Not my favorite Plato's Closet but have it a shot because it said it was under new management. What a scandal with the old one. But anyway, selections were slim, esp for plus sizes. And what they did have seemed WELL used. The shoes were sparse. The store had an odor. The whole place paled in comparison to other Plato's Closets. read more

Plato's Closet - Used, Vintage & Consignment Near Me - Ledgewood, New Jersey

I walked in and I walked out used pants for $20. What are they nuts? Everything was over the $10 range for used clothing lol

VERY rude staff. Totally unprofessional. Will never go back there again. They actually made unnecessary comments amongst each other about me and my bags I was carrying while i was walking to the register. And not friendly at all. Manager needs to teach this staff how to treat customers. This happened another time last year but I didn't leave a review. read more

Many reviews said the employees were rude. I went in and thought they were acting odd, then read the news about the owner filming them in the bathroom and having thousands of indecent images without their knowledge. read more

This place is very unwelcoming. There is two nice workers here and the rest feel the need to let everyone know how shitty their day is going by giving you the most disrespect known to mankind. I was helped by a girl who was kind and helpful. At the end of my visit, I was helped by a girl who made it clear she wasn't happy with her life. There was no welcoming smile whatsoever--and I'm not saying everyone must be smiling 24/7, but when you don't receive the classic "Hi, how are you?" or "Did you find everything okay?" or even a "Have a nice night" after checking out, you know the business isn't run correctly or by respectful people. I hope others do not have the same experience. read more

This place is terrible. The employees are so rude and unwelcoming. They also make you feel worthless. I brought in three bags of clothes (all name brand) didn't even look at any of the items (I watched them) besides a $80 button down and offered me $3 for it. Never going back read more

Really rude employees. The selection in the store was not very good either. I heard them give everything back to one woman who walked in bc it "wasn't in style" meanwhile a whole rack contained exactly what she brought in. I think they're just very picky and choosy and it's not worth it. read more

I went into this location excited to sell some clothes after hearing they changed hands. Unfortunately, I was met by extremely rude staff who mocked me and laughed at me in front of other customers! I politely told the girl at the register that the bin she was holding wasn't mine (it wasn't) and she SNAPPED at me and rudely said "these aren't your pants?" No they aren't. She then told me she was giving me back most of my items because "we're not taking summer items". I sweetly gave her a recommendation and asked if Plato's has ever considered posting on their social media page about which items they are and aren't taking. Another girl who claims to be the manager chimed in from behind and kept asking the girl assisting me "what did she say what did she say" to which the girl assisting me starting saying "shhhh". Extremely rude to talk about your customers in front of them like that. I then repeated myself and said "oh I had a suggestion that maybe Plato's closet could post about what types of items you are looking for!" And the girl assisting me then MOCKED ME to the manager and said in a condescending tone "it would be convenient". The "manager" then shook her shoulders at me, fluttered her eyes and said in an extremely rude manner "you can call". At this point I was extremely disappointed in the customer service and shocked that this is how a store would treat their customers. Upon mentioning that I would consider brining this to the managers attention on my way out of the store, all of the girls at the register started LAUGHING at me and one of them SCREAMED across the store "SHE IS THE MANAGER" and they all kept laughing. This childish behavior was DISGUSTING and something that i will not forget. I sincerely hope the owner sees the reviews and speaks with his employees. I would hope as an owner this would not be tolerated. read more

I really love the concept of this store. They buy and sell lightly worn clothing. Everything is priced super reasonable and you can find some really cute items. They sell everything from clothing to jewelry to sunglasses. Lots of cute little handbags and wallets! The store is clean and organized well. The workers are always so nice! I think I might sell some items next time. I asked about what they buy and as long as their inventory isn't too full, they will buy all kinds of current teen fashions from a variety of different stores. Cool! Overall a great place and I will be returning soon! read more

See all

Okay selection. Honestly, unsure if the owner of The Ledgewood location knows how much it impacts who you put in front of the store. Employees behind the register are very rude. I wish I was exaggerating when I say every time I have walked in I have not ever received a greeting...not once. To make matters worse the customer behind me as well was not greeted and there was a total of 3 people behind the register. I would also like to add that there was absolutely no traffic in the store, and yes they did see myself & the second customer walk in. So, owner or manager if you are reading this you might want advise your staff that they should start greeting customers. Something so simple is actually highly important for your reputation and of course business. read more

Stopped here on a whim - they took some of my items. Overall friendly store/staff. Good selection to buy-- seemed to have more upscale items than the other Platos closet locations. Well organized! I'd return! read more

This place is a complete sham when you sell clothing to them. I have been to numerous Plato's closet and they are far better than this location. I asked for an itemized receipt, which every other Plato's does, this location could not produce. Suspicious much? When you sell new with tags, I want to know what you are giving me for it. Don't come here. read more

Basically thieves! Brought in basket of clothes with tags still on from JCrew, Abercrombie and other quality brand names. They took my basket of clothes, scanned what they wanted, didn't let me see what they were keeping and only gave me $10.00 telling me that once they scanned me in, I automatically agreed to their price. Never ever bring your things here! read more

Ugh this place is really going downhill so fast. The latest few cycles of new clothes have been so bad nobody over the age of 18 would wear them. Lots of those cheap, lame graphic tees with sayings like "iM sO oVeR yOu" or "WhEn I wAnT yOuR oPiNiOn I'Ll ReMoVe ThE dUcKtApE LOOOLLL" Oh I forgot to mention that one of the last few times I went there, the teenage girls that were working I guess forgot I was in the store and were talking about some shit I really did not need to hear underage girls talk about. So gross. If you REALLY look hard you can still find some decent stuff but when they're selling sweaters with pit stains and clothes for toddlers and their staff is talking about their vaginas it's kind of a turn off. read more

The staff can be kind or rude and make you feel like you are somehow inconveniencing then by needing them to ring up your purchases. The selection is decent, however, I would not recommend selling here if you plan on making any money at all. I brought in probably about 300$ worth is hoodies and clothes (some of which still had tags on it) and they offered me like $23 for everything. read more

I can't give a rating very disappointed but in order to post this I had to mark a star...every time I've been there to drop clothes off they barely take anything and if they do chances are you won't walk out with anymore than a whopping $30 for 3 bags of clothing. They tell you the items are outdated???? I have nice items some with tags still on them!!! I'm going to try a different place recommended by a friend. Don't waste your time here. read more

You can find some nice pieces here, but the staff do not make you feel welcome. Definitely needs some work.

I've been to a few Plato's Closets and consignment stores and this one is by far my favorite! It's extremely neat and organized and the staff, especially the owner, is very friendly. He also does a great job explaining the process of how clothes are chosen. Whenever I have items that are in season and style, they are bought. It's as simple as that! Maybe people seem to complain because they aren't getting the perceived value for their items or are bringing in out of style/season items. It's happened to me too. However, if you're getting extra cash for items you know longer use, how could you complain? I simply just donate the rest! Plato's Closet is a business as well and they need to make money, so I believe the whole process is very fair. read more

Depressing vibe all the time. This place doesn't even deserve a star at all. Every time I've come here the staff acts like they are untouchable. There have been countless times I've brought brand new sweaters, men's wear and even unworn items and was sent home with it all because of "minor wear and stains". Then to be offered $5-10 for more than 2-3 items. Better off just donating clothes than wasting time making a stop here. Don't waste your time either. read more

This place is awesome! When you first walk in you are greeted by the friendly, knowledgeable staff and an awesome smell in the air (I know that's an unusual comment but it's true!) The clothes are in great condition and are very affordable. Everything is super organized (by size and clothing type) and they have several fitting rooms for your convenience. I found a few cute tank tops for the summer. Come check it out! read more

Plato's Closet - Used, Vintage & Consignment Near Me - Ledgewood, New Jersey

This Plato's is so organized. I was pleasantly surprised to see how well they have everything arranged. I've sold to them about 3 times now and the turnout is usually good, I've gotten from $30 to $100 for my items! I wasn't expecting to receive that much cash for my stuff but very happy about it. The staff is pretty friendly, I haven't had any problems coming here! The shoe selection could be widened a bit but otherwise it's a cute store, good prices. read more

Not a "Gold Star Store" like their website would have you believe. Really not worth your time or money. A few days I decided to sell 2 big bags of clothes, shoes, jewelry, scarves, and similar items. The girl working there said it would take about 20-25 minutes to go through. So I decided to browse, since it wouldn't take so long. The girl goes and helps another customer, and as soon as the guy left, she completely ignores my 2 bags and starts talking, loud enough for me to hear, to the other girls working about "if she totally knew that guy" for the next 15 minutes. Meanwhile, I'm still walking around the store. Once gossip time was over, she asks me about something in my bag, puts the 5 items she was "appraising" back in my bag, and tells me a laundry list of things that they're not taking, which included EVERYTHING that was in my 2 big bags, which she didn't even take the time to look at. My advice: go to a store that actually trains teenagers to have customer service skills. And from the other reviews I've seen, I'm glad I didn't sell any of my stuff there. Dodged a bullet on that one. read more

I love platos closet. But I find it ABSOLUTELY disgusting that the staff on Black Friday let this lady get away with buying most of the lululemon things (mind you there was a lot considering the event) so she could re sell them online. It was not fair to me who waited an hour outside in line and unfair for others as well to not be able to get much. Other then that good service. read more

Employees are very rude and will look at you as you watch into the store and not greet you. Their clothing selection has also gone SO DOWNHILL. They're very picky with what they'll buy from you, however the clothes on the ranks are outdated and ugly. Their prices have also gone up a lot. 1/5 stars from me. read more

My main problems come more with the staff and the appearance of the store than the product. I have been shopping here for years because I like the idea of the store and I like thrifting, but it's never truly a great experience. They have become more and more ridiculously selective when selling to them, and I get next to nothing for what I sell. Even a PINK sweatshirt I hardly wore got me only $2. The staff always act like they don't want to be there and don't like you (they never greet me but will greet other people). However the prices are phenomenal and if you're like me and are willing to dig through a whole bunch of stuff to find a hidden gem (recently I got a super cute tank for $3, and got a cotton sweater last year for $10) then I wouldn't hesitate to recommend. The fact that it's going to be a hit or miss selection is just the nature of the type of store it is. Love having the opportunity to get cute clothes sustainably for cheap! read more

I had a terrible experience with this specific Plato's Closet. The Princeton one was fantastic, this one.... not so much. My friend and I brought in several bags of high quality clothing, including Vineyard Vines, Michael Kors, Victoria's Secret, Brooks Brothers, etc. The staff was rude, and talked through us to each other. Our bags were untouched, items left exactly how I folded them and placed them into the bags. However they claimed the items had wear, which the majority of the items still had tags or were very well-kept. The Princeton store was very reasonable and went through nearly every item with us, even though they were busier when we went in. The store itself was not clean, poorly organized, and generally messy, which made for an unpleasant shopping experience. I would seriously NOT recommend coming here unless you want to leave FUMING! go to Princeton instead!! read more

Stay far away from this place if you're looking to sell anything over $100.00. This store in particular the one in Fairfield in which I had visited recently is awful. My wife had a few fabulous pieces to sell and being she's petite and a business professional we felt we should give this place a try given some other positive reviews on Yelp. Never again, while browsing the store while she consigned it seemed like it was littered with dirty nightclub attire. Or a young teenager's closet. They buy a lot of Forever 21, H&M, and Joyce Leslie clothing. The girls working there were very unprofessional, and seemed to lack not only customer service skills but a keen eye for the Fashion Industry. You'll be much happier selling your items on EBay then wasting your time traveling here. read more

This place is great! The staff is really nice and make you feel welcomed the minute you walk through the door. They have a really good variety of clothes, shoes, bags & other accessories at such great prices! Everything there is pretty good quality for being slightly used. I found 2 pairs of designer shoes for less than $20 each and a pair of designer jeans for $20 too! I definitely plan on going back regularly to look out for out new things! read more

Usually they aren't bad I have noticed long wait times for sells, but I live an hour away and got here two hours before they close, I had a bag of maybe ten things and they told me they stopped taking sales. I explained it's only a few things and that today was the only day I could make the drive here. Drove an hour here for literally nothing instead of making a few extra bucks I wasted it. read more

Good place to get some extra cash but they won't take everything you're trying to sell. I've come here numerous times and have never gotten more than $30 every time. The girls who decide if your clothes are "in" or not are not up to date with current trends and styles. To me it seems they only take poor quality clothing rather than designer brands. They once offered me $28 for a pair of $120 doc martins that I only wore once, they were in perfect condition. read more

I am extremely disappointed with my last 2 visits with this specific Plato's closet. The employees were EXTREMELY rude to me both times I came in and it was different employees each time. The second time I was going in I was hoping to get better customer service and it turned out to be even worse. I don't even think they went through my entire bag.. I had a Kate spade phone case that was in great condition that was still at the bottom of the bag. I had an entire bag of juicy couture jewelry that they did not even open. They took 6 of my items and I only got $9 dollars for all of it. Which is extremely confusing because they took a pair of BARELY used birkenstocks that were in perfect condition that run for about $175 new.... how does that make any sense that I only got $9 back with those shoes and 5 other items.. it doesn't I completely got ripped off. They also would not take a bunch of my other clothes that were totally in style and gently used when most of the clothes they have on their shelves are out of style and seem to be in the exact same condition as the clothes that I bought in????? I'm honestly extremely disappointed and will be going to a different location from now on read more

I wish I could give them zero stars, I don't even know where to begin. Walking in you instantly feel the negativity coming off from the staff, they will stare at you and make you feel like you are invading their space. The clothes feel dirty. The shoes have DUST in them. Cat hair EVERYWHERE. While trying on clothes, you have to wait until one of the few teenage employees decides to grace you with their presence to open up the fitting room. They always stare at what you bring in like you have no taste or are too cheap. If you want to sell clothes go literally anywhere else. I had an $80 Lia Sophia necklace that they wanted to give me $1.25 for, absolutely ridiculous! They will make fun of what you bring and judge everything. They also take forever to search through your stuff. Recently, I arrived at the store with a decent but not overwhelming amount of clothes that I wanted to sell. An employee told me they would write my name on the white board when they were finished appraising the clothing. I waited around for twenty minutes until I finally went up to ask if my stuff was done, apparently it had been done for a while. They didn't write my name on the board and didn't even have the courtesy to call my name to say that my clothing had been processed. Honestly, I only have bad things to say about this place. Judging by all their ads on Pandora I figured they would be somewhat decent, but I guess all their money goes to social media and funding the shit employees. Teach your staff appropriate customer service, clean your store, stop accepting damaged, ripped, and dirty clothing. If you actually accepted decent clothes, regardless of the "designer", you'd have better luck. But seriously, most of all, fire your bitchy staff. read more

Only have ever purchased here but my daughters love the clothes & I love the prices. Hit & miss like any other consignment store. Very nicely organized. You're not pulling through stuff. Staff is ok. Clothes are great. read more

This store has AMAZING inventory. Staff is friendly and Nick is the best. I love selling to them and buying from them! I can't wait for the UGG reveal again this year. I got amazing UGGs and Northface. I highly recommend this store. You will not be disappointed! read more

Overall a good place to shop. I've found great items here. The employees aren't that welcoming. They seem miserable the entire time. Sold clothes here, they don't take much. Had brands like j crew and loft that they didn't accept. Also had American Eagle jeans they didn't take either. read more

This place is run by absolute no experience, just a bunch of teenagers really. If you are looking to sell your clothes, shoes, or bags, try elsewhere! This place will offer you little to nothing for your clothes, and are very picky, even if you do bring in new items. Considering what they even have on the racks, it looks like they accept almost anything, but try again! Browsing their "selection" of clothes, a lot were out of fashion, holes in shirts/dresses, and they even tried selling a shirt that has a price tag from H&M of $2.99 for $6! Place is an absolute rip off, the people working there are very demeaning, and I will never be returning here. read more

We had a full bin of clothing to sell and after an hour they told us they only want young women's clothing. Waste of 2 hours.

I wanted to give this place negative stars....don't waste ur time here...employees who have no style and they only sell outdated more than gently used clothing....the store has a raunchy smell as soon as you walk in the door...I donate my clothes to people who need it. This place will not last long!!!! read more

The staff lacks professionalism and needs training ASAP. These people are very racist to those who do not speak proper English and they are also very rude and snobby. I do not recommend this place to anyone. read more

I love this store! Always such a great selection of clothes/items for great prices! It's like a modern new age consignment and I love it. Staff is very helpful and friendly as well and gave me a great deal on the clothes I turned in! Sooo happy they opened up close to me! read more