Wow. I came in close to closing time. Instead of shutting me away, they offered what they had and didn't even charge me for it. I had a tuna salad sandwich and Miss Vicky's dill pickle and jalapeño chips. The dill pickle chips were out of this world. The tuna salad was so cold and refreshing after a long bike ride. I loved every tasty fresh fresh bite. The kindest people inside. I was happy to pay. They literally gave me the lunch that they were gonna take home. Who does that? World class care of customers and understanding it's more than money. I really respect the people who work here. read more

Dominic's Delicatessen - Tuna sandwich - Delis Near Me - Tarrytown, New York

See all

Delicious sandwiches great service very friendly perfect neighborhood deli. Bring your appetite. The sandwiches are very big, but the prices are perfect. read more

See all

Stopped by Dominic's for lunch while passing through Tarrytown and it was so delicious that I came back in two weeks again, specifically for their signature sandwich #2. The hero loaf ($13.95) is studded with sesame and the hot roast beef is so tender and flavorful, while the chipotle aioli helps cut through the muenster and beef. The grilled onions add a sweetness to the sandwich and the grilled hot peppers can be a hit or miss depending on how spicy they are. Overall, a fantastic sandwich that I absolutely fell in love with. I also ordered the signature sandwich #3 on a roll ($10.50) with honey turkey, which was very generously portioned and also excellent (but not as standout as the roast beef). The staff are extremely helpful and chatty-- don't be afraid to ask questions! I came around the tail end of the lunch rush around 2pm and there were still people coming in after me as well. Fantastic neighborhood spot! read more

See all

4 years later Still the best deli in Tarrytown. FYI the macaroni salad sells out I've missed it twice lol. Here's an Italian combo on a roll. Pic of my face for reference of what you're ordering. Dominic's Deli is always Consistent read more

Dominic's Delicatessen - Italian combo on a roll, not a wedge not a hero but it's got its own zip code - Delis Near Me - Tarrytown, New York

I just had my first sandwich from Dominic's in Tarrytown. Being a roast beef fan, and discovering (like all good delis) their roast beef was homemade, I opted for the hot roast beef wedge. I am not overstating this. It was by far the best roast beef sandwich I have ever had. And as my go to sandwich order, I have had a LOT of roast beef sandwiches. This one was absolutely incredible. I don't know if it was how they cooked the beef, or the aioli they used, or both but it was warm and moist and so so tasty. The five star review are real. If you are anywhere near Tarrytown at breakfast or lunch time, do yourself a favor and give them a try. read more

Great old school sub shop. Some really great local flavor options. Love the vibe. It's all about the food, no frills. Oder and be on your way. Sometimes hard to find parking but worth finding a spot to taste the goods read more

Great deli! Fresh ingredients and sandwiches made to order! They have a full breakfast menu and all the cold cuts for a hero you can imagine! The bread is fresh and soft with a little crisp. Just what you want for a hero! The hero is huge and reasonably priced for how packed the sandwich is! I got soppressata, prosciutto, mozz, roasted peppers and arugula on a hero for $12. Can't beat it! They also have some salad and imported pantry items for all your Italian needs! The staff is super helpful and friendly. Would definitely recommend if you are craving a nice hero! read more

Dominic's Delicatessen - a cut in half sandwich - Delis Near Me - Tarrytown, New York

I had driven past Dominic's a number of times but had never stopped in One Saturday I had the urge for a good breakfast sandwich so I figured I'd give it a try I had eggs, turkey and grilled onions on a roll and it was extraordinary- good quality and quantity, reasonably priced and pleasant service Soon I hope to try lunch at Dominic's read more

I've lived all over the country after growing up in Delaware where they had some amazingly good Italian subs. No place comes close...until, finally, after decades of searching, I tried Dominic's. This is the real deal. read more

This place is plucked from the movies. This is exactly what a real New York deli is and should be forever and ever!! The woman behind the counter really makes the whole experience-- with her New York accent, friendly but not overbearingly friendly small talk, and no-BS vibe. A great place to stop in if you need a "why do I live in New York?" reminder. Good prices, super fresh rolls, perfectly seasoned sandwiches. Also convenient- some pantry items, especially of the Italian variety. You can't go wrong here. There is a small high-top counter if you'd like to sit and eat inside, but I'd recommend taking it to-go and enjoying the park down the street. read more

Dominic's Delicatessen - Turkey and egg on a roll - Delis Near Me - Tarrytown, New York

See all

Sandwich Heaven. We found it passing by. You name it, they have it, from Italian specialties like Mortadella with pistachio, Coppa and Dilusso Soppresata, to a nice tea selection, and even non-sandwich classics like LPs! You can build your own or choose from their "Signature" set. Mind you, the sandwiches are HUGE...both of ours could feed two people each. I had the #5 Signature - chicken cutlet, prosciutto from Italy, mozzarella, roasted red peppers and balsamic. On a roll for $9.95. Weighs in at 250lbs :) See pic. My wife had a turkey and Swiss (no pic) that included an entire turkey! Both delicious. Friendly service topped it off. We need a deli like this in our town in Florida. read more

See all

Must try: #5 Signature Sandwich (Chicken Cutlet and Prosciutto) and Italian Combo Sandwich! Why: Huge meaty sandwiches that were so delicious! I got the #5 Chicken Cutlet, Prosciutto, Mozzarella, Arugula, Roasted Peppers and Balsamic - and enjoyed every bite, but also loved being able to pull off the prosciutto that was hanging from the side to eat in between my bites. I was only able to finish half of my sandwich so saved the other half for when we got back home. My brother got the Italian Combo and it was also fantastic. Oh, and it's less than $11 for the massive sandwiches! Also, I paired my sandwich with some Italian fruit beverage (Tangerine & Prickly Pear), which was refreshing. Note: My brother and I came with our pups after our hike at Bear Mountain, and they were very friendly and were obvious dog lovers too. The lady who helped me was awesome and recommended #5 for which I am forever grateful! We wish we knew about this place before because it would have been great to enjoy the sandwiches for lunch on top of the mountain to give us extra fuel to hike down! Will definitely add this my bookmark favorites for when drive through Tarrytown or go hiking again! read more

Dominic's Delicatessen - #5 Chicken Cutlet, Prosciutto, Mozzarella, Arugula, Roasted Peppers and Balsamic ($11) - Delis Near Me - Tarrytown, New York

This may look like a hole in the wall, but literally the best subs/deli place I've been to. Even the ones in NYC cannot compare. Expect a line. Some seating outside and small counter inside. I would call ahead with your order. read more

The real deal for an Italian combo sandwich - always get the sesame seed roll. Super friendly and laughter abounds. Vinyl always playing. Italian specialty items also available. read more

Dominic's Delicatessen - Dominic's - Delis Near Me - Tarrytown, New York

Awesome sandwiches. Best to call in your order ahead of time. Great deli, wish we could take it home to So Cal!

While this place deserves five stars, I was extremely upset to discover that they went on vacation without calling me first to ask for permission (jk obviously). Our go to pitstop when my partner and I leave the city. Great sandwiches and nice people. read more

Went there twice while visiting NYC. I want them to open one down the street from us in IN so I can be a regular. So much charm and the quality of meat is top notch. The pastrami is nothing like we can get here. They know their regulars by name and even recognized us on our second visit. read more

Dominic's Delicatessen - Chef salad with oil and vinegar. - Delis Near Me - Tarrytown, New York

See all

Great big tasty sandwiches great value. Love the all the specialty sandwiches. Good service and quick turnaround.

The owners are always friendly, fun people. The food is tasty at a great price point, just make sure to come early because they sell out some ingredients later in the day. I've had the two grilled chicken special sandwich types, and one sandwich on a hero is enough food for me for a whole day (and I eat a ton of food). The sesame hero is a great bread btw. Honestly, my favorite though has to be the healthy breakfast B or #2 or something, on a spinach wrap. Perfect combo of sliced turkey, egg whites, tomatoes, and feta. Highly recommend it, and the place in general read more

Love this place. Can always get a HUGE fresh sub for around 10 bucks that can literally feed 2 to 4 people. It's a small store with not many things else but they're fresh food, but I definitely recommend this place! Also great, friendly staff. read more

Fantastic NY deli that I'd come back in a heartbeat! First off, amazing staff...the lady behind the counter taking our order was friendly and funny and helped us navigate ingredients when they ran out of some of the sandwiches, while the gentlemen making the sandwiches were truly connoisseurs. I really wanted the Signature #5 but the last one was ordered right in front of me (ugh!). Instead, I ordered an Italian hero while my wife ordered the Hot Roast Beef (Signature #2 - w/ Muenster cheese, hot peppers, grilled onions). Of course we had to add a mac salad side. Both sandwiches were delicious - well seasoned and loaded with the fixings. The mac salad was excellent. We should have ordered a pint! Very reasonably priced and even better given how big the sandwiches were (~$28 after tip for 2 large heroes and the mac). We will have to make a special trip back just to try the #5! read more

See all

Delicious sandwiches and super friendly staff! The sandwiches we got were huge and super filling! I'd definitely come back. read more

Dominic's Delicatessen - This signature sandwich #1. Really good highly recommend! - Delis Near Me - Tarrytown, New York

This deli is amazing. Their ingredients all taste fresh and the staff is truly amazing at making sandwiches. They have some good combos on the menu and a lot of items to make your choice simple and easy. I went for the first time today and the staff greeted me warmly, and made me one of the best sandwiches I've ever had. Place is nice and clean too. read more

Dominic's Delicatessen - Signature sandwich #5 - Delis Near Me - Tarrytown, New York

See all

Dominic's has a great breakfast sandwich and the staff are great! I would highly recommend if you're in Tarrytown for breakfast or lunch

As always, great sandwiches at a great price! Almost always stop in here when I'm in tarrytown and get an Italian sandwich or the #5 sandwich special. Friendly service and large portions! read more

See all

As the default Italian deli located right in the heart of Tarrytown, Dominic's is well trafficked and a little off center. This is the only Italian deli I've ever been to that has a record section. There's flyers for events in town. The family that runs the place is down to earth, honest and easy to talk to; they're also funny as hell which is a big plus, as I hate delis where everyone is pissed off all the time. They have Manhattan Special, which is a huge plus in and of itself; this is espresso coffee soda that is hard to find and an absolutely must if you love coffee. Sandwiches I've tried so far are the chicken parm and the #5. Chicken parm was solid with good bread that held up to the hefty sandwich. Wish they went heavier with the sauce, although it seems to go better with the eggplant parm. The #5 (chicken, proscuitto, mozzarella, arugula, roasted red peppers, balsamic) was even better. Not sure if the roasted red peppers are homemade, but they taste like it. Proscuitto portion was generous but not so much to overwhelm the sandwich. Balsamic was good quality and added the right amount of acidity. I got grilled chicken instead of a cutlet (to be healthy, blah blah blah) and I actually liked it more. Mozzarella was kind of just there, so might do it with a sharper cheese next time. Others have gotten eggplant parm, the #2 and other sandwiches to good results. Chip selection is limited but good stuff (Hal's) and there is also the obligatory assortment of other Italian goods. Short version: this is a great Italian deli that should make Tarrytown proud. Very happy to have this nearby! read more

If I could give a 0 I would. I ordered 2 sandwiches and waited with my husband while they helped 3 other people behind us. Finally went up and asked what's going on and he asked me what I ordered and I told him. He couldn't find the order. Didn't remember I had ordered in front of him 20 minutes prior and they were out of rolls and hero's. I left. Terrible service and people. read more

Just an update of photos, another week, five more sandwiches, can't go wrong in this place. This go around we had Chicken Cutlet, Ham & Cheese subs, Italian Combo, plain Roast Beef on rolls and an Eggplant warp. As I stated in my previous review the sandwiches are Jurassic Park proportions - love this place & by the looks of it so do many more. At prime time lunch hour usually there's a line of people outside either waiting to order or to pick up. My advice is to order by phone. They do know how to make a great sandwich. read more

See all

This is the first place we hit when in Tarrytown. It is a small mom and pop style deli with a broad sandwich menu. The prices are good, and the sandwiches are incredible. Today was cold and rainy, so I ordered a coffee. It was excellent, and the price was about half of the price at a "coffee" joint. read more

Wow! I don't even know how to start this, I tried the #5, with chicken cutlet, prosciutto, fresh mozz, arugula, roasted peppers and balsamic. The sandwich is not only insanely large but the ingredients are super fresh, top notch and perfectly portions and compiled. The bread is fresh and soft, easy to handle and nothing slides around. This was a total random drive by and I'm so happy I stopped!! Super friendly staff, nicest people I've met in a long time. Can't wait to get back here again and try out some of the other signature sandwiches! read more

Dominic's Delicatessen - #5 signature - chicken cutlet, fresh mozz, prosciutto, roasted peppers, arugula and balsamic on a sesame seed wedge - Delis Near Me - Tarrytown, New York

Fantastic spot. Super friendly staff and delicious food at very affordable prices! Loved my sandwich and would definitely come back.

Yelp never steers me wrong. I needed catering for a work event and I prefer only to use the local businesses. I found Dominic's and reached out to the owner to coordinate our lunch event for 50 people the following day. My coworker and I got ourselves sandwiches when we went in to place the order and his response was "I'm going to have to unhinge my jaw to eat this incredible sandwich." Needless to say the food was outstanding and the people that work at Dominic's are awesome. I'll definitely be back! Thanks again! read more

On my way from the doctor's office. I decided to look at Yelp and find a place to get a good breakfast sandwich. After some research I settled on Dominics. That was the best decision that I made that day. The food was fresh and tasty. It is not like your traditional breakfast spot where some of the items are premade and waiting for an order. The food was made to order which was a giant surprise for me. This is a little hidden gem that everyone should experience. The staff was very friendly read more

See all

The hot roast beef is probably the best deli sandwich I've ordered in about a decade. This sandwich, which is on their signature menu, came out with roast beef piled high (easily and inch thick) on crunchy bread. The outer layers of beef were brown and crisped from the grill, but the inner slices were still pink - like a perfect medium rare steak. The Muenster cheese was melted down to goo over grilled onions and hot peppers, all measured in perfect proportions to complement the beef. The sandwich comes in two bread options: a roll for $8.50 and a hero for $10.75. I opted for the larger of the two and will get two meals out of it. Deliciously perfect execution and a huge portion makes this a great value to me. The menu as a whole plays to their strong sandwich game. In addition to the 6 signature offerings, you can of course build your own, and they do offer some more eclectic options like mortadella. The rest is more limited. They also make wraps and some tempting salads, and while they listed some potentially good homemade sides like potato salad and cole slaw, I didn't see them on display in the case. The dessert bar I bought was locally sourced from a Hudson Valley bakery, but it was just OK. There is a small counter by the front window, but really this is a grab-and-go spot. The sandwich was in my hand five minutes after I ordered. We're looking forward to returning soon to take their breakfast menu for a test drive. read more

Dominic's Delicatessen - Delis Near Me - Tarrytown, New York

See all

I have been there twice and both visits were exceptional! Both times helped by Charlie. Warm, professional, and oh so knowledgeable. The breakfast sandwiches I got were extraordinary! I'm an owner of a hotel in the area and have already told our concierge to recommend. And was impressed with the cleanliness of shop and staff, and their adhering to COVID standards. With the combination of Charlie and the food taste/quality, I'm going to return a lot. Everyone go and enjoy!:)) read more

great customer service. The ownership cares about their regulars and they make a great sandwich

Simply put, the best sandwiches and service on planet earth. Incredible customer service from an adorable young lady and two gentleman I consider " Master Sandwich Makers" I get sandwiches/food here at least 3x week and I have to say " All there sandwiches are fantastic" Place is immaculate and a true neighborhood "Gem" Gets crowded during lunchtime but the wait is worth it, trust me. Try one of their sandwich combinations and experience "Sandwich Heaven" and thank me later. read more

Dominic's Delicatessen - # 5 combo Yummy - Delis Near Me - Tarrytown, New York

Absolutely 10 STARS. My whole family (7kids+ Son in law + husband) decided on a whim to meet in NY for the weekend and explore Sleepy Hollow. Not wanting to be stuck in long lines (party of 10!) waiting for a restaurant, we decided a picnic would be the best way. I found Dominic's and called them. I'm sure they thought I was nuts, but Joe was brave and took a chance. I sent in my order on Thursday and Saturday at 12:30, we went in to pick up and everything was PERFECT. I highly recommend- the sandwiches were HUGE and delicious. We sent the leftovers home with the Boston kids and they have food for days. Thanks to everyone at the Deli for making our weekend so much fun. read more

I tried out this deli for the first time today. I ordered a custom sandwich. eggplant, hot soppressata, provolone, roasted peppers, and arugula on a hero (sesame seed). Perfection. I also couldn't help but notice the best prices for coffee that I've seen in years. If only I lived a little closer to Tarrytown. read more

Italian combo is fucking fire! You won't regret it! It's the only thing I've tried there but it's amazing!