I have had many pies from Portage . All have been incredibly mouth wateringly good. I am in LA at the moment but dreaming of my next Portage pie. I am a pie maker myself and it is hard to get a pie that is as good as mine or in truth, at times better . read more

Wow! Great pie! Passed through in March. Pie was so good we called to say thanks. They said they get VERY busy in summer so call ahead. Cash/checks only. Enjoy! read more

I was so excited to discover that our airbnb was only 8 minutes from Portage Pie while we were visiting NY for the solar eclipse. I've been a fan of owner Connie's posts in a pie baking community on Facebook for many years, so it was serendipitous that I was so close to her shop without even knowing it. We arrived on Sunday morning right at 11 when they opened. I was worried the selection would be limited since we did not pre-order, but they had many extra fruit pies and cream pies for us to choose from. We got an apple crumb and a cherry pie. The crust is so crispy, and the fruit fillings taste fresh and just like homemade. Our cherry pie was still warm when we got it. I highly recommend Portage Pie for quality that is so hard to find in modern-day bakeries! read more

Portage Pie - Cherry pie - Bakeries Near Me - Westfield, New York

See all

We love their pies. Choc cream is our favorite. We are never disappointed. Our only comment is shop early as they sell out.

Perfect pie, not too sweet in any flavor. Perfection!! I can't recommend this more. I am from Buffalo and would drive any time to get a pie (and I bake my own) I just missed the grape pie and wished I would have come sooner to get one. read more

Delicious fresh baked. Recommended by the locals. Got peach/blueberry with fresh fruit.

The best pies I've ever had! Dessert is an important food group for me, and Chautauqua has no shortage of it. From Perry's ice cream to Amish baked goods, there is plenty to eat up. The pies I've had at various restaurants and farm stands have been good too, but none have compared to Portage Pie! Our family has been getting them for years and we look forward to picking them up each annual vacation. Over the years we've tried a variety of flavors: dutch apple, cherry, coconut, etc. My personal favorite, however, has always been chocolate. It was a wonderful flavor that other french silk or chocolate pudding pies lack. The crust is thin an flaky, never wet or mushy. And the whipped cream topping is a thick layer and homemade, definitely not from a can of Reddi Whip. I miss the smaller pies I remember buying, but knowing how fast our family inhales this delicious pie that would never suffice now. The shop has a delightful and bright exterior just a few storefronts down from the center of Westfield. I love visiting this picturesque town for the farmers market, architecture, and proximity to Lake Erie, so picking up pies is usually on our way. Due to their popularity you are best to order ahead of time, especially for the more popular flavors like chocolate. We've showed up last year and had to wait in a hot line outside due to the covid policy they had in place, but it was worth it. They also are pricier than most pies and went up again this past year, perhaps due to inflation or supply chain issues like many other businesses suffered from. Considering the quality and it being an annual splurge on our summer vacation, we find it worth it! Everyone should treat themselves to their favorite flavor from this wonderful shop, even if its just once. read more

Portage Pie - Exterior of Portage Pie with my chocolate pie in hand! - Bakeries Near Me - Westfield, New York

See all

I think everything has already been said about Portage Pie. Yes, their pies are delicious and one of the kind. Yes, you have to call and order what you want in advance because they are simply sold out around noon on weekends. That's what happened to us, unfortunately. We learned, during the summer time, it's wise to call even three days before, on Wednesday, if you need your wonderful treat to pick up on Saturday. This is just a bakery place -- order, buy, go and see you sooner or later again. It's all about how far you live from Westfield NY, because you are going to be back for sure if you are a pie lover. Now, if you don't want the whole thing, I mean a full 9 inch pie, or you missed the opportunity to buy one, you can go to two places in town, where Portage Pie slices are available -- Brazilli's on Main and Westfield Main Diner. Those two places are totally different, so the choice of where you would go depends on whether they have the kind of pie you want, price, vibe, occasion and all of the above. Brazilli's charge for a piece of pie is $6. Diner is cheaper, not even $4 per piece of goodness, but we don't know the size of the pieces they offer. So next time, we'll check and let you know. About the actual pies, I can only speak for my friend, who is real pie follower around the nation and she truly knows a lot about the subject of great pies. The Portage Pie place makes them with love straight from the heart. Making this long story shorter, we jumped into the first place we saw on our way, which was Brazilli's, and ordered three kind of pies: coconut, peach and raspberry. All of them were delicious. Although I would rather prefer to have a savory mushrooms tart, I have to say, it was really decent. read more

See all

Handmade pie with flaky crusts are hard to find. Their's are ALWAYS fresh, hand made and delicious enough to be worth the trip. Excellent fruits and fillings in tender flaky crusts. My grandfather would approve ; my Grandmother 's made from scratch pies were his gold standard so that's a pretty darn good review. read more

Cash only! This pie joint is a perfect pick me up spot when you're near Chautauqua. We got an apple crumble pie and it was delicious! The crust had the perfect flake and the apples were still solid and not too stiff or soggy. I went with the apple crumble instead of a double crust and it was definitely a hit! Can't wait to try more pies. The size and density was definitely worth it. Don't forget to order early if you're there over the weekend! read more

Portage Pie - Boxed apple pie - Bakeries Near Me - Westfield, New York

See all

Pie. They have it. You need it. Expensive, but worth it in my book. You will definitely want to call ahead to make sure they have the pie you want or to reserve read more

They have the most amazing pies! The crust is soooo good. I'm so spoiled that I can't buy pies from other places anymore There is not even a close second My husband doesn't care for Coconut Cream Pie but there is something about their pies that he devours it I just can't tell you enough how delicious they are You must try one, you won't regret it! read more

Tasty pie- the pecan pie is the best we have ever had. We aren't typically pecan pie people but this makes you want it again and again.

Incredible pies! Order in advance, since there is limited capacity for walk-ins. I especially recommend the Peanut butter chocolate.

Stopped for the first time, the apple pie with crumble topping was the best I ever had, the crust was cooked perfectly. The only problem I have is I live too far away to frequent it. I will go there again when I am in the area. read more

Ordered a grape pie and it was delicious! I rarely like pie crusts, but this was light and flaky. Highly recommend!.

This small business is a gem in Westfield. The BEST pies ever! After you have one, you will want to go back for another but get there early for the best selection. read more

Simply the best pies ever! Whenever we are in town, we stop by for their pies! Blueberry is the best!

I really think that this is the best pie I have ever had. We stopped in late in the afternoon about an hour before closing time. We were lucky to snag a Strawberry Rhubarb pie. It was amazing! The filing was fresh and well-balanced between tart and sweet. The crust was really perfect; flaky and light yet crisp and dry on the bottom. No soggy bottom at all! Even the next day after cutting into the pie, the crust remained perfect. read more

Had a little pie tasting last night. 9 of their best flavors. Not a dog in the group. But highest marks to Apple crumb, peach , strawberry rhubarb, chocolate cream and coconut cream. read more

Love the made from scratch pies. I have purchased a variety of the pies and they are all delicious. From the fruit pies to the cream! Amazing! read more

Best pies hands down.. call ahead to make sure you get what you want. Friendly staff quick in and out. It's a must stop if your in Westfield read more

Greatest pies ever! Love the fact that they only use fresh ingredients and don't overdo fillings with sugar.

This place is just a small, unassuming barn-like building in the center of Westfield. They are open year round but summer time is their busy season, so call ahead to order what you want because there's no guarantee you'll get what you need just walking in. The cream pies don't seem to be available on a walk-in basis, so call ahead to order banana, chocolate, coconut, key lime, peanut butter, pecan & pumpkin! The young man at the counter was so nice & witty, and his mom apparently is the braun and brains driving the kitchen in this establishment. She poked her head out and waved hello too! They have two sizes of pies, large and small. I'm not a huge pie enthusiast but my boyfriend was head over heels for the strawberry rhubarb we bought!! read more

Some say the old Portage Pie building is haunted. That when you walk in, you can still feel the presence of the bakers. Some even claim that they've smelled pies in the ovens, as if people were still baking here in this long abandoned building. I'm kidding, of course. Although it looks like an abandoned building, the streetside sign saying "OPEN / PIES" indicates otherwise. Portage Pie is open for business! We were here the day before Easter, and it was standing room only. If you hadn't ordered ahead, you were out of luck. You could either wait a few hours for a new pie, or if people didn't pick up their orders, you could buy one of those. No commercial ovens here. In the kitchen, I peeped a row of residential ranges, the same you have in your own kitchen, baking away. I wasn't sure what to expect from these pies. Luckily, grandma had ordered ahead for us, and we walked out with raspberry and key lime pies. Well, damned if these aren't the best pies I've ever had. The raspberries tasted fresh, and the crust was flaky and perfectly cooked (no soggy bottom). Key lime pie can very hit-or-miss, but this one was, pardon the expression, on fleek. The custard was strongly limed-out, and the graham cracker crust held up perfectly. You can't get more local than Portage Pie. I know people come here from all the surrounding towns, and I love the idea that they have probably influenced the whole area's dessert expectations. Family gathering? There'd better be a pie there. And if there's a pie, it'd better be Portage. Here's a nice video about the place: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Fyn7DWDyYVI read more

OMG! This is the best non home baked pie I have ever eaten! I stopped here on my way back to Buffalo and bought a just out of the oven blueberry pie.It has a flaky shortening crust, a just right thickened and sweetened filling. Maybe I should say had because I just couldn't keep out of it. Next time I'll call ahead & order a cherry but then I wouldn't mind another blueberry. It's a good thing this place is over an hour away! read more

All I can say is wow!!! Bought two pies a red raspberry and peanut butter pie. The owner said we were lucky to get any pies because they are usually sold out. The place is very unassuming and if it wasn't for other Yelp reviews we would have never found or stopped at this place.The pies are unbelievable with first place going to the peanut butter. So if you want to put on a few pounds and have $17 a pie to spend ,go for it!!! read more

The hype is real! So real. Like a scene out of Seinfeld and the Soup Nazi, I walked in at 3 PM on a Friday afternoon and the young lady asked me if I had an order in. I did not know I had to. I thought maybe this was like every other bakery I have ever been to and there would be a display case of pies that you could order a slice or a whole deal. Not the case. I reluctantly said, "no I did not," although my gut said to throw out, "Yes, that would be under Mr. Smith," and hope for the best. I mean it's pie and there has to be a Mr. Smith who ordered a pie in Westfield. Better question is who didn't order a pie from Portage Pie that day, as the line grew behind me. The young lady says, "well, we have a chocolate peanut butter pie left, and..." WAIT...you had me at peanut butter. I boldly tossed my debit card in the ring and was denied right there and then. Cash only, bruh. What? Noooooooo. Peter Pan just took his succulent jar or PB and laughed all the way to Neverland right in my face. Where is the closest ATM? I asked. She told me 7-11 around the corner. As I looked behind me, I knew that pie would be gone the second I walked out. But, she asked me for my name....YESSSSSSSS! So, I beat feet and actually found a Key Bank at the corner. I hit it up for an instant $20 and rushed back. I stood in line and when it was my turn, I demanded she take my money. She opened the fridge and BOOM, that pie had my name on it...literally. I drove home, which took me two hours and put it in the fridge for a late night snack. 10 PM rolled around and my wife and I indulged on a piece. Now, I need a moment of silence right now...... ...okay, Shut The Front Door...this pie was THE single best I have ever had. No Joke. It was not insanely rich, but somehow packed a mouthwatering punch. The whipped cream was smooth and fluffy and the PB and chocolate layered better than an Oreo. I swear I may have heard "My Precious" from my daughter when she finished her first bite. If you are ever within a 3 hour radius of this place, you need to make an effort to get her....but order ahead. read more

We love Portage Pie so much that we had their pie instead of cake for our wedding in 2013! Our wedding was over an hour away but my dad made the trip because we all love the pies THAT MUCH! read more

Wow, we stopped by on a lark one day when were were taking a springtime drive along lake Erie. I am sooo happy we stopped. We purchased the best apple pie that I have ever tasted. In addition to the pie, I was impressed by the cleanliness of her kitchen. We cannot wait to try her grape-peach and raspberry pies! read more

The pies are the best around. The customer service is what sucks. I called again today to order and was told No! not taking orders. I was Going to order 5 pies for middle of August. Thanks Connie for being so attentive to the customer. Will have to think long and hard about ordering from there again. read more

hate to be a dissenter about the quality of Portage Pies. This weekend I purchased a raspberry-rhubarb pie and a pecan one. The first has no discernable rhubarb flavor, but lots of thickening; so much so that I could taste it. But the crust was ever so flaky and fantastic. The pecan pie tasted more of corn syrup than pecans. In fact, the pie was way short of pecans even the skimpiest pecan pie. The filling was so sweet that my jaws ached. But the crust was ever so flaky and fantastic. This place was funky and cute. The person who sold the pie was endearing. However, for $38, I felt ripped off in a major way. When I pay that much, I expect quality filling, not just quality crust. First and last purchase from the shop Perhaps the shop should sell its crusts to bakers who can make much better filling than Portage Pies. read more

Without a doubt Portage has the best pies in the land! We live 80 miles from Westfield but whenever we are here we make a point of stopping by to see what may be available. The emphasis there is on May as the place is so popular people really do come from miles around! The best way to be assured that you get the pie you want is to order ahead. There is nothing more satisfying though then to have a bite of their Delicious Pies! Better than homemade? For most who walk through the door the answer is a resounding yes! Not done on an industrial scale but rather, individually made and baked with fresh quality ingredients. Well worth your while to pick up a pie! read more

Wow, the rhubarb cherry pie is incredible. Not a dessert fan, but this is too good to pass up. One could get addicted to these pies. The apple I sampled incredible. read more

OK, so let's start with the fact that I'm not really a pie person, but, my Father is a very discerning pie person So, on the way to Jamestown for the comedy festival (great time, there!), we stopped in Westfield for the renowned Portage Pies. We arrived at noon on a Saturday. I got the last blackberry and the last strawberry rhubarb. I wanted coconut cream but they were long gone (as was everything else except peach-blueberry)! The pies had to survive in the car until Sunday night/Monday when we got back home. I sampled the blackberry !! Absolutely deeeeeelish! But the real test came on Monday when I presented the strawberry rhubarb pie to my Father. I was excited and nervous because I loved it so much but knew he is very picky. I am happy to report that he was extremely happy with it. We both loved the crust and there was hardly any thickener in our pies. They lasted all that time in the trunk and there was no sogginess whatsoever! I will be going back (all the way from Grand Island) soon!!. read more

Yes, yes, yes. This place is the real deal. All they make are pies, and they are very, very good at it. You'll almost always need to order a few days in advance during the summer, although they may have a few extras if you arrive early enough. I have never had a bad pie here, but particularly appreciate their mixed berry and cherry pies. This place is truly a hidden gem. read more

Portage Pies cherry pies are perfection! I remember cherry pies when I was a boy. Full of cherries, sweet with delicious crusts! You can never find them like that any more (unless you can make them yourself). Purchased cherry pies are mostly cherry flavored corn starch with some cherry pieces. A good friend bought me a Portage Pie cherry pie because I always say how disappointed I am with ones I purchase. Portage Pies cherry pie was heavenly perfection! Full of cherries, deliciously sweet with wonderful crust! A pie that lived up to my most nostalgic memory of what cherry pies ought to be! read more

Delicious pies, pleasant people, we love it! We have had seasonal pies for every occasion, and been very pleased. Prices are great and the pies are delicious. read more

Best pies ever. I have been eating Connie and Jack's pies for years, even before they had the pie shop. Well worth your time to enjoy such a culinary delight. Many of their pies come from local produce. read more

Portage Pie - a blue building with white windows - Bakeries Near Me - Westfield, New York

Best pie around! The crust melts in your mouth! I never use to like pie because I didn't like the crust. Now I love pie but a little bit of a pie snob because I will only eat portage pie. I have had a number of the fruit pies including raspberry, grape, and apple crumb. The apple crumb is my favorite. The fruit in the pies were NOT so soft that they were liquid but not hard either. In other words the fruit was perfectly done! read more