Lenny is always cordial and amenable. Liked dealing with him. Pricing is fair…read more Would recommend highly.

The store has wonderful dresses and jewelry. We love to find fabulous items and beautiful vintage…read moreclothing and accessories. Mr. Lenny is the best!

Stage Coach Metuchen has an assortment of items: collectibles, antiques, jewelry, salt & pepper…read moresets, some wonderful vintage purses, lamps, some dishes and tableware. It's a small store, but they have packed a lot of stuff into a small space. In the back there are also some locally-made gift baskets. Worth stopping by if you are in the area, because you never know what you're going to find.

We were out for my husband's birthday on 10/26/23. We saw this shop and stopped in to take a look…read more They really didn't' have anything that interested us, so as we were about to leave, my husband asked the Lady if she had any coins. She said that she did and went to get a tin from behind the counter. The whole time she kept saying that she didn't really know that much about coins but proceeded to pull out some of the larger coins for us to view. My husband chose two of the $1.00 coins she showed him and some small change. After looking them up on her phone, she told us $40.00 for the 1900 dollar and then said $150.00 for everything he had chosen to purchase. The second coin was dated 1797 Trade dollar. When we got home the next day, I looked them up for him to check the values. My first clue was when I could only find "Trade dollars" minted in the 1800's. I then dug deeper and found out that it was a fake. After reading information on them, it was suggested to put a magnet to it to see if it stuck. Well, it did! I immediately checked the 1900 coin also. Guess what? Fake also. Lesson learned for $150.00 is always carry a magnet with us and have the equipment you need to verify what you have in your hand. I'm just glad we didn't get taken for any more than we did. Buyer beware is the right phrase for this shop!

I have paid a visit to the store twice. Twice, as noted in other reviews, the shop owner does not…read morekeep the hours posted. Even with a sign on the door stating closed returning at a specific time, if you return after that time, they are not always open. The door will be locked and if you knock, no one answers. The first time I did this, I had to call and spoke to somebody. The second time however, I did not bother. The store does have a decent selection of mostly jewelry items for sale. If you were looking for antiques, this is not a traditional antique store.

My little lady love thrift stores. We stopped here to shop for some things we could take back home…read morefrom our trip, and I was amazing too. Love the antics and houseware stuff you could decorate with. Nice owners and staff to show us around and answer questions. Wonderful experience we had.

The place is disgusting. My wife thought it was nice to buy me some vintage shirts so she went to…read morethis location and brought them home. A few days later, I noticed I had some marks on my arm and it was very itchy so I went to the urgent care, and they told me to go to the emergency room where they told me that I had bedbugs, and that the bedbugs came from the clothing I was wearing.. We went back to the location to tell them of the situation, and they assure us that they have no bedbugs, but we found out that everything that they sell is donated by people and then resold at a profit so there is no way of them knowing if someone has bedbugs or not so I suggest that you steer clear to this place. You have been given warning.!!!

I do not understand these love reviews. This place is quite accurate. It is amazing. The service is…read moreamazing. The selection is amazing. The value is very high for a very low price with 100% recommend to come here every day if you can.

Worst thrift store ! why say they buy clothes and they are very picky with it ! I got scammed over…read moreexpensive shoes .. I got not even close to what I payed for at an actual store .. And they were still good ! ... do not go if you're looking to sell your stuff. they are also nasty when you call over the phone they need to close this store down. they are fraud. MIND YOU ! I WAS SO MAD I JUST TOOK MY JORDANS BACK. AND I SAID WAY BEFORE WHY ARE TOU GUYS JUST GONNA GIVE ME 50$ FOR SHOES THAT ARE LITERALLY MORE THEN A 100 DOLLARS. Her answer was "usually these type of shoes are not very up to style and the sizing ! GIRL WHAT. Anyways I took my Jordan's back . I was upset I didn't bring my Uggs back. but at that moment I was so upset . and I did not wanna lose it . I left 4 items. On top the shoes. I got 32 dollars... Yea no worst place . horrible store. I would never ever waste my times with these scums. ABSOLUTELY NEVER! DONT WASTE YOU'RE TIME.

I called in regards to looking for furniture When I got the recording there was a message from last…read moreDecember saying they would be closed for the holidays and will reopen January 3rd

From the owner: We specialize in High Quality, New and Used Furniture at Affordable Prices!read more

A wonderful little thrift store with limited hours. There's none of the upcharging that you will…read moresee in corporate thrift stores - just genuine people with the money going to a good cause. Most prices ranged between $2-10 I've seen and they take Venmo. Hours are 12-4pm on Wednesdays and Fridays.

From the owner: We are a nonprofit organization sponsored by Second Reformed Church. All proceeds go to the Five…read moreLoaves Food Pantry also sponsored by the church. We sell gently used women's and men's clothing and accessories plus housewares. Come visit our friendly store and check out our great prices!