Prisco's Gourmet Deli and Caterer

One of the best sides of town to get a great hero. Serving locals FD Police & EMTs…read more Trained CPR Team Used of Hand hygiene A+ Doh & Ground team maintained The hygiene objective is, clean, fresh environment and safe environment Top shelf food 10 Star Quality

Chicken cutlet club was great. Really good hero size…read more Fast and good service. Pricing good for the size of your order. Inside and outside seating.

Build your own sandwich (on a roll). Unbelievably simple but one of the best sandwiches I've had in a very long time.

See all

Railroad Deli

3.0(11 reviews)

3.2 mi

most authentic and delicious taco on Long Island my new go to spot! I got Al Pastor tacos!…read moreEverything is fairly priced as well! Come over here y'all !

12.50 for a roast beef hero and a coffee. And I'm not even joking when I say there was not even a…read more1/4 pound of roast beef on the sandwich plus A thin slice of cheese to boot. I'll never spend a single penny here again.Not to mention that they have nothing that is on their menu (pastrami, corned beef, or bologna) ridiculous

New ownership!!

New ownership!

See all

Moriches Bagel Deli

2.5(44 reviews)

3.1 mi

Best bagels, egg sandwiches, and lunch. Always a good experience. great friendly staff and manager…read moreWil always helpful

Years later service never changes , rude staff and nasty owner. Horrible customer serviceread more

Everything Bagel Twist. More surface = More Chewy Goodness.

Breakfast.

See all

Absolutely disgusting cheese is not even melted!!

Your Bagel Cafe

3.7(30 reviews)

2.8 mi

The fine citizens of Long Island know a good bagel when they taste one. 5 years of living here and…read moreyou start to smell like everything bagel seasoning. 10 years? Cream cheese begins to run through your veins (kidding -- if that happens pls see a doctor). It may be named Your Bagel Cafe, but it is MY forever bagel spot (but we can share). Their tasty bagels have the perfect toasted balance of chew and crunch. Their cream cheese cannot be beat in quality, taste, or portion. The order is always friggin' correct -- their heads are clearly in the game, and they have such a wonderful, positive vibe. Their professionalism is aspirational. Their delicious hard work fuels me to do mine, and I am grateful.

bagels weren't that fresh at all or good. egg sandwich was $10 and not tasty. simple bacon egg…read morecheese. the bagel was what made it not that good

BLT, where's the lettuce?!?!?!

Egg everything bagel with cream cheese

See all

Handy Pantry Friendly Food Stores - Mastic Beach

3.5(13 reviews)

1.3 mi

Great staff the food is amazing and All the people here is very nice and the drinks are amazing and…read moreI love this place a lot I will come back again for more food it was so great and I love they breakfast bagels they are delicious thank you so much. I you guys and girls rock keep up the good job. Thank you so much, your friend Dj Dee Love.

Excellent , fresh food and great service!! I love handy pantry-been going there for years!!read more

The BEST deals on cold cuts.. the Best Homemade, Incredible custom Heros

Front checkout counter

See all

Been going to Handy Pantry for over 20 years

JackSpot

5.0(2 reviews)

0.9 mi

Just stopped in here for breakfast with a buddy after passing this place numerous times. I never…read morereally even thought to go in, but all of the deli's and diners were packed because it's New Years day. Immediately I noticed how CLEAN this place was, and the food on display looked fresh. I ordered a hungry man for breakfast. The food tasted amazing, it was fresh and the cost was significantly lower for breakfast than surrounding deli's. The coffee was fresh, not burned, and the staff was friendly. On top of being a deli, it also serves as a lotto hang out, though that isn't my thing. It's well lit, and has tables to sit down and eat while you watch TV. I think I found my new breakfast spot.

The first review said it perfect. They are clean, well priced, Great food, TV, tables and lots of…read morethe lottery. A great place to get breakfast.

See all

Logo

Giacalone's Deli

3.7(26 reviews)

1.4 mi

So. Much. Yes…read more Walking into any mastic deli can be quite... questionable. In fact, we walked into two before stopping here before the beach and immediately had to walk out. While Giacolones was a bit dated and had a couple prehistoric flies buzzing about, we were quickly greeted upon walking in. The women told us about a few things and the meatballs that were just freshly made. After pondering for a while I just wanted pastrami, and spicy... so I asked her to make me pastrami on a hero with Swiss, Russian, coleslaw, and cherry peppers; my friend got a basic salad with chicken over the top. Add a big water and an big iced tea, it came to about $27-$28 Before I talk about the food, I was a little upset I spent this much on a sandwich and side salad, that's sorta absurd to be honest. Then again, the drinks and tax add up quick, three bux less and I wouldn't even think to mention the price. Moving on, the salad was super fresh, lettuce and cucumbers were crisp, grilled chicken was somehow divinely tender, red onion was fresh, and they gave a nice huge side of blue cheese which was needed for dressing junkies like us. The hero... whoa, I kno it's just a hero and sliced pastrami, but somehow this pastrami was just out of this world tasty, I'm sure it's just your normal awesome board head sliced and tacked onto a sandwich but this sandwich wasn't normal or ordinary in flavor, it was extraordinary. It was perfect and it was sad when I finished gobbling it all up. I immediately knew I'd be making this deli a stop on the way to the beach in a pinch. They are friendly and make a lot of things fresh in-house. They charge two bux too much for everything but it's definitely easy to look past when served with a smile and tastes great.

I paid $33.72 for 3 sandwiches, none were heros. The quality is very basic, I remember this place…read moreuse to have a better vibe. I barely got the attention of the ladies working there, like eye contact when taking an order so I know you are listening and take notes would be nice. I think this is the last time I'm coming here, no pickle with my sandwiches and no macaroni salad offered. Fast food may just be the way to go. They also forgot my extra cheese

See all

Chalet Corrales

4.5(6 reviews)

1.8 mi

Best food & horchata staffing is very professional & super fun ! The place is very nice & very…read moreSalvadoran oriented ( which we all love ) . 100% do recommend

I went for pupusas. The owners are charming and made the pupusas to order. Heads up: Expect a bit…read moreof a wait because they are freshly made. There is seating inside for you to enjoy your food.

Boba Tea Menu

See all

Strathmore Bagels

3.0(45 reviews)

0.6 mi

This is how bagels and egg sandwiches are supposed to be done! There are some decent bagel places…read morein NC but they just can't compare to the meaty bagels on LI. I also have to get an egg sandwich when I visit where I grew up because they don't do it on a Kaiser roll anywhere else I've been. Why not? I don't have an answer for that.

All the employee's are very nice. The past couple times…read moreI've been my egg sandwich was cold.

See all

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

11 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Milk Y.

4 years ago

very very very good i am a food connoisseur and i find delight in eating food i consider deli sandwiches my specialty like lebron to basketball or batman to fighting crime i am very good at what i do and i have a particular set of skills which led me to believe these sandwiches might be the best in the world -food connoisseur read more

Maria G.

4 years ago

SAVE YOUR MONEY!!! Worst Deli in Mastic! Gourmet should not even be in the same sentence with this Deli! The sandwiches were DRY & tasteless!! There was absolutely no thought whatsoever when this $100.00 platter was put together!! Worst Mother's Day luncheon ever! I DO NOT RECOMMEND!! ‍‍ read more

Shannon K.

12 years ago

Awesome food, better than any other deli in the area for sure. Staff is amazing and very accommodating (I need a receipt for every sandwich for the clients I work for) very busy but very fast delicious food :) read more

J R.

4 years ago

Beacon Egg & cheese was on point! lots of options, always my go to deli when you can't decide.

Ryan W.

14 years ago

Great deli - great people. Kind, helpful and the best sandwiches around.

Marii L.

7 years ago

Great service, always fast, fresh food, clean, and very friendly .

Maria G.

11 years ago

Excellent deli with generous portions. Staff is always great.

T H.

10 years ago

Food is hit or miss. Its better when the owner is not there.

Jill F.

Elite 23

288

301

252

11 years ago

Still a big fan of this place. Delicious heroes, nice staff.

Mark J.

8 years ago

i have had better the deli they replaced was so much better!

Levent A.

13 years ago

very friendly staff, good food. a+++++++++

Prisco's Gourmet Deli and Caterer - delis - Updated October 2026

Browse Nearby

BEST of Mastic, New York Restaurants near Prisco's Gourmet Deli and Caterer

BEST of Mastic, New York Coffee near Prisco's Gourmet Deli and Caterer

BEST of Mastic, New York Breakfast near Prisco's Gourmet Deli and Caterer

BEST of Mastic, New York Desserts near Prisco's Gourmet Deli and Caterer

BEST of Mastic, New York Things to Do near Prisco's Gourmet Deli and Caterer

BEST of Mastic, New York Parking near Prisco's Gourmet Deli and Caterer

BEST of Mastic, New York Sandwiches near Prisco's Gourmet Deli and Caterer

BEST of Mastic, New York Shopping near Prisco's Gourmet Deli and Caterer

BEST of Mastic, New York Lunch near Prisco's Gourmet Deli and Caterer

BEST of Mastic, New York Thrift Stores near Prisco's Gourmet Deli and Caterer

Best of Mastic

Things to do in Mastic

Browse Brands

Brands by name

Browse Articles

Articles by date

People who viewed Prisco's Gourmet Deli and Caterer also viewed

Bayport Deli and Convenience

4.5

(8 reviews)

The sandwiches are so pricey and the guy was honestly pretty rude the guy who made my sandwich I…read moredon't know if he woke up on the wrong side or the bed or what but had a nasty attitude.

Great family owned operation; sandwiches are great, service is on point…read more Give them a try if you are in the area.

Lake Ave Deli

3.1

(33 reviews)

The food is all fresh and delicious. The best deli in…read moreSuffolk county ! The owner goes totally out of his way to help.

Gave daughter free water in the heat. Very nice people…read more Was a fair and they could've charged me up the arse

Se-Port Delicatessens

4.4

(636 reviews)

I see your port and I raise you mine. Se-Port Delicatessen IS the standard. Your local deli has no…read moreright to even compare itself. It's so far ahead of all delis and sandwich spots you've been. This is Long Island's gem. Five stars only is an injustice. It's one of the country's finest spots. It's what George Washington hoped for when he crossed the Delaware. It's what Qin Shi Huangdi believed would come when he unified China. It's what Moses split the Red Sea for. If aliens really existed, they'd be spotted here. If I ate one a day I'd gain 2 pounds a day and that's fine. I wouldn't care. 400 lbs? Ok. Bring it on, I say. Don't test me. As I sit on the John - Delta forcing out a few nukes - I think to myself... oh what a wonderful world. What a wonderful world I live in that I could experience the (and a) Gasm. The Anthony Kay. The Steven Matz. The Boone. The list goes on and on. The amount of underwear I've gone through from ordering the Gasm. Worth it. The M&M cookies on the counter that look at me as if I'm the newest bombshell on the island... oggling and boggling baby. The rumor is these guys churn out millions of cutlets a year. And that's just for me. - Sidebar: Weak sauce LB. Weak. Don't fall into the dad jokes just yet. Don't embarrass me in front of my people. Don't do it. - Anyways. As a poor young man(not that my circumstances have changed) I used to save up my measly funds for just one sandwich on the weekend. It would consume me all week and then I'd consume it in mere minutes. Every time me and my rapscallion crew would come we'd be certain that we'd eat half there and then eat the half later or save the rest for the week. Others had self control to stick to the plan. But I did not. And I'm proud of that. I'm proud of the man I've become. But not proud enough. For one day... one day... I'll go to Se-Port and I'll order The Linguini B. Only on that day, will I be allowed to die. To escape the brilliance of the world and head to the distraction of darkness. Until then - There is much to do. People to influence. Persuasion to persuade. Lust to lunge for. Sandwiches to feast on. The glory of Se-Port. I live a tender distance from this master factory of a deli; however, it's one of the few pieces in this world worth traveling a ridonk distance for. I will walk the Whitestone Bridge to be reacquainted. I would slosh around in the sewage of the Sound to make my way to this Mecca. I am currently working on my masters in astrophysics solely with the purpose of conjugating and coagulating a way to build the first wormhole - From my bed, straight to the parking lot of Seport. Few failed attempts, so far, but thankfully I'm not self-testing. Don't report me. Jokes on you... I'm closer than you'd think. Well. I'm sure you get my notes in the mail, so I'll wrap this up. One day, my love. One day, again, as we had it before. You and me, on the water, whisking the waves with the palms our feet. Our luscious hair sweeping the wind. Stopping time with the strength of our shared gazes. Our hands interlocked, just like our shared destinies. Yours tenderly and truthfully - LB.

It's a deli that has become extremely popular due to social media sharing…read more It is clean, there is plenty of space to sit and they have an immense number of specialty sandwiches that are posted on boards all around the counter. They serve hot food as well as standard sandwiches and they stuff the sandwiches quite a bit, almost too much. The service at the counter is always friendly when they take my order. The issue is, they are extremely overpriced. A bologna sandwich on a simple roll and a seltzer should not be approximately $20. The chicken cutlets are microwaved when they are ordered and they just aren't good and they are very pricy. Also, they don't sell drinks in cans, which would be a bit cheaper because a bottle of soda for $4 is just not fair. If you want a standard deli sandwich, at a reasonable price, I'd try a different deli in the area.

Weinisch's Deli

4.3

(60 reviews)

*CASH ONLY* This 40…read moreyear old, family-owned, deli is a true gem! I went here because of a Yelp elite review and it was the best decision I've made today. TGIF! Service was quick and friendly! The lady at the counter knew both of the other customers by name. Regulars are always a good thing in any establishment. The sandwich was excellent, and I miss my Long Island, Deli's! I didn't know it was cash only and came up short $.50. She told me not to worry about it. That won me over and every time I'm on Long Island I will attend this deli as well as tip her. I highly recommend you check this place out.

Good food, good service. An excellent example of small, local business that beats the corporate…read morealternatives. It's cash only, so no credit cards, debit cards or cash phony cryptoFake money. But that's understandable. The originators of this business have passed but their daughter (I am told) carries on in their footsteps. I hope she knows they'd be proud. It's a great deli.

Back Country Deli

3.1

(27 reviews)

Good local spot! Especially in area with no other food/Delis nearby. Quick grab and go deli with no…read morecomplaints!

9 dollars sausage egg cheese and felt like i was eating a egg and cheese sandwich. Spot decentread more

South Shore Deli & Grocery

3.0

(10 reviews)

I called in an order this afternoon and was told $25 for a few breakfast sandwiches, which was…read morefine. I questioned the owner over the phone, saying $25 was somewhat pricey. I then went into the store, where I confronted the owner, and we proceeded to argue for a 10-minute period, with him implying that he can't have feelings--when, as the customer, I believe we should be right, no matter how he feels. He then proceeded to not have any remorse for my inquiry, implying that he's been there for 30 years. Side note: I go to this deli often, and if you do not speak Spanish or don't look Spanish, you get poor service often. Please do not support this deli anymore.

That's my morning spot, I always call in advance, since they get busy, best BECspk around!!read more

Vargas Fam Deli

5.0

(4 reviews)

Best food around! I drive 30 minutes to eat here it's so great! Sandwiches and platters are 100%…read morerecommended. I love getting their BEC on a hero with mayo it's 100% worth it.

Great fresh food - staff is great…read more Frequent stop !! Good prices too! Location is always clean and well kept

Mooney Pond Deli & Market

3.7

(12 reviews)

* This deli is a hidden gem everything looks fresh and inviting…read more * The service here is very good. * The ambiance here is so warm and inviting

The egg sandwiches via Tonya are the best around.. Great service and clean rest room. I've also had…read morethe roast beef and cheese w garlic bread.. FANTASTIC U go Tommy....

TJ's Hero Shop

4.0

(153 reviews)

Found this amazing spot while heading to Montauk and wow... this has to be one of the best…read moresandwiches I've had! I ordered a warm turkey sandwich and I honestly couldn't believe how something so simple could be that delicious..The portions are generous, so you definitely get your money's worth. I'd easily give this place a 10/10! I also loved that they have a little grocery store inside it's a nice touch and makes it fun to browse while you wait for your food.

Incredibly delicious food, excellent and genuine service, in a classic sandwich spot ambiance is…read morehow I describe TJ's Hero shop in Patchogue. When you come in, you're greeted by warm smiles and positive energy. I've been here every time I come back to NY, and their consistency for making great sandwiches is unmatched. I get the Turkey, Roast Beef, and Provolone Hero hot with The Works (Lettuce, Tomato, onions, oil and vinegar) and it's amazing every time! I normally grab a big bag of Wise Onion and Garlic chips to compliment the Hero and it pairs perfectly. Anytime you're hungry and want a great Hero sandwich, this is the place to get it. I'm actually on my way to grab another one now!

Locust Avenue Deli

3.7

(105 reviews)