Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Portage Pie

    4.9 (45 reviews)
    ModerateBakeries
    Closed Closed

    Portage Pie Photos

    Business Info

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Portage Pie

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    Exterior of Portage Pie with my chocolate pie in hand!
    Christopher N.

    The best pies I've ever had! Dessert is an important food group for me, and Chautauqua has no shortage of it. From Perry's ice cream to Amish baked goods, there is plenty to eat up. The pies I've had at various restaurants and farm stands have been good too, but none have compared to Portage Pie! Our family has been getting them for years and we look forward to picking them up each annual vacation. Over the years we've tried a variety of flavors: dutch apple, cherry, coconut, etc. My personal favorite, however, has always been chocolate. It was a wonderful flavor that other french silk or chocolate pudding pies lack. The crust is thin an flaky, never wet or mushy. And the whipped cream topping is a thick layer and homemade, definitely not from a can of Reddi Whip. I miss the smaller pies I remember buying, but knowing how fast our family inhales this delicious pie that would never suffice now. The shop has a delightful and bright exterior just a few storefronts down from the center of Westfield. I love visiting this picturesque town for the farmers market, architecture, and proximity to Lake Erie, so picking up pies is usually on our way. Due to their popularity you are best to order ahead of time, especially for the more popular flavors like chocolate. We've showed up last year and had to wait in a hot line outside due to the covid policy they had in place, but it was worth it. They also are pricier than most pies and went up again this past year, perhaps due to inflation or supply chain issues like many other businesses suffered from. Considering the quality and it being an annual splurge on our summer vacation, we find it worth it! Everyone should treat themselves to their favorite flavor from this wonderful shop, even if its just once.

    Peach Pie, fresh, flavorful with big pieces of fruits.
    Anna W.

    I think everything has already been said about Portage Pie. Yes, their pies are delicious and one of the kind. Yes, you have to call and order what you want in advance because they are simply sold out around noon on weekends. That's what happened to us, unfortunately. We learned, during the summer time, it's wise to call even three days before, on Wednesday, if you need your wonderful treat to pick up on Saturday. This is just a bakery place -- order, buy, go and see you sooner or later again. It's all about how far you live from Westfield NY, because you are going to be back for sure if you are a pie lover. Now, if you don't want the whole thing, I mean a full 9 inch pie, or you missed the opportunity to buy one, you can go to two places in town, where Portage Pie slices are available -- Brazilli's on Main and Westfield Main Diner. Those two places are totally different, so the choice of where you would go depends on whether they have the kind of pie you want, price, vibe, occasion and all of the above. Brazilli's charge for a piece of pie is $6. Diner is cheaper, not even $4 per piece of goodness, but we don't know the size of the pieces they offer. So next time, we'll check and let you know. About the actual pies, I can only speak for my friend, who is real pie follower around the nation and she truly knows a lot about the subject of great pies. The Portage Pie place makes them with love straight from the heart. Making this long story shorter, we jumped into the first place we saw on our way, which was Brazilli's, and ordered three kind of pies: coconut, peach and raspberry. All of them were delicious. Although I would rather prefer to have a savory mushrooms tart, I have to say, it was really decent.

    Boxed apple pie

    See all

    10 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    13 years ago

    Helpful 2
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    11 years ago

    The best pies!!! Absolutely delicious! Must stop by this hidden gem, call and reserve a pie because it is that busy!!

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    11 years ago

    So much fun! Please if you are in the area stop in and get a pie! The apple pie was amazing and the owner is very friendly and helpful!

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of D S.
    0
    1
    0

    11 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Page 2 of 2

    Ask the Community - Portage Pie

    Review Highlights - Portage Pie

    Dessert is an important food group for me, and Chautauqua has no shortage of it.

    Mentioned in 2 reviews

    Read more highlights

    Ecklof Bakery - Fresh Apple Cider donuts & Delicious Bismarck's   LOVED THESE - October 2023

    Ecklof Bakery

    4.5(57 reviews)
    24.7 mi
    $

    Ecklof Bakery is a Jamestown classic, and I'm so glad I finally made it back after 20 years! My…read morefriend is a regular here, and she suggested we grab lunch. Walking in, I instantly loved the vibe -- cozy, welcoming, and the smell of fresh-baked goods hits you the moment you step through the door. It's the kind of place that feels like home, no matter how long you've been away. For lunch, I went with the 4-inch sub and, let me tell you, it was the perfect size for me. It was plenty of food and I couldn't even finish it (which is rare!). It came with one of their famous pink stripe cookies, which was just as delicious as I remembered. Soft, sweet, and totally iconic. We sat at the counter, and I love that vibe. You order and pay at the register, and they deliver your food. Ecklof's isn't just a bakery; they serve breakfast and lunch too, with a full bakery case that's impossible to resist. If you haven't been here yet (or it's been a while), it's definitely worth a visit. Whether you're grabbing a quick bite or sitting down to enjoy the atmosphere, it's a true Jamestown gem.

    I love this bakery. We always stop here whenever in the Jamestown area for the little cupcakes and…read moredonuts. I like that they actually put the goodies in a nice pastry box instead of just throwing them into a bag. With a long car ride back to Philly, we've never had damaged cupcakes:) the folks who work here are always really nice and patient while I'm looking around and can't decide what I want. Prices are great for fresh backed goods. Highly recommend!

    Photos
    Ecklof Bakery - Swedish bakery

    Swedish bakery

    Ecklof Bakery - Ecklof Bakery Inc

    Ecklof Bakery Inc

    Ecklof Bakery - Chocolate Easter egg cakes! 3 peanut butter 3 angel cream.

    See all

    Chocolate Easter egg cakes! 3 peanut butter 3 angel cream.

    Portage Pie - bakeries - Updated May 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...