak sub, steak was very tender and had a good taste, and mozzarella sticks, the cheese was deliciously melted, and a large meatlovers pizza for later. I reheated the pizza up for dinner and it was so filling, I couldn't finish a whole slice. It was very good with lots of cheese and meats. I will definitely stop in here again when I'm in the area. The gentleman at the counter took my order and read it back to me to make sure everything was right and told me he would hold the pizza on the oven and not cut it because it was going to be a long trip home before it would get eaten. read more

Procolino’s Pizza - Cheese steak and mozzarella sticks - Pizza Near Me - Chestertown, Maryland

See all

Legendary local spot, little has changed in years. Recommend both the Ziti Pizza and Garlic Knots.

I'm from the area and I'm currently living near DC. I still make the trip to get the best pizza EVER. The margarita is my absolute fav and will always be my go to! read more

I asked about a pizzeria place in town and was told about this place.I got a slice to go and one of those little dough fillers with cheese and pepperoni.Well the slice was ice cold!!!He asked if I wanted warm up and I said no figuring it would be a least Luke warm.The dame with the dough filler piece.The slice was bad and so was the other item.I would saved more on a domino's pizza.This place is a drive by, meaning drive by and keep going!!! read more

Ordered chick parm. Burned fryer. Raw chicken inside. Horrible. Hopefully I don't get sick from the raw chicken. They made new one. Outside still burned. Chicken tougher than shoe leather. Used to be great place. Now will never be back again. read more

Always a friendly atmosphere and great people. Best pizza in town by far. Great cheese steaks. read more

Best pizza I've had since I moved out of NJ and it's not even close. Excellent service every time. read more

the best pizza in Chestertown! My boss has to be the greatest, Tom , got us pizza for weekly working lunch meeting . I had a slice of vegetable and slice of pepperoni both were really good but the veggie rocked , it was a meal in itself . They do not deliver but close enough on Washington Ave .To pick up. They make a square Sicilian pizza but need 5 hours notice to make.. update: I got large cheesesteak with fried onions, mushrooms, and cheese $8.25 and it was really good. I have never tasted a cheesesteak like this before they should rename it... "juicy French dip sandwich" the au jus was so good, with each bite, the beef juice poured out. This broth gave the roll the most savory flavor. Perhaps this is Chestertown's take on a cheesesteak but as Mr. Food says from the test kitchen ,"OOOHH it's so good."! (oh la sua cosi buona) read more

This place seemed very popular with many people and families coming in and out while we were there on a Sunday. This was our first visit and the smell of garlic greeted us when we entered the dark space. We ordered a Margherita pizza, chicken cheesesteak and veal parmigiana and garlic knots. We waited about 20 minutes for our food. Unfortunately, the knots were cold. The pizza was undercooked so we scraped the toppings off to eat and ate the crust. The veal had been fried to death and was tough and chewy and the spaghetti was over cooked and marinara was sparse and bland. The cheesesteak had a generous amount of meat but was also under flavored. Unfortunately I won't be coming back for a second visit. read more

See all

We were in the area shopping and were looking for a quick place for lunch. My husband noticed this pizza shop so we decided to give it a try. We aren't the biggest pizza eaters but we do know good pizza. While thinner crust style pizza is really my favorite (only because I don't need too many carbs!),, this thicker crust (Sicilian?) style pizza was really good. He had a piece with grilled chicken and cheese on it - there was no sign to say what it was but I snuck a bite and it was really good. He definitely.enjoyed it too. I had a piece with fresh tomatoes, ricotta and mozzarella - very good! He also had a bowl of Italian wedding soup and I had a caesar salad both of which were good. He did miss the noodles typically found in Italian wedding soup though. The service was fast and friendly and when I posted on Facebook that we were there, several friends commented how they loved the place and had been going there for years. Overall it was a great visit - we will be going back for sure! read more

See all

Every time we go out to Chestertown, a visit to "Proc's" is a must-do! This place has been a staple in the area for 20 years or so at least. I'm happy to say the quality hasn't deteriorated at all in those years. The last visit was a large group gathering, but the food was still excellent. The garlic knots are spot on, especially with their marinara dipping sauce. The pizzas are generously topped and very heavy for their size. You can't get past two slices without reaching critical mass! Their prices are very competitive, not only for Chestertown but overall. We have also never had a bad service experience here. They always go out of their way to make you feel welcomed and valued. I hope Proc's is there for many more years to come! I can't imagine Chestertown without them. read more

The food is delicious, the staff is friendly, and there's no waiter to tip! The prices are also very reasonable!

Absolutely best local family owned restaurant in chestertown. Food is wonderful. Everyone is always friendly when you walk in. They always have time to give back to our community, always helping our youth sports and schools. It doesn't matter if your there for a quick bite, or you need to hold a party, your food is always HOT FRESH and delicious. Pizza is by far the best in town. The cheesesteaks are hands down the best around. read more

Pizza is one of the best in town. It's a Chestertown staple and a great place to meet up with friends.

reliable . Try the ziti pizza. Or garlic knots

Cool place. Owner is very nice. Drink refills are awkward. They should really put the soda machine where the public can get their own drinks. They do charge for refills but they have it to us my fam of 5 on the house. I appreciate the gesture but I'd pay more I order to get the drink faster. Anyone with children would understand what I mean. The steak sub was really good along with the pizza and mozzarella sticks. The portion for the mozzarella sticks were lame though. Again with a large fam I'd be willing to pay more to get a better portion. The pasta...not so good. Alfredo was sort of lame. I guess with the ascent from the chef we were expecting some authentic pasta but not so much. Stick to the carry out foods. Having a runner to deliver the food to each table under a numbering system would really suit this place well. Overall I would def return, but some small tweaks could make this place more efficient. The pricing of the food was a little high but manageable. read more

Best pizza I've ever had! It's worth the drive- the crust is perfect and the toppings are fresh!

1 ownership driven. 2 Tremendous selection of pizza by slices 3 friendly and clean 4 cheesesteak with fries pizza is excellent great crust good dough a First for me. Could not resist and it actually tasted great 5 broccoli tomato cheese pie was good also lots of goey mozzarella but no grease stains ricotta swirls provide nice contrast 6. This place is about the food high quality generous portions inexpensive 7 dining room is industrial tables and booths no tv no music 8. Mostly locals 9 great for takeout 10. Have to come and try the ziti next time. People next to me were raving about it read more

Procolino’s Pizza - Cheesesteak and fries pizza - Pizza Near Me - Chestertown, Maryland

See all

We were in town for the weekend. We stopped by here to pick up a pizza because of all the good reviews. It was very good! Absolutely did not disappoint. Also, it seemed like the whole town was there to get food on a Friday night. read more

Tired, hungry, and looking for a quick bite to eat and didn't want to wait, so I decided on pizza. I waked in for the first time and Procolino's is wide open and spacious. They had about ten different specialty pizzas available by the slice all ready to heat and eat. I saw the Hawaiian slices and had to have one, and ordered a cheese with mushrooms as well. MMmmm, I noticed they have bottled beer and ordered a Yuengling to go with my pizza (Total cost @ $12). I love mushroom pizza...well, I love mushroom almost anything...lol!! Procolinos added a ton of fresh (that's fresh as in not cooked) mushrooms and added a bit more yummy stretchy mozzarella cheese. The crust was tender and crispy, the sauce was delish, the cheese...well it was yummy n stretchy, the mushrooms were good, but really I would have liked them better sauteed as they were not still not cooked by slightly dehydrated from the hot oven. I noticed the Hawaiian pizza looked different... it was covered in BACON...YUM!!! OMG, I had to try!!! Glad I did too. There was a literal mound of toppings with crispy Bacon...Yum!!!, pineapple (not very sweet, could have been sweeter), and what's this??? Ham under the Bacon...Yum!!! and pineapple... Oh how I love pig!! This was a fantastic piece of pizza. I only intended to eat part of both slices, but the crust was so good and I ate the mushroom first and was only going to sample the other... but the Hawaiian was so damn'd good I had to eat the whole thing!!! Can you say belly ache...because I'm too full!!! read more

See all

Pizza cheese slice was good, nice crispy crust, a little of that good tomato sauce, friendly service, but no music or tv to watch, lights really dim at night. Good place to talk with a friend, as its quiet except for the patrons. read more

Procolino’s Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Chestertown, Maryland

It never ceases to amaze me how different pizza is from region to region. Go from one town to another - and one state to another - and what the locals refer to as pizza won't even resemble what it is you are used to back at home. I know this pizza place is very popular with locals, so I give them praise for that. As someone from New Jersey, it just wasn't for me. I don't actually know what you would call the style of pizza which they serve here. Maybe it's Maryland style pizza? Maybe it's Chestertown style pizza? I don't know. The pizza crust was way too thick - I've never had a pie like it. The crust was a meal in itself. The cheese also just sort of sat on top of the pie - almost like it was a separate entity rather than part of it. Like someone just took a ton of cheese and melted it on top of a plate of the dough after it was already cooked. You could easily pull the cheese off if you wanted and have a cheese meal and a separate crust meal if you wish. Again, the locals praise this place - and it was busy. They also had virtually every type of topping you could possibly imagine. Great selection --- and beyond the pizza they have subs and other assorted offerings. But at the end of the day it comes down to the pizza itself - and I just didn't like it. So for local flavor, they do their job. But as a guy from New Jersey who has been spoiled with good pizza his whole life - I wouldn't be back. read more

The Greatest Pizza in the Universe! Been coming here since the day they opened and now I get to share this slice of awesome with my grandkids. read more

Love this place it's a Chestertown landmark! I've eaten their since I was a child. I would walk there after school from the Chestertown middle school with my friends and we would grab a slice of pizza . I now take my kids and my grandson there. The pizza is the closest you will get to New York style pizza. read more

This place is amazing. Got a medium deep dish pizza half steak/fries half ziti. Most places don't even have this as an option for toppings. As a 6'4 300 pound man I could only finish half. Come hungry. It's delicious. I'd kill to have this place local to me. read more

Procolino’s Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Chestertown, Maryland

My favorite pizza outside of New York City. I LOVE their veggie pizza, it's my favorite, however there isn't a bad thing on the menu, but try the veggie pizza. read more

See all

I wish I could be as positive as some other reviews. The reality is that Procolino's is a great disappointment. However, for those that fondly remember eating soggy pizza after an after-school game will love the place. True, it is a local favorite and apparently has been for many years. Why? It reeks from garlic and is a dank, order at the counter place. I guess it may actualy be owned by an Italian, but that is where any positive connection to Italian food ends. Buy any pizza and as you carry the box you will be dripping oil all the way home. Garlic, oil and wilted greens are the hallmarks of this joint. Much better choices at any of the nearby fast-food places and that is not saying much for the fast-food. read more

I've been to New York and Italy, among other cities, and tried pizza all over the place. This is the best pizza I've ever had. From this unassuming strip-mall restaurant's oven comes crunchy, chewy, garlicky, tomato-ey, cheesy goodness like I've never had anywhere else, all with nothing but smiles from the pizza pros making and serving it. Procolino is a reason to come to Chestertown all by itself. Get off the main drag and get in here--it will be the best meal you have in town, bar none, no question. 10 stars. read more

The best pizza I've found on either coast! This is the only place in town to grab a slice. Lots of variety. Not just for pizza though, they have great authentic Italian food with great service. Try anything on their menu, it's all great! read more

I enjoyed the meat lovers pizza. Delicious food. Polite staff. I would order from here again when I return to the area.

Amazing food. The owner is so kind. You must check them out. The Pizza is fantastic and I have never seen a chicken Cesar salad so beautiful read more

Small local Italian family restaurant that is to die for. It's my favorite place in Chestertown. Food is fantastic, and reasonably priced for huge portions, the staff is super nice and treats everyone like family, and located very conveniently in the Acme shopping plaza. There are not enough kind words to describe this place! 10/10 recommend read more

when i was 7 sal scolded me for trying to carry my slice on a paper plate on top of my head. when he turned his back i lost it negotiating the door with the slice back on top of my head. i thought i was in trouble but he just smiled and gave me another one. by the time i was in highschool i swear 70 percent of my cellular makeup was built out of procs pizza. if you want a square foot slice of thin brooklyn style, youre going to need to adjust your expectations a little, but all you have to do is walk in the door and take a whiff and youll know why all the ctown locals eat here first if they havent been home in a while. favorites: next day cold plain slice. chicken caesar salad mushroom cheesteak mushroom and black olive brocoli tomato and when you pick up dinner for the fam: get a large pizza comprised of one slice of every kind of pizza on display on display on the counter. love you sal and vinnie read more

This has also become a college/Chestertown institution over the past couple of years. In my opinion the best pizza in town. Then again, they only have competition from Domino's and Pizza Hut. Nonetheless, this is a good place to get a cheap and quick bite to eat before getting your drinking hat on. Or before you're going to watch a movie. Or do whatever. You get the point. Actual old-world Italians run the place (don't know where from exactly), so they get a little theatrical at times. Be sure to order the garlic knots. Bottom line: good pizza without hassle in a friendly atmosphere. read more

I don't like flies, sweat, dirt on my pizza. Therefore the sbarro style of pizza selling only works if the pizza turns over quick. the pizza doesn't turn over quick so it sits out. Yes they have some gourmet slices with great toppings, but they are also pricey. Top it off that the manager/owner is loud intrusive and unprofessional into others business. To some he may be considered personable, it depends what your looking for when you go in. I wasn't looking for a discussion on me and whether you like it or not that's what will prob happen The other foods are good but mediocre. Self service means you do all the work and have to deal with the owners Italian style loud boisterous rants at seconds notice. read more