Mozzarella sticks were cold and so was the marinara sauce. The chicken wing sauce was okay and blue cheese, but wings were room temp. Would probably not get this again sad as that is because it is convenient. read more

Pontillo's Pizza - chicken wings with ranch dressing - Pizza Near Me - Victor, New York

They seem to have closed down. I called and got a disconnected phone message. My favorite pizza!

Love Pontillos pizza! Their wings are great! We love their pizza and their subs. We went there once and there was a magician doing tricks at the tables. The ambiance is casual and it's fun to sit outside on a warm day and eat and people watch. read more

Was very disappointed when we got our pizza today. very skimpy on the toppings, not much sauce, and the crust was very tough. For the price of pizza these days, you should be able to get a decent pizza. We haven't had Pontillo's in a while, and it's been good in the past. Was looking forward to not cooking and having some good pizza for dinner, but that didn't happen. read more

Great place to stop for a couple of slices or a sub at lunch time. The store is kind of a little stand alone hole in the wall which, in my opinion, is preferable to fancy chain pizzarias or one of the latest wood fired pizza bistro joints... Adds to it's charm. The guys who work lunch are great and chat with the customers, often plugging their pizza of the day. Love that they have a variety of toppings on slices at lunch time... And the reasonable prices. This is not fancy dining but it's tasty, comfortable and convenient. A regular stop for me when I'm in Victor. read more

Pontillo's Pizza - two slices of pizza on a paper plate - Pizza Near Me - Victor, New York

+ Friendly service, fresh wings - pizza overcooked with hard crust, pricey Ordered tonight: large pizza, wings, and garlic bread with cheese. Girl on the phone was friendly but had to call me back saying they ran out of rolls, so no garlic bread anymore. No problem. She said it would be ready in 20 minutes. I walked in where two girls were working. There is seating in the place but I got the order to go. Gave her my name and pizza was just coming out the oven. A large pizza with 3 items (pep, mush, & meatball) and 12 wings came to $25, and that was a special. I find that a little steep. At any rate, the friendly girl taking the pizza out of the oven asked me if it was "dark enough". I was thinking it should have been taken out 10 minutes ago!--ugh. I asked her to cut the pizza in squares. Upon opening the pizza box, I noticed the pizza was not cut in squares. And, it was indeed overcooked--crust was very very hard and lacking taste. Lots of cheese and toppings were good (fresh mushrooms), but there was hardly any meatballs and the overcooked crust indeed ruined it. The crust is also pretty thick. if you are into that sort of thing. Wings were good, tasted fresh, but I personally like them cooked more. Blue cheese was tasty. Not sure I would go back after a poor pizza experience and it not being very good value for what you get. read more

Pontillo's Pizza - Front entrance - Pizza Near Me - Victor, New York

This was the worst pizza I have had. First of all for a medium pizza that cost $16.00 they could have at least put some ingredients on it. It was like eating dough. There was barely any cheese and it looks like they must have run out of sauce as there was hardly anything on it. Very disappointed for a pizza place that was voted #1 pizza in Rochester. read more

Super disappointed Ordered a ham sub but received a chicken parm which I was okay with, until I tasted it. It was just so mushy and flavorless. read more

Pizza crust is very thin now and Pizza was burned on the last two orders. What happened, they used be the best in town, now the worst

Wonderful service and great food! From the moment I walked in I was greeted and treated just like I was a part of our great community. The food was a cut above the rest and really tasted my Italian grandmother's pizza! Overall this is THE BEST PIZZA in Victor by far! read more

This pizza reminded me of the pizza my parents would buy with coupons as a kid. You know the stuff, overly cheesy but using the cheapest cheese possible. The sauce tastes like it came out of a can. I'm guessing it was sysco. The wings weren't crispy at all and the sauce was boring. Definitely a simple Frank's red-hot sauce. I ordered hot and they were barely spicy. Driving up, it looks nice. Walking in the door was terribly disappointing. Let's just say I'm glad I got it for take out... but I really wish I had ordered it for delivery. It looks like they haven't cleaned up in years. It's clear that this place has given up. There is better pizza and wings in the mall. It's a shame that the best garbage plates and pizza in victor are in the Eastview food court. read more

Hot wings and Buffalo wings are the Best here, in all of Rochester!!! Especially if you request them extra crispy... Also. The Pizza is Dynamite. The Buffalo Chicken Pizza is the best. Even better than Shells in Canan4on 332, better than Marks, Pudgies, Mr.Shoes, Cam's, Salvstores.... Pontillo's does it BEST! read more

We've ordered here a few times and I always expect it to be better, but usually disappoints. Tonight's pizza had a soupy center and all the cheese and toppings slid right off when you picked up a slice. Too many other pizza places to go to. If you like a crunchy crust with a wet noddle texture slice with only sauce on it this place is for you! read more

Outstanding! The crust definitely did not taste like cardboard, it was crispy with a chewy finish and the sauce was slightly sweet but not too much. I got my go to which is xtra cheese ham pep. and mushroom and it was great. If you do not like greasy pizza then this may not be for you but if you do then order up, I live in Ohio and am here on business and this will be my go to the next time I am in town. Kudos to Pontillos's! read more

Totally worth trying but for sure not all the pizza is the same. I've been back and tried different combinations I think it depends on what you get but I do love the wings. I do recommend trying different variations until you find one that you like best. read more

Nice crisp veggies on our pizza Bottom of the pizza was soggy but very tuff to bite or cut. Wings were nice and crispy with adequate amount of sauce read more

Not all of these are the same quality, I should say that right up front. With that said, I do really like the one in Victor - it is better than many of the others in the chain, in my opinion. The wings and pizza are pretty good - it's not New York City style thin crust, but it is very very good. And the wings always seem really close to perfect. When they have made a mistake, they have always been quick to correct it. Even when it was delivery - they would come back to our house with whatever we needed. Good folks, good customer service - I like these guys :-) read more

This place is VERY hit and miss. It's like opening a mystery box, you just don't know what's going to be inside. Every pizza you order is totally different than the one you ordered before. One is saucy, the next one is not, one is thick, the next one is paper thin etc. Typical cheap pizza chain. But, some of the pizza's out of this place are excellent. It's just too bad it depends on whose working. The buffalo chicken is usually great. I ordered a standard red pizza with pepperoni and it was terrible so I stick with the specialty pizzas. I usually stick with Marks down the street who put out good coupons or FAROS in Canandaigua. read more

On Halloween night, they delivered to eastview mall like the true angels they are. The pizza was good and hot. It was a slow night for mall workers and I wasn't expecting Pontillos to accept the delivery challenge (I was totally unprepared when I called) and they were patient with my ordering struggles. The pizza made my night and I am a true Pontillos convertee now. read more

Great Food, HORRIBLE delivery service! They are always extremely late, they even forgot my order sitting and had to remake it as it got cold. read more

Please tell me why I just watched a girl mop yes mop the oven ? Probably the dirtiest places I've been to in awhile. Mold covered ceiling fans and vents! Very dirty floors. The garbage can was so old and sticky ! Never eating here again I almost vomited looking behind the counter at how dirty and unsanitary the working station was read more

The pizza is very inconsistent depending on who makes it. Sometimes the crust is very thick and very chewy other times it's alright. The pizza sauce is just meh. The chicken wings are usually soggy and not very crispy. There is better pizza and wings around. read more

The restaurant looks nice for dining. But I was looking for carry out pizza and decided to try this one. This is the place to go if you like chewy pizza dough with no taste, if you like bland tomato sauce, or only want a thin layer of mozzarella. I however do not. The pizza is the worst I've had. But I don't know what the rest of the food is like so I give the place 2 stars. read more

I ordered a pizza at 8 pm and they told me 40 minutes. When I arrived at 8:52 every worker was standing around talking and hanging out and the worker said my pizza would be a minute. He cashed me out while I wait, then he started to actually make my pizza. I thought that there was no way that was my pizza so I waited. When he opened the oven to clean it before putting the pizza in I asked if that was my pizza and he said yes that they forgot to make it. I couldn't believe that they would take my money and lie to me all while allowing me to stand there thinking my pizza would be done in a minute or two. Then when I demanded my money back because there was no way I was going to sit there and wait for the pizza to cook for who knows how long, he couldn't figure out how to reverse the credit card charge, which took 5 minutes at which point he finally gave me cash instead. I certainly did not want cash. I love Pontillos pizza and get it every week since I was a child living in honeoye falls, but will never return to this location again! read more

The pizza here is good, but it's because of the ingredients and recipes. The last 4 times I've ordered from here, they get at least one thing wrong with the order. The most recent time, they put the wrong ingredients on it, put an obscene amount of olives on it(which was a topping I did not order) and the cut resulted in a ton of uneven slices, some 1/16 and some 1/4 slices. It's too bad because like I said, when they do get it right the pizza is delicious and I would choose here over Mark's any day. read more

Pizza, the way it's supposed to be! Wings were equally good. Pontillos is a staple of this area.

The pizza from Pontillo's is usually pretty reasonable, but this review is about bad service. We placed an order for delivery and a half hour later they called to say the pizza was ready but they couldn't deliver to our address. "The girl that took your order is new and she made a mistake." When I told the manager that we were literally a couple of minutes outside of their delivery zone, she didn't care. "We can't deliver out of the delivery zone even if it's our mistake. It would take too long." It sad that a manager can't see that making a customer satisfied (after they made a mistake) is more important than following their rule to the letter. A few minutes of extra driving to fix their own mistake, but they won't do it. Bad service. I will not go back. read more

Pizza is good and they let you do half one topping and half another topping without charging you for two toppings (just how it should be)! We get half boneless and half traditional wings often and they're decent sized (unlike some pizza shops I know). Delivery speed is average but the pizza is usually hot, like it was just made. Good energy from the employees in the store too! read more

Pizza was delivered to the hotel in 45 min as promised but the crust tasted like cardboard. The delivery person was very friendly though.

Loved it loads of pepperoni and cheese. Just the way I like it. Crust was a little tough just the way it should be.

Ordered 4 sheet pizzas for delivery at noon , the pizza didn't come until 12:20 with no plates or napkins and the top of the pizza was doughy , i called and asked for a manager he was rude and told me he made the pizza himself so basically 100 employees over here are lieing right? BAD FOOD BAD CUSTOMER SERVICE read more

Placed an order for delivery on Saturday 9/17/16. Thought I ordered a small pizza and one order of plain chicken fingers and one order of chicken fingers tossed in country sweet. What I got was two orders of half a dozen wings. I called to let them know they sent the wrong food and the phone girl was very nice and professional and apologized. She took ownership and said she made a mistake when she put in my order and that she would send the correct food but she had to tell her manager first. Well, the manager got on the phone with me and was incredibly rude. She sounded like she couldn't have been older than 22 years old. Very snarky. She answered "hi". That's it. So I explained the situation and she told me I was lying and that it was my fault the order was placed incorrectly and she would charge me if I wanted more food sent out. I couldn't believe how unprofessional she was being so I said that's okay have a good night and she said "have a good night" in the most chipper offensive way possible. The "manager" was just mean. None of the attitude was necessary. I did not call them freaking out. It was a simple misunderstanding that could have easily been fixed but she refused to help me, even after the first girl offered to send the correct food. Totally disappointing. I actually downloaded this app to leave this feedback. I would call and ask for the owner or a different manager because I would at the very least like an apology and also my money back but I fear it will only aggravate me more if they are as rude and disrespectful as the Saturday night manager. read more

Pontillo's Pizza - This is one of the "wings" they sent. Looks a little sad doesn't it? - Pizza Near Me - Victor, New York