I love the different themes they do and the pizza is good, alittle spicy. The service is good too. I don't like that theyre carry out only.

Ordered takeout this week and Poseidons did not disappoint! I tried the Joe Burrow pizza with an extra side of house made ranch. All of it was soooo good. The service was quick even though they were very busy for Monday night. I will be back! read more

Went here for lunch and they did not disappoint. The bread sticks and pizza were very good. Highly recommend!

I would happily leave zero stars if I could. I don't usually leave bad reviews, I just don't return. Tonight was the third time they did not have my order. This time, they said they gave it to someone else. Other times, they said they didn't receive the order until I showed them where I ordered and paid for it. No apologies any of the times. Just said they'd make it and I ended up waiting for an hour. Said they gave it to someone else this time but would remake it but it would take a while. When I asked for a refund, they didn't have the amount right, had to show them the order/amount. No apologies any of the times. This time all I got was "Do you want your change?" Pizza isn't good enough to struggle to get my orders. Beware. All the times I've sat in the lobby waiting, I'm not the only one. For me, third time, you're out. read more

The pizza wasn't close to be round. Like a 5th grader was on dough this particular night. The toppings are scarce. What toppings were there ended up in the middle of the pizza. Not enough cheese and not enough toppings for $27. read more

I don't know how this restaurant even still exists. Everytime I order it's very salty ,hardly no sauce, pizza tastes like it's old, rubbery and cardboard. Little Ceasers probably tastes better read more

Thursday Pizza deal was Awesome & was cooked perfectly! Wait time can Improve but overall pizza was great!!

Who in their right mind would $25 on a large pizza that is only 12"? Are you kidding me!!! Never again. What a huge waste of money. Besides the exorbitant cost, the pizza was no better than any other pizza place in the area. Basic in every way. How this place gets voted best in Northern Kentucky is beyond me. read more

Poseidon's Pizza Company - Pizza Near Me - Florence, Kentucky

See all

Overpromised, under delivered $30 for some cheese sticks and crappy medium pizza, order bourbon barrel house, Dewey's, Strong's, etc read more

Poseidon's Pizza Company - So cheesy garlic drips with burnt up cheese. Skip it - Pizza Near Me - Florence, Kentucky

Food was outstanding and especially loved the buffalo bread. We had the pizza where you could pick a few you wanted to try and put it all on one big pizza - there were too many good types to try. The gentleman at the desk was very kind and helpful - great family friendly pizza pickup place! read more

Every experience we've had with Poseidon's and the owners, Savannah and Brad has been great! We get pizza from there at least once a week. Our favorite is the Dab of Ranch. They are very helpful in the community. The staff is always friendly. It bothers me if someone were to ever put a bad review. I truly don't know how they could be or do any better. They offer specials throughout the week and have a punch card that when it's filled, you'll get 50% off, also. read more

I wouldn't call myself a regularly customer by any means, but I've been ordering from Poseidon's two to three times a year since it opened in Florence. It was always a decent experience until the last two times, which had been my first visits in quite a while. A couple months back I picked up a pizza about 30 minutes after I ordered it. I received no notification like I usually do, but I figured it was probably close to done and I could just wait there if not. Well, it was definitely done when I received it, seeing as it was completely room temperature. They must have made it right after I ordered it and failed to notify me and it just sat. I guess they have no means of keeping their food warm? Whatever. I understand sometimes mistakes happened. I'm not usually one to complain unless something is really bad. Like inedible. Which leads me into the last time I ordered from there... On this occasion I was notified that my pizza was done. Great. I had been running an errand and was near the store already so I arrived just a couple minutes later. I pick up my pizza and decided to check it when I got back to my car. Pepperoni can make for a greasy pizza already, but when I say this thing was greasy I mean it was like sopping wet. There was a pool of grease that had collected on one side of the pizza like someone dumped a cup of the stuff on it. I lifted a slice up to check underneath and it was complete mush. Exactly how you would expect a pizza to be that had been left to sit in a liquid, and it was soaking into the cardboard. I would've for sure had grease in the seat of my car if I drove home with it. Like I said, I'm not one to complain, but this *was* inedible. At least in any traditional way you eat a pizza. I might've been able to use a spoon. I mean, it wasn't merely "not to my preference" or going to make for a disappointing mediocre dinner that I paid good money for. It was pizza soup. I immediately took it back in and asked for my money back. I didn't make a big deal about it but I told and showed them why. The guy at the counter (an older gentleman, not the person who handed me the pizza) gave me my money back without argument, but also didn't apologize or comment on what was clearly not an acceptable pizza by any stretch of the imagination. I don't need them to fall all over themselves apologizing or anything, but I found this kind of strange. I know restaurants get picky customers who are impossible to please and will complain about anything, but the issues with this pizza were incontrovertible. No one there would eat something like this had they ordered it. I kind of expected at least an excuse or a "my bad, dude" or something. Anyway... I don't know what's going on behind the scenes there. I saw there was a change in ownership at some point in some of these reviews and I guess they've had a drop in quality since then. Or maybe I'm unlucky and just went on two off nights. I don't know. Either way that's the last time I roll the dice with them. I don't eat out often enough to want to deal with stuff like that. read more

Not the best, but not the worst. We ordered Poseidon's Pizza for pick-up on a Thursday night, and had a positive experience placing our order online and picking everything up. Our food was ready in less than 30 minutes - and the location of this restaurant was easily accessible for takeout. We ordered a medium Hot Honey pizza, a medium GOAT pizza, and some garlic knots. The garlic knots were fluffy with a nice crust, but they didn't have much flavor to them. You're provided with some garlic butter sauce to dip them in, but we got more butter than garlic, and were left a little disappointed. Of the two pizzas, the Hot Honey was definitely the favorite, although I wasn't picking up much of that hot honey flavor. Instead - it just tasted like a solid pepperoni pizza with a crispy crust and a sweet tomato sauce. I also ordered a side of their ranch for dipping, and thoroughly enjoyed this housemade sauce. The GOAT didn't quite live up to its name - while I'm all for a fully loaded pie, there were so many toppings that the cheese (and everything else) slid right off when we picked up each slice. After reassembling, we noted again that both the crust and sauce were quite tasty, and that the bacon was quite crispy. That said, the sausage bits didn't really bring that classic meatiness we were hoping for, and I ended up picking them off. Both of our pies weren't sliced all the way through - meaning we had to pull out our own pizza cutter and finish the job ourselves. I'd be open to giving Poseidon's Pizza another try - but I think I'd definitely switch up our pizza order, and probably leave off the Garlic Knots next time. read more

Pizza was awesome, but I ordered Deep Dish and was not delivered a deep dish. Haven't decided if I'll order again. Pretty pricey for a regular pizza. read more

Got the sampler pizza and it is the most amazing idea to begin with being able to try 4 different pizzas in one... and the pizza was delicious!!!! read more

We didn't plan on trying Poseidon's, but decided to after our go-to deep dish pizza place was slammed on a Saturday night, during Pizza Week no less. We tried their Deep Dish Pizza with Pepperoni & Sausage and their Pepperoni Pizza along with an order of Garlic Drips. The Garlic Drips were definitely overly exaggerated in their description. They're just plain balls of bread. Due to the name we had expected it to be dripping in garlic butter, but instead it just came with a tiny side of the butter. Now, onto the pizza. The Pepperoni Pizza good while the Deep Dish was sparse on its ingredients we would have liked more cheese & pepperoni and would have given it only 3 stars, BUT the sausage and sauce were amazing. They were so flavorful that it really helped save the whole dish. For being disappointed that we couldn't have the pizza that we originally wanted for dinner, we were pleasantly surprised by the flavor-packed punch that Poseidon's delivered. read more

See all

​Web really did not enjoy this food. We ordered two pizzas, one with extra sauce and one cannoli. The canolli wasnt delivered and neither pizza had much sauce. Extremely salty. We havent had the best results the past two orders but to give it one last try before we decided to make a comment . In addition to it when we tried to call the restaurant to tell them about the error the phone would go directly to voicemail which said that we couldn't leave a voicemail because it hadn't been set up . After calling six times finally reach someone and explain to them that we needed to have a refund for the cannoli and they said they would refund it and I had to explain that their phone system is not working properly either . We really had high hopes because other people had commented how great theirs​ read more

l order 60$ food they tell me be delivered 8.45 pm they doesn't delivery and l drive for pick up they close 9 pm this is just bullshit

We had generally enjoyed our experience until the last time (several months ago). We ordered 2 subs and they called and said they ran out of buns. No problem. After offering me the equivalent in pizza, I declined and asked for my credit card purchase to be credited. They agreed. It is here where they fell way short. So the charge was on my card for a week and the credit never came through. I disputed the charge with my bank and Poseidon's still was fighting me that they fulfilled their service (even though I made it quite clear they did not). Ultimately the bank sided with me and gave me my credit under protest by Poseidon's. It wasn't a huge amount and we were regular customers so it's quite shocking when a business calls a customer a lier. So it's over but we will NEVER return as a customer again read more

Well, like a sympathetic fool I decided to try this place again. What a mistake after several attempts to order online failed I finally called this disaster after the call dropped multiple times I finally got the privilege of being put on hold. Finally Jeff Spicoli answered as I attempted to muddle through Jeff's marijuana haze he took my order. As I was not going to trust a delivery I decided to pick up based on the time frame Spicoli gave me. Upon pick up at the advised time I was told my pizza was not ready. Funny thing when I got it it was cold so ready to this pizza place is Luke warm, when I got home I took one bite and decided a ritz cracker with some Ragu sauce would be better. Please whatever you do go buy a frozen Tombstone before you try this turd pile. I know a good a bankruptcy lawyer you are gonna need them. read more

Honestly, very disappointing pizza. We got the G.O.A.T pizza, which is supposed to have bacon, pepperoni, sausage, green peppers, mushrooms, onion, and black olives. We got it without the olives. If you look at the picture, you will see many missing ingredients. Where is the bacon, mushrooms, green peppers? There's hardly any onion. How can you be a pizza place, forget ingredients, and the ones you do give me, you skimp me? Will not be coming back here and I suggest you look at the picture that is supposed to show the greatest of all time pizza. read more

Poseidon's Pizza Company - Pizza Near Me - Florence, Kentucky

See all

Unique good pizza needs a better sauce blend to be 5 stars preferably sweeter it's on the bitter side.

Just got carry out from Poseidons Pizza. The Joe Burrow and cheesy bread knots. Outstanding. Food was ready on time and was delicious. Fast pick up. Reasonable price. Next time will be a deep dish! read more

Poseidon's Pizza Company - a box of doughnuts - Pizza Near Me - Florence, Kentucky

I do not recommend this place. Purchased gift cards right before it switched hands and was assured they would transfer. The new owners will not honor them and quite frankly we're very rude about it. Sad to see the old owner gone as he was much friendlier. You would think they'd want to retain old customers. I'll never spend another dime at Poseidons. Sad to see the customer service left with the previous owner. If you want deep dish pizza, go to Bourbon House. They will treat you much better there read more

I wouldn't serve this to starving children in Africa. Dough has 0 flavor and the texture of wet cardboard. The sauce is 98% water which makes the pizza soggy and gross. Pizza crust should be crisp and airy and light especially when ordered well done. Unfortunately like 99% of pizza places in this area, it's read more

They must not wear hair nets long hair found in my $40 door dash pizza. Photos below read more

Poseidon's Pizza Company - Hair in pizza deliver door dash - Pizza Near Me - Florence, Kentucky

See all

We got it delivered so I can't speak for the inside of the restaurant but the delivery was decent in speed and the driver was very friendly. Now I'll move on to the yummies. The breakfast pizza blew it out of the water. I'm a southern breakfast gravy fan but can get picky and this was crazy delicious. It was also plentiful but I think I'd easily ask for extra gravy next time cause it's just that good. The crust was nice. Crunchy but not TOO thin. I will absolutely get it again. The deep dish was good. It could have been deeper and have been more melted but that could just been a sacrifice of delivery since it had time to cool. The sauce is a little spicy which was different for a pizza sauce but still good. I'd probably get it again but the breakfast pizza wins by far!! read more

Poseidon's Pizza Company - Breakfast pizza - Pizza Near Me - Florence, Kentucky

See all

The food is excellent. The only problem with the place is that they never stay open till their posted hours. It's a true shame!

We are going to have pizza here for the 3rd time in just over a week. That should pretty much sum up our thoughts about it. Our first pizza was a GOAT (Greatest Of All Time) and then we had the Taco pizza. They were both excellent but we liked the GOAT better. That certainly doesn't mean that we didn't like the Taco Pizza. The only problem I can foresee is that we need to decide what to get today! We decided on the Buffalo Soldier. This is all that is left. read more

Poseidon's Pizza Company - I thought this was what was left. - Pizza Near Me - Florence, Kentucky

See all

We got delivery from the new Crescent Springs location and, OMG, it was amazing! The pizza arrived at our house 20 minutes ahead of schedule, it was fully cooked and hot, and the driver was nice. The pizza itself was amazing - soft, yummy crust; bright and delicious sauce; and crispy pepperoni. Overall, the best pizza I've had in a long time and a clear pick over chain places. We will be back! read more

Poseidon's Pizza Company - Deep dish pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Florence, Kentucky

See all

Used to be our favorite pizza in the area. Staffing issues, Ownership change, and (maybe) inflation seem to have cause them to be way more inconsistent with what used to be, high quality pizza. I still like it and order on occasion, but it's difficult to order from our nearest location when they are closed without notice or don't answer the phones. I hope they get back to be awesome because their specialty pizzas are some of the best! read more

In have eaten from Poseidon's a few times now, trying a variety of menu items. My family likes their sandwiches. I like that it is not a big chain. The normal pizza is pretty good with a generous amount of toppings. My last order was a deep dish Chicago style. If had steamed up in the box and was somewhat wet all over the crust. During delivery this pizza had slid to one side of the box, almost ruined, squashed and misshapen. I showed it to the driver who just kind of shrugged like he wasn't sure what to say or do. read more

I wanted to like this place because I had heard good things and had tasted the garlic drips before. However, it was not good. The garlic drips had no taste of garlic, just like bland bread. The taco pizza was sooooo light on toppings and sauce. One piece had a large dry spot in the middle. One piece had one piece of meat one piece of tomato and one piece of diced green pepper. That is soooo light. I feel like it was just not good enough. read more

Generic pizza made worse by terrible customer service. They push a positive vibe brand but it's very insincere and cynical. It's the typical dude bro venture where the owner runs the place into the ground by being toxic then blames everyone for failing him. So gross. read more

So, the wife and I decided to try this place out tonight, and are very glad we did. We got two pizzas, but did a half & half on both. We got the Garden and their Hawaiian on one and The Goat and their take on Buffalo Chicken on the other. We also decided to try their inverted version on the latter. My wife was the one who insisted on getting the Garden, as she's not too fond of meat, and will only eat it on occasion. However, she and I both agreed that The Goat Pizza was the best, with the Buffalo and Hawaiian not being far behind. I'd definitely recommend. read more

Worst pizza place I have ever been to, steer clear! The owners are incredibly rude and entitled. I wanted to like this pizza, trying several of their intriguing options, but it all comes down to the dough and sauce having absolutely no flavor. I will continue going to Strong's off of 42 in Union, or the classics. Don't waste your time on this overpriced "pizza." The place also smelled of cigarette smoke when I walked in. read more

Was looking for a late dinner while staying in a hotel and came across this gem. So many awesome specialty pizzas to choose from. We tried the IGY6 with pep,sausage and bacon and then the grippos pizza. Oh man, they were soooo good. This place is a must try for sure. read more

Solid, solid, solid. 5 stars doesn't come easy. Ordered a medium hand tossed G.O.A.T. minus onions and bacon plus an order of cinnamon rolls. First time customers with high expectations given FB reviews. We were not disappointed at all. If I had to criticize I would ask for more sauce on the pizza, but that doesn't diminish the satisfaction overall. Toppings were very good and the sausage is perfect! The crust is perfectly balanced. The cinnamon rolls were really good, but given my desire to stay fit... those won't be back on my order anytime soon. read more

Poseidon's Pizza Company - Forgot to take a pic before we dove in. - Pizza Near Me - Florence, Kentucky

See all

Obvious knock-off of Bourbon House Pizza. Foods not even good. You want the real deal go to Bourbon House. Original is always better. So support the business that created all of their menu items. Seriously. Look at the menu... exactly the same... except they have the racist and offensive "taco/border pizza". read more

Poseidon's Pizza Company - Offensive branding. Pizza name. - Pizza Near Me - Florence, Kentucky

We have been wanting to come to Poseidons Pizza for a while and finally made it. Oh my goodness was it good. The GOAT was all that the name implied. We are definitely coming back. The two gentleman we encountered were personable and answered all of our questions. Thank you for a great first time experience. read more