How can this place even be serious calling themselves an Italian deli?!?! The few specialty…read more sandwiches I gotten here before were mediocre at best and way over priced for the quality. Decent place if you just need a sandwich or something quick to eat but by no means an Italian deli. This is a fake Italian deli. Go to sansotta in Cortlandt instead

Beware - this is not an Italian deli. Food is abysmal. Chicken cutlet was frozen and not fried…read morelong enough, bread was stale, they forgot the oil and vinegar, and the prosciutto was as dry as leather. All this for $28. Are you kidding? BTW - I went there a few weeks before for breakfast. How do you mess up two bacon, egg, cheese on a roll.

A ++++ the Best Sandwich Spot with customer service to the top levels. They catered to our veterans…read moregroup on a regular and even named a sandwich after a few of the best customers

I've had several sandwiches here. All of them were delicious and the quality is what I'd expect…read morefrom a local deli in New York. Would come again.

Awesome food great people!! If you want a great Italian combo go there!! They go out of their way…read morefor you however you want your food!!

Nice friendly deli with great service The food is all…read morehomemade with a lot of choices. The layout is all open with an area to sit and eat or just enjoy a hot or cold drink Plenty of parking right off Albany Post Road. I really enjoyed my bacon egg and cheese sandwich

Asked a local where to grab sandwiches to take over to George's Island Park and they said Cole's…read morewithout hesitation. They were right.

Stopping in to Coles is like a flashback of my childhood; I grew up in the area and haven't been…read moreback in many years. Remarkably, nothing has changed: THIS SHOP/Market is very CLEAN the shop is well lit and you would be hard-pressed to find dust on anything. Shelves are well stocked as are the reach in coolers stocked with grab and go take out items. PRICES are reasonable considering the quality. I picked up freshly ground chuck for $7.99/lb which is just slightly more expensive than mega supermarket chains with questionable sell-by dates. PANTRY items weave in and out, beckoning to take them home. (I DID). SYSTEMS are really great. after your selection at the butcher, they assign you a basket # so you can shop with both hands free. This is a well organized order and pick up system; if you need fresh meats, head to the back, past the enormous freezer selection of ravioli, manicotti, and other Italian specialties. SERVICE: you are immediately greeted by friendly staff ( this reminds me of the Japanese culture of greeting every patron immediately. A very nice feeling ( clever also; once you are greeted so warmly, you are compelled to shop.) I'm so pleased to have made a little detour on my way home

Had a Philly cheesesteak on a hard roll - delicious!!! Worth the time to visit! The clerk was…read morefriendly and the service quick!

Hello my name is Jess and I frequently order from Baisleys. That is why I feel compelled to write a…read morereview. I've never had an issue with this until the new owner. This is the 2nd time in *less* than 3 weeks of finding hair in my food. The owner did apologize the 1st time but at this point a Corrective measure needs to be taken due to the frequency of this issue. Possibly a hair net ? Men and women, who ever is cooking. As a frequent customer that spends a lot of money at the deli I must say I feel Disappointed, and may not return until a solution is provided.

Came here For the first time the basic sandwich I ordered…read morewas pretty descent. The service was quick didn't have to wait long for my Food . Small place but a lot of variety to choose from I will definitely be back again.

Do not come here looking for a good breakfast sandwich. This was the worst showing of a bacon egg…read moreand cheese on a bagel I have ever seen. Quite an accomplishment for a deli to win this award. Cheese wasn't melted...and tasted just as unappetizing as it looks. This is New York, if you can't make a bacon egg and cheese, what are you even doing?

I wished so hard that I lived closer to this deli. I would eat so much more from here. Such a…read moregreat friendly service. They will answer any questions you have. They have a huge selection of pre made sides and entrees to take home and make. Along with an amazing sandwich and deli counter. The chicken parm is fire. And may favorite is prosciutto fresh mozzarella and sun dried tomatoes on a wedge. Perfect !!!

Their rare roast beef, alone, is worth the trip. Made in house and almost always super rare…read more Incredibly tasty and thinly sliced, it's like a little slice of meat heaven. The olive selection is outstanding. Mix and match your favorites. The place isn't cheap, but you get what you pay for. Service is always friendly. This place gets very busy around lunchtime during the week. Budget some wait time if you go during a high traffic period.