Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Pompelmo By The Sea

    4.0 (1 review)

    Pompelmo By The Sea Photos

    You might also consider

    More like Pompelmo By The Sea

    Recommended Reviews - Pompelmo By The Sea

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    5 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    You might also consider

    Main St Gelato

    Main St Gelato

    (5 reviews)

    I'm a fan of ice cream, gelato, and Italian icees. This…read moreplace answers all of my cravings! Located going down a hill, parking at it is non existing. You either have to park in the lower lot, or stop in when walking the shops. Some of the flavors are unique. Lately I'm stuck on Ube, which I was told is Phillipino eggplant. It has a slight chocolate taste to me. Again, there's so many flavors there that you can't get or find at any local ice cream stand or shop. Best part is they're open all year round, so this isn't seasonal. They do have a freezer unit that has many products and flavors that they carry, in 1 pint containers to take home. They have what was a store front window display area where you can sit and enjoy, while overlooking traffic going by. If you're going to eat at any of the area restaurants, don't eat dessert there, but instead come here. You won't be disappointed.

    While in town for a few days we visited Main St. Gelato and were so pleased. They had a huge…read moreselection of flavors and had one of the owners was telling us how he had recently started working to add diffrent spirts to his flavors. While we were there someone came in asking for a bourbon flavor which unfortunately he was out of but I did get the Kahlua flavor which I would absolutely recommend. We went pretty late on a Wednesday so there was plenty of parking and seating but I understand from my parents, who have gone many times, that it can get pretty busy. So plan accordingly.

    Aldo's Bakery - Bakery case

    Aldo's Bakery

    (71 reviews)

    $

    This is one of our go-to spots whenever we're on Block Island. It's become a nightly tradition…read moreafter dinner, and our 10-year-old absolutely loves it--she's been coming here since she was 3! The ice cream is always delicious, the employees are so sweet, and the cookies... OMG honey, they're massive. One cookie is big enough for four adults to share and still be happy. Another highlight is the little carousel out front--it's such a charming touch and perfect for kids. Between the treats, the atmosphere, and the friendly service, this place is a must-stop every time we visit.

    I was originally intending to go to a different shop for ice cream but since they did not take…read morecash, I stumbled upon this one. The ice cream/gelato prices were a bit high in my opinion, and I was not too impressed by the flavor selection or quality. I was sold on getting a peanut butter ice cream scoop but after looking at the tub physically, I decided against it since it looked like it has melted and been refrozen. Instead, I got a scoop of the cookie dough gelato. One thing I did appreciate is that it did not have chocolate chips. I can't believe I'm saying this, but it did have too many cookie dough chunks - I would say on average, 3-5 chunks per spoonful so I couldn't really taste the gelato as much. I should've asked for a sample beforehand. It also had a mild freezer taste which I did not like. I think one standard scoop ending up being around $9. There were a lot of people when I got there so it might have been just me who did not have such a great experience. They did have a couple benches and tables outside. Also, I believe they have a sit down outdoor dining area for their restaurant portion, and they had some live music going which was nice. In addition, when you first walk in, they have a LARGE selection of pastries and they all look tasty. This shop is very close to where the ferry picks up and drops off in case you are looking for a treat before hopping on.

    Pompelmo By The Sea - gelato - Updated May 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...