I highly recommend Bay Street Deli. The food is delicious with many varying options; the location also has a cooler with additional options for beverages. The staff were very accommodating of the allergens in our party, and we greatly appreciated it. Overall, a fun, lowkey deli and a great option for families, and a great view of the other shops and famous carousel. read more

Lobster roll was awful expensive and tasted bad. Like canned or old fish. Would not recommend. Save your money. Service and staff pleasant but the lobster roll was a joke. Gross. Inedible. read more

The staff is amazing and the food always delicious, they are always accommodating with my special requests!

Came here looking for a hot lobster roll and Rhode Island clam chowder. Both items did NOT disappoint. Fresh, flavorful, and so so good. Really kind, friendly service as well. Minimal seating inside but there are a few tables outside or you can take it to go and eat by the water. The perfect no frills seafood shop that is sure to please. read more

Bay Street Deli - Rhode Island clam chowder - Delis Near Me - Westerly, Rhode Island

See all

My favorite hot lobster roll in the area. Very straightforward, warm, delicious and worth every penny. Love getting it taken out to eat across the street on the water. Great clam chowder too!! Recommend for an easy lobster roll fix if you are in the area. read more

Bay Street Deli - Lobster roll clam chowder - Delis Near Me - Westerly, Rhode Island

First of all, I don't even like sandwiches but this place makes the best sandwiches ever, breakfast ones too (served until ~11am). I love ham but Bay Street Deli really made me realize it because in fact, they have the best ham you'll ever have in your life -- it's light, fluffy, and so flavorful. Check out the pic (the dunes) and you'll see what I mean but you'll have to taste it too. You can modify it to your liking like I do most of the time with the dunes (but only cos I have a sweeter tooth): white instead of marble bread, provolone instead of Swiss, and honey mustard instead of mustard. You seriously never had a ham or sandwich like this before. I also love getting breakfast sandwiches here (on a roll). In the morning, when you walk in, you hear the fresh egg shells cracking in the background -- it's a familiar sound like when you're at home and mom or dad make you breakfast, it's a great feeling -- followed by the far away sound of one egg at a time hitting the hot surface straight out of its shell, you can hear it bubble up and freshly fry away, and eventually you finally get the wrapped up sandwich with a swirl of breakfast goodness in the air. I look forward to every season when they reopen. They also have hot/iced coffee, with flavor options. I love their chocolate chip cookies too, freshly baked every day. Outdoor seating is available for a quick bite. They're sweet people, it's a family-run business, and you can see their love of family in some wall decorations too. Now go get that sandwich! read more

Bay Street Deli - a person holding a sandwich - Delis Near Me - Westerly, Rhode Island

See all

Ordered lunch takeout for the beach- this place is located on the Bay Street stretch right near the beach. Got a cold lobster roll, and Italian sandwich, cookies, chips, cream soda. The lobster roll was refreshing and not as mayo'd like most places. Convenient and did the job! read more

Best place to eat in watch hill. Great service, delicious sandwiches and fair prices. It is a really small shop on the Main Street. No bathrooms. Maybe one table inside and two outside. Try the meatball grinder. read more

This is your good basic deli - open early for breakfast with the usual takeout things and nice selection of the classic stuff you'd expect - right across from the bay. Clean store - food prepped and cooked right in front of you, good staff. read more

We have had sandwiches at sift (so overrated and honestly I do not get the long lines) and ten sandwiches (fine) and the ocean house when we stayed there (truly just okay) and of course the cooked goose (used to be amazing but the quality has gone down horribly so), I do not understand these reviews. We have been coming to watch hill for 20 plus years and bay st cafe has always had the best sandwiches. They have baked turkey for their turkey cold cuts and it is THE BEST turkey sandwich I've ever had. I live in nyc and can get any kind of sandwich from anywhere I want and yet, I am thinking of the Carrousel sandwich with baked turkey, sprouts, tomatoes, white bread and a lil Mayo from this cafe -- truly an outstanding sandwich. From a picky New Yorker, go with Bay st cafe -- it is the best sandwich going (it's not fancy inside bc it doesn't have to bc its food is SO good!)! read more

By far my favorite lobster roll in Rhode Island! Tons of buttery lobster inside a delicious homemade fresh roll! I'm horrified to read some of these crazy reviews about the poor bread quality because I've never had a bad experience! The bread is fresh and homemade! Absolutely delicious and pairs perfectly for a nice lobster roll. I've had their roast beef grinder on the same type of roll there before and it's honestly delicious! Their New England chowder is probably my favorite as well- tons of clams in every bite! They also serve homemade cookies and you can get them directly from the hot pan which is an awesome perk! I've read reviews about the service and yes some of the workers are miserable but they are efficient and hard workers! Watch hill can be very busy at times so I can totally understand not being 100% perky 24/7. If you love lobster rolls, grinders, chowder and homemade desserts definitely hit up Bay Street Deli! read more

Bay Street Deli - Delicious hot buttery lobster roll! - Delis Near Me - Westerly, Rhode Island

Small cold lobster roll was $15.99. They don't douse the lobster roll in mayo, so that's a huge plus. It was the "purest" lobster roll I've ever had! Very tasty. At 2pm, there was not much of a line. We got our sandwiches pretty quickly. I just wish there were more spaces to sit! read more

You can't go to Watch Hill without stopping at the Bay Street Deli! The lobster rolls are simply the best. Just real yummy lobster meat and a bit of mayo or butter, depending on whether you want it hot or cold. They have other sandwiches available, and baked goods too that always look tasty... but I always go for the lobster rolls. Soooo good. It's a mom and pop place, and either mom or pop or both are always there. There are a few tables, 1 or 2 indoors and maybe 3 on the sidewalk. But hey, you're in Watch Hill. Grab your sandwich and go eat it on the beach! Funny the other reviewer mentions Conan O'Brien, because his picture is now up on the wall, along with Mark Wahlberg. read more

Bay Street Deli - This would be a better picture if it weren't off-season. - Delis Near Me - Westerly, Rhode Island

Great family run business! They have great sandwiches and also the best iced coffee in Watch Hill For the best price!

I really love this place when we come to Watch Hill! One of the best delis ever been to. Sadly I only have couple times per year. I always get the Dunes (#10) and it might be one of best sandwiches ever had. I love a good deli and this was is worth the visit. It's a little pricey but worth it in my opinion. They also have amazing baked goods like cookies and donuts along with Del's lemonade! Must try if your at Watch Hill and want a good lunch. Those reviews I just read aren't accurate. The staff isn't rude not overly friendly but it is what it is. Worth it for the food. read more

Hot butter lobster roll...you say those four words to me, and thanks to Bay Street Deli, I will have a pavlovian drool response. I don't have New England roots so my main experiences with lobster rolls are the ones served cold in mayo in New York restaurants that charge them for almost $30. With its hot butter lobster roll, Bay Street revealed certain truths to me: First, lobster rolls taste just as good if not better when they are doused in hot butter compared to the cold, mayo-y kind. Which way you choose your lobster roll done is a matter of how you feel, but the universal fact is both taste amazing. Why more places in New York do not provide the hot buttered option is simply tragic... Second, lobster rolls are simply better on a butter-griddled hot dog bun than on any other bread-holder. Bay Street's bun was crispy and buttery, and it provided the perfect pedestal for the thick claws and lobster meat erupting from the bread. It was just as appealing to my eyes as it was to my stomach. No more lobster rolls in hamburger buns for me (well, maybe Mermaid is an exception). Last, the era of lobster shacks is over, and the era of lobster delis will soon reign. Bay Street shatters the preconception that good, cheap seafood can only be found in isolated shacks in New England. I walked into Bay Street and it looked like just a regular deli with cold cuts in the glass counter, soda bottles in the refrigerated glass case, and a menu with sandwiches written in chalk/marker. The deli was also located on a main drag in Westerly. However, the $14 "small" hot butter lobster roll was one of tastiest seafood dishes I have ever eaten. read more

I got a tuna sandwich there today and when I opened it, the bread had bright green mold. I mean, it wasn't subtle. When I walked back over to show it to the cashier, she just said "yup, yup." No apologies. No offer to reimburse the 10 (10?! 10!!) bucks the (very) basic tuna sandwich costs. They replaced the sandwich. No apology, no refund. I'll probably take my business back to Ten Sandwiches next time. read more

I was told that the lobster rolls here are GREAT and my friend did not steer me wrong! It was mouth-wateringly, savor-every-bite, delicious! Made fresh after you order and the lobster chunks are meaty and succulent. The bread is warm and soft. MMM...I will be dreaming about this place forever. My only regret is that I didn't get the large roll. I still kick myself. The lobster is sauteed in butter in the "hot" roll. That's the one I got and it's so freaking good. Words don't do it justice. I didn't try the "cold" roll but it's made with mayo. I think the price was $11 something for the small and $13 something for the large. Quite a steal considering the sub-par lobster rolls I find in the Bay Area go for $15+. The owner told me that I just missed Conan O'Brien by an hour. It's good to know that he is a fellow lobster roll fan. I am in pain just talking about it. I must go kick myself some more for not buying a LARGE. Go there, it's unbelievable! read more

Debated between three and four stars... I would recommend this place but it's nothing absolutely spectacular. I saw the review of the lobster roll being amazing so I decided to go with the large. It was very good and I did inhale it, however I've had far better rolls. They put a fair amount of lobster on and the bun was only pretty good... Nothing to write home about. read more

Went yesterday for the first time. While the prices were what I expected for being at the beach, being greeted by a miserable, older woman who took our order certainly did not leave a great first impression. The sandwich was ok, given it was on generic, wheat bread that comes in bulk ( I got the carousel). My wife and daughter ordered lobster rolls, and to be honest, and she was a little disappointed. I would honestly try a different place next time. read more

Great coffee! My absolutely favorite brand: Douwe & Eggbert... Sitting in my beach chair on my most favorite beach ever, East Beach, Watch Hill. Doesn't get much better than this! read more

Hidden gem in Watch Hill! Great place to bring people because the food is great, the staff is incredible, and it's priced right. I'd highly recommend the Italian or heated up Reuben. The iced tea was also very refreshing and the outdoor seating was nice. Most importantly the staff were extremely friendly and polite, they smiled, welcomed us in, made a few recommendations, and thanked us for our business (most people in Watch Hill are stuffy/arrogant for no apparent reason). I will definitely come back here again! read more

This deli was the worst deli i've ever been to! very u friendly bitter workers and unorganized. we waited almost 20 minutes for only 2 sandwiches. it was $10 for a custy tuna sandwich that was tiny and we even found a long hair in it. even the italian grinder was nasty! who can mess up an italian grinder what the hell!!! we will never be returning to the stinky deli again read more

Looked forward to a good lobster roll. Was disappointed. Years ago they were good. Now, not so much. Dry, lots of roll, sad

Had the raved about hot lobster roll. Decent amount of meat and nice big fresh chunks at that. Overall however, the experience was greatly brought down by the awful bread. It was a dry, seemingly almost stale, un-grilled roll. I like my lobster rolls on fresh, soft hot dog buns with crispy, buttery, grilled sides. Fix the bread and you'll have a winner (in my opinion). read more

A 17 dollar lobster roll should not include bread that is moldy. Not a little speck, but a quarter size blotch on the underside. I noticed it about 1/2 way through the roll. Yum. read more

I'll be very sorry when the season ends and one my favorite sandwich shop closes. Where else will I get meat piled high? Where will I get such fresh quality meat on my sandwich, with a generous portion of their cheese spread? This not Subway, this is the "REAL DEAL". When you go to Watch Hill and you need a sandwich for the beach- this is where you go. read more

Love the lobster rolls here but the last three times we have come they were closed for no apparent reason. Saturday of labor day weekend and you are closed at 5:30 that makes no sense. If you don't feel like working then just close your establishment. Watch Hill is not the easiest place to get in and out of and if your coming here just to get a lobster roll I expect you to adhere to your posted hours. read more

The people running the place could care less for your business. They have an attitude and the food is sub par. Bring in food from elsewhere if you're going to picnic in Watch Hill. read more

The lobster roll was good but needed a few more items in it. Maybe some lettuce or some sort of greens. Toasting a bread roll and adding some mayonnaise did't do it for me. The clear clam chowder was really good. Had a lot of clams and not to many potatoes. read more

I am still dreaming about the hot lobster roll (naked-style)... pure heaven! Oh how I wish I could have you in the Bay Area. This little, unassuming deli puts Bay Area lobster rolls to shame! read more

Terrific lobster roll. My daughter and I shared one hot and one cold. Nothing fancy just tasty. Kids working there are humorless and lack affect but owners are delightful. read more

Great hot lobster rolls! Good iced coffee. Meatball aub was tasty. Chowder just ok not good. Steak sub was ok but not good. Yummy choc chip cookies fresh out of the oven. read more

Reasonably priced deli sandwiches - the end. They have great baked sweets as well! Grab a sandwich and head to east beach for a perfect Watch Hill day!! read more

Stopped in for clam chowder right before closing. Soup was tasty, but the old woman that works there was nasty and visibly upset because they were ready to close. She literally was throwing things! Needless to say, next time Im in Watch Hill, I'll head to Ten Sandwiches instead. I imagine they'll be happy with the customers.... read more

Little deli makes fresh New England clam chowder. It is well seasoned and much better than the other chowders I tried in town. Also makes good iced coffee. read more

Great location and friendly service! Food and shop conditions leave a lot to be desired. Sandwiches were a bit expensive and not very good.

Maybe you go for the lobster rolls, but definately will not go to this dive again. Simply because the owner was so rude & gruff. I asked for the chicken ceaser wrap with tomatoes. The very large rude man says... "no tomatoes - we make 'em like we make 'em". Really nasty. On top of that the wrap was barely acceptable at best. Give your $$ to another establishment who actually wants to provide & serve their customers. read more

The best place for a lobster roll In Westerly, Ri. I've had both the cold with mayo tomatoe and lettuce (toasted roll of course) and the hot with yummy butter. A no nonsense business, with good counter service and great food. You may get lucky and get a table outside, or just go sit out on the harbor wall and let Watch Hill harbor sink in....a summer must... read more

Great breakfast sandwich. Egg bacon cheese in the brioche roll is terrific. Can't comment on anything else. Not a fancy place